Bhavesh Kumar and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

[2014] AATA  944

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number

 2014/0782

Re

Bhavesh Kumar

APPLICANT

And

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Senior Member Bernard J McCabe

Date 18 December 2014
Place Sydney

The decision under review is affirmed.

........................[SGD]................................................

Senior Member Bernard J McCabe

CATCHWORDS

AUSTRALIAN CITIZENSHIP – Applicant living in Fiji – Failure to meet general residence requirement – Discretion to treat periods of absence as time spent in Australia enlivened –
No compelling reason to exercise the discretion – Decision under review affirmed.

LEGISLATION

Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) ss 21(2), 22(1), (9)

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Australian Citizenship Instructions

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member Bernard J McCabe

18 December 2014

  1. Mr Bhavesh Kumar (“the applicant”) wants to become an Australian citizen. To do that, he must satisfy the criteria set out in the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth)


    (“the Act”). Different criteria apply to different types of applicants. One of the criteria


    Mr Kumar must satisfy is referred to in s 21(2) of the Act. It is known as the general residence requirement and it is defined in s 22. The usual way of satisfying the general residence requirement is explained in s 22(1). It contemplates the applicant being physically present in Australia for a minimum period before the application.


    But Mr Kumar was absent for long periods, so he has asked the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection to exercise the discretion in s 22(9) to effectively deem him to be present in Australia during those periods of absence. The discretion is only available in limited circumstances, including where the Minister is satisfied “the person had a close and continuing association with Australia during that period”: s 22(9)(d).

  2. The Minister denies Mr Kumar had a close and continuing association with Australia during the relevant period but says in any event that it would not be appropriate to exercise the discretion in s 22(9) in Mr Kumar’s favour. Mr Kumar has asked the Tribunal to review that decision.

    THE BACKGROUND TO THE APPLICATION

  3. Mr Kumar lives and works in Fiji where he is a citizen. He is an executive in a family business that is carried on by a group of companies in which he has a significant shareholding. He came to Australia briefly for the first time in 1990 although he explained in his statement (exhibit 4) that he had become an Australian permanent resident in 1989. Immigration records show Mr Kumar did not visit this country in 1991 but he was here for 273 days in 1992 and 244 days in 1993 (see summary at exhibit 6).

  4. Mr Kumar visited Australia on many occasions since 1993. Most of the visits were of shorter duration, although on at least four or five occasions Mr Kumar visited for longer periods of several months in order to provide relief for his brother, with whom he continues to be in business. Exhibit 6 sets out the total amount of time he spent in this country during each year…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bhavesh Kumar and Minister for Immigration and Border Protec... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 944
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves Mr Bhavesh Kumar, who resides and works in Fiji, appealing a decision by the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection denying his application for Australian citizenship. The key issue before the court was whether Mr Kumar had a close and continuing association with Australia, and if so, whether the Minister's discretion under section 22(9) of the legislation should be exercised in his favour to treat periods of absence as if he had been physically present in Australia. The court was also required to determine if there was a compelling reason to exercise the discretion in Mr Kumar's favour.

The court examined the statutory language and found that Mr Kumar did indeed have a close and continuing association with Australia, based on his significant shareholding and executive role in a family business carried on by a group of companies, as well as his regular visits to Australia, some of which were of several months' duration. However, the court was not satisfied that there was a compelling reason to exercise the discretion in Mr Kumar's favour at that point in time. The court found that he would not suffer any disadvantage if he could not immediately access Australian citizenship and that he could reapply if circumstances changed.

The court affirmed the decision under review, upholding the Minister's decision to deny Mr Kumar's citizenship application. The court emphasised the importance of focusing on the words of the statute in their context, and did not consider the Australian Citizenship Instructions to be useful aids to the interpretation of the legislation. Instead, the court focused on the ordinary English meaning of the statutory language and the evidence presented by Mr Kumar.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The Minister denies Mr Kumar had a close and continuing association with Australia during the relevant period but says in any event that it would not be appropriate to exercise the discretion in s 22(9) in Mr Kumar’s favour. Mr Kumar has asked the Tribunal to review that decision. THE BACKGROUND TO THE APPLICATION Mr Kumar lives and works in Fiji where he is a citizen. He is an executive in a family business that is carried on by a group of companies in which he has a significant shareholding. He came to Australia briefly for the first time in 1990 although he explained in his statement (exhibit 4) that he had become an Australian permanent resident in 1989. Immigration records show Mr Kumar did not visit this country in 1991 but he was here for 273 days in 1992 and 244 days in 1993 (see summary at exhibit 6). Mr Kumar visited Australia on many occasions since 1993. Most of the visits were of shorter duration, although on at least four or five occasions Mr Kumar visited for longer periods of several months in order to provide relief for his brother, with whom he continues to be in business. Exhibit 6 sets out the total amount of time he spent in this country during each year since 1990. In the four years preceding the application, the respondent calculated Mr Kumar was present in Australia for between 215 to 218 days. That is not nearly long enough to meet the criterion in s 22(1). Section 22(9) offers what amounts to an alternative way of satisfying the general residence requirement in s 21. It is potentially available in cases like the present where a permanent resident with an Australian spouse is absent overseas for long periods. The subsection provides the Minister with the discretion to treat absences from Australia as if the individual were physically present in this country. But there is a catch: the discretion is only enlivened if “the Minister is satisfied that the person had a close and continuing association with Australia during that period”: s 22(9)(d). It follows I must first satisfy myself that Mr Kumar had a close and continuing association with Australia during the periods of absence from Australia. If I am satisfied he did, I must then consider whether the discretion should be exercised in his favour. DID THE APPLICANT HAVE A CLOSE AND CONTINUING ASSOCIATION WITH AUSTRALIA? The statutory language uses ordinary English words. Everyone knows what those words mean. There is no point parsing or paraphrasing the expression, or parts of it; indeed, doing so would create the risk of error. I would add that I do not accept the Australian Citizenship Instructions are useful aids to the interpretation of the statute. At best, they represent the respondent’s opinion as to the correct interpretation of the legislation. My task is to focus on the words of the statute in their context. The Act says what it says, and the words mean what they say. I am satisfied there is a close and continuing association over the period of review – and for many years before that – on the basis of the following evidence that was given by Mr Kumar in particular.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

I am not satisfied there is a good reason to exercise the discretion in Mr Kumar’s favour at this point. He will not suffer any disadvantage if he is not immediately able to access the privilege of Australian citizenship. If something changes, he can reapply.CONCLUSION The decision under review is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established