Elw17 v Minister for Immigration

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

ELW17 v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR [2019] FCCA 2191
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Migration Act 1958 (Cth) – Refugee visa application – application for judicial review of decision of Delegate of the Minister for Immigration refusing to grant a Refugee and Humanitarian (Class XB) (Subclass 200) visa to the applicant because he did not satisfy the compelling reasons criterion – applicant claims denial of procedural fairness and that the Delegate did not consider all of the relevant material – grounds of application not made out – applicant fails to establish jurisdictional error – application dismissed.

Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss.54, 56, 66, 411, 476, 477

Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Abebe v The Commonwealth of Australia (1999) 197 CLR 510

CJR17 v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2018] FCA 1627
Plaintiff M64/2015 v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection (2015) 258 CLR 173

Applicant: ELW17
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION
Second Respondent: ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
File Number: SYG 3092 of 2017
Judgment of: Judge Dowdy
Hearing date: 17 August 2018
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 15 August 2019

REPRESENTATION

The Applicant appeared
in person by telephone from Moscow, Russia.
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr J. Pinder
Solicitors for the First Respondent: Minter Ellison

THE ORDERS OF THE COURT ARE AS FOLLOWS:

  1. Grant leave to the Applicant to appear at the delivery of judgment on 15 August 2019 by telephone from Thessaloniki, Greece.

  2. Pursuant to s.477(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) the time for the Applicant to file his Application in this Court be extended to 6 October 2017.

  3. The Application filed in this Court on 6 October 2017 is dismissed.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT SYDNEY

SYG 3092 of 2017

ELW17

Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. The Applicant is a male citizen of Russia aged 37 years, having been born on 9 November 1981, and at all material times was resident in Moscow, Russia.

  2. By Application filed in this Court on 6 October 2017, he sought to quash and have re-determined two decisions, namely:

    a)the decision of the Second Respondent, the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal), dated 29 September 2017 which found that it did not have jurisdiction to review the decision of the Delegate (Delegate) of the First Respondent, the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Minister), dated 20 July 2017 refusing to grant to him a Refugee and Humanitarian (Class XB) (Subclass 200) visa (Refugee visa); and

    b)the Delegate’s decision of 20 July 2017 itself.

  3. However, by his affidavit sworn or affirmed on 15 October 2017 the Applicant stated that he was only seeking judicial review of the Delegate’s decision, and not the decision of the Tribunal.

  4. I note that as the Applicant was a non-citizen who was not physically present in Australia at the date of the decision of the Delegate, such…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Elw17 v Minister for Immigration and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCCA 2191
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant sought judicial review of a decision by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration to refuse his application for a Refugee and Humanitarian (Class XB) (Subclass 200) visa. The applicant contended that he was denied procedural fairness and that the delegate failed to consider all relevant material.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the delegate's decision to refuse the visa application constituted a jurisdictional error. This involved determining whether the delegate adequately considered the applicant's circumstances in relation to the criteria for granting the visa, specifically the requirement to be satisfied that there were compelling reasons for giving special consideration to granting the visa. The applicant also raised concerns about the lack of a merits review and the delegate's assessment of the applicant's connection to Australia and the capacity of the Australian community to provide for his settlement.

The court found that the delegate was not required to provide a statement of reasons under section 66(2)(c) and (3) of the Migration Act 1958. However, the delegate's Decision Record indicated that all relevant information had been considered in light of the four factors outlined in clause 200.222 of Schedule 2 to the Regulations, including the degree of persecution, the applicant's connection with Australia, the availability of suitable alternative countries, and the capacity of the Australian community. The delegate's reasoning explained that the assessment was made within the context of the Australian Government's annual humanitarian program and the large number of applicants facing persecution, prioritising those referred by UNHCR or proposed under the Special Humanitarian Programme. The court concluded that the applicant had failed to establish that the delegate had overlooked relevant material or denied procedural fairness, and therefore, no jurisdictional error had occurred. The application was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

By force of s.66(2)(c) and (3) of the Act the Delegate was not required to give a statement of reasons in relation to his decision to refuse to grant the Refugee visa to the Applicant. Nevertheless, in his Decision Record the Delegate stated as follows:Reasons for DecisionUnder migration law, an application is made for a class of visa and your application must be considered against the criteria for all subclasses within that visa class.Your application has been considered against the criteria for the following subclasses within REFUGEE AND HUMANITARIAN visa class.200- REFUGEE201- IN-COUNTRY SPECIAL HUMANITARIAN PROGRAM202- GLOBAL SPECIAL HUMANITARIAN PROGRAM203- EMERGENCY RESCUE204- WOMAN AT RISKYour application is refused because you do not satisfy the criterion of the Migration Regulations at 200.222, 201.222, 202.222, 203.222, and 204.224, which state:(see [8] above for the terms of cl.200.222)Please note that as you did not meet the 'compelling reasons' criterion in each of the five subclasses, I did not assess you application against the other criteria in those subclasses.It may assist you to understand this decision if I explain the context in which the 'compelling reasons' criteria are applied.The assessment of the four factors included in the 'compelling reasons' criteria is made in the context of the Australian Government's annual decision on the size of the Humanitarian Programme, and the reality of a very large number of applicants who are subject to persecution or substantial discrimination. Australia does not have the capacity to resettle all the people who apply for a Refugee and Humanitarian visa.The Australian Government has decided that the fairest way to deal with the high number of applications is to give priority to applicants who are outside their home country and are either assessed as refugees by the UNHCR and formally referred to Australia for resettlement, or proposed by a close family member under the Special Humanitarian Programme. I note that your application does not fall into either of these priority categories.I appreciate that you wish to resettle in Australia, and I understand you will be disappointed with this decision. I assure you that I have considered all the information included in your application. However, I must consider the information you have provided having regard to the four factors mentioned above, including the capacity of the Australia community to provide for resettlement of persons such as yourself. Having done that, I was not satisfied that there are compelling reasons for giving special consideration to granting you a permanent visa.(emphasis added) Accordingly, the Delegate refused the application of the Applicant and his family members for the Refugee visa. The Applicant’s Grounds, which are diffuse and argumentative in their terms, are verbatim as follows:1. My application for a REFUGEE AND HUMANITARIAN (Class XB) REFUGEE (Subclass 200) visa was lodged at Moscow on 21 October 2016.2. 05.09.2017 I was noticed about the decision David Gilks Position Number: 11582 Second Secretary Australian Embassy Berlin Department of Immigration and Border protection by email (to my mailbox [omitted]). The decision was dated 20 July 20173. I was not satisfied with the decision because it can not be reviewed by Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Migration & Refugee Division) and there is no explanation why there is no right to merits review for this decision. If the reason is that the Australian Security Intelligence Organization assess me as a threat to the security of Australia, so it is a complete nonsense. Up to the present day I have never personally had a criminal record. In the meaning of the law and in the sense of justice a person needs to know why he’s threatening Australia. And it is in the interests of Australia because only in this case the man is able to consciously change the situation to decrease the threat of Australia for his part. I honestly reported in the application that my relative (my wife’s father) was an officer of the secret service of Russia (FSB). Any way I did not hid this information, showing my integrity to the interests of Australia security.4. Also I was failed to provide two protocols of the FSB in time because of the Departments of Immigration and Border Protection formal approach with me. But it is not my fault in whole. No one contacted with me, I had no interviews, so I was unable to update information. So my case was not studied by Second Secretary Australian Embassy (Berlin Department of Immigration and Border Protection) at all items that might have value. I did not lodge the FSB-protocols originally submitted with my application because rightly feared tightening of persecution if the Russian authorities would be alerted about provided by me these documents to Australian authorities. The Australian mechanism does not provide the opportunity to submit the refugee application online via the Internet (or by another method which can ensure a sufficient level of inaccessibility of a massage to Russian authorities). A delivery by mail or personal delivery by sender (using personal transport) available for inspection by the FSB. In its power to check mail and it has the right to carry out checking (personal inspection) of any persons moving on territory of Russia.5. The decision record states that there are no compelling reasons for giving special consideration to granting the applicant a permanent visa, having regard to: (i) the degree of persecution to which the applicant is subject in the applicant’s home country; and (ii) the extent of the applicant’s connection with Australia; and (iii) whether or not there is any suitable country available, other than Australia, that can provide for the applicant’s settlement and protection from persecution; and (iv) the capacity of the Australian community to provide for the permanent settlement of persons such as the applicant in Australia. I don’t agree with it because the conclusions were made without all the necessary information (including me the FSB-protocols that I want to provide). There also a few words about the assessing the capacity of the Australia community to provide for resettlement of persons such as me in the decision. But this category should be dictated by the interests of Australia. The migration officials must not being apply one size fits to all approach, instead they must study specific of the personality and the ability of the applicant to be useful for the country. Mr. David Gilks did not used this approach.6. The facts allow to assert there were a few jurisdictional errors (see following). The decision-maker not adopting a fair process in making the decision; ignoring materials the decision-maker was required to look at. Due to an insufficient level of communication between the Department of Immigration and Border Protection and the applicant there was failing to provide the FSB-protocols which in details reveals the essence of the facts related to the impact of the state on the applicant. In particular, these evidence clearly characterize the degree “of persecution to which the applicant is subject in the applicant’s home country”.7. The reason for decision is that I did not meet the “compelling reasons” criterion on each of the five subclasses. But because of the fear of being punished in Russia, I did not attach all important documents (“Evidence supporting claim” or “Two protocols of the FSB” – 10 pages in PDF) to my application. The acts of the applicant (my acts) to provide the authorities of another state information about the investigative activities of the FSB can be considered under section 275 of the Russian Criminal code. That referred as a treason through a provision of foreign government information classified as state secret. The punishment for this in Russia – imprisonment from 12 to 20 years. The Australian system does not allow to submit documents via the Internet using privacy features of items, including encryption. So that is not my fault that I was not able to provide all the information at once. The same applies in respect of “international organization”. That is why the complainant (me) was not able to take action to obtain the status of a person being assessed as a refugee by the UNHCR. The term international organization is explicitly mentioned in article 275 of the Russian Criminal code.8. As for the fact that I couldn’t go to any other country to explain that because of my plight and deterioration of my financial situation due to the impact of the Russian authorities, I had debts. The debts arose largely because of persecution justified by the applicant the original application caused by political motives of the state (seizure from the applicant his tools of production and labour – computers and electronic equipment). Debts not allowed to leave the Russian Federation. This follows from the practice of section 67 of the Federal law of the Russian judicial enforcement proceedings. This section the so-called “Temporary restrictions on leaving the debtor of the Russian Federation”. I have attached proof of my debt to the present application.9. These evidence (documents – two protocols of the FSB) is the compelling provement of the facts: Being persecuting me for political reasons (specified in my application originally filed), the Russian authorities seized the items I use my work (to ensure the sustenance of my life and the lives of my family members). It is 9 items (total). Computers and electronic equipment. This fact confirms the illegal actions and evil intent on the part of the authorities. To this date the Russian authorities have not filed any criminal or administrative proceedings against me. They just took my property, which I need in order to survive. In particular this resulted in the inability to legally leave Russia.10. The process of consideration and adoption of a decision on my question in the absence of any contact with me from the Department of Immigration and Border Protection resulted in the impossibility of any argument from my side, including the inability to provide important information and evidence referred to above. This constitutes a violation of substantive law implemented by the Migration Act 1958.11. I pose no threat to the security of Australia and I meet the requirements (according to the prosecution, the degree of the relationship to Australia (representative of English-speaking people), the capacity of the Australian community in relation to people such quality like me). But the Department probably thought otherwise. The Australian Government has decided that the fairest way to deal with the high number of applications is to give priority to applicants who are outside their home country and are either assessed as refugees by the UNHCR and formally referred to Australia for resettlement, or proposed by a close family member under the Special Humanitarian Programme. I think that it was the incorrectly interpreting and applying the law because of the next. The decision of a government of Australia cannot be a substitute of the Migration Act 1958. Also the decision of the government may not have legal force above the law. The Migration Act 1958 states that “The object of this Act is regulate, in the national interest, the coming into, the presence in, Australia of non citizens” (Section 4) and that “Despite any legislative instrument made for the purposes of section 39, the Minister must take all reasonably practicable measures to ensure the grant in a financial year of at least the minimum total number of Protection (Class XA) visas and Refugee and Humanitarian (Class XB) visas that is determined by the Minister under subsection (3) of this section for that year.” (section 39F). However, in the Migration act 1948 there are no rules establishing mandatory automatic denial of a migration visa persons applying for it and not having the status of refugees by the UNHCR and not formally referred to Australia for resettlement, or proposed by a close family member under the Special Humanitarian Programme.12. According to section 4 of the Migration Act 1958 (1) The Object of this Act is to regulate, in the national interest, the coming into, and presence in, Australia of non-citizens. Getting all the necessary information about the person who is coming into Australia consistent with the national interests, including security interests. The Department of Immigration and Border Protection has not done this although he had the opportunity. The decision was not made in accordance with the Migration Act 1958 and is not a ‘privative clause decision’ within the meaning given by subsection 474 (2) of the Migration Act 1958.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

To obtain the grant of the Refugee visa the Applicant had to satisfy the Minister at time of decision under cl.200.222 of Sch.2 to the Regulations that there were compelling reasons for giving special consideration to granting him the Refugee visa. At the time of decision cl.200.222 relevantly provided as follows:The Minister is satisfied that there are compelling reasons for giving special consideration to granting the applicant a permanent visa, having regard to:(a) …(b) in any other case—the following:(i) the degree of persecution to which the applicant is subject in the applicant’s home country; and(ii) the extent of the applicant’s connection with Australia; and(iii) whether or not there is any suitable country available, other than Australia, that can provide for the applicant’s settlement and protection from persecution; and(iv) the capacity of the Australian community to provide for the permanent settlement of persons such as the applicant in Australia.(emphasis added) By force of s.66(2)(c) and (3) of the Act the Delegate was not required to give a statement of reasons in relation to his decision to refuse to grant the Refugee visa to the Applicant. Nevertheless, in his Decision Record the Delegate stated as follows:Reasons for DecisionUnder migration law, an application is made for a class of visa and your application must be considered against the criteria for all subclasses within that visa class.Your application has been considered against the criteria for the following subclasses within REFUGEE AND HUMANITARIAN visa class.200- REFUGEE201- IN-COUNTRY SPECIAL HUMANITARIAN PROGRAM202- GLOBAL SPECIAL HUMANITARIAN PROGRAM203- EMERGENCY RESCUE204- WOMAN AT RISKYour application is refused because you do not satisfy the criterion of the Migration Regulations at 200.222, 201.222, 202.222, 203.222, and 204.224, which state:(see [8] above for the terms of cl.200.222)Please note that as you did not meet the 'compelling reasons' criterion in each of the five subclasses, I did not assess you application against the other criteria in those subclasses.It may assist you to understand this decision if I explain the context in which the 'compelling reasons' criteria are applied.The assessment of the four factors included in the 'compelling reasons' criteria is made in the context of the Australian Government's annual decision on the size of the Humanitarian Programme, and the reality of a very large number of applicants who are subject to persecution or substantial discrimination. Australia does not have the capacity to resettle all the people who apply for a Refugee and Humanitarian visa.The Australian Government has decided that the fairest way to deal with the high number of applications is to give priority to applicants who are outside their home country and are either assessed as refugees by the UNHCR and formally referred to Australia for resettlement, or proposed by a close family member under the Special Humanitarian Programme. I note that your application does not fall into either of these priority categories.I appreciate that you wish to resettle in Australia, and I understand you will be disappointed with this decision. I assure you that I have considered all the information included in your application. However, I must consider the information you have provided having regard to the four factors mentioned above, including the capacity of the Australia community to provide for resettlement of persons such as yourself. Having done that, I was not satisfied that there are compelling reasons for giving special consideration to granting you a permanent visa.(emphasis added)