Re Sharma and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

Sharma and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Citizenship) [2015] AATA 608 (19 August 2015)

Division

GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s)

2014/6518

Re

Madhav Sharma

APPLICANT

And

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President J W Constance

Date 19 August 2015 
Place Sydney

The reviewable decision, being the decision of the delegate of the Minister to refuse Mr Sharma’s application for Australian citizenship, is affirmed.

............................[sgd]............................................

Deputy President J W Constance

Catchwords

CITIZENSHIP – good character – previous convictions – domestic violence – whether applicant has reformed – decision affirmed

Legislation

Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) ss 21(2)(h), 24

Cases

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Ethnic Affairs (No.2) (1979) 2 ALD 634
Irving v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1996) 68 FCR 422

Zheng and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2011] AATA 304

Secondary Materials

Australian Citizenship Instructions (Cth) issued 1 July 2015.

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President J W Constance

INTRODUCTION

  1. Mr Sharma applied for Australian citizenship by conferral in July 2014.

  2. A delegate of the Minister refused Mr Sharma’s application in a decision dated 16 September 2014. The delegate was not satisfied that Mr Sharma was shown to be of good character for the purposes of the grant of citizenship.

  3. Mr Sharma has applied to this Tribunal for a review of the delegate’s decision.

  4. For the reasons which follow, the decision under review will be affirmed.

    BACKGROUND

  5. Mr Sharma is a citizen of Nepal and currently holds a permanent visa.

  6. He first arrived in Australia on 24 January 2007. Police records[1] indicate that from 2011, Mr Sharma has been involved in at least four domestic incidents that brought about the involvement of the police. Each incident involved disputes between Mr Sharma and his eldest daughter. She was aged 17 at the time of the earliest recorded incident on 2 February 2011.

    [1] Exhibit R2.

  7. Police records of this incident indicate that Mr Sharma’s daughter alleged that Mr Sharma “had grabbed her arm whilst trying to steal her mobile phone off her”.[2] She also alleged that over the previous months Mr Sharma had broken one of her mobile phones as well as her ipod. The police report indicates that:

    Police formed the opinion that no offence had occurred in this incident and the incident was simply a family dispute which was not being won by [the daughter], as such she contacted police. ... Police informed [Mr Sharma] that if he was to break any items belonging to his daughter, that is an offence and he could be arrested for that.[3]

    [2] Exhibit R2, p.6.

    [3] Exhibit R2, p.6.

  8. Approximately four months after this incident, on 4 June 2011, police were once more called to Mr Sharma’s family home. Police records indicate that Mr Sharma contacted the police alleging that his daughter had assaulted him. The police noted that the focus of the dispute for Mr Sharma appeared to be that he regarded his daughter as…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Sharma and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] AATA 608
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Re Sharma and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, Mr. Sharma, a Nepalese citizen with a permanent visa, applied for Australian citizenship. The central issue before the court was whether Mr. Sharma met the requirement of being of good character, particularly in light of his previous domestic violence convictions. The court had to determine if Mr. Sharma had reformed and could demonstrate qualities consistent with good character.

The legal issues involved interpreting the definition and requirements of good character under Australian law, particularly focusing on past conduct, admissions, and the seriousness of any prior offences. The court examined Mr. Sharma's past domestic violence incidents, his convictions, and his assertions of reform and changed circumstances. The court also considered the characteristics of a person of good character as outlined in the relevant statutory instructions, including respect for the law, truthfulness, and non-violence.

After reviewing the evidence, the court concluded that Mr. Sharma had not demonstrated that he met the standard of good character. His past conduct, particularly the domestic violence incidents and convictions, showed a pattern of behavior inconsistent with the qualities expected of a person of good character. The court found that while Mr. Sharma disputed some aspects of the police reports, his past actions and admissions indicated a failure to uphold the law and community standards. Consequently, the court affirmed the decision to refuse Mr. Sharma's application for citizenship, while leaving open the possibility for a future application if he could demonstrate reformed behavior.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons which follow, the decision under review will be affirmed.BACKGROUND Mr Sharma is a citizen of Nepal and currently holds a permanent visa. He first arrived in Australia on 24 January 2007. Police records[1] indicate that from 2011, Mr Sharma has been involved in at least four domestic incidents that brought about the involvement of the police. Each incident involved disputes between Mr Sharma and his eldest daughter. She was aged 17 at the time of the earliest recorded incident on 2 February 2011. [1] Exhibit R2. Police records of this incident indicate that Mr Sharma’s daughter alleged that Mr Sharma “had grabbed her arm whilst trying to steal her mobile phone off her”.[2] She also alleged that over the previous months Mr Sharma had broken one of her mobile phones as well as her ipod. The police report indicates that:Police formed the opinion that no offence had occurred in this incident and the incident was simply a family dispute which was not being won by [the daughter], as such she contacted police. ... Police informed [Mr Sharma] that if he was to break any items belonging to his daughter, that is an offence and he could be arrested for that.[3][2] Exhibit R2, p.6.[3] Exhibit R2, p.6. Approximately four months after this incident, on 4 June 2011, police were once more called to Mr Sharma’s family home. Police records indicate that Mr Sharma contacted the police alleging that his daughter had assaulted him. The police noted that the focus of the dispute for Mr Sharma appeared to be that he regarded his daughter as being disrespectful as she refused to do as he wished. Police reported that Mr Sharma’s view was that she should not have a life beyond the family home, with the exception of her attending school and casual employment. After dismissing police suggestions of counselling, Mr Sharma demanded in the presence of police that his daughter leave home. Police noted that Mr Sharma “could not be reasoned with” and the police escorted Mr Sharma’s daughter to alternative accommodation. On taking Mr Sharma’s daughter to a friend’s house, the police were advised by the friend’s family that:... this is not the first time [Mr Sharma] has thrown [his daughter] out of home. Further to this, they have advised police that the victim had previously disclosed to them that [Mr Sharma] had ordered her from the family vehicle recently during an argument whilst in Sydney, leaving her stranded at the time.[4] The Police found that there were no grounds for an apprehended violence order and no evidence of any physical abuse. The Police held “nil fears for the immediate wellbeing of the victim”.[4] Exhibit R2, p.5. Police were once more called to the family home on 19 June 2011. This involved an argument over money, leading to both Mr Sharma and his daughter calling the police and complaining of assault. The police found that this was a verbal argument only. On 13 June 2012, Mr Sharma was convicted of the offences of assault occasioning actual bodily harm and destroying or damaging property. Both offences were domestic violence related. The convictions arose out of an incident on 21 January 2012. The Police records detail:When the victim [Mr Sharma’s eldest daughter] arrived home she informed the accused person [Mr Sharma] that she was going out for the evening. The accused person demanded the victim cook him dinner and do the housework and started to argue with the victim. The victim walked outside to the backyard when the accused person approached the victim and attempted to rip the victims [sic] handbag off her shoulder. A melee then occurred between the accused person and the victim. During the melee the accused person has dug his finger nails into the victims [sic] fingers, causing several deep cuts to her fingers, causing bleeding. The victims [sic] handbag was ripped off the victim by the accused person resulting in the strap of the handbag being snapped in two. While the accused person and the victim were in the backyard the accused person has thrown a plastic pot at the victim, striking the victim’s right wrist, causing pain and bruising to the victims [sic] right wrist.[5][5] Exhibit R2, p.2.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Instructions go on to say that an applicant of good character would, amongst other things, respect and abide by the law of Australia, and be truthful and not practise deception in dealings with the Australian Government.[9][9] Paragraph 10.3.4.EVIDENCE OF MR SHARMA Mr Sharma gave evidence at the hearing with the assistance of a Nepalese interpreter. He disputed a number of comments contained within the police reports. With respect to the offences which resulted in conviction, Mr Sharma stated that he never threatened to kill his daughter. He accepted that a dispute arose out of his telling his daughter not to go out. Mr Sharma accepted that he was convicted, however claimed that he did not engage in the conduct that gave rise to the offences. Mr Sharma stated that when he entered a plea of guilty he did not fully comprehend what he was doing as he did not have any support and struggled with the English language. According to Mr Sharma, the laptop broke when Mr Sharma and his daughter were fighting over its use. He and his daughter were both pulling the computer, resulting in its breaking apart. Mr Sharma also stated that he did not dig his fingers into his daughter’s hands so hard that they bled, as reported by the police. He said that he did not touch her on this occasion. Mr Sharma described the incident as a “minor issue”. Throughout his evidence, Mr Sharma complained about his daughter’s behaviour. He noted that she had no discipline. He disputed throwing his daughter out of home before she turned 18, stating that she left by herself. At the conclusion of the giving of evidence at the hearing, Mr Sharma observed that he could not recall seeing a copy of the Minister’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions. In order to allow Mr Sharma an appropriate opportunity to respond to the Minister’s submissions, I allowed him two weeks from the conclusion of the hearing to file any written submissions. Those submissions focussed on Mr Sharma’s relationship with his daughter. He stated that his daughter was very good from 2007 to 2009 and there were no problems at home or at school. He then detailed an incident in about late 2009/early 2010 when he states that his daughter ran away from home after he refused her permission to travel to Nelson Bay by train. He further stated that from 2010, his daughter did not come home on time from school. The school informed him that she was regularly absent.CONSIDERATIONCharacteristics of a person of good character In paragraph 10.3.4 of the Instructions there is a non-exhaustive list of characteristics which a person of good character would have. These are to be considered with other provisions of Chapter 10. They include: ·respect and abide by the law in Australia and other countries; … ·be truthful and not practise deception or fraud in their dealings with the Australian Government, or other governments and organisations, for example: …oconcealment of convictions that could lead to the cancellation or refusal of a visa or citizenship; … ·not be violent … and not cause harm to others through their conduct. ...

Decision

Reasons for decision

Taking into account all of the above, I am not satisfied that Mr Sharma presently satisfies the legislative requirement to be shown to be of good character.CONCLUSION My conclusion does not preclude Mr Sharma from making a further application for citizenship at some time in the future. It may be that with the passage of time, Mr Sharma will be able to demonstrate that he does meet the requirements for a grant of citizenship. The decision to refuse Mr Sharma’s application for Australian citizenship by conferral will be affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Those submissions focussed on Mr Sharma’s relationship with his daughter. He stated that his daughter was very good from 2007 to 2009 and there were no problems at home or at school. He then detailed an incident in about late 2009/early 2010 when he states that his daughter ran away from home after he refused her permission to travel to Nelson Bay by train. He further stated that from 2010, his daughter did not come home on time from school. The school informed him that she was regularly absent.CONSIDERATIONCharacteristics of a person of good character In paragraph 10.3.4 of the Instructions there is a non-exhaustive list of characteristics which a person of good character would have. These are to be considered with other provisions of Chapter 10. They include: ·respect and abide by the law in Australia and other countries; … ·be truthful and not practise deception or fraud in their dealings with the Australian Government, or other governments and organisations, for example: …oconcealment of convictions that could lead to the cancellation or refusal of a visa or citizenship; … ·not be violent … and not cause harm to others through their conduct. ... Paragraph 10.5 provides a “Framework for making ‘good character’ decisions”. Its provisions are not exhaustive. The factors listed “may have different weights, depending on the circumstances of the case”. The relevant factors to be taken into account in considering why an applicant might not be of good character (as set out in paragraph 10.5.2) include the following: ·Has the applicant committed any offences and if so, did they admit that in their citizenship application?· If the applicant has committed an offence, was it serious or minor? ·Were there victims of the offence? In particular, were the victims vulnerable people like children, the elderly or disabled, or others who trusted the applicant? The Instructions provide that this framework should be considered first before considering whether there are any mitigating factors which may indicate that a person is now of good character. Under the heading, Weighing up the decision, the Instructions provide:Essentially, the question for decision makers is whether any mitigating circumstances and/or explanation provided by the applicant outweigh the behaviour in question. The assessment about whether an applicant is of “good character” requires the consideration of an aggregate of qualities.In weighing up the various factors, the decision maker must not apply their own personal standards, but must apply community standards. Having regard to the words of the Preamble, and the pledge to be made if citizenship is approved, decision makers are asking themselves:• would a person of good character have behaved the way the applicant did• what is there to demonstrate that the applicant has upheld and obeyed the law• has the applicant behaved in accordance with Australia's community standards• does the applicant share Australia’s democratic beliefs and respect its rights and liberties.[10][10] Paragraph 10.5.4.The offences