Odesho and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship)

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

Odesho and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) [2019] AATA 3946 (27 September 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2019/2522

Re:Gorgees Odesho

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Home Affairs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Chris Puplick AM, Senior Member

Date:27 September 2019

Place:Sydney

The decision under review is set aside and the matter remitted to the Respondent with a direction to the effect that the Applicant meets the good character requirements of section 21(2)(h) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007.

.........................[sgd]...............................................

Chris Puplick AM, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

CITIZENSHIP – refusal – whether applicant of good character – common assault – apprehended domestic violence order issued – traffic offences – consideration of applicant’s character – decision set aside and remitted

LEGISLATION

Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth)

Crimes Act 1900 (NSW)

Migration Act 1958 (Cth)

CASES

Ahori and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Citizenship) [2017] AATA 601

Assafiri and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2014] AATA 35

Chen v Minister for Immigration [2007] AATA 1815

Collector of Customs (NSW) v Brian Lawlor Automotive Pty Ltd (1979) 24 ALR 307

Collins v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1981) 4 ALD 198

Commonwealth v Twyman (1985) 8 ALD 554

Contreras v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCAFC 47

Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 46 FLR 409

Fenn and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] AATA 931

Irving v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1996) 68 FCR 422

Kakar and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2002] AATA 132

Kumar and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2014] AATA 944

Mahmood and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Citizenship) [2017] AATA 2033

Mendoza and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] AATA 686

Minister from Home Affairs v G [2019] FCAFC 79

Prasad and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Citizenship) [2017] AATA 1506

Re Aston and Secretary, Department of Primary Industry (1985) 8 ALD 366

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs(No.2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

Re KLGL and Australian Prudential Regulation Authority [2008] AATA 542

Sharma and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Citizenship) [2015] AATA 608

Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority [2008] HCA 31

Sui and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2008] AATA 1062

Umer and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Citizenship) [2018] AATA 1630

Zheng v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2011] AATA 304

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Australian Citizenship Instructions, 1 July 2014

Citizenship Policy, effective 1 June 2016

Citizenship Procedural Instructions

Dennis Pearce: Administrative Appeals Tribunal (LexisNexis, Butterworth, 4th edition, 2015)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Chris Puplick AM, Senior Member

27 September 2019

  1. Mr Odesho (the Applicant) seeks a review of a decision by a Delegate of the Minister (the Respondent) to refuse his application for a grant of Australian citizenship by conferral.

  2. The initial application for citizenship was lodged on 28 June 2017; the refusal decision was made on 17 April 2019; the application for review was received by the Tribunal on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Odesho and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 3946
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Odesho against a decision by the Minister for Home Affairs to refuse his application for Australian citizenship. The refusal was based on the Minister's assessment that Mr Odesho was not of good character, primarily due to a conviction for common assault and the issuance of an apprehended domestic violence order. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal was required to determine whether the Minister's decision was correct.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether Mr Odesho met the character requirements for citizenship, specifically considering his conviction for common assault, the associated apprehended domestic violence order, and certain traffic offences. The Tribunal had to assess the weight to be given to these matters in light of the time elapsed since their commission and the applicant's demonstrated remorse and rehabilitation.

The Tribunal reasoned that while criminal offences are relevant to character assessments, their impact depends on factors such as the seriousness of the offence, the time elapsed, and the degree of rehabilitation. The Tribunal noted that the common assault conviction, while serious, resulted in a good behaviour bond rather than a custodial sentence, and the victim's evidence suggested a retraction of earlier statements about prior violence. The traffic offences were considered minor and not indicative of a persistent disregard for the law. The Tribunal found that sufficient time had passed since the offending conduct, and that Mr Odesho had expressed shame and remorse. Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the Minister's decision and remitted the matter for reconsideration.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Applicant, Mr Odesho, and Ms Tufonic were in a relationship that began in 2011. In August 2013, Ms Tufonic discovered that Mr Odesho had been communicating with another woman on Facebook and receiving intimate messages from her, which led her to decide to end their relationship. On 20 August 2013, Ms Tufonic went to Mr Odesho’s unit to retrieve her laptop, where a heated argument ensued. Mr Odesho insisted that she delete certain images from the laptop before leaving, and when she refused, he grabbed her by the hair, pulled her back into the living room, and slapped her in the face. Ms Tufonic then left the unit and called the Police. The Police arrived, questioned Mr Odesho, and arrested him.

Mr Odesho admitted to assaulting Ms Tufonic, expressing remorse and stating that he was not a violent person. Ms Tufonic initially told the Police that there had been previous incidents of violence but later clarified that any past incidents were minor and not serious. On 12 September 2013, Mr Odesho was convicted of common assault and sentenced to a 9-month good behaviour bond. An Apprehended Domestic Violence Order (AVO) was also issued against him. Ms Tufonic requested the AVO be lifted after the court case, but the Police refused and issued another AVO on the same date, which she believed lasted for about 12 months.

In addition to the assault conviction, Mr Odesho had minor traffic offences in 2014, including disobeying traffic signals or signs and a parking offence in a school zone. These offences resulted in fines and a brief suspension of his Provisional licence. The Tribunal reviewed these incidents and found no evidence of a persistent, wilful, or dangerous disregard for road rules. The Tribunal also noted that while Mr Odesho had been involved in other aggressive altercations, he was often the victim in these situations.

The matter before the Tribunal in Odesho and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) originated from the applicant's citizenship application, which was subsequently refused by the Minister. The applicant sought review of this decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The Tribunal was tasked with determining whether the applicant was of good character, a critical consideration for citizenship approval under Australian law. The applicant had a history of common assault and traffic offences, which the Tribunal examined closely. The Tribunal considered the seriousness of the assault, the time elapsed since the offence, and the applicant's efforts towards rehabilitation. Additionally, the Tribunal looked into an apprehended domestic violence order (AVO) issued against the applicant and whether there was a pattern of aggressive behaviour. The case involved several prior hearings and submissions, including evidence from the applicant and his partner, as well as relevant police reports and documentation. This case was a judicial review application, focusing on the procedural fairness and correctness of the Minister's decision, rather than a first-instance hearing of the merits of the citizenship application itself.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Applicant’s partner, who was the victim in this instance, told the Tribunal in her oral evidence that while she had applied for an AVO immediately after the incident (August 2013) she had asked for it to be lifted after the Court case (September 2013) but that the Police had refused this request and another AVO was issued on that date on their initiative. There is no evidence before the Tribunal as to the length of time of the AVO,[14] but the Applicant’s partner believes it was in the order of 12 months.[14] Section 37 Supplementary Tribunal Documents at [10].EVIDENCE OF THE APPLICANT Mr Odesho gave evidence to the Tribunal in which he admitted freely that he had slapped his partner, pulled her hair and otherwise assaulted and detained her following an incident which had taken place on 20 August 2013. He agreed that the Facts Sheet[15] created by the Police Force was correct in its description of the incident and the extent of confrontation leading to the assault.[15] Section 37 Further Supplementary Tribunal Documents at [26]-[29]. In essence what occurred was: The Applicant and Ms Tufonic had been in a relationship since 2011 but in August 2013 Ms Tufonic found out that the Applicant had been “cheating on her” by talking to another woman on Facebook and receiving intimate messages from her. Ms Tufonic decided to end their relationship and to that end went to the Applicant’s unit (where he was living with his mother and sister) in order to retrieve her laptop computer. While there, a verbal screaming/shouting match arose between the parties with the Applicant insisting that before Ms Tufonic left the unit she should delete certain images from the laptop. She refused and attempted to leave. The Applicant sought to restrain her by grabbing her by the hair and pulling her back into the living room. She demanded that he free her. He did not. She confronted him. He slapped her in the face. She then left the unit, went downstairs and called the Police. She waited for the arrival of the Police and then accompanied them back to the unit where they questioned the Applicant and arrested him. Under questioning from the Respondent’s representative he was unable to recall whether the slap in question was “hard” or “gentle”. At the time, Ms Tufonic told the Police that the Applicant had been violent towards her on previous occasions and that she had not reported such incidents. In her sworn evidence to the Tribunal, Ms Tufonic resiled from this position. She said that there had been instances in the past when each of the parties had been “physical” with each other but that they were only (to use her words) “mucking about” and there was “nothing serious” in such incidents. She said that she only told the Police that there had been previous incidents because she “wanted to get him into more trouble”. The Applicant agreed that he had assaulted Ms Tufonic in the manner described but he expressed both shame and remorse for his actions, stating that he was not a violent person by nature and that he realised that assaulting anybody, especially women or children was unacceptable behaviour.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The length of the sentence, if one has been imposed, may be a factor for decision makers to take into account. The decision-maker must also take into account any ongoing obligations in relation to the sentence received, such as good behaviour bonds. When weighing information, the CPIs provide that a decision-maker should take into account the length of time since the offending was committed and, in relation to serious offences, a significant amount of time may have to have passed before a decision-maker can be satisfied that a person is of good character.THE BASIS OF THE REFUSAL DECISION The basis for the Delegate’s refusal of the citizenship application is set out in the Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions as follows (footnotes omitted):(23) The applicant was convicted on 12 September 2013, and was sentenced to a good behaviour bond for 9 months. The NSW Police facts sheet for this offence indicates that the applicant and his girlfriend argued after they had ended their relationship earlier that day. The applicant “grabbed the victim by the top of her hair and pushed her head down” to the same level as his stomach and did not let go for about two minutes. The applicant then slapped the victim with his open hand on her face/ear area. The victim left the residence in fear and called the Police after the applicant said “I’m going to come to your house”.(24) The applicant pleaded guilty to the common assault. He was convicted and directed to enter into a good behaviour bond for 9 months. A final Apprehended Domestic Violence Order was also issued against the applicant. The Statement goes on (footnotes omitted):(25) While the Minister accepts that this is the applicant’s only offence and the offending took place in 2013, the police facts sheet indicates that the applicant had been violent to the victim in the past, but she had never reported any of the incidents to the Police. Further, the police records reveal that the applicant was also involved in aggressive altercations in August 2013 and November 2012. There are a number of resultant observations to be made arising from the above. The first is that the Applicant was charged and convicted of the offence of Common assault (dv) T2 under the provisions of section 61 of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW) which provides:“Whoever assaults any person, although not occasioning actual bodily harm, shall be liable to imprisonment for two years.” It follows that the Police did not prefer a charge which alleged that the victim suffered actual bodily harm and the Magistrate, with the option of imposing a custodial sentence of up to two years imprisonment, chose instead to impose a sentence of a 9 month good behaviour bond. The Applicant’s partner, who was the victim in this instance, told the Tribunal in her oral evidence that while she had applied for an AVO immediately after the incident (August 2013) she had asked for it to be lifted after the Court case (September 2013) but that the Police had refused this request and another AVO was issued on that date on their initiative. There is no evidence before the Tribunal as to the length of time of the AVO,[14] but the Applicant’s partner believes it was in the order of 12 months.[14] Section 37 Supplementary Tribunal Documents at [10].EVIDENCE OF THE APPLICANT

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Respondent also confirmed that in the initial assessment of the application, the Applicant had been found to have met all the requirements outlined in sections (a) to (g) of section 21(2) of the Act.[22][22] Section 37 Tribunal Documents at [13]-[14].CONSIDERATIONS As a preliminary consideration the Tribunal takes note of what was said by a previous Tribunal in Kakar, another case relating to a citizenship application:When criminal offences have been committed by an applicant they will obviously be taken into account. The extent to which the existence of criminal conduct will weigh in the scales against a finding of good character will depend upon many things including the seriousness of the crime, the length of time since its commission and the degree of rehabilitation of the offender.”[23][23] Kakar and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2002] AATA 132 at [14]. Working in reverse order through the Respondent’s submissions, the Tribunal takes note of the following matters. In relation to the matter of the Applicant’s driving offences: these were laid before the Tribunal by the Respondent in the Section 37 Documents[24] but were not actively pressed as part of the Respondent’s submission. Nevertheless the Tribunal has examined them and noted that they consist of three offences related to disobeying traffic signals or signs and one is a parking offence (school zone). Various fines were levied and there was a brief suspension of a Provisional licence.[24] Section 37 Supplementary Tribunal Documents at [2]-[4]. The Tribunal has noted that there may well be instances in which an applicant’s driving record may be taken as weighing against them in terms of character assessment where such record indicates a persistent, wilful and dangerous disregard for the road rules and the safety of others[25]. This is not such an incidence and no negative conclusions are drawn in relation to this application from details of traffic offences.[25] Bowdler and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Citizenship) [2018] AATA 347 at [53]-[55]; Bartlett and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration) [2017] AATA 1561 at [45]. Similarly, careful reading of the various police reports relating to the “aggressive altercations” noted by the Respondent do not reveal any pattern of aggressive behaviour on the part of the Applicant. Indeed on a number of occasions it was the Applicant who was the victim of the aggressive behaviour in question.[26][26] Section 37 Supplementary Tribunal Documents at [9], [13], [14]. In relation to the passage of time since any offences were committed, it has been six years since the assault took place and five years since the expiry of both the AVO and the Bond. In relation to traffic offences, the last of these was in 2014. The Tribunal has frequently examined the question of the length of time which should have elapsed between the last commission of an offence and the granting of an application for citizenship where issues of “good character” are central. This is a multi-factorial exercise as made clear in Kakar (above).