Hardie Finance Corporation Pty Ltd v Ahern [No 3]

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   HARDIE FINANCE CORPORATION PTY LTD -v- AHERN [No 3] [2010] WASC 403

CORAM:   PRITCHARD J

HEARD:   15 JUNE - 2 JULY & 20­23 JULY 2010

DELIVERED          :   22 DECEMBER 2010

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1426 of 2000

BETWEEN:   HARDIE FINANCE CORPORATION PTY LTD

Plaintiff

AND

MARCUS AHERN
First Defendant

FERGUSON CORPORATION PTY LTD
Second Defendant

Catchwords:

Joint tortfeasors - Joint purpose and concerted action

Trespass - Trespass to land - Implied consent to entry - Purported right to enter pursuant to a Romalpa clause

Trespass - Trespass to goods

Trespass - Conversion of goods

Trespass - Apology - Relevance of published apology and settlement deed to liability for trespass

Negligence - Duty of care - Duty to take reasonable care not to cause economic loss to plaintiff

Negligence - Duty of care - Duty of care not to cause economic loss to plaintiff - Vulnerability of plaintiff

Economic torts - Tort of causing loss by unlawful means - Existence of the tort in Australian common law

Legislation:

Chattel Securities Act 1987 (WA)
Fair Trading Act 1987 (WA)
Sale of Goods Act 1895 (WA)
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)

Result:

Action dismissed

Category:    A

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:     Mr M L Bennett

First Defendant             :     Mr D R Williams QC & Mr G K Macnish

Second Defendant         :     Mr D R Williams QC & Mr G K Macnish

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:     Lavan Legal

First Defendant             :     Cocks Macnish

Second Defendant         :     Cocks Macnish

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Alleslev-Krofchak v Valcom Limited (Unreported, Court of Appeal for Ontario, 24 August 2010)

Allstate Life Insurance Co v Australia & New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (1995) 58 FCR 26

Aluminium Industrie Vaassen BV v Romalpa Aluminium Ltd [1976] 1 WLR 676

Ansett Transport Industries (Operations) Pty Ltd v Australian Federation of Air Pilots [1991] 1 VR 637

Banco de Portugal v Waterlow & Sons Ltd [1932] AC 452

Barker v The Queen (1983) 153 CLR 338

Beaudesert Shire Council v Smith (1966) 120 CLR 145

Bennett v Minister of Community Welfare (1992) 176 CLR 408

Bonnington Castings Ltd v Wardlaw [1956] AC 613

Brodie v Singleton Shire Council (2001) 206 CLR 512

Bryan v Maloney (1995) 182 CLR 609 618

Burns v MAN Automotive (Aust) Pty Ltd (1986) 161 CLR 653

Byrne v Kinematograph Renters Society Ltd [1958] 1 WLR 762

Caltex Oil (Australia) Pty Ltd v The Dredge 'Willemstad' (1976) 136 CLR 529

Canberra Data Centres Pty Ltd v Vibe Constructions (ACT) Pty Ltd [2010] ACTSC 20

CBS Songs Ltd v Amstrad Consumer Electronics Plc [1988] AC 1013

Chappel v Hart (1998) 195 CLR 232

Coco v The Queen (1994) 179 CLR 427

Correia v Canac Kitchens (2008) 91 OR (3d) 353

Credit Lyonnais Bank Nederland NV v Export Credit Guarantee Department [1998] 1 Lloyd's Rep 19

Crimmins v Stevedoring Industry Finance Committee (1999) 200 CLR 1

Cuff v Broadlands Finance Ltd [1987] 2 NZLR 343

DC Thomson & Co Ltd v Deakin [1952] Ch…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hardie Finance Corporation Pty Ltd v Ahern [No 3] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] WASC 403
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Hardie Finance Corporation Pty Ltd v Ahern [No 3] involved Hardie Finance Corporation (HFC) suing several defendants for trespass and conversion of goods, as well as for causing economic loss by unlawful means. The defendants included individuals and companies associated with Pac-Am, a company that went into administration and subsequently deregistered. The dispute arose from events surrounding the management of a property known as the Piazza, which Pac-Am had leased from HFC. The central issue in the case was whether the defendants owed a duty of care to HFC to prevent economic loss, and whether they breached this duty or caused such loss through unlawful means.

The court was tasked with determining if the defendants owed HFC a duty of care not to cause economic loss, and if so, whether this duty was breached and if such a breach caused the claimed damages. Additionally, the court had to assess whether the defendants committed the tort of causing loss by unlawful means, a tort whose existence in Australian common law was also in question. The court needed to consider whether the defendants' actions constituted a trespass to land and goods, and if their purported right to enter under a Romalpa clause could serve as a defence. The relevance of a published apology and a settlement deed in relation to the liability for trespass was another point of contention.

The court concluded that HFC failed to prove that the defendants owed it a duty of care to prevent economic loss, or that such a duty, if it existed, was breached. The court found no evidence that the defendants caused economic loss to HFC by unlawful means. The court also noted that HFC did not establish that the defendants had trespassed to land or goods, nor did it prove that the defendants' actions were unlawful. The court's reasoning was based on the lack of a demonstrable duty of care in the context of economic loss, and the absence of clear evidence linking the defendants' actions to the specific economic damages claimed by HFC. Consequently, the court did not find it necessary to assess damages, as HFC's claims were dismissed on the balance of probabilities.

Given the findings, the court will hear the parties to determine the appropriate orders in light of its decision. HFC's claims for trespass, conversion, and causing loss by unlawful means were dismissed, and no damages were awarded. The court's decision effectively closed the legal battle between HFC and the defendants, with the terms of any further orders to be determined in subsequent proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Factual background It is convenient to begin by briefly identifying the parties to the proceedings, the persons who were the primary participants in the events giving rise to the proceedings, and those who gave evidence in the proceedings. HFC was incorporated in August 1981. Mr Graham Hardie has been a director of HFC since its incorporation and he has been the secretary of the company since 10 January 2002. Mr Terry Pilbeam was employed as a property manager for HFC from mid‑1991 until August 1998, and again from February 2000 until October 2005. In that role he was responsible for the management of the Piazza. Pac-Am was incorporated on 4 April 1997. It was established with an initial shareholding of one ordinary $1 share, which was beneficially owned by Mr Hin Wee Khoo (Mr HW Khoo). Mr HW Khoo was a director of Pac-Am from its incorporation until 4 March 1998. Mr Hin Hiong Khoo (Mr HH Khoo) was a director of Pac-Am from 13 January 1998 until 30 January 2007. Mr HH Khoo was Mr HW Khoo's brother. Mr Subramani Krishnamoorthy was a director of Pac-Am from 13 January 1998 until 30 January 2007. Mr Mark Kim Hock See was a director and company secretary of Pac‑Am from 4 March 1998 until 12 October 1998. Mr Krishnamoorthy and Mr Dato Ronald Khoo ( Mr DR Khoo) were investors in Pac‑Am. Mr HH Khoo also invested funds in Pac-Am, although to a lesser extent. Pac-Am went into administration on 5 July 1999. Mr Glenn Featherby and Mr Mark Reilly of Featherby Reilly Chartered Accountants were appointed the administrators of Pac-Am until 28 September 1999 when they were appointed the liquidators of the company. They ceased that appointment on 30 January 2007, when Pac-Am was deregistered. Mr Giovanni Carrello was appointed a receiver and manager of Pac‑Am on 15 July 1999 and acted in that capacity until 10 January 2003. The Spageddies Italian Kitchen restaurant chain was established in the United States by Brinker International Inc (Brinker), an American company. Pac-Am Food Concepts (PAFC) was a holding company based in the British Virgin Islands. Mr HH Khoo was the Chairman of PAFC from its incorporation. Brinker sold the worldwide franchise rights for Spageddies to PAFC in the early 1990s. Brinker subsequently acquired a 25% interest in PAFC. In about August 1993, PAFC formed a subsidiary company, Pac-Am Restaurants (S) Pte Ltd (Pac-Am Singapore), to operate Spageddies in Singapore. Pac-Am Singapore was described by Mr HH Khoo as a 'joint venture company' between three other companies, Dinervest Investments Pte Ltd (a subsidiary of Singapore Technologies, which was a company incorporated in Singapore and owned by the Singaporean Government), Nations Corp Ltd and Brinker. Mr HH Khoo was the Chairman of Pac‑Am Singapore from its incorporation. In March 1995, PAFC and Pac-Am Singapore opened the first Spageddies Italian Kitchen restaurant in Singapore, in the Tanglin Mall. It subsequently opened a second Spageddies Italian Kitchen restaurant at the Marina Megaplex.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Conclusion HFC has not established, on the balance of probabilities, that the defendants owed it a duty of care not to cause it economic loss, that there was a breach of that duty, or that any such breach caused the loss and damage HFC claims. The defendants did not establish that HFC failed to mitigate its loss. HFC has also not established, on the balance of probabilities, that the defendants committed the tort of causing loss by unlawful means. Had it been necessary to do so, I would have assessed damages in the sum of $1,090,026.35, together with interest from 21 March 1998 until the date of judgment pursuant to s 32 of the Supreme Court Act. However, in light of my other conclusions, I make no such order. I will hear the parties on the terms of the orders which should be made in view of my reasons for decision.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established