Prasad v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

Prasad and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Citizenship) [2017] AATA 1506 (15 September 2017)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2017/1145

Re:Ravin Prasad

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Immigration and Border Protection

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President J W Constance

Date:15 September 2017

Place:Sydney

The reviewable decision of the delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection made 28 November 2016 to refuse Mr Prasad’s application for Australian citizenship is affirmed.

....................................[sgd]....................................

J W Constance
Deputy President

CATCHWORDS

CITIZENSHIP – citizenship by conferral – whether applicant of good character – whether has enduring moral qualities – whether will respect and abide by Australian laws – whether truthful and does not practise deception – assault – domestic violence – traffic offences – false statement in citizenship application – decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) ss 21(2), 24

CASES

Irving v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1996) 68 FCR 422

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Ethnic Affairs (No.2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

Zheng and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2011] AATA 304

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Citizenship Policy, Department of Immigration and Border Protection, 1 June 2016

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President J W Constance

15 September 2017

INTRODUCTION

  1. Mr Prasad applied for Australian citizenship by conferral on 28 March 2016. On 28 November 2016, a delegate of the Minister refused the application on the basis that he had not established that he was of good character at that time. Mr Prasad has applied to this Tribunal to review of the delegate’s decision.

  2. For the reasons which follow the decision under review will be affirmed.

    BACKGROUND

  3. Mr Prasad was born in Fiji and is a citizen of that country.[1] He is 40 years old. He migrated to Australia in February 2009 and currently holds a subclass 155 (permanent) visa.  He is married and has a 13 year old son with his wife.

    [1] Exhibit R1 p.98.

    Conviction of common assault (domestic violence)

  4. On 6 April 2013 Mr Prasad was charged with the offence of common assault (domestic violence) upon his wife. 

  5. The Police Fact Sheet sets out the following:[2]

    The accused in this matter is Ravin PRASAD, identified by the victim……..as pushing her to the floor. The assault was witnessed by the accused and victim’s son,…….who is eight years old. The victim and accused are married. They have one son, who is eight years old, and they all reside at the same location. On Saturday 6th April 2013 the accused and the victim engaged in numerous verbal arguments throughout the day regarding food, chores, money and property. About 1pm the same day the accused became angry at the victim over his Subway sandwich which she brought home for him. The accused threw the sandwich at her stating, “There’s no meat.” The victim pulled the meat out of the sandwich and threw it at him stating there was meat. About 4.30pm the same day a further argument ensued regarding money and the victim’s excessive…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Prasad v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 1506
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for Australian citizenship by conferral by Mr Ravin Prasad, a citizen of Fiji. The Minister for Immigration and Border Protection had refused Mr Prasad's application on the grounds that he was not of good character. Mr Prasad sought review of this decision before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether Mr Prasad possessed the enduring moral qualities expected of a person of good character, specifically whether he respected and abided by Australian laws, and whether he was truthful and did not practise deception. This assessment was to be made in light of Mr Prasad's prior conviction for common assault (domestic violence) against his wife, and a false statement made in his citizenship application.

The Tribunal considered the Citizenship Policy, which outlines that an applicant of good character must respect and abide by Australian laws, be truthful, and not practise deception. The Policy also states that decision-makers must weigh various factors, placing more weight on significant offences, and apply community standards rather than personal ones. While Mr Prasad's wife provided evidence of reconciliation and his remorse, the Tribunal noted the seriousness of the domestic violence offence, which was witnessed by their young son. The Tribunal also considered the false statement made in the application.

Ultimately, the Tribunal affirmed the delegate's decision to refuse Mr Prasad's application for Australian citizenship, finding that he had not demonstrated he was of good character. However, the Tribunal noted that Mr Prasad could reapply for citizenship in the future if he could demonstrate he met the character requirements.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons which follow the decision under review will be affirmed.BACKGROUND Mr Prasad was born in Fiji and is a citizen of that country.[1] He is 40 years old. He migrated to Australia in February 2009 and currently holds a subclass 155 (permanent) visa. He is married and has a 13 year old son with his wife.[1] Exhibit R1 p.98.Conviction of common assault (domestic violence) On 6 April 2013 Mr Prasad was charged with the offence of common assault (domestic violence) upon his wife. The Police Fact Sheet sets out the following:[2]The accused in this matter is Ravin PRASAD, identified by the victim……..as pushing her to the floor. The assault was witnessed by the accused and victim’s son,…….who is eight years old. The victim and accused are married. They have one son, who is eight years old, and they all reside at the same location. On Saturday 6th April 2013 the accused and the victim engaged in numerous verbal arguments throughout the day regarding food, chores, money and property. About 1pm the same day the accused became angry at the victim over his Subway sandwich which she brought home for him. The accused threw the sandwich at her stating, “There’s no meat.” The victim pulled the meat out of the sandwich and threw it at him stating there was meat. About 4.30pm the same day a further argument ensued regarding money and the victim’s excessive spending. The victim walked into the main bedroom and the accused followed. The accused pushed the victim with both his hands. His hands connected with her shoulders causing her to fall backwards. The victim landed, on the floor on her left side, her head hitting a near by washing basket. The victim felt pain down her left side of her neck and her back. The accused left the room. The assault was witness by the victim's son who immediately called Triple 0 for an ambulance. Police attended the location and saw the victim sitting on a bed. She was crying and walling and rubbing her neck. When asked if she was alright the victim replied, “He pushed me and I feel to the floor and hit my head...It hurts my neck and back.” The victim was unable to sit or walk comfortably and as a result was taken to hospital for treatment. The accused, who was still at the location, was arrested and cautioned. The accused was conveyed to Mt Druitt Police Station where he was introduced to the Custody Manager and informed of his rights in accordance with Part 9 of the Law Enforcement Powers and Responsibilities Act. The accused was interviewed electronically where he made full admissions to assaulting the victim. When asked what happened the accused stated, “She made a situation where I pushed her.” The accused further stated that “she come to my face” and was “aggressive” and “making fun” of the accused. As a result the accused “pushed her”. An AVO was applied for and served on the accused whilst in custody.I am satisfied that the above is an accurate statement of the events which gave rise to Mr Prasad’s conviction. It was not challenged by Mr Prasad when he pleaded guilty in the Local Court.[3][2] Exhibit R2 p.21.[3] Exhibit R1 pp.123-125.

Decision

Reasons for decision

My decision does not mean that Mr Prasad cannot again apply for citizenship. At some future time he may be able to demonstrate that he is of good character and be able to meet the other requirements of the Act to enable him to enjoy the privileges of Australian citizenship. CONCLUSION The reviewable decision of the delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection made 28 November 2016 to refuse Mr Prasad’s application for Australian citizenship will be affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Policy goes on to say that an applicant of good character would, amongst other things, respect and abide by the law of Australia, and be truthful and not practise deception in his or her dealings with the Australian Government.[15] All of these authorities along with the Citizenship Policy make it clear that abiding by Australian laws is a very important factor that I need to consider.CONSIDERATION [15] At p. 147.Characteristics of a person of good character Chapter 11 provides a non-exhaustive list of characteristics which a person of good character would have. These are to be considered with other provisions of the Chapter. They include: ·respect and abide by the law in Australia and other countries.… ·be truthful and not practise deception or fraud in their dealings with the Australian Government, or other governments and organisations, for example: …· concealment of convictions that could lead to the cancellation or refusal of a visa or citizenship; … ·not be violent … and not cause harm to others through their conduct. ... It is a matter of weighing up the various factors in the evidence before me. Under the heading of Weighing up the character decision, the Policy provides:Essentially, the question for decision makers is whether any mitigating circumstances and/or explanation provided by the applicant outweigh the behaviour in question. The assessment about whether an applicant is of “good character” requires the consideration of an aggregate of qualities. Decision makers should place more weight on significant offences. In weighing up the various factors, the decision maker must not apply their own personal standards, but must apply community standards. Having regard to the words of the Preamble, and the pledge to be made if citizenship is approved, decision makers are asking themselves: •would a person of good character have behaved the way the applicant did •what is there to demonstrate that the applicant has upheld and obeyed the law •has the applicant behaved in accordance with Australia's community standards •does the applicant share Australia’s democratic beliefs and respect its rights and liberties.[16]I note that, once again there is a reference to the question of whether an applicant for citizenship has upheld and obeyed the laws of Australia. [16] At pp. 149-150.Character referencesEvidence of Ms Maharaj, Mr Prasad’s wife Ms Maharaj provided a statutory declaration dated 27 April 2017[17] and gave evidence. The declaration reads in part:2.My husband Ravin Prasad and I have reconciled and are living together harmoniously.3.We have not had any issues since the incident for which we attended court.4.Ravin has accepted and understood the responsibility of a good husband and a good father.5.Ravin has shown lots of remorse for his conduct.[17] Exhibit A2. When she gave evidence as to the assault upon her Ms Maharaj said that “there was a little bit of pushing and shoving ……. he pulled my hair.”[18] Immediately after the assault her neck was painful. She said also that their son (then aged eight) was there and he called the ambulance. [18] Transcript 12/07/17.Statement of Mr Reddy, Mental Health Worker