In the Matter of Assimina Krinas

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Testamentary Causes Jurisdiction)

In the Matter of ASSIMINA KRINAS

[2016] SASC 9

Reasons of Judge Dart a Master of the Supreme Court

8 February 2016

SUCCESSION - MAKING OF A WILL - TESTAMENTARY CAPACITY - LOSS OR LACK OF CAPACITY AND STATUTORY WILLS

Application for order authorising making of a will for person lacking testamentary capacity - not opposed - whether proposed testator lacks testamentary capacity - whether proposed will reflects likely intentions of testator - whether proposed order reasonable in circumstances - whether order of Guardianship Board prevents making of a statutory will.

Held: permission to make application granted - application granted - person lacks testamentary capacity - proposed will accurately reflects likely intentions.

Administration and Probate Act 1919 (SA) s 72B, s 72G; Guardianship and Administration Act 1993 (SA) s 56; Wills Act 1936 (SA) s 7, referred to.
Banks v Goodfellow (1870) LR 5 QB 549; In the Matter of Brown [2009] SASC 345; In The Will of Wilson (1897) 23 VLR 197; Re Fenwick (2009) 76 NSWLR 22; Timbury v Coffee (1941) 66 CLR 277, discussed.
In the Matter of Marion Shirley Manley [2013] SASC 98; Hill v Hill [2001] VSC 83; In the Matter of Shaun Arthur Pickles [2013] SASC 175, considered.

In the Matter of ASSIMINA KRINAS
[2016] SASC 9

JUDGE DART:

  1. These reasons deal with what was an urgent application for the making of a statutory will.  An order was made on 25 January 2016 permitting the making of such a will.

    Background

  2. The application was made by Mr Peter Krinas, a nephew of Ms Assimina Krinas (“Ms Krinas”), the person for whom the will is to be made.  The reason for the urgency of the matter was that Ms Krinas is suffering from advanced neurological disease.  She has been in care at the Highgate Park Clinic since 2004 and is unable to communicate.  She is in a vegetative state in palliative care.  The medical evidence is that she has now entered the terminal phase of her disease and that she could die at any time. 

  3. Ms Krinas married Spiros Krinas (“Spiros”) in Greece, in 1982.  It was her first marriage, but it was the second marriage for Spiros, who had a daughter by an earlier marriage.  Spiros had previously lived in Australia and in 1983 the couple returned to Australia to live and remained in Australia thereafter. 

  4. Sprios’ brother George also lived in Adelaide.  The applicant, Peter Krinos, is the son of George and, thus, the nephew of Ms Krinas.  Spiros died in 2005.  The couple had no children.  Ms Krinas has no siblings.  The evidence is that Ms Krinas’ mother has died.  It is not known whether her father is still alive.  He lived in Greece.  It is believed that he has died as well, but there is no conclusive evidence as to that fact.

  5. Upon moving to Adelaide Ms Krinas and Spiros socialised regularly with George and his…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read In the Matter of Assimina Krinas and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] SASC 9
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Supreme Court of South Australia, Mr Peter Krinas applied for an order authorising the making of a statutory will on behalf of his aunt, Ms Assimina Krinas, who lacks testamentary capacity due to advanced neurological disease. The application was not opposed. The legal issues before the court were whether Ms Krinas lacked testamentary capacity, whether the proposed will accurately reflected her likely intentions, whether the proposed order was reasonable in the circumstances, and whether the order of the Guardianship Board prevented the making of a statutory will. The court found that Ms Krinas lacked testamentary capacity due to her medical condition and that the proposed will accurately reflected her likely intentions based on evidence of her wishes and the interests of relevant parties. The court also found that the proposed order was reasonable in the circumstances and that the order of the Guardianship Board did not prevent the making of a statutory will. Permission to make the application was granted, and the application was approved. The court ordered that a will be made in specific terms approved by the court on behalf of Ms Krinas.

Orders

Orders of the court

permission to make application granted - application granted - person lacks testamentary capacity - proposed will accurately reflects likely intentions.

Background

Background to the litigation

These reasons deal with what was an urgent application for the making of a statutory will. An order was made on 25 January 2016 permitting the making of such a will.Background The application was made by Mr Peter Krinas, a nephew of Ms Assimina Krinas (“Ms Krinas”), the person for whom the will is to be made. The reason for the urgency of the matter was that Ms Krinas is suffering from advanced neurological disease. She has been in care at the Highgate Park Clinic since 2004 and is unable to communicate. She is in a vegetative state in palliative care. The medical evidence is that she has now entered the terminal phase of her disease and that she could die at any time. Ms Krinas married Spiros Krinas (“Spiros”) in Greece, in 1982. It was her first marriage, but it was the second marriage for Spiros, who had a daughter by an earlier marriage. Spiros had previously lived in Australia and in 1983 the couple returned to Australia to live and remained in Australia thereafter. Sprios’ brother George also lived in Adelaide. The applicant, Peter Krinos, is the son of George and, thus, the nephew of Ms Krinas. Spiros died in 2005. The couple had no children. Ms Krinas has no siblings. The evidence is that Ms Krinas’ mother has died. It is not known whether her father is still alive. He lived in Greece. It is believed that he has died as well, but there is no conclusive evidence as to that fact. Upon moving to Adelaide Ms Krinas and Spiros socialised regularly with George and his family. Ms Krinas had limited English and it appears that she mainly socialised within the Greek community in Adelaide. It also appears she has had almost no contact with Spiros’ daughter. After the death of Spiros, George and his family regularly visited Ms Krinas at her care facility. They took her out on day excursions. That continued until about 2012. By that time Ms Krinas’ health had deteriorated to such an extent she was no longer able to communicate. The visits from George and his family continued, but were less frequent thereafter. The making of a statutory will The Court’s jurisdiction to make a statutory will is found in s 7 of the Wills Act 1936 (SA), which provides as follows:7—Will of person lacking testamentary capacity pursuant to permission of court(1)The Court may, on application by any person made with the permission of the Court, make an order authorising the making or alteration of a will in specific terms approved by the Court, or the revocation of a will, on behalf of a person who lacks testamentary capacity.(2)An authorisation under this section may be granted on such conditions as the Court thinks fit.(3)Before making an order under this section, the Court must be satisfied that—(a)the person lacks testamentary capacity; and(b)the proposed will, alteration or revocation would accurately reflect the likely intentions of the person if he or she had testamentary capacity; and(c)it is reasonable in all the circumstances that the order should be made.(4)In considering an application for an order under this section, the Court must take into account the following matters:(a)any evidence relating to the wishes of the person;(b)the likelihood of the person acquiring or regaining testamentary capacity;(c)the terms of any will previously made by the person;(d)the interests of—(i)the beneficiaries under any will previously made by the person;(ii)any person who would be entitled to receive any part of the estate of the person if the person were to die intestate;(iii)any person who would be entitled to claim the benefit of the Inheritance (Family Provision) Act 1972 in relation to the estate of the person if the person were to die;(iv)any other person who has cared for or provided emotional support to the person;(e)any gift for a charitable or other purpose the person might reasonably be expected to give by a will;(f)the likely size of the estate;(g)any other matter that the Court considers to be relevant.(5)An order may be made under this section in relation to a minor.(6)The Court is not bound by rules of evidence in proceedings under this section.(7)The following persons are entitled to appear and be heard at proceedings under this section:(a)the person in relation to whom the order is proposed to be made;(b)a legal practitioner representing the person or, with the permission of the Court, some other person representing the person;(c)the person holding or acting in the office of Public Advocate under the Guardianship and Administration Act 1993;(d)the person's administrator, if one has been appointed under the Guardianship and Administration Act 1993;(e)the person's guardian, if one has been appointed under the Guardianship and Administration Act 1993;(f)the person's manager, if one has been appointed under the Aged and Infirm Persons' Property Act 1940;(g)the person's attorney, if one has been appointed under an enduring power of attorney;(h)any other person who has, in the opinion of the Court, a proper interest in the matter.(8)In determining an application under this section, the Court may make such incidental orders relating to costs or other matters as it thinks fit.(9)A will or instrument altering or revoking a will made pursuant to an order under this section must be executed as follows:(a)it must be signed by the Registrar; and(b)it must be sealed with the seal of the Court.(10)The will or instrument altering or revoking a will must be retained by the Registrar and will be taken to have been deposited with the Registrar under section 13 of the Administration and Probate Act 1919.(11)The will may not be withdrawn from deposit with the Registrar by or on behalf of the person on whose behalf it was made unless the Court has made an order under this section authorising the revocation of the will (in which case the Registrar must withdraw it on presentation of a copy of the order) or the person has acquired or regained testamentary capacity.(12)In this section—testamentary capacity means the capacity to make a will1.Note—1The cause of incapacity to make a will may arise from mental incapacity or from physical incapacity to communicate testamentary intentions.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established