JURISDICTION : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
CITATION: DARAJA LTD -v- HOGAN & PARTNERS STOCKBROKERS PTY LTD [2012] WASC 256
CORAM: KENNETH MARTIN J
HEARD: ON THE PAPERS
DELIVERED : 13 JULY 2012
FILE NO/S: CIV 1550 of 2010
BETWEEN: DARAJA LTD
First Plaintiff
MARK JOHN MULLER
Second PlaintiffBRIAN WILLIAM BRIDGES
Third PlaintiffDELON GOTFRIED VAN ZYL
Fourth PlaintiffPAUL MACHIEL BERGH
Fifth PlaintiffAND
HOGAN & PARTNERS STOCKBROKERS PTY LTD
First DefendantJONATHON KUR
Second DefendantSECURITIES EXCHANGE GUARANTEE CORPORATION LTD
Third Defendant
Catchwords:
Practice and procedure - Application for further and better discovery - Third defendant - Guarantee fund - Tax returns sought - Foreign residents - No issues raised by pleadings - Serious misconduct - Fishing expedition - No basis in potential relevance of documents shown
Legislation:
Nil
Result:
Application refused
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
First Plaintiff : No appearance
Second Plaintiff : No appearance
Third Plaintiff : No appearance
Fourth Plaintiff : No appearance
Fifth Plaintiff : No appearance
First Defendant : No appearance
Second Defendant : No appearance
Third Defendant : No appearance
Solicitors:
First Plaintiff : Tottle Partners
Second Plaintiff : Tottle Partners
Third Plaintiff : Tottle Partners
Fourth Plaintiff : Tottle Partners
Fifth Plaintiff : Tottle Partners
First Defendant : DLA Piper Australia
Second Defendant : In person
Third Defendant : Clayton Utz
Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):
Armitage v Nurse [1998] Ch 241
Compagnie Financière du Pacifique v Peruvian Guano Co (1882) 11 QBD 55
Oldfield Knott Architects Pty Ltd v Ortiz Investments Pty Ltd [2000] WASCA 255
Technomin Australia Pty Ltd v Xstrata Nickel Australasia Operations Pty Ltd [2010] WASC 218
KENNETH MARTIN J: This application, determined on the papers, is the third defendant's application by chamber summons for discovery of particular documents and the provision of particulars.
On 24 May 2012 I ordered the plaintiffs to file any affidavit evidence in relation to the third defendant's chamber summons by 7 June 2012. I also ordered the third defendant to file and serve an outline of submissions and list of authorities in support of its application by 14 June 2012, with the plaintiffs to file their submissions and list of authorities in opposition by 28 June 2012.
A request for further particulars also made by the third defendant is no longer pressed save in respect of costs. On 15 June 2012, the plaintiffs provided answers to the third defendant's request for further and better particulars which had been made on 11 April 2012. The third defendant is satisfied with those answers.
The residual issue concerning the costs of the application as it relates to particulars raises the unappealing prospect of evaluating a dead argument to determine the merits of the third defendant's request for further and better particulars, with each side contending that it was in the right. For the third defendant's part, it says it has been vindicated by the eventual answers, which were filed only shortly before the third defendant was due to file its written submissions.…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Daraja Ltd v Hogan and Partners Stockbrokers Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] WASC 256
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to decide whether the plaintiffs' application for further and better discovery was justified. Specifically, the court had to determine whether the plaintiffs had demonstrated that the documents sought were potentially relevant to the issues in the case. The court also had to consider whether the plaintiffs' request was a fishing expedition, which would not be permitted.
The court found that the plaintiffs had not demonstrated that the documents sought were potentially relevant to the issues in the case. The court noted that the plaintiffs' request appeared to be a fishing expedition, and that there was no basis in the potential relevance of the documents sought. The court held that the plaintiffs' application for further and better discovery was not justified.
The court dismissed the plaintiffs' application for further and better discovery. The court also ordered the plaintiffs to pay the defendants' costs of the application.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The process of discovery, given its origins in the Court of Chancery, carries discretionary considerations: see Technomin Australia Pty Ltd v Xstrata Nickel Australasia Operations Pty Ltd [2010] WASC 218 [4] (Murphy JA). Moreover, since this is an action proceeding in the CMC List, this court's paramount objectives of efficiency, cost minimisation and proportionality, particularly against any prospect of unnecessary interlocutory disputation, are important surrounding policy considerations. To evaluate the potential relevance of the categories of documents sought, it is necessary to say something about the wider context of the present dispute, by reference to the parties' pleadings. In that regard, I refer to the plaintiffs' substituted statement of claim filed 12 December 2011 (SSOC) and the defence of the third defendant filed 3 February 2012. The background to the action essentially is a serious fraud perpetrated by the second defendant, Mr Kur, against the plaintiffs' funds held with the first defendant. Mr Kur, at relevant times, was an employee of the first defendant, which was a firm of stockbrokers operating out of Perth, Western Australia. Default judgment for an unliquidated amount was obtained by the plaintiffs against the second defendant on 24 May 2010. Hence Mr Kur has not been an active participant in proceedings. The third defendant was only recently added as a party to the action pursuant to my orders of 9 December 2011. In pars 23 ‑ 27 of the SSOC, which appear under the heading 'Kur's Fraud', the plaintiffs allege:23.From about December 2005, whenever necessary Kur applied funds which Hogans held on account of the second to fifth plaintiffs, alternatively the plaintiffs, to settle daily amounts due from Hogans to the Australian Stock Exchange in respect of losses which any clients of Hogans had incurred on that particular day.24.Notwithstanding that Kur applied funds as alleged in paragraph 23 above, between December 2005 and November 2008 Hogans sent monthly statements (the Monthly Statements) to the second to fifth plaintiffs, alternatively the plaintiffs, each of which:(a)falsely concealed the use of the funds as alleged;(b)falsely represented that the plaintiffs' capital had been preserved; and(c)falsely represented that each of the plaintiffs had earned a return on that capital.25.The second to fifth plaintiffs, alternatively the plaintiffs, relied upon the Monthly Statements which were sent to them by continuing to place funds with Hogans, and by not withdrawing the funds held on their behalf by Hogans.26.In December 2008:(a)the matters referred to in paragraph 23 were discovered by the principals of Hogans;(b)consequently, Kur ceased being employed by Hogans.27.On 30 January 2009, Hogans returned all of the funds which it then held on account of the second to fifth plaintiffs which totalled $205,626.32. (particulars omitted) (In the particulars to SSOC par 10(b), it is asserted that the first plaintiff, Daraja Ltd, placed $5,464,583.43 with the first defendant in a trading account in the period between May and December 2005, for purposes of trading. The second plaintiff, Mr Muller, is said to have placed $498,285 with the first defendant in the same period. The third plaintiff, Mr Bridges, is said to have placed $437,145.39 with the first defendant in the same period. Paragraph 19 alleges that further sums were placed with the first defendant by Mr Muller and Mr Bridges, in the amounts of $1,633,912.65 and $1,619,965.99 respectively.)