Background
Background to the litigation
The following materials are before the Court:(a)the Originating Application and Statement of Claim filed by the FWO on 10 September 2021;(b)the Defences and Responses of Su and Yuxuan Group filed on 19 November 2021;(c)the Statement of Agreed Facts filed by the FWO on 24 March 2022 (which was marked as Exhibit 1 in the proceedings);(d)the affidavit of a Fair Work Inspector, James Roberts, affirmed 17 May 2022 (“Roberts Affidavit”);(e)the affidavits of Su affirmed 13 July and 18 November 2022 (“Su July 2022 Affidavit” and “Su November 2922” Affidavit respectively);(f)outlines of submissions from the FWO dated 5 August and 10 October 2022;(g)an outline of submissions from Su dated 13 September 2022;(h)an extract from the Domain.com.au website in respect of a property in Campbelltown, South Australia (which was marked as Exhibit 2 in the proceedings); and(i)the Transcript of the proceedings on 24 November 2022 (“Transcript”), which the Court has read and referred to in the course of preparing these Reasons for Judgment.THE STATEMENT OF AGREED FACTS The Statement of Agreed Facts provides as follows:A. INTRODUCTION1.This Statement of Agreed Facts (Statement) is made by the Applicant and the Second Respondent for the purposes of section 191 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth).2.The Second Respondent admits that she was involved in, within the meaning of section 550 of the FW Act, the contraventions specified in Part G of this Statement.B. PARTIES The Applicant3.The Applicant is and was at all relevant times a:(a)statutory appointee of the Commonwealth appointed by the Governor-General by written instrument pursuant to section 687(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act);(b) Fair Work Inspector pursuant to section 701 of the FW Act; and (c)person with standing under section 539(2) of the FW Act to apply for orders in relation to contraventions of civil remedy provisions of the FW Act.The First Respondent 4.Yuxuan Group Pty Ltd (Yuxuan Group), is and was at all relevant times:(a)incorporated under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) since 12 September 2017;(b) a company with a registered business name ‘FUNTEA’;(c)the company that owned and operated takeaway fast food outlets trading under the name ‘FUNTEA’ at the following locations in South Australia: (i)shop 3, 31-39 Gouger Street, Adelaide (Fun Tea Chinatown);(ii)shop LG.21, 100 Rundle Mall, Adelaide (Fun Tea David Jones); and(iii) 6-10 York Street, Adelaide (Fun Tea Rundle Mall);(collectively, Fun Tea Stores); (d)a ‘constitutional corporation’ within the meaning of section 12 of the FW Act;(e)a company that employed individuals to work in the Fun Tea Stores; and (f)by reason of subparagraphs (d) and (e), a ‘national system employer’ within the meaning of section 14 of the FW Act.5.On 19 November 2021, Yuxuan Group entered into liquidation by passage of a resolution for voluntary winding up. Pursuant to section 500(2) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), the proceedings as against Yuxuan Group are stayed. Fun Tea Stores6.At all relevant times, Fun Tea Chinatown was open to the public between 11:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m. on Monday to Sunday.7.At all relevant times, Fun Tea David Jones was open to the public between:(a) 10:30 a.m. to 4:00 p.m. Monday to Friday;(b) 11:30 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. on Saturday; and(c) 12:00 p.m. to 5:00 p.m. on Sunday.8.At all relevant times, Fun Tea Rundle Mall was open to the public between 11:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m. on Monday to Sunday.The Second Respondent 9.The Second Respondent, Ms Yang Su, is and was at all relevant times: (a) a director of Yuxuan Group between 1 July 2019 and 1 April 2021;(b) in respect of Yuxuan Group’s employees, a person responsible for:(i) providing rosters;(ii) paying wages;(iii) making and keeping records relating to Yuxuan Group’s employees’ hours of work; and (iv)making and keeping records relating to the amounts paid to Yuxuan Group’s employees for the performance of work; (c)responsible for ensuring that Yuxuan Group complied with its legal obligations under the FW Act;(d)by reason of section 793(1) of the FW Act, a person whose conduct as specified in this Statement, was conduct engaged in by Yuxuan Group; and (e)by reason of section 793(2) of the FW Act, a person whose state of mind was the state of mind of Yuxuan Group for the purposes of the matters specified in this Statement. C. LEGISLATION AND MODERN AWARD10.At all material times, Yuxuan Group was required to comply with the FW Act and the Fair Work Regulations 2009 (FW Regulations) in relation to its employment of employees at the Fun Tea Stores.11.At all material times, the Fast Food Industry Award 2010 (Fast Food Award) covered and applied to Yuxuan Group in relation to its employment of employees at the Fun Tea Stores.D. THE INVESTIGATION12.The Applicant commenced an investigation into Yuxuan Group on or about 3 February 2021.13.On 8 February 2021, Townsends Solicitors acting on behalf of Yuxuan Group sent a letter to Fair Work Inspector (FWI) Dale Woods advising that Yuxuan Group had underpaid staff.14.On 19 February 2021, FWI James Roberts sent a letter to Yuxuan Group and the Second Respondent, advising them that the Applicant was investigating whether Yuxuan Group had breached the FW Act, including potential contraventions of sections 535 and 536 of the FW Act. The letter also invited the Second Respondent to participate in a recorded interview, in her capacity as a director of Yuxuan Group, in relation to the potential contraventions and the involvement of any individuals or entities as an accessory to those contraventions.15.Also on 19 February 2021, FWI Roberts issued a Notice to Produce Records or Documents pursuant to section 712 of the FW Act (NTP) to Yuxuan Group seeking the production of various categories of employment records, including records containing the name, start date and status of each of the Employees (as defined in paragraph 19 below), and copies of any pay slips held by Yuxuan Group.16.On 12 March 2021, Townsends Solicitors on behalf of Yuxuan Group responded to the NTP by providing documents to the Applicant, including rosters and copies of records of payments made to the Employees. The records provided did not include records containing the name, start date and status of each the Employees, or copies of any pay slips.17.On 28 April 2021, the Second Respondent participated in an interview conducted by the Applicant with FWI Kristen Walsh and FWI Roberts. In the course of the interview the Second Respondent discussed her role in finalising and distributing rosters for Yuxuan Group via WeChat group chats with the Employees, and her practice of attending the Fun Tea Stores to pay wages to the Employees. 18.On 8 June 2021, FWI Roberts issued a Findings of Contravention letter (Findings Letter) to Yuxuan Group which set out identified contraventions by Yuxuan Group of the Fast Food Award and the FW Act. The Findings Letter noted that the Applicant may commence proceedings against Yuxuan Group and any individuals involved in the identified contraventions.E.THE EMPLOYEES19.Yuxuan Group employed the individuals set out in Schedule A (Employees):(a)in the case of Siew Lee See, during the period from 29 July 2019 to 13 August 2019; and (b)otherwise, on the dates specified in column C of Schedule A during the period from 6 April 2020 to 18 February 2021 (Second Assessment Period);(collectively, Assessment Periods). 20.At all relevant times during the Assessment Periods, each of the Employees was a ‘national system employee’ within the meaning of section 13 of the FW Act.21.During the Second Assessment Period, the following Employees were in Australia on visas:(a) Huaxuan Du;(b) Shan Shan Kyaw Min Kahn;(c) Yikun Peng;(d) Danlin Cheng;(e) Danni Yang; and (f) Yingyi Ou.Status of Employees 22.During the Second Assessment Period, Keyu Deng and Jun Song:(a)were engaged by Yuxuan Group to work an average of 38 hours per week on an ongoing basis; and accordingly,(b)were each engaged as full time employees pursuant to clause 11 of the Fast Food Award. 23.During the Assessment Periods, each of the Employees listed in rows 1 to 18 of Schedule A (Casual Employees):(a) were engaged by Yuxuan Group: (i) on the basis of the hours that they were available to work; and (ii)without any offer made of a firm advance commitment to continuing and indefinite work according to an agreed pattern of work;(b) worked hours which varied from week to week; and therefore,(c)were engaged on a casual basis pursuant to section 15A(1) of the FW Act and clause 13 of the Fast Food Award.Hours and overtime hours worked 24.During the Assessment Periods, the Employees performed work at the Fun Tea Stores:(a) according to a weekly roster;(b)on the days of the week and within the hours that the Fun Tea Stores were open to the public as admitted in paragraphs 6 to 8 above; and(c)on some occasions, outside of the hours the Fun Tea Stores were open to the public.25.During the Assessment Periods:(a)Keyu Deng and Jun Song performed hours of work that were considered overtime hours pursuant to clause 26.2(a) of the Fast Food Award; and(b)the Casual Employees performed hours of work that were considered overtime hours pursuant to clause 26.3 of the Fast Food Award. F.CONTRAVENTIONS OF YUXUAN GROUPFailure to make and keep required records26.By reason of section 535(1) of the FW Act and paragraphs 22 to 25 above, during the Assessment Periods, Yuxuan Group was required to make and keep the following records in relation to the Employees as required by the FW Regulations:(a)whether each of the Employees was full time or part time, pursuant to regulation 3.32(c);(b)whether each of the Employees was engaged on a permanent, temporary or casual basis, pursuant to regulation 3.32(d);(c)the date on which each of the Employees’ employment with Yuxuan Group began, pursuant to regulation 3.32(e); and (d)the number of overtime hours worked on each day by each of the Employees who worked overtime, or when each of those Employees started and ceased working overtime hours, pursuant to regulation 3.34. 27.During the Assessment Periods, typically on a Sunday, the Second Respondent, on behalf of Yuxuan Group, would finalise a weekly roster and post a copy of the roster on an employee WeChat forum.28.During the Assessment Periods, Yuxuan Group did not make or keep any of the records set out in paragraph 26 above in respect of the Employees and therefore contravened section 535(1) of the FW Act.Failure to provide pay slips 29.By reason of section 536(1) of the FW Act, during the Assessment Periods Yuxuan Group was required to provide a pay slip to each of the Employees within one working day of paying an amount to them in relation to the performance of work.30.During the Assessment Periods, on each Friday, the Second Respondent, on behalf of Yuxuan Group, paid the Employees for the performance of work in cash.31.At the time of making each payment, the Second Respondent asked each of the Employees to sign a document called a ‘Wage Book’ confirming the amount they had received. The wage book recorded the employee’s name and hourly rate of pay, as well as the total hours worked, any bonuses and total pay for the week.32.During the Assessment Periods, Yuxuan Group did not give the Employees a pay slip within one working day of making each payment, or at all, and therefore contravened section 536(1) of the FW Act.G. ADMITTED CONTRAVENTIONS OF THE SECOND RESPONDENT33. The Second Respondent admits that during the Assessment Periods she knew:(a) the Employees were employed by Yuxuan Group;(b)the Employees were engaged to work on either a full-time or casual basis;(c) the days and hours that the Employees were rostered to work;(d)the amounts Yuxuan Group paid to the Employees for the performance of work;(e)the records kept by Yuxuan Group in respect of the Employees and the hours they worked;(f) that the Employees were not provided with pay slips;(g)that during the Assessment Periods Yuxuan Group failed to make and keep records of:(i)the dates on which the Employees began working for Yuxuan Group;(ii) whether the Employees were full-time or part-time; and (iii) whether the Employees were permanent, temporary or casual; (h) that during the Assessment Periods Yuxuan Group failed to make and keep records of overtime hours worked by the Employees; and(i) that during the Assessment Periods Yuxuan Group failed to provide pay slips to the Employees within one working day of making a payment in relation to the performance of work, or at all.34. The Second Respondent admits that she was, pursuant to section 550 of the FW Act, directly or indirectly, knowingly concerned in, or party to contraventions of, and therefore taken to have herself contravened, the provisions of the FW Act set out at paragraphs 35 and 36 below.Involvement in failure to make and keep records35. The Second Respondent admits that during the Assessment Periods she was involved in the contravention of section 535(1) of the FW Act set out at paragraph 28 above.Involvement in failure to provide pay slips36. The Second Respondent admits that during the Assessment Periods she was involved in the contravention of section 536(1) of the FW Act set out at paragraph 32 above.37. The Proceedings were filed on 10 September 2021. The Second Respondent subsequently advised the Applicant by letter that she intended to formally admit the allegations. On 19 November 2021 the Second Respondent filed a Defence formally admitting her involvement in the contraventions at paragraph 28 and 32 above.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Having regard to all of the submissions made (both orally and in writing) by the FWO and Su, and its consideration if the factors set out above, the Court considers that the penalty which is appropriate for both contraventions is 40 percent of the maximum penalty of 60 penalty units, or 24 penalty units. A discount of 25 percent should be applied, co-operation with the FWO and because Su is a first time contravener so that the penalty for each contravention is 18 units. In monetary terms the penalty for each contravention is therefore $3,996 (18 x $222), giving a total penalty of $7,992. Having regard to the totality principle the Court is satisfied that no further reduction in penalty is necessary. Having regard to all of Su’s circumstances the Court considers that Su ought to be given 3 months to pay the penalties, rather than the usual 28 days. CONCLUSION AND ORDERS The Court has concluded that:(a)Su is liable for two contraventions of the FW Act under:(i)section 535(1) of the FW Act for failing to keep records as required by regs 3.32(c), (d) and (e) and 3.34 of the FW Regulations; and (ii)section 536(1) of the FW Act by failing to provide pay slips to the Employees within one working day of making payment in relation to the performance of work; and (b)in relation to each contravention a penalty of $3,996 is to be imposed, with 3 months to pay. The Court will hear the parties as to costs, if any: FW Act, s 570(2).
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The table at Schedule A of the Statement of Agreed Facts listing the Employees (and other information) has not been reproduced.CONSIDERATIONGeneral principles in imposing penalties In relation to the approach to imposing penalties the general principles are uncontroversial and can be summarised as follows:(a)the Court may impose penalties pursuant to s 546 of the FW Act if it is satisfied that a person has contravened a civil remedy provision and that the relevant sections of the FW Act in issue in these proceedings are civil remedy provisions;(b)when applying s 546 of the FW Act, the Court’s “real task” is “fixing the penalty which it considers fairly and reasonably to be appropriate to protect the public interest from future contraventions of the [FW] Act”: Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Pattinson [2022] HCA 13; (2022) 274 CLR 450; (2022) 96 ALJR 426; (2022) 314 IR 301; (2022) 399 ALR 599; (2022) 175 ALD 383 (“Pattinson”) at [71] per Kiefel CJ, Gageler, Keane, Gordon, Steward and Gleeson JJ. This is because the purpose of civil penalties ordered under s 546 of the FW Act is to promote the public interest in compliance with the statutory regime: Pattinson at [15] per Kiefel CJ, Gageler, Keane, Gordon, Steward and Gleeson JJ, citing The Commonwealth of Australia v Director, Fair Work Building Inspectorate and Others (“Agreed Penalties Case”) [2015] HCA 46; (2015) 258 CLR 482; (2015) 90 ALJR 113; (2015) 255 IR 87; (2015) 326 ALR 476; (2015) 67 AILR 102-494 at [55] per French CJ, Kiefel, Bell, Nettle and Gordon JJ;(c)promoting public interest in compliance with the statutory regime is achieved by putting a price on contravention that is sufficiently high to deter repetition by the contravenor and by others who might be tempted to contravene the Act: Trade Practices Commission v CSR Ltd [1991] FCA 762; [1991] ATPR 41-076 (“CSR Ltd”). More recently the High Court has further explained, in Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union and Another [2018] HCA 3; (2018) 262 CLR 157; (2018) 92 ALJR 219; (2018) 273 IR 211; (2018) 351 ALR 190; (2018) 70 AILR 102-917 (“ABCC v CFMEU”) at [116] per Keane, Nettle and Gordon JJ, that the “principal object” of deterrence depends on a penalty having the necessary “sting or burden” to secure the specific and general deterrent effects that are the raison d’être of its imposition. That purpose has been reinforced by the High Court in Pattinson at [9] per Kiefel CJ, Gageler, Keane, Gordon, Steward and Gleeson JJ where the purpose of the civil remedy regime in the FW Act was described by the majority as being the promotion of the public interest in compliance with the provisions of the FW Act by way of deterrence of further contravention. In Pattinson at [66] per Kiefel CJ, Gageler, Keane, Gordon, Steward and Gleeson JJ the High Court expressed the view that s 546 of the FW Act had, as its underlying theory, the notion that the financial disincentive imposed by way of pecuniary penalty will be such as to encourage compliance with the law by ensuring that contraventions are viewed by the contravener, and others, “as an economically irrational choice”. The High Court further observed that the function of the Court imposing a penalty was to give effect to the intention of the FW Act in this regard, and that the courts must do what they can to deter non-compliance with the FW Act;(d)the maximum penalty available is a relevant consideration but “does not constrain the exercise of the discretion under s 546…beyond requiring “some reasonable relationship between the theoretical maximum and the final penalty imposed””: Pattinson at [55] per Kiefel CJ, Gageler, Keane, Gordon, Steward and Gleeson JJ, citing Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Reckitt Benckiser(Australia) Pty Ltd [2016] FCAFC 181; (2016) 340 ALR 25; [2016] ATPR 42-530 at [155]-[156] per Jagot, Yates and Bromwich JJ;(e)the “reasonable relationship” should be considered by reference to the need for deterrence: Pattinson at [55] per Kiefel CJ, Gageler, Keane, Gordon, Steward and Gleeson JJ, there being a requirement to ensure that any penalty “strikes a reasonable balance between deterrence and oppressive severity” and is thus proportionate: Pattinson at [41] per Kiefel CJ, Gageler, Keane, Gordon, Steward and Gleeson JJ;(f)the Court has a broad discretion to assess the appropriate penalty. The discretion is approached in a process identified in Fair Work Ombudsman v NSH North Pty Ltd (t/as New Shanghai Charlestown) [2017] FCA 1301; (2017) 275 IR 148; [2017] 69 AILR 102-890 (“New Shanghai”) at [36] per Bromwich J, and relevant to this case the Court must:(i)identify the contraventions and consider the maximum penalty a court might impose for each separate contravention;(ii)consider whether the course of conduct provisions in s 557 of the FW Act apply to any of the contraventions: Fair Work Ombudsman v Lohr [2018] FCA 5; (2018) 356 ALR 424; (2018) 158 ALD 457; (2018) 70 AILR 102-906 at [33]-[34] per Bromwich J;(iii)assess the appropriate penalty in respect of each contravention or group of contraventions, with reference to any factors relevant to the imposition of penalties, and to the extent that two or more contraventions have common elements, or arise out of the same course of conduct or transaction, this should be taken into account in considering what is an appropriate penalty in all the circumstances for the contravention as a respondent ought not be penalised more than once for the same conduct; and(iv)consider the overall penalties arrived at including by reference to those which may be proposed by the parties and apply the totality principle to ensure that the penalties for the respondent are appropriate to the conduct viewed as a whole, making such adjustments as are necessary: Agreed Penalties Case at [55] per French CJ, Kiefel, Bell, Nettle and Gordon JJ; Australian Ophthalmic Supplies Pty Ltd v McAlary-Smith [2008] FCAFC 8; (2008) 165 FCR 560; (2008) 246 ALR 35; (2008) 60 AILR 100-089 (“Australian Ophthalmic Supplies”) at [96]-[97] per Buchanan J.