Civic Video Pty Ltd v Paterson [No 2]

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

CITATION:   CIVIC VIDEO PTY LTD -v- PATERSON [No 2] [2014] WASC 14

CORAM:   ACTING MASTER GETHING

HEARD:   15 JANUARY 2014

DELIVERED          :   22 JANUARY 2014

FILE NO/S:   CIV 2144 of 2008

BETWEEN:   CIVIC VIDEO PTY LTD (ACN 003 851 152)

Plaintiff

AND

ROBERT HENRY PATERSON
First Defendant

MALCOLM THOMPSON
Second Defendant

BARBARA THOMPSON
Third Defendant

Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - Further and better discovery

Legislation:

Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA), O 26

Result:

Limited further discovery ordered

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:     Mr D R Chandler

First Defendant             :     Mr L Hager

Second Defendant         :     No appearance

Third Defendant           :     No appearance

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:     Marque Lawyers

First Defendant             :     Metaxas & Hager

Second Defendant         :     Clifton Tham

Third Defendant           :     Clifton Tham

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University [2009] HCA 27; (2009) 239 CLR 175

Australian Railroad Group Pty Ltd v Rowan [2004] WASC 165

Beecham Group Ltd v Bristol Myers Co [1979] VR 273

British Association of Glass Bottle Manufacturers Ltd v Nettlefold [1912] AC 709

Chandler v Water Corporation [2004] WASC 95

Civic Video Pty Ltd v Paterson [2013] WASCA 107

Civic Video Pty Ltd v Paterson [2013] WASCA 107 (S)

Compagnie Financiere et Commerciale du Pacifique v Peruvian Guano Company (1882) 11 QBD 55

Daraja Ltd v Hogan & Partners Stockbrokers Pty Ltd [2012] WASC 256

Dowd v McCloskey [2005] WADC 99

Hardie Finance Corporation Pty Ltd v Ahern [No 3] [2010] WASC 403

Livingstone v Rawyards Coal Company (1880) 5 App Cas 25

Mann v Carnell [1999] HCA 66; (1999) 201 CLR 1

Mulley v Manifold [1959] HCA 23; (1959) 103 CLR 341

North Kalgurli Mines Pty Ltd v GRD Minproc Ltd [2002] WASC 275

Perpetual Trustees Company Ltd v Burniston [2012] WASC 26

Roe v The State of Western Australia [2013] WASC 130

Singh v Friedman [2013] WASC 78

Smith v Leveraged Equities Ltd [2011] WASC 282

Technomin Australia Pty Ltd v Xstrata Nickel Australasia Operations Pty Ltd [2010] WASC 218

Tremeer v City of Stirling [2002] WASCA 281

Youlden Enterprises Pty Ltd v Health Solutions (WA) Pty Ltd [2005] WASC 60

ACTING MASTER GETHING: 

Background

  1. Civic Video and Video Ezy are competitors in the business of operating stores which rent and sell movies in DVD and Blu‑ray format, and computer games, along with peripheral retail goods such as confectionary, drinks, mobile phone cards and promotional items.  Civic Video Pty Ltd (Civic), the plaintiff in the action, is the franchisor of the Civic Video stores.  Robert Paterson, the first defendant, and his family, own multiple Video Ezy franchises in Western Australia.

  2. In September 2006 Mr Paterson purchased the assets of two Civic Video franchises operating in Geraldton, one at Durlacher Street and the other on North West Coastal Highway (which I will refer to as the Durlacher store and the Highway store respectively).  The vendors were Malcolm and Barbara Thompson, who are…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Civic Video Pty Ltd v Paterson [No 2] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] WASC 14
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Civic Video Pty Ltd sought further and better discovery against Paterson in the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The application was for additional documents that Civic Video believed were relevant to the proceedings but had not been disclosed by Paterson. The central issues were whether certain financial statements, general ledgers, and performance reports were relevant and whether they should be discovered.

The court needed to determine if Civic's financial statements and general ledgers for specified years were relevant documents, as well as whether specific performance reports for certain stores were relevant. It was undisputed that these documents existed, but their relevance and the court's discretion in ordering their disclosure were in question. The court examined the three sources of power to order further discovery, including the inherent jurisdiction and the specific provision in RSC O 26 r 6. The primary requirements for ordering further discovery were that the documents must exist, be relevant, and should have been disclosed.

The court found that some of the documents were relevant, as they pertained directly to the financial and operational aspects of the case. However, the exercise of discretion led the court to conclude that not all relevant documents should be discovered, as some were not necessary for the fair resolution of the proceedings. The court considered the balance between the need for full disclosure and the potential prejudice to the opposing party.

The final orders included directions for Paterson to disclose certain financial documents and performance reports, while some other documents were deemed not necessary for disclosure. The court emphasised the importance of relevance and discretion in the discovery process, ensuring that the interests of both parties were protected.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The second source of power to make orders where there has been a deficiency in discovery is the inherent jurisdiction of the Supreme Court: Technomin Australia Pty Ltd v Xstrata Nickel Australasia Operations Pty Ltd [2010] WASC 218 [3] ‑ [5] (Murphy JA); Chandler [16]. The court's inherent jurisdiction is not modified by the power in RSC O 26 r 6: Technomin [5]; Chandler [16]. A limitation on this power is that the deficiency cannot be demonstrated by a contentious affidavit from the party seeking to challenge the discovery: Technomin [4]; Chandler [17]. The third source of power to make orders where there has been a deficiency in discovery is RSC O 26 r 6. This was introduced to modify the rules which apply in the inherent jurisdiction, in particular to allow a challenge to discovery based on a contentious affidavit seeking discovery of particular documents, or a particular class of documents: Technomin [4]; Mulley v Manifold [1959] HCA 23; (1959) 103 CLR 341, 343 (Menzies J). The power in RCS O 26 r 6(1) is that:[T]he Court may at any time, on the application of any party to a cause or matter, make an order requiring any other party to make an affidavit stating whether any document specified or described in the application or any class of document specified or described is, or has at any time been, in his possession custody or power, and if not then in his possession custody or power when he parted with it and what has become of it. Whichever of the three sources of power is relied upon, there are three primary requirements which the applicant must satisfy, namely that:(a)the court has reasonable grounds for being fairly certain that the documents sought (or class of documents sought) are in existence;(b)those documents sought are relevant; and(c)those documents ought to have been disclosed.Perpetual Trustees [29]; Technomin [6]; Youlden Enterprises Pty Ltd v Health Solutions (WA) Pty Ltd [2005] WASC 60 [3] (Newnes M); Beecham Group Ltd v Bristol Myers Co [1979] VR 273, 276, 279 (Menhennitt J); British Association of Glass Bottle Manufacturers Ltd v Nettlefold [1912] AC 709, 714 (Viscount Haldane LC). In the present application, it is not in issue that there are documents in existence falling within the remaining classes of document identified above [11]. The issues for determination focus on relevance and discretion. Five issues thus arise for determination:1.Are Civic's financial statements and general ledger for each year for the periods ending 30 June 2001 to 30 June 2007 relevant documents (item 1)?2.Are the KPI/BART reports for the Civic Video stores in Albany, Carnarvon, Esperance, Malaga, Kalgoorlie (three stores), Greenwood, Applecross, Forrestfield and Armadale for the 2003 ‑ 2005 financial years relevant documents?3.Are the KPI/BART reports for the remaining Civic Video stores for the 2003 ‑ 2006 financial years relevant documents?4.Ought any relevant documents be discovered in the exercise of the court's discretion?5.What final orders are appropriate?