GPG18 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs
Link copied
CaseCopied
31 min read
Full text
FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA
(DIVISION 2)
GPG18 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2024] FedCFamC2G 1120
File number(s):
ADG 506 of 2018
Judgment of:
JUDGE LUCEV
Date of judgment:
31 October 2024
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Judicial review application - decision of the Immigration Assessment Authority – citizen of Vietnam of the Catholic faith – claims of persecution on the basis of religion, Australian Government data breach and asylum seeker status – single unparticularised ground of review – whether jurisdictional error otherwise – whether material jurisdictional error
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Application for adjournment – whether right to legal representation – other factors – length of time in the Court’s lists – further delay before hearing – backlog of unheard cases – length of time in which legal representation might have been obtained – where proper explanation of processes and nature of proceedings provided at earlier directions hearing.
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read GPG18 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultu... and more:
GPG18, a citizen of Vietnam who arrived in Australia in 2013, is the applicant in this judicial review case against the Minister for Home Affairs, Immigration and Multicultural Affairs. The applicant is challenging the decision of the Immigration Assessment Authority to affirm a decision of the delegate not to grant him a Safe Haven Enterprise (Class XE) visa. The primary issue before the court was whether there was a jurisdictional error in the Authority's decision. The Minister argued that no jurisdictional error was identified in the application and that the Authority's decision was based on an accurate summary of the applicant's claims and the evidence provided.
The court found that the applicant's claims were indeed addressed by the Authority, and the findings and conclusions reached were open to the Authority on the evidence presented. The court also noted that the applicant had not asserted a specific jurisdictional error, and the single ground of review was insufficiently particularised. Additionally, the court rejected the applicant's request for an adjournment to brief a lawyer, stating that there is no right to legal representation in migration proceedings in the Federal Court. The court found that the applicant's claims did not meet the refugee or complementary protection criteria, and therefore, they did not satisfy the family unit criterion.
In conclusion, the court dismissed the judicial review application, affirming the decision of the Immigration Assessment Authority. The court found that no jurisdictional error was apparent in the Authority's decision, and the applicant's claims did not meet the necessary criteria for a Safe Haven Enterprise visa. The court denied the request for an adjournment, finding that the applicant's assertion of a right to legal representation was based on a false premise.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Before the Court is an application for judicial review (“Judicial Review Application”) filed by the applicant, GPG18, on 14 December 2018. The Judicial Review Application is made under s 476(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“Migration Act”). The Judicial Review Application seeks judicial review of a decision made by the Immigration Assessment Authority (“Authority Decision” and “Authority” respectively) to affirm a decision of a delegate (“Delegate’s Decision” and “Delegate” respectively) of the first respondent, now the Minister for Home Affairs, Immigration and Multicultural Affairs, Cyber Security and the Arts (“Minister”), not to grant GPG18 a Safe Haven Enterprise (Class XE) (Subclass 790) visa (“SHE Visa”). The Authority Decision appears in the Court Book (“CB”) at CB 153-166.BACKGROUND The background to the matter prior to the Authority Decision is as follows:(a)GPG18 is a citizen of Vietnam who arrived in Australia at Christmas Island on 8 May 2013 as an unauthorised maritime arrival, and was accompanied by his brother-in-law and sister: CB 40 and 60;(b)on 30 May 2017 GPG18’s brother-in-law lodged a SHE Visa application, which included GPG18 as a secondary applicant: CB 20-62;(c)in a statement dated 28 February 2017 annexed to his brother-in-law’s SHE Visa application GPG18 claimed to fear harm from the Vietnamese authorities because of his Catholic faith, as a member of his brother-in-law’s family who were members of a religious Catholic group targeted by police, and his status as someone who had departed Vietnam illegally: CB 60-62. These claims were substantially similar to and reliant on the claims of his brother-in-law;(d)on 4 July 2017 the Department advised GPG18 that the Minister had exercised the power under s 46A(2) of the Migration Act to lift the bar in s 46A(1) of the Migration Act for the making of a valid visa application: CB 82;(e)on 22 February 2018 GPG18 attended an interview with the Delegate (“Delegate’s Interview”): CB 88;(f)following the Delegate’s Interview a submission was provided on 8 March 2018 by the brother-in-law on behalf of his family and GPG18 which provided further details on their claims: CB 98-112, and in which it was claimed that the personal details of the brother-in-law and “his family” were released online during a data breach by the Department in February 2014 which disclosed all their names (“2014 Data Breach”): CB 99 at [6];(g)on 12 October 2018 in a separate decision to that of his brother-in-law’s family, the Delegate refused to grant GPG18 a SHE Visa: CB 126-135. The Delegate:(i)was not satisfied that GPG18 was a person in respect of whom Australia had protection obligations under s 36(2)(a) or (aa) of the Migration Act; and (ii)found that GPG18 was not a member of the same family unit as a non-citizen who held a SHE Visa under s 36(2)(b) or (c) of the Migration Act; and(h)the matter was referred to the Authority pursuant to s 473CA of the Migration Act: CB 140-141.AUTHORITY DECISION
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
The background to the matter prior to the Authority Decision is as follows:(a)GPG18 is a citizen of Vietnam who arrived in Australia at Christmas Island on 8 May 2013 as an unauthorised maritime arrival, and was accompanied by his brother-in-law and sister: CB 40 and 60;(b)on 30 May 2017 GPG18’s brother-in-law lodged a SHE Visa application, which included GPG18 as a secondary applicant: CB 20-62;(c)in a statement dated 28 February 2017 annexed to his brother-in-law’s SHE Visa application GPG18 claimed to fear harm from the Vietnamese authorities because of his Catholic faith, as a member of his brother-in-law’s family who were members of a religious Catholic group targeted by police, and his status as someone who had departed Vietnam illegally: CB 60-62. These claims were substantially similar to and reliant on the claims of his brother-in-law;(d)on 4 July 2017 the Department advised GPG18 that the Minister had exercised the power under s 46A(2) of the Migration Act to lift the bar in s 46A(1) of the Migration Act for the making of a valid visa application: CB 82;(e)on 22 February 2018 GPG18 attended an interview with the Delegate (“Delegate’s Interview”): CB 88;(f)following the Delegate’s Interview a submission was provided on 8 March 2018 by the brother-in-law on behalf of his family and GPG18 which provided further details on their claims: CB 98-112, and in which it was claimed that the personal details of the brother-in-law and “his family” were released online during a data breach by the Department in February 2014 which disclosed all their names (“2014 Data Breach”): CB 99 at [6];(g)on 12 October 2018 in a separate decision to that of his brother-in-law’s family, the Delegate refused to grant GPG18 a SHE Visa: CB 126-135. The Delegate:(i)was not satisfied that GPG18 was a person in respect of whom Australia had protection obligations under s 36(2)(a) or (aa) of the Migration Act; and (ii)found that GPG18 was not a member of the same family unit as a non-citizen who held a SHE Visa under s 36(2)(b) or (c) of the Migration Act; and(h)the matter was referred to the Authority pursuant to s 473CA of the Migration Act: CB 140-141.AUTHORITY DECISION On 13 November 2018 the Authority Decision affirmed the Delegate’s Decision: CB 153-162. In the Authority Decision the Authority:(a)had regard to the material referred to it by the Secretary under s 473CB of the Migration Act, and noted that no new information had been obtained or received: CB 155 at [4];(b)accepted:(i)GPG18’s brother-in-law’s background as claimed and that he was a Catholic from a province in Vietnam: CB 156 at [6]-[7]; and(ii)that GPG18 was born in December 1998 and that he, his sister and his brother-in-law departed Vietnam using legally issued passports: CB 156 at [6];(c)recorded the inconsistencies and implausibility in GPG18’s brother-in-law’s evidence given at an entry interview, in the SHE Visa application and Delegate’s Interview, and:(i)was not satisfied that the brother-in-law had attended a prayer meeting on 1 July 2012 that was disrupted by the Vietnamese authorities;(ii)was not satisfied that the brother-in-law subsequently went into hiding, and that the brother-in-law’s children could not attend school because of their faith or that they were otherwise of interest to the Vietnamese authorities: CB 156-157 at [8]-[13]; and(iii)found that the brother-in-law’s claim regarding his attendance at the prayer meeting in July 2012 was fabricated and that he was not a witness of truth: CB 157 at [12];(d)based on its credibility findings above:(i)did not accept GPG18’s brother-in-law’s claim that he was the leader of a Catholic religious group, but accepted that it was plausible that he was a member: CB 158 at [14];(ii)did not accept that GPG18’s brother-in-law’s membership of the Catholic religious group was of any particular interest to the Vietnamese authorities, or that he was harassed, threatened or subjected to surveillance from 2006 onwards; and (iii)found that GPG18, his sister and brother-in-law were not prevented from practising their faith in Vietnam: CB 158 at [14];(e)found that GPG18’s brother-in-law had not undertaken anti-Vietnam government political activities in either Vietnam or Australia: CB 159 at [17](f)found that there was no evidence of harm or harassment due to the alleged “Catholic activism” of GPG18’s cousin, and found that GPG18, his sister and brother-in-law would not be harmed because of the cousin’s activities or incarceration: CB 159 at [17];(g)based on country information and the lack of evidence that suggested GPG18’s brother-in-law had to modify his religious practice or conceal his views to avoid harm:(i)found that the brother-in-law: (A)did not face a real chance of harm due to his Catholic faith: CB 159-160 at [20]; and(B)was not a religious activist and would not participate in religious activism on return to Vietnam: CB 160 at [21]; and (ii)was not satisfied that the brother-in-law faced a real chance of any harm on the basis that he would be considered a political activist: CB 160 at [21];(h)had serious doubts about the route GPG18, his sister and brother-in-law claimed to have taken prior to arriving in Australia, but accepted evidence that they departed Vietnam for Malaysia on legally issued passports, and found that their immigration records would indicate that they departed Vietnam legally: CB 158 at [15];(i)accepted that GPG18’s brother-in-law:(i)would have been affected by the 2014 Data Breach in that it may have revealed that he had sought asylum in Australia, and that he may be identifiable on re-entry as a person who sought asylum: CB 158 at [16]; and(ii)if returned to Vietnam involuntarily, the Vietnamese authorities would be aware that he was a failed asylum seeker: CB 160 at [22];(j)recorded that it was an offence under Vietnamese law to flee the country in order to oppose the Vietnamese Government, however, noting country information, did not accept that there was a real chance that GPG18’s brother-in-law would suffer harm on return to Vietnam or that his family would face a real chance of persecution: CB 160 at [22]-[23];(k)found that the brother-in-law’s children who were born in Australia would be regarded as Vietnamese citizens and rejected a claim that the children would not be allowed to live in Vietnam: CB 161 at [24];(l)based on a its cumulative assessment of the claims made, was not satisfied that GPG18, his sister and brother-in-law would face a real chance of serious harm on return to Vietnam: CB 161 at [25], and concluded that they did not: (i)satisfy the definition of refugee in s 5H of the Migration Act: and (ii)meet s 36(2)(a) of the Migration Act: CB 161 at [26];(m)relying on its anterior findings, was also not satisfied that there were substantial grounds for believing that, as a necessary and foreseeable consequence of being returned from Australia to Vietnam, there was a real risk that GPG18, his sister and brother-in-law would suffer significant harm, and concluded that they did not meet s 36(2)(aa) of the Migration Act: CB 162 at [29]-[30]; and(n)found that as none of GPG18, his sister and brother-in-law met the refugee or complementary protection criterion, it also found that they also did not meet the family unit criterion in either s 36(2)(b) or (c) of the Migration Act: CB 162 at [31]-[32].THE JUDICIAL REVIEW APPLICATIONGround
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Minister submitted that:(a)no jurisdictional error was asserted and none was sufficiently particularised to be the subject of a meaningful response, and that that was a basis for the sole ground of review in the Judicial Review Application to be dismissed;(b)the Authority had accurately summarised GPG18’s brother-in-law’s claims, and that the Authority Decision disclosed an active intellectual engagement with those claims, and the findings and conclusions ultimately reached in respect of those claims were open to the Authority on the evidence;(c)the claims made by GPG18 were addressed by the Authority; and(d)by reason of the foregoing no jurisdictional error had been demonstrated or was otherwise apparent.Consideration – application for adjournment As set out at [8(b), (c) and (d)] above, GPG18 sought, at hearing, an adjournment to enable him to brief a lawyer to provide further information and evidence to the Court. The Court refused to grant the adjournment, indicating that it would provide its reasons in these Reasons for Judgment: Transcript, 7 February 2024, p 4. Those reasons are set out hereunder. Insofar as the adjournment request relied upon the assertion in GPG18’s oral submissions that GPG18 was not aware of the reasons for the dismissal of his SHE Visa application: see [8(a)] above, that assertion is implausible in circumstances where: (a)the Authority Decision was sent to GPG18 at a postal address in Elizabeth South in the state of South Australia: CB 150, which is the same postal address as subsequently appears as the address for service on the Judicial Review Application and GPG18’s contemporaneously filed affidavit (“GPG18’s Affidavit”), and is the same postal address to which the Delegate’s Decision had earlier been sent: CB 122; and(b)the Authority Decision was annexed to GPG18’s Affidavit, and both GPG18’s Affidavit and the Judicial Review Application were signed by GPG18 personally.When pressed during submissions on this issue by the Court at the hearing: Transcript, 7 February 2024, pp 3-4, GPG18 ultimately said “I don’t remember accurately what happened”: Transcript, 7 February 2024, p 4. In making the request for an adjournment GPG18 relied upon the need for a lawyer to provide information and evidence to the Court on his behalf. If, in so doing, GPG18 assumed that there was a right to have a lawyer represent him in migration proceedings in this Court, then he proceeded upon a false premise. In SZHTI v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2006] FCA 702 (“SZHTI”) at [3]-[4] per Gyles J, the Federal Court observed as follows:3 The first paragraph of the affidavit in support of the application is:I was not given access to free legal advice which is commonly available to applicants through the NSW Legal Advice Scheme. I was denied natural justice at the Federal Magistrates Court.4That contention was put to the learned Federal Magistrate and, in my opinion there is no doubt about the correctness of the view he expressed that there is no right to free legal advice and that the fact that an adjournment was not granted to access free legal advice was not a denial of natural justice.