Court of Appeal
Supreme Court
New South Wales
- Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Fairfax Media Publications v Zeccola [2015] NSWCA 329 Hearing dates: 11 November 2014, final submissions 14 April 2015 Date of orders: 23 October 2015 Decision date: 23 October 2015 Before: McColl JA at [1]; Macfarlan JA at [112]; Sackville AJA at [113]. Decision: (1) Grant leave to appeal;
(2) Appellants to file the notice of appeal in the form of the draft appearing in the White Book at page 34 within seven days;
(3) Appeal allowed in part;
(4) Set aside order 1 made by McCallum J on 13 March 2014 insofar as her Honour struck out the appellants’ contextual imputations 19(a)(i), and (v), 27(a)(i) and (v) and 35(a)(i) and (v);
(5) Respondents to pay fifty per cent of the appellants’ costs and have a certificate under the Suitors’ Fund Act 1951 (NSW) if otherwise qualified.Catchwords: TORTS – defamation – defence of contextual truth – s 26, Defamation Act 2005 (NSW) – plaintiffs pleaded imputations of not returning profits, withholding returns and dishonouring distribution commitments –defendants pleaded contextual imputations of general financial default – whether contextual imputations must differ from plaintiff’s imputations in kind as well as in substance – whether “differ in substance test” is a sufficient exposition of s 26 – whether defendants’ imputations capable of being “other imputations” carried “in addition to” appellants’ imputations
TORTS – defamation – defence of contextual truth under s 26, Defamation Act 2005 (NSW) – whether imputation capable of being carried – imputation of “reasonable suspicion” – holder of “reasonable suspicion” not identified – matters complained of did not refer to any person or authority holding “reasonable suspicion”
TORTS – defamation – practice and procedure – whether appropriate to strike out contextual imputations prior to trialLegislation Cited: Civil Law (Wrongs) Act 2002 (ACT)
Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW)
Defamation Act 1974 (NSW)
Defamation Act 2005 (NSW)
Defamation Act 2005 (Vic)
Suitors’ Fund Act 1951 (NSW)Cases Cited: Alcan (NT) Alumina Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Territory Revenue [2009] HCA 41; (2009) 239 CLR 27
Allen v John Fairfax & Sons (Supreme Court (NSW) Hunt J, 2 December 1988, unrep)
Amalgamated Television Services v Marsden (1998) 43 NSWLR 158
Ange v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd [2010] NSWSC 745
Ange v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd & Ors [2011] NSWSC 204
Bateman v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd (No 2) [2014] NSWSC 1380
Bateman v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd (No 3) [2014] NSWSC 1601
Born Brands Pty Ltd v Nine Network Australia Pty Ltd [2013] NSWSC 1651
Born Brands Pty Ltd v Nine Network Australia Pty Ltd [2014] NSWCA 369; (2014) 88 NSWLR 421
Crosby v Kelly [2013] FCA 1343
David Syme & Co Ltd v Hore-Lacy [2000] VSCA 24; [2000] 1 VR 667
Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd v Bateman [2015] NSWCA 154
Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd v Kermode [2011] NSWCA 174; (2011) 81 NSWLR 157
Greig v WIN Television NSW…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd v Zeccola and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] NSWCA 329
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether the imputations relied upon for the defence of contextual truth, as provided by section 26 of the *Defamation Act 2005* (NSW), must differ in kind as well as in substance from the imputations pleaded by the plaintiffs. The court also considered whether the "differ in substance test" was a sufficient exposition of section 26, and whether the imputations pleaded by the defendants were capable of being "other imputations" carried "in addition to" the plaintiffs' imputations. Furthermore, the court had to determine if an imputation of "reasonable suspicion" could be pleaded in defence, particularly when the holder of that suspicion was not identified. Finally, the court considered whether it was appropriate to strike out these contextual imputations prior to trial.
The Court of Appeal held that section 26 of the *Defamation Act 2005* (NSW) requires that the contextual imputations must differ in substance from the imputations pleaded by the plaintiff, but not necessarily in kind. The court found that the "differ in substance test" was a sufficient exposition of the section. The court also determined that the imputations of general financial default pleaded by the appellants were capable of being "other imputations" carried in addition to those pleaded by the respondents. However, the court agreed that an imputation of "reasonable suspicion" where the holder of the suspicion is not identified is not capable of being pleaded as a contextual imputation.
The appeal was allowed in part. The order of McCallum J striking out certain of the appellants' contextual imputations was set aside. The respondents were ordered to pay fifty per cent of the appellants' costs, with a certificate under the *Suitors’ Fund Act 1951* (NSW) available if otherwise qualified.
Orders
Orders of the court
(1) Grant leave to appeal;
(2) Appellants to file the notice of appeal in the form of the draft appearing in the White Book at page 34 within seven days;
(3) Appeal allowed in part;
(4) Set aside order 1 made by McCallum J on 13 March 2014 insofar as her Honour struck out the appellants’ contextual imputations 19(a)(i), and (v), 27(a)(i) and (v) and 35(a)(i) and (v);
(5) Respondents to pay fifty per cent of the appellants’ costs and have a certificate under the Suitors’ Fund Act 1951 (NSW) if otherwise qualified.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case emerged from articles published by Zeccola, the defendants, in Fairfax Media's publications. The plaintiffs, Fairfax Media, claimed these articles defamed them by implying unethical financial practices. The defendants argued their articles were truthful and necessary to provide context, a defence permissible under section 26 of the Defamation Act. The central issue was whether the defendants' contextual imputations differed sufficiently from the plaintiffs' imputations. The plaintiffs argued the contextual imputations should differ both in kind and substance, while the defendants maintained that a difference in substance alone was sufficient.
The defendants also introduced the concept of a "reasonable suspicion" as an imputation. They argued that their articles conveyed a sense of reasonable suspicion regarding the plaintiffs' financial practices. However, the plaintiffs contended that no person or authority holding such a reasonable suspicion was identified in the articles. This led to a debate over whether an imputation of reasonable suspicion could be considered when the source of the suspicion was not specified.
The case reached the court, which had to determine whether it was appropriate to strike out the defendants' contextual imputations before trial. The trial judge, McCallum J, struck out certain contextual imputations, which the defendants appealed. The appeal court had to decide whether the trial judge’s decision to strike out the imputations was correct, and whether the imputation of reasonable suspicion could be valid under the circumstances. The court's decision to allow the appeal in part and set aside the trial judge's order highlighted the contentious nature of these factual disputes.
The matter of Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd v Zeccola originated in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, where the appellants, Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd and others, sought to establish a defamation case against the respondents, including Zeccola. The trial judge, McCallum J, dismissed the plaintiffs' claims on the basis that the defendants had successfully raised the defence of contextual truth under section 26 of the Defamation Act 2005 (NSW). The appellants then filed an application in the Court of Appeal, seeking leave to appeal against the trial judge's decision. The Court of Appeal granted leave to appeal and subsequently heard the matter on its merits. During the appeal, the appellants challenged the trial judge's ruling that certain contextual imputations were struck out, arguing that these imputations were necessary to establish the defence of contextual truth. The Court of Appeal ultimately allowed the appeal in part, setting aside the trial judge's order that struck out specific contextual imputations and remitting the matter back to the trial court for further proceedings.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether contextual imputations must differ from plaintiff’s imputations in kind as well as in substance to satisfy s 26 of the Defamation Act 2005 (NSW).
2. Whether the “differ in substance test” is a sufficient interpretation of s 26 of the Defamation Act 2005 (NSW).
3. Whether the defendants’ imputations are capable of being considered “other imputations” carried “in addition to” the plaintiffs’ imputations under s 26 of the Defamation Act 2005 (NSW).
4. Whether an imputation of “reasonable suspicion” can be considered a defamatory imputation under s 26 of the Defamation Act 2005 (NSW) when the holder of the “reasonable suspicion” is not identified and the matters complained of do not refer to any person or authority holding such suspicion.
5. Whether it is appropriate to strike out contextual imputations prior to trial in defamation cases under the Defamation Act 2005 (NSW).
Held
1. Whether contextual imputations must differ from plaintiff’s imputations in kind as well as in substance to satisfy s 26 of the Defamation Act 2005 (NSW). The court concluded that contextual imputations must differ in kind from the plaintiff's imputations. Appeal allowed in part in relation to this issue.
2. Whether the “differ in substance test” is a sufficient interpretation of s 26 of the Defamation Act 2005 (NSW). The court held that the “differ in substance test” is not a sufficient interpretation of s 26 of the Defamation Act 2005 (NSW). Appeal allowed in part in relation to this issue.
3. Whether the defendants’ imputations are capable of being considered “other imputations” carried “in addition to” the plaintiffs’ imputations under s 26 of the Defamation Act 2005 (NSW). The court concluded that the defendants' imputations were not capable of being considered “other imputations” carried “in addition to” the plaintiffs' imputations. Appeal allowed in part in relation to this issue.
4. Whether an imputation of “reasonable suspicion” can be considered a defamatory imputation under s 26 of the Defamation Act 2005 (NSW) when the holder of the “reasonable suspicion” is not identified and the matters complained of do not refer to any person or authority holding such suspicion. The court concluded that an imputation of “reasonable suspicion” cannot be considered a defamatory imputation under s 26 of the Defamation Act 2005 (NSW) in these circumstances. Appeal allowed in part in relation to this issue.
5. Whether it is appropriate to strike out contextual imputations prior to trial in defamation cases under the Defamation Act 2005 (NSW). The court concluded that it is not appropriate to strike out contextual imputations prior to trial in defamation cases under the Defamation Act 2005 (NSW). Appeal allowed in part in relation to this issue.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The reasoning of the court in Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd v Zeccola begins with the examination of whether contextual imputations must differ from the plaintiff’s imputations both in kind and in substance to satisfy section 26 of the Defamation Act 2005 (NSW). The court explored the statutory language of s 26, which provides a defence to a defamation claim if the imputations are "other imputations" carried "in addition to" those pleaded by the plaintiff. In this case, the plaintiffs pleaded imputations of not returning profits, withholding returns, and dishonouring distribution commitments. The defendants, however, pleaded contextual imputations of general financial default. The court assessed whether the contextual imputations need to differ in kind and substance from the plaintiff's imputations to qualify as "other imputations" under s 26.
The court examined the established jurisprudence on the interpretation of s 26, particularly the "differ in substance test" as previously applied. It deliberated whether this test was sufficient to encompass the requirements of the statute. The court referenced prior cases to understand how the "differ in substance test" had been applied and evaluated whether this test adequately covered the intent of the legislation. The court concluded that while the "differ in substance test" had been applied, it was not the exclusive test and that the contextual imputations needed to be more than just substantially different; they had to be genuinely additional and distinct from the plaintiff’s imputations.
In addressing whether the defendants’ imputations could be considered "other imputations" carried "in addition to" the plaintiffs’ imputations, the court considered the nature and scope of the imputations. The court found that the imputations of general financial default, as pleaded by the defendants, were not sufficiently distinct from the plaintiffs’ imputations of specific financial misconduct. The court held that the imputations must not only differ in substance but also in kind to be considered "other imputations" under s 26. The court’s interpretation underscored the necessity for contextual imputations to provide additional information or perspectives that go beyond what is already pleaded by the plaintiff.
Another significant issue was whether an imputation of "reasonable suspicion" could be considered defamatory under s 26 when the holder of the "reasonable suspicion" was not identified, and the matters complained of did not refer to any person or authority holding such suspicion. The court deliberated on the meaning of "reasonable suspicion" and its potential to cause defamation. It examined the statutory context and the requirement for the imputation to be reasonably capable of being carried in the published material. The court concluded that an imputation of "reasonable suspicion" could indeed be defamatory if it was reasonably capable of being carried, but in this instance, the lack of identification of the holder and the absence of reference to any person or authority holding such suspicion undermined the capacity for the imputation to be defamatory.
Lastly, the court considered the appropriateness of striking out contextual imputations prior to trial in defamation cases under the Defamation Act 2005 (NSW). The court reviewed the practice and procedure for dealing with contextual imputations in defamation litigation and assessed the timing and circumstances under which such imputations could be struck out. The court noted that while it is within the trial judge's discretion to strike out pleadings, this should be done judiciously to ensure that all relevant defences are preserved for trial. In this case, the court found that the trial judge had prematurely struck out certain contextual imputations without adequately considering their potential relevance and the broader defences available under s 26.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that contextual imputations under s 26 of the Defamation Act 2005 (NSW) must differ in kind as well as in substance from the plaintiffs’ imputations to be considered "other imputations" carried "in addition to" the plaintiffs’ imputations. The court departed from the previous understanding that the "differ in substance test" alone was sufficient, emphasizing the need for contextual imputations to provide genuinely additional information. Furthermore, the court held that an imputation of "reasonable suspicion" could be considered defamatory if reasonably capable of being carried, but such imputations must be clearly identified and relevant to the published material. Lastly, the court underscored the importance of preserving all relevant defences and cautioned against premature striking out of contextual imputations prior to trial.