In the Matter of G, CL

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Testamentary Causes Jurisdiction: Application)

In the Matter of G, CL

[2015] SASC 80

Reasons for Decision of The Honourable Justice Gray

27 May 2015

SUCCESSION - MAKING OF A WILL - TESTAMENTARY CAPACITY - LOSS OR LACK OF CAPACITY AND STATUTORY WILLS

Application for making of a statutory will. CLG suffered a severe traumatic brain injury when she was seven years of age after a large brick column collapsed on top of her. A compromise of personal injury proceedings was approved by a Master in the District Court in 2012. As part of the compromise, a protection order was made and the Public Trustee was appointed litigation guardian and manager of the protected estate. CLG’s mother, JKM, the plaintiff in this action, applied for an order authorising the making of a statutory will pursuant to section 7 of the Wills Act 1936 (SA). CLG, her maternal half-siblings DOSM and EGM, and her father, MRG, were joined as defendants to the action. The main issue in dispute between the parties was the relationship between CLG and her father MRG, including the length of time MRG had lived with CLG and JKM, and why MRG ceased to have contact with CLG. The guardian ad litem appointed for CLG put forward a proposed will. JKM and the guardian ad litem for DOSM and EGM supported the terms of the proposed will but MRG did not.

Whether CLG lacks testamentary capacity.  Whether CLG’s likely testamentary intentions accord with the proposed will.  Whether the making of a will in the proposed terms is reasonable in the circumstances:

Held per Gray J (allowing the application):

1.  CLG lacks testamentary capacity.

2. The will proposed by CLG’s guardian ad litem does not reflect CLG’s likely testamentary intentions based on her present and likely future relationships with particular members of her family.

3.  The making of a will in the terms proposed in these reasons reflects CLG’s likely testamentary intentions and is reasonable in all the circumstances.

Aged and Infirm Persons’ Property Act 1940 (SA) s 8A; Wills Act 1936 (SA) s 7; Probate Rules 1997 (SA) r 98, referred to.
Re W, DJ [2015] SASC 45; In the Matter of Shaun Arthur Pickles [2013] SASC 175; In the Matter of Rak [2009] SASC 288; Re Brown [2009] SASC 345; In the Matter of De Jager [2012] SASC 236, considered.

In the Matter of G, CL
[2015] SASC 80

Testamentary Causes Jurisdiction

GRAY J.

  1. This is an application for the making of a statutory will.

  2. The defendant, CLG, was born on 1 October 2001.  She suffered a severe traumatic brain injury when she was about seven years of age after a large brick column collapsed on top of her.  The injury resulted in a profound disability affecting gross and fine motor skills, cognition and communication.  CLG is fed via a tube and is confined to a wheelchair.  She is unable to mobilise herself and, except for some varied…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read In the Matter of G, CL and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] SASC 80
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of CLG, a young girl who lacked testamentary capacity, the court was tasked with determining the appropriate distribution of her estate. The primary issue was whether the draft statutory will accurately reflected CLG's likely testamentary intentions. Counsel for JKM, CLG's mother, raised concerns that the estate might diminish in value, potentially resulting in the family home becoming the only asset of significant worth. This scenario could force JKM to liquidate the estate to pay off other beneficiaries, including MRG, to remain in the family home. The court noted that any material change in circumstances would require revisiting the court to apply for a codicil or further statutory will.

The court found that the will annexed to its reasons appropriately represented CLG's likely testamentary intentions if she had testamentary capacity. The court was satisfied that the proposed distribution of the residuary estate was fair and just, with 50% going to JKM, 20% to MRG, and the remaining 30% divided among CLG's maternal grandparents and half-siblings. The court emphasized that intestacy should be avoided and granted an order authorizing the making of the statutory will. However, JKM was not satisfied with the option to purchase the family home instead of receiving it outright. The court clarified that if there were significant changes in the estate's value, the parties could return to court for further orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

GRAY J
On 13 May 2015, prior to making an order authorising the making of the statutory will, I asked the parties whether they agreed with the revised terms of the draft will. Counsel for JKM expressed concern that the estate may diminish in value to such an extent that the family home became the only asset of value. This would result in a situation where JKM would need to pay out the entitlements of other beneficiaries, including MRG, in order to remain in the family home. I noted that this would be a material change in circumstance and would need to be dealt with by returning to Court to apply for the making of a codicil or further statutory will. No other issues were raised. Conclusion I am satisfied that the will annexed to these reasons accurately reflects CLG’s likely testamentary intentions if she had testamentary capacity. I believe it is desirable for an order to be granted authorising the making of the statutory will as intestacy should be avoided in these circumstances. The will that I am prepared to direct the Registrar to sign divides the residuary estate as follows; 50 per cent to JKM, and if she predeceases, 25 per cent to CLG’s maternal grandparents and 25 per cent to CLG’s maternal half-siblings; 20 per cent to MRG, or his children if he predeceases; 10 per cent to CLG’s maternal grandparents; and 20 per cent to CLG’s maternal half-siblings in equal shares, to be held on trust until they attain 25 years of age. I note that all parties, including CLG’s guardian ad litem, are comfortable with the division of the residuary estate but that JKM is not content with the option to purchase the family home in the alternative to the outright gift. It should be understood that if there is a material change in circumstances, such as the value of the estate greatly diminishing over CLG’s life, the parties could approach the Court again for further orders. SCHEDULETHIS IS THE LAST WILL of me CLG of [address] in the State of South Australia authorised by an Order dated the Thirteenth day of May 2015 made under Section 7 of the Wills Act 1936.1.I REVOKE all former wills and testamentary dispositions previously made by me.2.(a) I APPOINT PUBLIC TRUSTEE of 211 Victoria Square Adelaide in the said State to be the sole executor and trustee of this my will.(b)I DECLARE that the expression "my trustee" in my will and in any and every codicil hereto shall mean the trustee or trustees for the time being whether original or substituted.3.I GIVE the sum of ONE HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS ($100,000.00) to the Women’s and Children’s Hospital Foundation Inc Adelaide South Australia AND I EXPRESS THE WISH that that sum be applied towards funding a home visiting programme in the rehabilitation unit of the Women’s and Children’s Hospital Adelaide and I DECLARE that the receipt of the treasurer or other officer of such Foundation shall be a full and sufficient discharge to my trustee who shall not be liable to see to the application of such sum.4.(a) I GIVE all my books toys television sets computers compact disks digital video disks and jewellery to such of them my brother DOSM and my sister EGM as shall be living at my death and if both then in equal shares absolutely.(b)IN the event that any brother or sister of mine shall be under the age of eighteen years at my death then I EMPOWER my trustee to deliver their share of the items referred to in sub-clause 4(a) to their parent or guardian for the time being and I DIRECT that the receipt of such parent or guardian shall be a full and sufficient discharge to my trustee who shall not be bound to see the application of the benefit hereby conferred.5.SUBJECT to clause 4(a) of this my will I GIVE all my household furniture and effects my items of personal wear use and adornment and articles of domestic household use or ornament including any motor car to my mother JKM (hereinafter referred to as “my mother”) absolutely if she shall survive me by the period of twenty eight days but if she fails to survive me by that period then I DIRECT my trustee to hold the same upon the trusts declared by the provisions of clause 6(c) of this my will.6.I GIVE all the rest of my estate to my trustee to pay thereout my debts and funeral and testamentary expenses and to hold the balance then remaining (“my residuary estate”) upon the following trusts namely:-(a)As to FIFTY PER CENT (50%) thereof for my mother if she survives me by the period of twenty eight days but if she fails to survive me by that period then:-(i) As to half thereof upon the trusts declared by the provisions of clause 6(c) of this my will; and(ii) As to the remaining half thereof upon the trusts declared by the provisions of clause 6(d) of this my will.(b)As to TWENTY PER CENT (20%) for my father MRG if he survives me but if he predeceases me then upon trust for such of them his children CJG and ACG and any further child or children of my father MRG hereinafter born as shall be living at my death and shall attain or shall have attained the age of twenty five years and if more than one then in equal shares absolutely.(c)As to TWENTY PER CENT (20%) thereof for such of them my brother the said DOSM and my sister the said EGM and any further child or children of my mother JKM hereinafter born as shall be living at my death and shall attain or shall have attained the age of twenty five years and if more than one then in equal shares between them.(d)As to the remaining TEN PER CENT (10%) thereof for such of them my grandmother GCAM and my grandfather BDM as shall be living at my death and if both then in equal shares absolutely PROVIDED HOWEVER if both of my said grandparents predecease me then upon the trust declared by the provisions of clause 6(c) of this my will.7.IF any brother or sister of mine predeceases me or survives me but dies before attaining the age of twenty five years and in either event leaves a child or children who shall be living at my death or at the death of such deceased brother or sister of mine (which ever happens later) and shall attain or shall have attained the age of twenty five years then I DECLARE that the said child or children shall take and if more than one then in equal shares between them all the benefit share and interest in my estate which their his or her parent would have taken if such parent had survived me and attained the age of twenty five years.8.IF no beneficiary lives to attain a vested interest in any part of my estate pursuant to the previous provisions of this my will then I DIRECT my trustee to hold such part of my estate UPON TRUST for such of them my aunts ARG and CMW and my uncle JDM as shall be living at my death and if more than one then in equal shares between them.9.IF any of my said aunts or uncle predeceases me leaving a child or children who shall be living at my death and who shall attain or shall have attained the age of twenty five years then I DIRECT that such child or children shall take and if more than one then in equal shares all the benefit share and interest in my residuary estate which their his or her parent would have taken had such parent survived me.10.I EMPOWER my trustee:-(a)To apply the whole or any part of the contingent or vested share in the capital and income of my estate of any beneficiary of this my will under the age of twenty five years towards the maintenance education or advancement in life or generally for the benefit of such beneficiary and I further empower my trustee at their discretion to make such payments to the guardian for the time being of such beneficiary or to any person with whom such beneficiary may be living without being in any way answerable for the application thereof.(b)At such time or times as my trustee shall think fit and in such manner and upon such terms and conditions as my trustee shall think fit to sell call in or convert into money any part or parts of my estate which shall not consist of money.(c)To appropriate any part or parts of my estate in or towards the satisfaction of the share or interest of any beneficiary in my estate and for such purpose to determine the value or values of any asset or assets to be so appropriated.(d)To retain in the same state of investment any property held by me at the date of my death notwithstanding that the same may be of a wasting speculative or reversionary nature and I declare that my trustee shall not be liable for any loss occasioned by retaining the said investments under the power herein contained.(e)To determine in the absolute discretion of my trustee (in the event of my trustee disposing of or being deemed to have disposed of an asset) what part or parts of the capital or income of my trust estate will be resorted to in payment of any income tax liability flowing from the disposal or deemed disposal.(f)From time to time to lease or let all or any part of the real or leasehold property forming part of my estate and remaining unsold either from year to year or for any period not exceeding three years at the best rent to be obtained therefor and in their absolute discretion to manage and superintend the management of such real or leasehold property and generally to deal therewith in a proper and due course of management as if beneficially entitled thereto.11.In the event that following my death the trustee of any superannuation fund of which I am a member has a discretion as to the distribution of any superannuation held on my behalf then I EXPRESS the deepest desire that my superannuation is paid to the trustee of my Will to be distributed pursuant to the terms of my Will.12.NOTWITHSTANDING the previous provisions of my will I DIRECT my trustee to offer to sell all of my estate and interest in my house property located at [insert] (“ my house property”) to my mother JKM (hereinafter called "the purchaser") if the purchaser shall be living at my death and I DECLARE that the following conditions shall apply to the said offer:-(a)The price at which the house property shall be offered shall be equivalent to the value placed thereon by an independent valuer to be appointed by my trustee and such valuation is to be at the expense of my estate.(b)The said offer shall be personal to the purchaser and shall lapse should she die before accepting the same.(c)The offer shall be communicated in writing by my trustee to the purchaser as soon as conveniently may be after the property shall have been valued as aforesaid.(d)The offer shall be accepted by the purchaser by notice in writing delivered to my trustee within one calendar month after the communication of the offer to the purchaser and in the event of the offer not being accepted by the purchaser within that period then the offer shall be deemed to have been declined.(e)In the event of the purchaser accepting the offer then settlement shall be held three calendar months after the acceptance of the offer and at settlement the purchaser shall be entitled to vacant possession of the property.(f)All rates and taxes and other outgoings shall be adjusted as at the date of settlement.(g)All income (if any) derived in respect of the house property until the date of settlement shall belong to my estate.(h)My trustee may (if my trustee thinks fit) permit the whole or any part of the purchase price of the house property to be met from the amount of the benefit to which the purchaser shall be entitled from my estate.(i)The purchaser shall be entitled to purchase the property notwithstanding that the purchaser may be acting as an executor and trustee of this my will.(j)If at the date of my death the purchaser shall be residing at the house property as the purchaser’s principal place of residence then the purchaser shall be entitled to continue to reside in the house property rent free until the said offer shall be declined by the purchaser or if accepted then until the date of the payment of the full purchase price for the property as determined by the provisions of clause 12(e) of this my will.DATED the day of 2015 Registrar of

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GRAY J

Full text does not contain this section.