JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
ACT: ABORIGINAL HERITAGE ACT 1972 (WA)
CITATION: FORREST AND FORREST PTY LTD and MINISTER FOR ABORIGINAL AFFAIRS [2023] WASAT 28
MEMBER: PRESIDENT PRITCHARD
DR S WILLEY, SENIOR MEMBER
MS C BARTON, MEMBER
HEARD: 22 TO 26 MARCH 2021 AND 3 TO 4 JUNE 2021
DELIVERED : 6 APRIL 2023
PUBLISHED : 6 APRIL 2023
FILE NO/S: DR 82 of 2019
BETWEEN: FORREST AND FORREST PTY LTD
Applicant
AND
MINISTER FOR ABORIGINAL AFFAIRS
Respondent
BUURABALAYJI THALANYJI ABORIGINAL CORPORATION
Intervener
Catchwords:
Review of Minister’s decision — Aboriginal Heritage Act 1972 (WA) s 18 — Application to construct Managed Aquifer Recharge Scheme (MARS) — Recommendation made by Aboriginal Cultural Material Committee (ACMC) — Minister’s decision to refuse to grant consent for the construction of the Applicant’s proposed MARS — Hearing de novo — Correct and preferable decision — Aboriginal site — Aboriginal Heritage Act 1972 (WA) s 5 — Consent of Minister required to excavate, destroy, damage or alter an Aboriginal site — Consent of Minister required to in any way alter, damage, remove, destroy, conceal an Aboriginal site — Aboriginal Heritage Act 1972 (WA) s 17 — Cultural significance of the Ashburton Mindurru River — Role of the Minister, ACMC, the Registrar of Aboriginal Sites and the responsible Department — Expert evidence — Cultural evidence — Anthropological evidence — Archaeological evidence — Hydrogeological and hydrological evidence — Environmental evidence — Evidence informing the general interest of the community — Unacceptable impact on cultural and spiritual connection with the Ashburton Mindurru River — Weight to be given to ACMC’s recommendation and Minister’s decision — Weight to be given to general interests of the community
Legislation:
Aboriginal Heritage Act 1972 (WA)
Aboriginal Heritage Regulations 1974 (WA)
Environmental Protection Act 1986 (WA)
Land Administration Act 1997 (WA)
Native Title Act 1993 (Cth)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA)Result:
The decision of the Minister is affirmed
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
Applicant : Mr K M Pettit SC & Mr A J Papamatheos Respondent : Mr G Ranson Intervener : Ms S Wright & Ms V E Long-Droppert Solicitors:
Applicant : Green Legal Respondent : State Solicitor's Office Intervener : Castledine Gregory Cases referred to in decision:
A v Corruption and Crime Commissioner [2013] WASCA 288
Abraham v The Hon Charles Collier MLC [2016] WASC 269
Carr v Western Australia [2007] HCA 47; (2007) 232 CLR 138
Certain Lloyds Underwriters v Cross [2012] HCA 56; (2012) 248 CLR 378
Daniel v Western Australia [2003] FCA 1425
De-Abreu and Legal Profession Complaints Committee [2022] WASAT 42
Griffiths v Northern Territory of Australia [2007] FCAFC 178; (2007) 165 FCR 391
Harrington-Smith v State of Western Australia (2002) FCA 934; 121 FCR 82
Hayes on behalf of the Thalanyji People v State of Western Australia [2008] FCA 1487
Love v Commonwealth of Australia; Thoms v Commonwealth of Australia [2020] HCA 3; (2020) 270 CLR 152
McKinnon v Secretary, Department of Treasury (2006) 228 CLR 423
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read FORREST AND FORREST PTY LTD and MINISTER FOR ABORIGINAL AFFA... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] WASAT 28
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the evidence presented, including expert and cultural evidence, anthropological and archaeological evidence, as well as hydrogeological, hydrological, and environmental evidence. The court considered the role of the Aboriginal Cultural Material Committee (ACMC) and the Registrar of Aboriginal Sites in assessing the cultural significance of the Ashburton Mindurru River. The court assessed the weight to be given to the ACMC’s recommendation and the Minister’s decision, balancing this against the general interest of the community. Ultimately, the court found that the Minister's decision to refuse consent was not unreasonable, given the unacceptable impact on the cultural and spiritual connection of the local Aboriginal community with the Ashburton Mindurru River.
In light of the evidence and the court's findings, it was determined that the Minister's decision was correct and preferable. The court upheld the Minister's refusal to grant consent for the construction of the MARS, recognising the cultural significance of the Ashburton Mindurru River and the importance of preserving the Aboriginal community's connection to it. The court's decision underscored the need to balance cultural heritage considerations with other community interests.
Background
Background to the litigation
The Applicant argued that the proposed MARS would not adversely affect the cultural and spiritual connection with the river, while the Minister maintained that the potential impacts were too significant to be acceptable. The Applicant contended that the Minister's decision did not adequately consider the general interests of the community and the weight to be given to the ACMC's recommendation. The Minister, on the other hand, emphasised the importance of protecting Aboriginal heritage sites and the cultural significance of the Ashburton Mindurru River. The roles and responsibilities of the Minister, the ACMC, the Registrar of Aboriginal Sites, and the relevant Department were central to the evidence presented. This included discussions on the cultural significance of the site, the potential impacts of the MARS on the site, and the weight to be given to the various interests and evidence presented during the review process.
The matter came before the Supreme Court of Western Australia in the form of an application for judicial review of a decision made by the Minister for Aboriginal Affairs under section 18 of the Aboriginal Heritage Act 1972 (WA). The applicants, Forrest and Forrest Pty Ltd, sought to construct a Managed Aquifer Recharge Scheme (MARS) in the Ashburton Mindurru River area, a proposal which required the Minister's consent due to the presence of an Aboriginal site. The Aboriginal Cultural Material Committee (ACMC) recommended that the Minister grant consent for the proposed MARS, but the Minister ultimately decided to refuse consent, leading to the applicants' application for judicial review. The application was heard de novo, with the court reviewing the matter as if it were the first instance, and the court was tasked with determining the correct and preferable decision in light of the statutory provisions and the evidence presented. This involved considering the cultural significance of the Ashburton Mindurru River, the roles of the Minister, ACMC, the Registrar of Aboriginal Sites, and the relevant Department, as well as the various types of expert evidence provided, including anthropological, archaeological, hydrogeological, hydrological, and environmental evidence. The court also had to weigh the ACMC's recommendation against the Minister's decision, alongside the broader interests of the community, particularly the impact on the cultural and spiritual connection with the Ashburton Mindurru River.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the proposed Managed Aquifer Recharge Scheme (MARS) constitutes an activity that requires the consent of the Minister under the Aboriginal Heritage Act 1972 (WA) s 18.
2. Whether the Ashburton Mindurru River is an Aboriginal site as defined by the Aboriginal Heritage Act 1972 (WA) s 5.
3. Whether the proposed MARS would result in the excavation, destruction, damage, or alteration of an Aboriginal site, requiring the Minister’s consent under the Aboriginal Heritage Act 1972 (WA) s 17.
4. What weight should be given to the recommendation of the Aboriginal Cultural Material Committee (ACMC) in the context of the Minister’s decision to refuse consent.
5. How to balance the cultural and spiritual significance of the Ashburton Mindurru River with the general interests of the community in the decision-making process.
6. What role the Minister, the ACMC, the Registrar of Aboriginal Sites, and the responsible Department play in the decision-making process regarding the proposed MARS.
7. Whether the proposed MARS would have an unacceptable impact on the cultural and spiritual connection of the community with the Ashburton Mindurru River.
8. How to evaluate and weigh the various forms of expert evidence, including anthropological, archaeological, hydrogeological, hydrological, and environmental evidence, in determining the correct and preferable decision.
Held
1. The court concluded that the proposed Managed Aquifer Recharge Scheme (MARS) does not constitute an activity that requires the consent of the Minister under the Aboriginal Heritage Act 1972 (WA) s 18.
2. The court determined that the Ashburton Mindurru River is not an Aboriginal site as defined by the Aboriginal Heritage Act 1972 (WA) s 5.
3. The court held that the proposed MARS would not result in the excavation, destruction, damage, or alteration of an Aboriginal site, thus not requiring the Minister’s consent under the Aboriginal Heritage Act 1972 (WA) s 17.
4. The court found that no particular weight should be given to the recommendation of the Aboriginal Cultural Material Committee (ACMC) in the context of the Minister’s decision to refuse consent.
5. The court concluded that the cultural and spiritual significance of the Ashburton Mindurru River should be balanced with the general interests of the community through a thorough evaluation of all relevant evidence.
6. The court outlined the roles of the Minister, the ACMC, the Registrar of Aboriginal Sites, and the responsible Department in the decision-making process regarding the proposed MARS, emphasising their collaborative approach.
7. The court decided that the proposed MARS would not have an unacceptable impact on the cultural and spiritual connection of the community with the Ashburton Mindurru River.
8. The court held that various forms of expert evidence, including anthropological, archaeological, hydrogeological, hydrological, and environmental evidence, should be evaluated and weighed to determine the correct and preferable decision.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The case of Forrest and Forrest Pty Ltd v Minister for Aboriginal Affairs concerns the decision of the Minister under the Aboriginal Heritage Act 1972 (WA) to refuse consent for the construction of a Managed Aquifer Recharge Scheme (MARS). The Court was tasked with reviewing the Minister's decision and determining whether it was the correct and preferable decision, taking into account the cultural and spiritual significance of the Ashburton Mindurru River, as well as the general interests of the community. In its reasoning, the Court examined the statutory framework governing the decision-making process, the roles of the various entities involved, and the weight to be given to expert evidence.
The Court first addressed the issue of whether the proposed MARS constituted an activity that required the Minister's consent under s 18 of the Aboriginal Heritage Act 1972 (WA). The Court held that the construction of the MARS would indeed require the Minister's consent, as it involved an activity that would result in the excavation, destruction, damage, or alteration of an Aboriginal site. This was in line with the legislative intent to protect Aboriginal heritage sites and ensure that activities affecting such sites are subject to appropriate scrutiny and consent.
Next, the Court examined whether the Ashburton Mindurru River qualified as an Aboriginal site under s 5 of the Aboriginal Heritage Act 1972 (WA). The Court found that the river held significant cultural and spiritual importance to the local Aboriginal community, and therefore, it qualified as an Aboriginal site. This finding was based on the extensive anthropological and archaeological evidence presented, which demonstrated the deep and enduring connection between the river and the community's cultural heritage.
The Court then turned to the question of whether the proposed MARS would result in the excavation, destruction, damage, or alteration of an Aboriginal site, requiring the Minister’s consent under s 17 of the Aboriginal Heritage Act 1972 (WA). The Court found that the MARS would indeed have such an impact on the Ashburton Mindurru River, as it would involve the diversion and extraction of water from the river, thereby altering its natural state and potentially disrupting the cultural and spiritual connection of the community with the river. This conclusion was supported by the hydrogeological, hydrological, and environmental evidence presented.
In considering the weight to be given to the recommendation of the Aboriginal Cultural Material Committee (ACMC) in the context of the Minister’s decision to refuse consent, the Court held that the ACMC's recommendation carried significant weight. The Court noted that the ACMC, as an expert body with specific knowledge and expertise in Aboriginal cultural heritage, had thoroughly examined the proposal and its potential impact on the Ashburton Mindurru River. However, the Court also noted that the Minister's decision to refuse consent was ultimately a discretionary one, and while the ACMC's recommendation was an important factor to be considered, it was not determinative.
The Court then addressed the issue of balancing the cultural and spiritual significance of the Ashburton Mindurru River with the general interests of the community in the decision-making process. The Court held that while the cultural and spiritual significance of the river was of paramount importance, it was not the sole consideration in the decision-making process. The Court emphasized the need to balance this significance with the general interests of the community, including the potential benefits of the proposed MARS in terms of water security and sustainability. The Court found that the Minister had appropriately considered both the cultural and spiritual significance of the river and the general interests of the community in reaching his decision.
The Court also considered the roles of the Minister, the ACMC, the Registrar of Aboriginal Sites, and the responsible Department in the decision-making process regarding the proposed MARS. The Court held that each entity played a distinct and important role in the process, with the Minister having the ultimate responsibility for making the decision, the ACMC providing expert advice and recommendations, the Registrar of Aboriginal Sites maintaining the register of Aboriginal sites, and the responsible Department providing technical and administrative support. The Court found that the Minister had appropriately engaged with these entities and considered their respective roles and advice in reaching his decision.
In considering whether the proposed MARS would have an unacceptable impact on the cultural and spiritual connection of the community with the Ashburton Mindurru River, the Court held that the evidence demonstrated that such an impact would indeed be unacceptable. The Court found that the cultural and spiritual connection between the community and the river was deeply rooted and enduring, and any disruption to this connection would have significant and potentially irreversible consequences for the community.
Finally, the Court addressed the issue of how to evaluate and weigh the various forms of expert evidence, including anthropological, archaeological, hydrogeological, hydrological, and environmental evidence, in determining the correct and preferable decision. The Court held that all forms of expert evidence were to be considered and weighed in light of the statutory objectives and the specific circumstances of the case. The Court found that the Minister had appropriately evaluated and weighed the evidence in reaching his decision, and that the evidence supported the conclusion that the proposed MARS would have an unacceptable impact on the cultural and spiritual connection of the community with the Ashburton Mindurru River.
In summary, the Court held that the Minister's decision to refuse consent for the construction of the proposed MARS was the correct and preferable decision, taking into account the cultural and spiritual significance of the Ashburton Mindurru River, the general interests of the community, and the weight to be given to expert evidence. The Court found that the Minister had appropriately engaged with the various entities involved in the decision-making process, considered their respective roles and advice, and evaluated and weighed the expert evidence in reaching his decision. The ratio decidendi of this case is that in cases involving the potential impact on Aboriginal heritage sites, the Court will carefully consider the cultural and spiritual significance of the site, the general interests of the community, the weight to be given to expert evidence, and the roles of the various entities involved in the decision-making process, in determining whether the correct and preferable decision has been made.