Gandini v Paterson and Dowding

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

JURISDICTION     :   DISTRICT COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

LOCATION:   PERTH

CITATION:   GANDINI -v- PATERSON & DOWDING [2012] WADC 13

CORAM:   DEPUTY REGISTRAR HEWITT

HEARD:   25 JANUARY 2012

DELIVERED          :   14 FEBRUARY 2012

FILE NO/S:   CIV 2648 of 2010

BETWEEN:   LEONARD GANDINI

Plaintiff

AND

PATERSON & DOWDING
Defendant

Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - Application to strike out - Solicitor's duty of care to third party

Legislation:

Nil

Result:

Statement of claim struck out  

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:     Not applicable

Defendant:     Mr S F Popperwell

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:     In person

Defendant:     Pynt & Partners

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Hardie Finance Corporation Pty Ltd v Ahern [No. 3] [2010] WASC 403

Hawkins v Clayton (1988) 164 CLR 539

Hill v Van Erp (1997) 188 CLR 159

Tobin v Dodd [2004] WASCA 288

White v Jones [1995] 2 AC 207

  1. DEPUTY REGISTRAR HEWITT:  In this matter the defendant has applied to strike out the plaintiff's statement of claim.  The basis of that application is that the facts and circumstances pleaded in this statement of claim are incapable of giving rise to the duty care relied upon by the plaintiff for the relief sought.

  2. By way of a brief overview the plaintiff was in 2004 embroiled in proceedings in the Family Court of Western Australia between himself and his former wife Colleen Marie Gandini.  It is relevantly pleaded in par 2 and par 3 in the statement of claim as follows:

    In or about March 2004, the Plaintiff's wife, Colleen Marie Gandini ('Mrs Gandini') instructed and retained Paterson & Dowding to advise her and to act as her solicitors in proceedings in the Family Court of Western Australia ('Family Court') between her and the Plaintiff involving property settlement ('the Gandini Proceedings') and on all matters on which she might require legal advice incidental thereto ('the Gandini Retainer').

    At all material times, Paterson & Dowding owed Mrs Gandini and the Plaintiff a duty to exercise due care, skill and diligence expected of a reasonably competent solicitor in carrying out the Gandini Retainer.

  3. It is further pleaded in par 9 and par 10 as follows:

    In March 2005, Mrs Gandini engaged Paterson & Dowding to provide her with legal advice, and to act as her solicitors, in relation to the Woolven Proceedings ('the Woolven Retainer').

    At all material times, Paterson & Dowding owed Mrs Gandini and the Plaintiff a duty to exercise due care, skill and diligence expected of a reasonably competent solicitor in carrying out the Woolven Retainer.

  4. The circumstances which give rise to the plaintiff's claim arise initially in November 2004 when the plaintiff entered a contract with one Woolven to sell property at and known as 33A Mitchell Street, Ardross.  The matters giving rise to the claim concern dealings with that property in the Family Court which are set out in pars 5, 6, 7 and 8 of the statement of claim which are as follows:

    5.Between November and December 2004, with the knowledge that the Plaintiff had entered into the Contract with…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gandini v Paterson and Dowding and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] WADC 13
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Gandini v Paterson and Dowding, the plaintiff, Mr Gandini, brought an application to strike out the defendant's defence. The defendants, solicitors, had been retained by Mr Gandini’s ex-wife to represent her in proceedings against him. Mr Gandini argued that the solicitors owed him a duty of care to perform their retainer with due care, skill and diligence. The defendants denied this claim and sought to have the matter dismissed for want of jurisdiction. The court was required to determine whether the solicitors owed a duty of care to Mr Gandini in relation to their retainer with his ex-wife.

The court examined the nature of the retainer and the relationship between the parties. The court found that the retainer was intended solely for the benefit of Mr Gandini’s ex-wife, and that any duty of care owed by the solicitors was owed to her, not to Mr Gandini. The court held that the interests of Mr Gandini and his ex-wife were not coincident, and that it would be impossible for the solicitors to properly carry out their duties under the terms of their retainer to Mrs Gandini if they were required to also owe a duty of care to Mr Gandini. The court concluded that there was no basis upon which the solicitors could owe a duty of care to Mr Gandini.

Accordingly, the court granted the application to strike out the defence and dismissed the proceedings for want of jurisdiction. The court found that the pleading did not disclose any cause of action against the defendants. The court also noted that there appeared to be no precedent for a duty of care being owed in circumstances such as those alleged by Mr Gandini.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In a recent case of Hardie Finance Corporation Pty Ltd v Ahern [No. 3] [2010] WASC 403 Justice Pritchard concluded that the defendant, a solicitor who had negligently instructed a client as to its rights and repossession under a romalpa clause, owed no duty of care to the party from whom repossession was taken nor to those in a contractual relationship with that party who might damaged by the repossession. At [452] Justice Pritchard said:Although I have found that it was reasonably foreseeable that FC's creditors would suffer financial loss if Mr Ahern negligently provided advice to FC in relation to its conduct of the Repossession, the salient features of this case weigh heavily against the conclusion that any duty of care was owed by Mr Ahern to FC. Prior to the Repossession, Mr Ahern had no actual or constructive knowledge that Pac-Am leased the Premises from HFC. In addition, this is a case where (but for the expiry of the limitation period) a finding of a duty of care to HFC would have given rise to liability to an indeterminate class of plaintiffs. Further, HFC was not vulnerable to incurring loss if Mr Ahern negligently advised FC and that advice was acted upon by FC, and Mr Ahern did not exercise control in respect of any of HFC's rights, interests or expectations which might be affected if FC acted on his advice. At the same time, this is a case where the imposition of a duty of care would be inconsistent with Mr Ahern's duty to FC. All of the salient features of the case point to the conclusion that the relationship between Mr Ahern and HFC was not such as to warrant the imposition of a duty of care. Accordingly, in my view, Mr Ahern was no subject to a duty of care not to cause economic loss to HFC. None of the cases relied upon by the plaintiff even come close to establishing the duty of care which he claims existed and was owing by the defendants to him. To once again to recap, the pleading alleges that by the plaintiff's wife retaining the defendant to represent her in proceedings against the plaintiff there was created a duty of care to the plaintiff in those solicitors to perform their retainer with due care, skill and diligence. Likewise it is alleged that in retaining the defendant to act in the Woolven action there was likewise created a duty to the plaintiff to exercise due care, skill and diligence. I can see no basis upon which such a duty could possibly exist. In proceedings of the kind which have been outlined in the statement of claim, the interests of Mrs Gandini and the plaintiff were not coincident. It was not intended by her retainer of the defendant that Mr Gandini should benefit, quite the opposite and it appears to me that it would be impossible for the defendant to properly carry out their duties under the terms of their retainer to Mrs Gandini if indeed the duty of care which is alleged did exist. I think it is more than a coincidence that in the long history of the evolution of the tort at negligence there appears to be no case in which a duty such as that propounded by this plaintiff has been found to exist.