CJR17 v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

CJR17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 1627

Appeal from: CJR17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCCA 2959
File number: WAD 631 of 2017
Judge: BANKS-SMITH J
Date of judgment: 31 October 2018
Catchwords: MIGRATION - protection visa - appeal from decision of Federal Circuit Court to dismiss application for review - whether Administrative Appeals Tribunal denied the appellant procedural fairness - where correspondence to Administrative Appeals Tribunal post hearing unanswered - where error on part of appellant or agent - content of procedural fairness on review - whether Federal Circuit Court denied the appellant procedural fairness by accepting Minister's affidavit prior to hearing - where appellant on notice of matter in issue
Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) s 422B, Pt 7, Div 4

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 39.05

Legal Profession Conduct Rules 2010 (WA) r 23

Cases cited:

Abebe v The Commonwealth [1999] HCA 14; (1999) 197 CLR 510

Autodesk Inc v Dyason (No 2) [1993] HCA 6; (1993) 176 CLR 300

BLD15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (No 2)[2018] FCA 790

De L v Director-General, NSW Department of Community Services (No 2) [1997] HCA 14; (1997) 190 CLR 207

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v WZARH [2015] HCA 40; (2015) 256 CLR 326

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZIAI [2009] HCA 39; (2009) 259 ALR 429

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZLIX [2008] FCAFC 17; (2008) 245 ALR 501

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZNVW [2010] FCAFC 41; (2010) 183 FCR 575

Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; Ex parte Lam [2003] HCA 6; (2003) 214 CLR 1

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs v SGLB [2004] HCA 32; (2004) 207 ALR 12

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs v VSAF of 2003 [2005] FCAFC 73

Patel v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (No 4) [2012] FCA 1170

Prasad v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1985) 6 FCR 155

Sullivan v Department of Transport (1978) 20 ALR 323

SZFDE v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2007] HCA 35; (2007) 232 CLR 189

SZVIA v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCA 1228

SZSXT v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2014] FCAFC 40; (2014) 222 FCR 73

United Group Resources Pty Ltd v Calabro (No 6) [2012] FCA 431

WEI v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] HCA 51

Date of hearing: 9 July 2018
Registry: Western Australia
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 79
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr FA Robertson
Solicitor for the Appellant: Jessy Legal
Counsel for the First Respondent

Mr A Gerrard

Solicitor for the First Respondent: Australian Government Solicitor
Solicitor for the Second Respondent: The Second Respondent filed a submitting notice save as to costs

ORDERS

WAD 631 of 2017
BETWEEN:

CJR17

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CJR17 v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 1627
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court was an appeal from the Federal Circuit Court's decision to dismiss the appellant's application for review of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal's (AAT) decision to refuse the appellant a protection visa. The appellant, a citizen of Zimbabwe, sought a protection visa based on claims of persecution by the Zimbabwean Government and ZANU-PF supporters due to his and his family's involvement with the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC). The central issue before the court was whether the Federal Circuit Court had denied the appellant procedural fairness by accepting an affidavit from the Minister prior to hearing the matter, and whether the AAT had denied the appellant procedural fairness by not responding to a letter sent post-hearing.

The court found that the Federal Circuit Court did not deny the appellant procedural fairness. The court reasoned that the appellant was on notice of the matter in issue and had not sought an adjournment to address the late filing of the affidavit. Furthermore, the court held that the error in the case was attributable to the appellant or his agent, rather than the Tribunal, and thus did not warrant a finding of procedural unfairness. Regarding the AAT's handling of the post-hearing correspondence, the court concluded that the AAT was not obligated to respond to the letter, especially given the ambiguity of its content and the lack of an extension of time sought by the appellant.

The court dismissed the appeal and ordered the appellant to pay the respondent's costs, should they not be agreed upon. This decision underscores the importance of timely and proper submission of evidence and the limited obligations of tribunals to address post-hearing communications that do not meet formal submission requirements.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The appellant pay the first respondent's costs to be assessed if not agreed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The issue as to the Federal Circuit Court was whether the late delivery of an affidavit on behalf of the Minister had the effect of denying the appellant procedural fairness.Background The appellant is a citizen of Zimbabwe who was born in the Bikita district and moved to Harare in 2001. The appellant arrived in Australia on 15 February 2007 as the holder of a student visa. His second student visa expired in March 2010. In January 2013 the appellant applied for a protection visa. In March 2015 a delegate of the Minister refused the application and the appellant sought review in the Tribunal. The appellant appeared before the Tribunal on 23 March 2016. On 1 May 2017 the Tribunal affirmed the delegate's decision. The Tribunal found that there was no real chance that the appellant would suffer serious harm if returned to Zimbabwe. Relying on the same reasoning process, the Tribunal also found that there was no real risk the appellant would suffer significant harm as identified in the complementary protection guidelines.Protection claim before the Tribunal The appellant claimed to fear persecution by the Zimbabwean Government and Zimbabwe African National Union - Patriotic Front (ZANU‑PF) supporters because of the involvement of his family, in particular his father and brother, with the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC), because of his own involvement with the MDC and on the basis that he would be regarded as a traitor because he and members of his family had been residing in western countries.Evidence and submissions as to brother's position It is not in issue that the appellant's brother, who I will refer to as Mr F, has been granted asylum in the United Kingdom. Nor is it in issue that a written decision regarding Mr F was delivered by the First-tier Tribunal of the Immigration and Asylum Chamber (UK decision). A copy of the UK decision was provided to the Federal Circuit Court and to this Court. It is necessary to set out the evidence given about Mr F before the Tribunal. The appellant appeared at the Tribunal hearing by video but was represented by a registered migration agent (Agent). The transcript of the hearing was not before the Court, but by an affidavit filed in the Federal Circuit Court proceedings, a lawyer from the Australian Government Solicitor's office, Mr Gao, deposed to listening to the audio recording of the hearing (Gao affidavit). Mr Gao attached certain transcript extracts. The first extract dealt with Mr F's position in the United Kingdom:TRIBUNAL MEMBER: Was [Mr F] - was he a member of the MDC?APPLICANT: Yes he was.TRIBUNAL MEMBER: OK so did he continue - was he involved in any activity for the MDC when he was in Harare?APPLICANT: Yes I do believe and I have - I did put some recommendation in my application. I am not sure whether its … full information but I did put the recommendation in my application showing that he was and I do believe he is still an active member … branch of the MDC in the UK.TRIBUNAL MEMBER: What I have in relation to that, I will just let you know because it appears you were unsure of this in the past. I have here a document which indicates that your brother was granted a 5 year visa in England in relation to protection claims.APPLICANT: Yes, yes.TRIBUNAL MEMBER: Umm sorry, just let me explain to you what I, what I have on the file. I also got some statements from family members. So I've got a statement from a branch of the MDC in the UK saying that he was involved there.APPLICANT: Yeah.TRIBUNAL MEMBER: And mentioning that he was a teacher in Zimbabwe. Umm and I also have a couple of documents from, it appears your family members supporting [Mr F's] application, umm and I have got some interview notes I suppose. Umm but what I don't have is, I don't have a decision as such, or anything like that outlining what his claims were or why he feared persecution or anything like that.APPLICANT: Oh right, I umm, a long time ago I was asked about this, I made sure I sent in a consent form which allowed him to get that information on his side so. I am not sure if the Department was provided because they give him form which said can you send this post and liaise with Britain Immigration and he give them that so I thought it could come from them …TRIBUNAL MEMBER: Yep umm, I am just letting you know the information that I have. From the information that I have, it appears that in 2012 this correspondence from the UK Order Agency indicating that [Mr F] was granted. Sorry, that his appeal was allowed by a tribunal. And it appears that unless there was any appeal of that, that your brother would have been granted a - umm 5 year visa in relation to a political asylum claim. And from umm, the other family members it appears that your brother claimed that he was a member of the MDC and that he was also a teacher. But that's - APPLICANT: Yes.TRIBUNAL MEMBER: I don't have all that much more information about his claim, I am just letting you know what I have.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The appellant claimed to fear persecution by the Zimbabwean Government and Zimbabwe African National Union - Patriotic Front (ZANU‑PF) supporters because of the involvement of his family, in particular his father and brother, with the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC), because of his own involvement with the MDC and on the basis that he would be regarded as a traitor because he and members of his family had been residing in western countries.Evidence and submissions as to brother's position It is not in issue that the appellant's brother, who I will refer to as Mr F, has been granted asylum in the United Kingdom. Nor is it in issue that a written decision regarding Mr F was delivered by the First-tier Tribunal of the Immigration and Asylum Chamber (UK decision). A copy of the UK decision was provided to the Federal Circuit Court and to this Court. It is necessary to set out the evidence given about Mr F before the Tribunal. The appellant appeared at the Tribunal hearing by video but was represented by a registered migration agent (Agent). The transcript of the hearing was not before the Court, but by an affidavit filed in the Federal Circuit Court proceedings, a lawyer from the Australian Government Solicitor's office, Mr Gao, deposed to listening to the audio recording of the hearing (Gao affidavit). Mr Gao attached certain transcript extracts. The first extract dealt with Mr F's position in the United Kingdom:TRIBUNAL MEMBER: Was [Mr F] - was he a member of the MDC?APPLICANT: Yes he was.TRIBUNAL MEMBER: OK so did he continue - was he involved in any activity for the MDC when he was in Harare?APPLICANT: Yes I do believe and I have - I did put some recommendation in my application. I am not sure whether its … full information but I did put the recommendation in my application showing that he was and I do believe he is still an active member … branch of the MDC in the UK.TRIBUNAL MEMBER: What I have in relation to that, I will just let you know because it appears you were unsure of this in the past. I have here a document which indicates that your brother was granted a 5 year visa in England in relation to protection claims.APPLICANT: Yes, yes.TRIBUNAL MEMBER: Umm sorry, just let me explain to you what I, what I have on the file. I also got some statements from family members. So I've got a statement from a branch of the MDC in the UK saying that he was involved there.APPLICANT: Yeah.TRIBUNAL MEMBER: And mentioning that he was a teacher in Zimbabwe. Umm and I also have a couple of documents from, it appears your family members supporting [Mr F's] application, umm and I have got some interview notes I suppose. Umm but what I don't have is, I don't have a decision as such, or anything like that outlining what his claims were or why he feared persecution or anything like that.APPLICANT: Oh right, I umm, a long time ago I was asked about this, I made sure I sent in a consent form which allowed him to get that information on his side so. I am not sure if the Department was provided because they give him form which said can you send this post and liaise with Britain Immigration and he give them that so I thought it could come from them …TRIBUNAL MEMBER: Yep umm, I am just letting you know the information that I have. From the information that I have, it appears that in 2012 this correspondence from the UK Order Agency indicating that [Mr F] was granted. Sorry, that his appeal was allowed by a tribunal. And it appears that unless there was any appeal of that, that your brother would have been granted a - umm 5 year visa in relation to a political asylum claim. And from umm, the other family members it appears that your brother claimed that he was a member of the MDC and that he was also a teacher. But that's - APPLICANT: Yes.TRIBUNAL MEMBER: I don't have all that much more information about his claim, I am just letting you know what I have.

Decision

Reasons for decision

There was no evidence of receipt of or any reply to the letter.Tribunal's decision The Tribunal's reasons were published on 1 May 2017. The Tribunal in its reasons acknowledged receipt of the submissions of 7 April 2016 (presumably a reference to the re-filed version). In short, the Tribunal found there was no real chance that the appellant would suffer serious harm if returned to Zimbabwe, and there was no real risk the appellant would suffer significant harm as identified in the complementary protection guidelines. The appellant's evidence was that he had been signed up as an MDC member when he was a child and that he would say he was 'affiliated' with the MDC but he was too young to have been an MDC leader. The Tribunal had regard to Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT) country information which assessed that mere membership of the MDC does not mean that an individual would attract adverse attention from the government or face community prejudice: the profile and activities of an individual are more relevant to an individual's risk profile than MDC membership. The Tribunal accepted that the DFAT assessment was that MDC members face a moderate threat of violence from ZANU‑PF supporters in that they are subjected to occasional violence, mostly from ZANU‑PF supporters and that all MDC members face a moderate level of official discrimination throughout Zimbabwe. Next, the Tribunal recorded that the current DFAT assessment is that Zimbabwean authorities only take an interest in the return to Zimbabwe of high profile individuals. The Tribunal referred to a DFAT assessment that family members of MDC members, including high profile MDC members, have a low risk of harm in Zimbabwe for their association with their MDC family member. The Tribunal accepted that the appellant's father and Mr F were members of the MDC, and that despite some inconsistent evidence, the appellant's father sought pre-selection in Bikita for the MDC. The Tribunal also accepted that Mr F was an MDC member who was a teacher, attended MDC rallies and was granted asylum in the United Kingdom. The Tribunal noted that 'very little is known in relation to [Mr F's] asylum case as the [UK] decision was not provided to the Tribunal'. The Tribunal also noted that the appellant appeared to know very little about Mr F's involvement with the MDC and when asked whether Mr F was involved in any MDC activities he stated that 'I believe he was'. The Tribunal did not accept that the appellant was ever assaulted or threatened because of his connections with the MDC. The Tribunal did not accept that the appellant's father or other brothers were killed by the ZANU-PF or their supporters for their connection with the MDC. When the Tribunal asked the appellant whether any of his family members had been harmed or threatened the appellant referred to a letter from Mr F, but was unable to say what the letter said and could provide no details about any harm that had occurred to Mr F. The Tribunal accepted that MDC members face a moderate threat of violence. However, it did not consider the appellant had any real involvement with the MDC at any point in time. The Tribunal said that while it accepted that the appellant's father may have signed his sons up as MDC members when they were children, and that the appellant may have attended MDC events as a child, the appellant has not shown any significant involvement with the MDC as an adult or since he moved from Bikita in 2001. The Tribunal said that significantly, unlike Mr F, the appellant has not had any involvement in Zimbabwean politics since he arrived in Australia and it did not accept that he would have an involvement in politics if he were to return.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Finally, the Minister submitted that there are many examples where the Tribunal might receive evidence or documents that do not meet their description but it is not incumbent on the Tribunal to inform a visa applicant of the veracity of the documents. For example, it was submitted, a purported medical certificate might not in fact provide sufficient details for it to be probative or might only be a receipt but that would not oblige the Tribunal to inform the applicant that it is inadequate prior to making a decision. A similar argument might apply to a range of evidence or submissions that might be provided to the Tribunal or that an applicant might indicate he or she wishes to submit but fails to provide to a Tribunal. Counsel for the Minister somewhat reluctantly described this as a 'floodgates' argument, but contends (in effect) that such examples indicate that procedural fairness does not require the Tribunal to in effect take an interventionist supervisory role of the manner in which an applicant runs his or her case. The content of procedural fairness must be considered in the context of the Tribunal's statutory obligations and the circumstances of a particular case.Consideration Counsels' research did not reveal authorities that deal with the content of any obligation on the part of the Tribunal when it is given notice of a misapprehension such as in this case outside the extended time period for provision of submissions and where no extension of time has been sought. I would add to the factual matrix the ambiguity of the terms of the 28 April 2016 letter itself. There are examples where the court has made an internal error relating to communications or filing and so made orders on an artificial basis. One example is provided by Patel v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (No 4) [2012] FCA 1170, where submissions were not properly filed but were provided by email to Collier J's associate. The submissions were not brought to the attention of her Honour before orders were made on the papers. Submissions form part of the formal court record of proceedings. Accordingly, her Honour, having been informed of the issue, vacated the orders under r 39.05 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), which permits in limited circumstances the varying or setting aside of orders after entry, including where there is an error arising from an accidental slip or omission. See also as to the exceptional circumstances in which such jurisdiction might be exercised: United Group Resources Pty Ltd v Calabro (No 6) [2012] FCA 431; Autodesk Inc v Dyason (No 2) [1993] HCA 6; (1993) 176 CLR 300 at 303; De L v Director-General, NSW Department of Community Services (No 2) [1997] HCA 14; (1997) 190 CLR 207 at 215. To my mind, these authorities, concerned as they are with the finality of litigation and the particular circumstances that apply to applications to vary or set aside orders, are not sufficiently analogous to the circumstances of the Tribunal in this case. To the extent there was error, it was not on the part of the Tribunal. The error cannot fairly be described as mutual, and the circumstances cannot fairly be described as otherwise exceptional. The error was on the part of the Agent or the appellant, and there appears to have been an element of calculated risk in relying on information apparently from Mr F that suggested (at least to the Agent/appellant) that the UK decision may have been provided to the Tribunal directly by Mr F (not by the Agent or appellant). As already explained, there is simply no evidence the Tribunal ever received the UK decision.