Gutierrez Martinez and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration) [2019] AATA 955 (20 May 2019)
Division:GENERAL DIVISION
File Number(s): 2019/1111
Re:Cesar Gutierrez Martinez
APPLICANT
AndMinister for Home Affairs
RESPONDENT
DECISION
Tribunal:Senior Member C Puplick AM
Date:20 May 2019
Place:Sydney
The Delegate’s reviewable decision of 22 February 2019 is set aside, and in substitution the 31 August 2017 decision to cancel the applicant’s Class BO, Subclass 115 (Remaining Relative) visa is revoked on the basis that there is “another reason” to do so.
..............................[sgd].................................
Senior Member C Puplick AM
CATCHWORDS
MIGRATION – whether to revoke the mandatory cancellation of a visa – applicant does not pass the character test – other reason to revoke cancellation – Ministerial Direction No. 79 – protection of the Australian community – risk of reoffending – expectation of the Australian community – best interests of minor children – when to consider non-refoulement obligations – Honduras – impediments to removal – genuine fear of consequences of return – strength of ties – impact on victims – domestic violence – decision set aside and substituted
LEGISLATION
Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 499, 500, 501 and 501CA
Crimes Act 1900 (NSW) s 61AA
CASES
Aciek and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration) [2018] AATA 2755
AFY18 v Minister for Home Affairs [2018] FCA 1566
Ahori v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] AATA 601
BFXK v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] AATA 886
Bochenski v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCAFC 68
CHFQ and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration) (2018) AATA 3858
Contreras v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCAFC 47
DFW18 v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCA 599
DKXY v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCA 495
Do and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] AATA 390
Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 46 FLR 409
FYBR v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCA 500
Goundar v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCA 1203
HZCP v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 1803
Jupp and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2002] AATA 458
LMYW and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration) [2016] AATA 936
Mendoza v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] AATA 686
Minister for Home Affairs v HSKJ [2018] FCAFC 217
Minister for Home Affairs v Sharma [2019] FCA 597
Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v BCR16 [2017] HCATrans 240
Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v BHA17 [2018] FCAFC 68
Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs v Gray (1994) 33 ALD 13
Murphy and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] AATA 750
Nevistic v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1981) 34 ALR 639
Omar v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCA 279
Rabino and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] AATA 999
Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No.2) (1979) 2 ALD 634
Re ER Aston and Y Aston and…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Gutierrez Martinez and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] AATA 955
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the AAT were how to interpret and apply Ministerial Direction No. 79, particularly concerning the weight to be given to the "expectations of the Australian community" as a primary consideration. The AAT had to assess whether these expectations invariably weighed against revocation, or if they could, in certain circumstances, support revocation. The Tribunal also considered the interplay between the primary considerations and other relevant factors, including the applicant's genuine fear of returning to Honduras, impediments to removal, the best interests of minor children, and non-refoulement obligations.
The AAT, referencing previous judicial interpretations, clarified that the "expectations of the Australian community" are not always a consideration that weighs against revocation. Instead, decision-makers must give "due regard" to government views on community expectations while also considering all other relevant circumstances of the particular case. The Tribunal found that while the applicant's conduct was serious and the Ministerial Direction imposed strictures, the factors favouring revocation, specifically the applicant's genuine fears regarding return to Honduras and the impediments to removal, outweighed the factors against revocation.
Consequently, the AAT set aside the Delegate's decision of 22 February 2019 and substituted a decision to revoke the cancellation of the applicant's visa, finding that there was "another reason" to do so.
Background
Background to the litigation
The applicant's circumstances included a history of domestic violence, which affected her ability to reoffend and placed her at risk of harm in Honduras. She also had two minor children in Australia who would be adversely affected if she were removed. The Tribunal considered these factors alongside the applicant’s criminal history and the Ministerial Direction's provisions. The Tribunal also weighed the applicant's genuine fear of returning to Honduras due to potential consequences of her past activities and the impediments to her removal from Australia, including the impact on her children and her non-refoulement obligations.
Despite the seriousness of the applicant’s criminal conduct, the Tribunal found that her genuine fears about returning to Honduras and the potential harm to her children outweighed the considerations against revoking the cancellation of her visa. The Tribunal determined that the applicant’s case presented compelling circumstances that warranted the revocation of the visa cancellation decision, setting aside the Delegate’s decision and substituting it with a decision to revoke the original cancellation.
The matter before the court involved a challenge to the decision of the Minister for Home Affairs to cancel the visa of the applicant, Gutierrez Martinez, under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). The applicant's visa was subject to mandatory cancellation due to failing the character test, as outlined in Ministerial Direction No. 79. The Tribunal was tasked with reviewing the Delegate’s decision dated 22 February 2019, which upheld the mandatory cancellation of the applicant's visa. This review followed an application by the applicant for the Tribunal to revoke the cancellation decision under section 364B of the Migration Act. The application was based on the existence of "another reason" to revoke the cancellation, as permitted by section 364BA of the Act. The proceedings were initiated in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT), and the decision under review had been previously determined in the Federal Circuit Court, which affirmed the Minister's decision to uphold the visa cancellation. The Tribunal considered the relevant provisions of the Migration Act, Ministerial Direction No. 79, and pertinent case law in reaching its determination. The Tribunal deliberated on the balance of factors supporting and opposing the revocation of the visa cancellation, ultimately concluding that the applicant's genuine fears about returning to Honduras and the associated impediments outweighed the factors against revocation.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
By contrast in DKXY v Minister for Home Affairs[46], Griffiths J stated:[30] In my respectful view, her Honour’s reasoning in [76] and [77] of YNQY would be plainly incorrect if this reasoning is read as stating that the primary consideration of expectations of the Australian community will always weigh against revocation. The Minister contended that the reasoning simply reflected the facts in YNQY and did not purport to be a construction of Direction 65 as suggesting that the expectations of the Australian community can never weigh in favour of an applicant. The difficulty with the Minister’s submission is that the language in YNQY at [76] and [77] is not in its terms confined to the circumstances of the particular applicant there and, on one view, appears to have been intended to have a more general application. The ambiguity of the language is reflected in the division of opinion in the large number of decisions of the AAT in which the language has been viewed inconsistently and as supporting either a broad or a narrow approach to cl 13.1.[31] As the applicant here pointed out, there are numerous statements in Direction No 65 which require the primary consideration of expectations of the Australian community to be assessed in the light of all the relevant circumstances which appertain to it and it has to be weighed against all other relevant considerations (while noting that the Direction requires that primary considerations be given more weight than other considerations). In an appropriate case, and depending upon all relevant circumstances, the expectations of the Australian community may not weigh against revocation of the mandatory visa cancellation. Undoubtedly, decision-makers who are bound to give effect to the Direction are required to have due regard to the Government’s view regarding community values, standards and expectations, as set out in, for example, cll 6.2 and 6.3 of the Direction, but nothing in the Direction indicates that community expectations will always favour non-revocation. Indeed, the totality of the relevant circumstances which bear upon the assessment and weighing of all three primary considerations and other considerations need to be considered, as is made clear in many clauses of the Direction, including those which are referred to in [23] above.[32] I also respectfully disagree with the primary judge’s reference at [77] of YNQY that Robertson J’s reasons for judgment in Uelese v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2016] FCA 348; 248 FCR 296 (Uelese) at [64]–[66] supported her Honour’s view that it was “inevitable” that the primary consideration of the expectations of the Australian community would weigh against revocation because that is what this primary consideration is intended to do……[33] ……… There is nothing in these passages from Uelese which indicates that a primary decision-maker who is bound to apply the Direction cannot also take into account any material which is before the decision-maker which is relevant to an assessment of this primary consideration. The Government’s views have to be taken into account and given “due regard”, but so must all other circumstances which are relevant in the particular case. As Robertson J pointed out in the final sentence at [64] of Uelese, cl 9.3 of the Direction ends by stating that decision-makers should have “due regard” to the Government’s views on Australian community expectations. What amounts to “due regard” will necessarily require attention to be given to all relevant circumstances in the particular case which bear upon a general assessment of Australian community expectations.[46] [2019] FCA 495.Other Considerations