Bhatia and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

Bhatia and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration) [2017] AATA 927 (23 June 2017)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2016/4220

Re:Vikram Bhatia

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Immigration and Border Protection

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President Gary Humphries  

Date:23 June 2017

Place:Canberra

The decision under review is affirmed.

...........................[sgd].............................................

Deputy President Gary Humphries

Catchwords

MIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP – application for Australian citizenship denied on character grounds – domestic violence – criminal convictions – convictions of applicant deemed ‘serious’ under the Australian Citizenship Instructions – evidence of applicant before Tribunal inconsistent with finding of Court – inconsistency weighs against applicant – attempt to downplay seriousness of criminal offences in evidence to Tribunal weighs against applicant demonstrating enduring moral qualities – that denial of application for citizenship will create ‘significant hardship’ to applicant irrelevant in assessment of good character – decision affirmed.

Legislation

Australian Citizenship Act 2007

Cases

Divane and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] AATA 728
Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634)
Irving v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1996) 139 ALR 84
Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs v Ali [2000] FCA 1385
Sharma and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] AATA 608
Zheng and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2011] AATA 304

Secondary Materials

Citizenship Policy Document, June 2016

Australian Citizenship Instructions

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Gary Humphries

23 June 2017

BACKGROUND

  1. Mr Vikram Bhatia came to Australia from India in 2006. In 2009 he returned to India to marry Ramandeep Kaur, whom he had known since childhood. There was some opposition to the marriage from family members, however, as Mr Bhatia and Ms Kaur belonged to different castes and religions. He returned to Tamworth in northern New South Wales where he was employed, and in 2011 his wife joined him there. Her command of English on arrival in Australia was rudimentary.

  2. On 29 June 2012 an incident occurred at their home in Tamworth. The following day, Ms Kaur went to the Tamworth police station to complain that she had been assaulted by her husband. Mr Bhatia later attended the police station and was arrested. The police applied for and were granted an urgent apprehended violence order (AVO) on her behalf. Mr Bhatia was charged with domestic common assault and released on strict bail conditions, and served with the AVO. Ms Kaur did not return to their home that night.

  3. Mr Bhatia repeatedly made phone calls and sent texts to Ms Kaur that day and the following day, in contravention of the terms of the AVO. The following day he identified the house where Ms Kaur was staying, and he went to the front door, where he was turned away by the owner of the house. Later that day, Ms Kaur returned to the Tamworth police station and reported Mr Bhatia’s conduct. Mr Bhatia was arrested and spent two days in custody.

  4. On 11 October 2012 Mr Bhatia was convicted…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bhatia and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (M... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 927
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Bhatia against the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection's decision to deny his application for Australian citizenship. The denial was based on character grounds, specifically relating to Mr Bhatia's criminal convictions for domestic violence offences. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) affirmed the Minister's decision.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether Mr Bhatia possessed the requisite good character for Australian citizenship, as defined by the relevant legislation and Australian Citizenship Instructions (ACIs). This involved assessing the weight to be given to his criminal convictions for domestic violence, and considering any mitigating factors or evidence of rehabilitation he presented. A key aspect of the dispute was the inconsistency between Mr Bhatia's account of the domestic violence incident and the facts underpinning his criminal conviction.

The Tribunal reasoned that domestic violence offences are considered serious and fundamentally inconsistent with the standards of behaviour expected by the Australian community, thus weighing heavily against an applicant's good character. While acknowledging Mr Bhatia's remorse and evidence of rehabilitation, the Tribunal found that his attempt to present a version of events significantly less culpable than that accepted by the court undermined his claim of good character. The Tribunal applied the principle that, as a general rule, it cannot go behind a criminal conviction and question the basis upon which it was reached; rather, it must accept the conviction and the essential findings of fact upon which it was based. The Tribunal noted that the applicant's assertion of significant hardship resulting from the denial of citizenship was irrelevant to the assessment of good character.

The Tribunal affirmed the decision to deny Mr Bhatia's application for Australian citizenship.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Both Mr Bhatia and Ms Kaur gave evidence to the Tribunal, in each case partly in Hindi through an interpreter and partly in English. Summonsed police and court records were also tendered.Mr Bhatia’s evidence Mr Bhatia told the Tribunal he was born in 1980. He gave evidence about the concerns of his and Ms Kaur’s families with respect to their marriage, and ongoing friction between the families. When his wife came to Australia in 2011 he was able to find her a job, but there were financial difficulties, leading to some problems for us. One night his wife had a migraine, which he interpolated they later discovered was a different condition, relating to a brain haemorrhage. On this night Mr Bhatia was speaking to her father in India by telephone but Ms Kaur had a headache. She lay down on the bed beside him while he was on the phone. She could not speak to her father because of her headache and Mr Bhatia just got angry because it happened in front of …her father. He said we didn’t have a scuffle… we just had argument. His evidence was that, after she had gone to work the next day, she sent him a text message to say that she was at the police station. He went to the police station where he was arrested. He did some paperwork and then was allowed to go home. His wife was not at home and he got a bit worried. He tried to call her. He rang both the families to tell them she was not there, and they told him to go and find her. The following morning he went to Manila Road, where he understood his wife might be. He went to a house on that road and spoke to a lady and asked her to tell his wife that she should ring home because her family were worried about her. He was later arrested and spent two days in custody. He said that he later met his wife, and that they sat together and sorted everything, and then we started our life again. After that everything was okay, she was happy. Later, a baby girl was born to them. He also gave evidence about medical problems his wife later experienced with her eyes, brain and leg. He said he worked two jobs, one in a factory and another in the evening at Woolworths. He said he had changed a lot, and had tried to fix my anger. He said I feel very remorseful about what happened in mid-2012. He wanted to volunteer with the Salvation Army but his heavy work commitments prevented that. Mr Bhatia also gave evidence of two traffic convictions, an offence of driving through a red light signal in Sydney in 2010 and a speeding offence on the New England Highway in April 2016, where he drove at 130kph in a 100kph zone. More information about the incidents in mid-2012 was elicited during cross-examination. In relation to the assault, Mr Bhatia denied that he had struck the back of his wife’s head with his fist, but said rather that I tried to pick up the phone but my elbow hit her. His wife then left and went into the other bedroom, where she covered herself in a quilt. He said that she fell off the bed when he pulled the quilt off her. He denied that he kicked her while she was on the bed. It was put to him that he then kicked his wife several more times; he denied this.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Dr Elizabeth Varughese, who gave evidence by telephone, became Ms Kaur’s doctor after the incident in 2015. She said that Ms Kaur always spoke about him [Mr Bhatia] highly. She said that Mr Bhatia was always very supportive of his wife when she saw them.CONSIDERATION The question facing the Tribunal is whether Mr Bhatia qualifies for citizenship on the basis that he is of good character, in the sense that term is used in the Act. Mr Bhatia has been convicted of what the ACIs describe as – and what the community would consider to be – serious offences, namely domestic violence offences. In Sharma and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] AATA 608 at [37] the Tribunal described domestic violence as: …conduct that is fundamentally inconsistent with the standard of behaviour expected by the Australian community and usually weighs heavily against an individual being of good character. Mr Bhatia has placed before the Tribunal factors which he contended should be considered mitigating factors in assessing the extent to which his convictions count against his good character. He is truly remorseful for his actions in 2012 and has rehabilitated himself, the Tribunal was told. A number of matters relating to his conduct since July 2012 were before the Tribunal. Most conspicuously, however, Mr Bhatia placed before the Tribunal a version of the events of 29 June-1 July 2012 which was substantially different to the one contained in the fact sheets handed up by the police to the court when he was convicted in October 2012. The following sets out only some of those differences (the police version in bold, Mr Bhatia and Ms Kaur’s version unbolded): Quite evidently, the version of events put before the Tribunal by Mr Bhatia and Ms Kaur suggests much less culpability on Mr Bhatia’s part than the version put to the court. The implication of this was clearly that the incident in 2012 was less serious than the court had been led to believe, and that the convictions should therefore figure less significantly in weighing whether Mr Bhatia is of good character. The principle however is well established that, as a general rule, the Tribunal cannot go behind the fact of a criminal conviction and question the basis upon which it was reached; rather it must accept the conviction and the essential findings of fact on which it was based. In Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs v Ali [2000] FCA 1385 the Federal Court considered a contested prior conviction of the applicant in the context of the power to deport in s 200 of the Act. It determined (at [41]-[43]):41 First, it seems to me to be clear beyond argument that the administrative decision maker is entitled to receive evidence of a conviction and sentence and to treat it as probative of the factual matters upon which the conviction and sentence were necessarily based... 42 Secondly, the overwhelming weight of authority is that where the conviction and sentence are the foundation of the exercise of the power vested in the applicant by s 200 of the Act, the Tribunal, when reviewing the decision of the Minister, may not impugn or go behind either the conviction or the sentence... 43 Thirdly, although there is no absolute rule that the Tribunal may not consider material which challenges the grounds on which a prior conviction was based …, policy considerations suggest that the legislature intended that the Act, to the extent that it is concerned with the control in the public interest of the presence of non-citizens in Australia who have been convicted of criminal offences, should be administered in a way which: (a) recognises that the criminal justice system is pre-eminently suited to the determination of the guilt of persons charged with criminal offences …; and (b) limits inconsistency between decisions of the criminal courts and those of tribunals... As a consequence, in my view, the Act should be construed as requiring a decision maker under s 200 of the Act to treat a conviction and sentence (not being the conviction and sentence upon which the power to deport is based) as strong prima facie evidence of the facts upon which they are necessarily based so as to throw a heavy onus on a person who seeks to challenge such facts to show why they should not be accepted... [References omitted]