Bell v The Queen; Independent Commissioner Against Corruption v Bell

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

BELL v THE QUEEN; R v BELL; INDEPENDENT COMMISSIONER AGAINST CORRUPTION v BELL

[2020] SASCFC 116

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Chief Justice Kourakis, The Honourable Justice Peek and The Honourable Justice Blue)

3 December 2020

CRIMINAL LAW - APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - PROCEDURE - POWER TO BRING APPEAL - FROM INTERLOCUTORY OR ANTECEDENT JUDGMENT OR ORDER

CRIMINAL LAW - PROCEDURE - ADJOURNMENT, STAY OF PROCEEDINGS OR ORDER RESTRAINING PROCEEDINGS - STAY OF PROCEEDINGS

PROCEDURE - STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS: JURISDICTION, POWERS AND GENERALLY - DECLARATIONS - CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS - GENERALLY

The appellant Troy Bell is being prosecuted by the Director of Public Prosecutions in the District Court on 20 counts of theft and six counts of dishonestly dealing with documents. The prosecution followed a referral for prosecution by the Independent Commissioner Against Corruption to the Director (following an investigation by the Commissioner).

Mr Bell sought a permanent stay of the prosecution on the grounds that he cannot receive a fair trial and the administration of justice would otherwise be brought into disrepute by reason of:

(a) the referral by the Commissioner of the matter for prosecution to the Director, which Mr Bell contends was beyond power;

(b) the provision by the Commissioner to the Director of evidentiary material obtained using compulsive powers, which Mr Bell contends was beyond power;

(c) the exercise by the Commissioner after the referral and after the institution of the prosecution of compulsive powers and taking of other steps, which Mr Bell contends was beyond power; and

(d) the taking of steps, or failures to take steps, by the Commissioner that Mr Bell contends wrongly resulted in the maintenance of confidentiality in respect of dealings with and the evidence of witnesses.

A Judge of the District Court largely upheld Mr Bell’s contentions concerning conduct by the Commissioner but dismissed his application for a permanent stay because that conduct did not entail that Mr Bell cannot receive a fair trial or that the administration of justice would otherwise be brought into disrepute.

Mr Bell appeals against the dismissal of his application for a permanent stay of the prosecution. The District Court Judge reserved for the consideration of the Full Court a series of questions of law concerning the powers and conduct of the Commissioner. The Commissioner seeks declarations that the impugned conduct was within power and not unlawful.

Held by the Court:

1. The Commissioner is authorised by section 7(1)(a)(i) of the Independent Commissioner Against Corruption Act 2012 (SA) to refer a matter for prosecution to the Director. The referral by the Commissioner to the Director in May 2017 was not unlawful. The Judge erred in concluding to the contrary (at [196]).

2. The Commissioner is entitled on a referral for prosecution to provide to the Director evidentiary material compiled during the course of an investigation, including evidentiary material obtained using compulsive powers. The provision of such material by the Commissioner to the Director in May…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bell v The Queen; Independent Commissioner Against Corruptio... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] SASCFC 116
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia considered an originating application by the Independent Commissioner Against Corruption (ICAC) seeking declarations that it possessed certain powers and had acted lawfully. This proceeding arose in the context of criminal proceedings against Mr Bell, who contended that the ICAC lacked the powers it claimed to exercise.

The Court was required to determine the scope of the ICAC's powers, particularly concerning the use of evidence obtained during investigations and the circumstances under which non-communication directions could be issued. Specifically, the Court had to interpret section 56A of the Independent Commissioner Against Corruption Act 2012 (SA), which governs the use of evidence obtained by the ICAC, and Schedule 2, clause 3(9) and (10) of the Act, which relates to the power of an examiner to issue non-communication directions. The Court also considered the definition of "corruption in public administration" as defined by the Act.

The Court reasoned that section 56A(1) permits evidence obtained by the ICAC to be used for criminal investigations and proceedings, even if the evidence was not originally obtained for those specific proceedings. Furthermore, section 56A(1a) clarifies that such evidence is considered lawfully obtained despite any jurisdictional error in the exercise of the ICAC's powers. Regarding non-communication directions, the Court noted that Schedule 2, clause 3(10) mandates such directions if a person's safety or reputation, or the fair trial of a person charged with an offence, might be prejudiced. The Court also affirmed the broad definition of corruption in public administration under the Act, which includes various offences committed by public officers.

The Court made declarations that the Commissioner had the powers that Mr Bell contended the Commissioner lacked and had acted lawfully.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

By originating application, the Commissioner seeks declarations that the Commissioner had the powers that Mr Bell contends the Commissioner lacks and acted lawfully. This proceeding was directed to be heard and determined by this Court.BackgroundProsecution case The prosecution case, drawn from a summary prepared by the Director for the Judge, can be summarised as follows. Obviously, these are just allegations at this stage, which are not proved, and various of the allegations will or may be in contest at the trial of the criminal proceeding (if the matter proceeds to trial). Mr Bell was employed by the Department of Education and Children’s Services[12] (the Department) from 1996 to 2001 and 2003 to 2013. This included positions at the Department’s Limestone Coast Regional Office from 2003 to 2013 and concurrently at Millicent High School from 2011 to 2013.[12] Known later during Mr Bell’s employment as the Department of Education and Child Development. John Shelton has been the principal of Millicent High School since 2005. Mr Bell was instrumental in the establishment by the Department, and more specifically Millicent High School, of an off-school campus in Mount Gambier known as the Independent Learning Centre as a learning centre for students who had become disengaged from formal education. The Independent Learning Centre operated from January 2007 out of premises at 5 Percy Street Mount Gambier. A youth worker, Christine Hart, was initially engaged for six months. The Independent Learning Centre was managed by a Department employee designated as Manager, being Robert Barton from January 2007, Peter Fox from January 2008 and Mr Bell from January 2011 to March 2013. The Independent Learning Centre was funded initially by the Department and by the Federal government-funded FOCiS on Youth program and thereafter by Department funds administered by Millicent High School derived from State and Federal government grants. The operation of the Independent Learning Centre was at least initially conducted by the Department. The Independent Learning Centre was never a legal entity as such. By 2008 Mr Bell had become an executive member of the South East Education and Training Association Inc (SEETA), a not-for-profit association incorporated under the Associations Incorporation Act 1985 (SA). Helen Strickland was the Chairperson of SEETA until October 2008, when Mr Bell became Chairperson and Public Officer. Jan Shanahan performed the bookkeeping for SEETA. In February 2008 it was resolved at a general meeting of members of SEETA that, at the request of the Independent Learning Centre, SEETA would provide payroll services for, and enter into a lease agreement for the premises at 5 Percy Street Mount Gambier occupied by, the Centre. Mr Bell and Ms Strickland executed on behalf of SEETA a lease agreement with the landlord of the Percy Street premises. In May 2008 SEETA became the employer of Ms Hart instead of merely providing payroll services. In August 2008 SEETA employed a second youth worker, Palma Edmonds. Thereafter SEETA employed all staff working at the Independent Learning Centre other than Department employees (such as the Manager).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 56A provides for the use of evidence and information obtained by the lawful exercise of powers in relation to suspected corruption or misconduct/maladministration. It provides:56A—Use of evidence or information(1)Subject to this Act (but despite any other Act or law) evidence or information obtained (whether before or after the commencement of this section) by the lawful exercise of powers in relation to suspected corruption, misconduct or maladministration in public administration—(a) may be used for the purposes of any other investigation in relation to suspected corruption, misconduct or maladministration in public administration; and(b) may be provided to, and may be received and used by—(i)law enforcement agencies and prosecution authorities for the purposes of any criminal investigation or proceedings or proceedings for the imposition of a penalty; and(ii)public authorities for the purposes of any disciplinary investigation or action in relation to suspected corruption, misconduct or maladministration in public administration,whether the investigation, proceedings or action relate to, or arise from, the same matter or a different matter; and(c) is not inadmissible in proceedings before a court merely because the evidence or information was not obtained for the purposes of those proceedings.(1a)For the purposes of subsection (1), evidence or information will be taken to be obtained by a lawful exercise of powers in relation to suspected corruption, misconduct or maladministration in public administration notwithstanding a jurisdictional error in the exercise of those powers.(2)No civil or criminal liability lies against a person in respect of any use of evidence or information permitted by this section.ConfidentialityNon-communication and non-disclosure directions Schedule 2 clause 3(9) empowers an examiner to give a direction (a non-communication direction) that certain information in relation to an examination under clause 3 not be communicated to any person subject to specified exceptions. Subclause (10) provides that a non-communication direction must be given if:·the safety or reputation of a person; or·the fair trial of a person charged with an offence,might otherwise be prejudiced. Subclauses (9) and (10) provide:(9)An examiner may direct that—(a) any evidence given before the examiner; or(b) the contents of any document, or a description of any thing, produced to the examiner; or(c) any information that might enable a person who has given evidence before the examiner to be identified; or(d) the fact that any person has given or may be about to give evidence at an examination,must not be communicated or provided to any person, or must not be communicated or provided except in such manner, and to such persons, as the examiner specifies.(10)The examiner must give such a direction if the failure to do so might prejudice the safety or reputation of a person or prejudice the fair trial of a person who has been, or may be, charged with an offence.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Thus subsections 5(1) and (2) provide:(1)Corruption in public administration means conduct that constitutes—(a) an offence against Part 7 Division 4 (Offences relating to public officers) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935, which includes the following offences:(i)bribery or corruption of public officers;(ii)threats or reprisals against public officers;(iii)abuse of public office;(iv)demanding or requiring benefit on basis of public office;(v)offences relating to appointment to public office; or(b) an offence against the Public Sector (Honesty and Accountability) Act 1995 or the Public Corporations Act 1903, or an attempt to commit such an offence; or(ba) an offence against the Lobbyists Act 2015, or an attempt to commit such an offence; or(c) any other offence (including an offence against Part 5 (Offences of dishonesty) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935) committed by a public officer while acting in his or her capacity as a public officer or by a former public officer and related to his or her former capacity as a public officer, or by a person before becoming a public officer and related to his or her capacity as a public officer, or an attempt to commit such an offence; or(d) any of the following in relation to an offence referred to in a preceding paragraph:(i)aiding, abetting, counselling or procuring the commission of the offence;(ii)inducing, whether by threats or promises or otherwise, the commission of the offence;(iii)being in any way, directly or indirectly, knowingly concerned in, or party to, the commission of the offence;(iv)conspiring with others to effect the commission of the offence.(2)If the Commissioner suspects that an offence that is not corruption in public administration (an incidental offence) may be directly or indirectly connected with, or may be a part of, a course of activity involving the commission of corruption in public administration (whether or not the Commissioner has identified the nature of that corruption), then the incidental offence is, for so long only as the Commissioner so suspects, taken for the purposes of this Act to be corruption in public administration. A “public officer” is defined by subsection 4(1) to be a person listed in the first column of the table in Schedule 1. This includes members of the legislature, executive and judiciary, police officers, Public Service employees and various other persons.Primary objects and functions of Commissioner The Act creates the office of the Commissioner (and Acting Commissioner)[20] and allocates the primary responsibility for the investigation or assignment of the investigation of potential corruption offences, and insofar as addressed by the Act referral for prosecution, to the Commissioner.[21] Before the enactment of the Act, the primary responsibility for the investigation of offences defined by the Act to be corruption offences was that of the South Australian Police (SAPOL).[20] Independent Commissioner Against Corruption Act 2012 (SA) sections 8 and 11.[21] Independent Commissioner Against Corruption Act 2012 (SA) sections 7, 23, 24, 26 to 32, 43, 56A, Schedule 2 and Schedule 3.