Edelsten v Health Insurance Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

1

1 No. TG3 of 1987
1

1

BGIWEEN: CAFIKE PTY. LTD. trading as
PORT ARTHUR CIDER COMPANY
Applicant
m:  R.R. & S.M. POWELL PTY.
- LTD.

Respondent

BE!rwEm:  R.R. & S.M. P O m L PTY.
-  LTD.
Cross-Claimant
AND:  CAF'IKE PTY. LTD. trading as
PORT ARTHUR CIDER COMPANY
Cross-Respondent
CORAM :  BEAWONT J
PLACE:  Hobart
DAm:  25 May 1988

MINUTES OF ORDER

.- .,

THE COURT ORDERQ:

1. That judgment be entered for the applicant on its

claim in the sum of $54,965.57; and that judgment be entered for the respondent on its cross-claim in the sum of $1,320.77; order that the respondent do pay the applicant the sum of $54,965.57 and that the applicant do pay the respondent the sum of $1,320.77; direct that the one judgment be set off against the other and that execution do issue for the balance of $53,644.80 only.

I

2.

. 2. That, without prejudice to any order tor- costs ,
dlraudy made, Lhe respondent pay three-quarters of

the applicant's costs of the proceedings.

Note :  Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order
36 of the Federal Court Rules.

.

IN T E F E Z 3 A L CCUF!T OF ATJS?TALIA )
)
TASYANZAN D I S T R I C T REGISTRY ) N o . TG3 of 198:
)
GEVERAL D I V I S I O N )

AND: CAFIKE PTY. LTC. tra?lnq as

PORT ARTHUR CIDE? C3VP.N'I

Cross-Responder,:

CORAM :  BEAUMONT J
PLACE  : HOBART
DATE : 25 MAY 1988

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Cafike Pty . Ltd. ( "Cafike") , trading as Pot-! A?-'.?.ur
Cider Company, sues R.R. & S.F. Powe11 P5y. Ltd., t r a < ? r ~ 3:
G m v e Frx i t Juices (Tas.) ("Gt-Gve"), on several c a ~ s ~ s nf a,:?-.c,n
'a:lesrd t o have ariser. out. of an arrangemert made betx2en the

parties in 1994 for the marketing and distribution gf

juice. Grove has cross-claimed a3a:nst Caf-ke in re?pe.:t .-f

severa: causes of aczion said to arise out of their r?lat:onsh1?,

which suhiated u n t l l early 1987.

A: "ze tine of t>.e5+ neqatiations, Sc;ve was ergage6 ',r

the whclesale rarketlng and dls:<:Sut:sr of fr.Al'r ; l l l C ? Z

throughout Tasmania on a ;ubstantla1 scale. Caf.-ke "ad cmnmencer!

the production of apple j u i . : ~ in a. relatively srrall way ar. Yno?.ys
OII 2he Tasman peninsular 3 few years eIr11Pr. At t ; T = ,
Cafike was distrihting its product Imder the trade name 'Grzhat-2
PresseC: Fro:? Apple JLI~CP" or! a mcdest scale t c l o c a l r e f a l l
outlets. I: was also supplying juice tcr C'r-ung Sing, a wx-esale . .
f ru i t and vegetable merchant in Hcbart. I n early 1OP4, Csfi!r=.
carriec! out a num3er of improvements to 5 2 s pr8331iLct ar? c+,ng+<
%he name of the juice to "ILDPL,%:D".
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Edelsten v Health Insurance Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1988] FCA 258
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Cafike Pty. Ltd. ("Cafike"), trading as Port Arthur Cider Company, sued R.R. and S.M. Powell Pty. Ltd. ("Grove") on several causes of action arising out of an arrangement made in 1984 for the marketing and distribution of juice. Grove cross-claimed against Cafike in respect of several causes of action said to arise out of their relationship, which subsisted until early 1987. The primary dispute between the parties was whether there had been a breach of the terms of the marketing arrangement made in 1984. The court found that Grove had breached the agreement by increasing its prices without informing Cafike of its intention to do so. Consequently, Cafike was entitled to terminate the agreement in May 1986. The court held that Cafike was entitled to the price of goods sold and delivered in January and February 1987, as well as damages for the passing off of its product by Grove. Grove was ordered to pay Cafike's costs of the proceedings, three-quarters of which were awarded to Cafike.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.