Chibanda v Chief Executive, Queensland Health

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Chibanda v Chief Executive, Queensland Health & Anor [2020] QCA 144

PARTIES:

JOHN CHIBANDA
(applicant)
v
CHIEF EXECUTIVE, QUEENSLAND HEALTH
(first respondent)
MEDICAL BOARD OF AUSTRALIA
(second respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 9021 of 2018
SC No 12141 of 2017

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

Application for Extension of Time/General Civil Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:


Supreme Court at Brisbane – [2018] QSC 128 (Applegarth J)

DELIVERED ON:

30 June 2020

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

Heard on the papers

JUDGES:

Sofronoff P and Boddice and Davis JJ

ORDERS:

1.   Grant the application for an extension of time to appeal.

2.   Refuse the application to adduce further evidence.

3.   Dismiss the appeal with costs.

CATCHWORDS:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – JUDICIAL REVIEW – PROCEDURE AND EVIDENCE – TIME FOR APPLICATION – where the applicant applied for a statutory order of review of decisions made by the respondents which resulted in the termination of the applicant’s employment with Queensland Health and the end of his conditional registration as a medical practitioner – where the application was made, at best, five years out of time – where the trial judge dismissed the application because the applicant had not provided an adequate justification for the grant of an extension of time in the circumstances – where the applicant seeks to appeal out of time – where the applicant applies to adduce further evidence on appeal – whether the new evidence overcomes the delay and the availability of other avenues of review – whether the trial judge erred in determining it was in the interests of justice for the judicial review application to be dismissed

Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Qld), s 3
Crime and Corruption Act 2001 (Qld)
Crime and Misconduct Act 2001 (Qld), s 15, s 33, s 34, s 35, s 48, s 49, s 219F, s 219G, s 219BA
Health Practitioners (Disciplinary Proceedings) Act 1999 (Qld)
Health Practitioners (Professional Standards) Act 1999 (Qld), s 51, s 115, s 116, s 118
Health Practitioner Regulation National Law Act 2009 (Qld)
Health Quality and Complaints Commission Act 2006 (Qld)
Judicial Review Act 1991 (Qld), s 4, s 9, s 13, s 20, s 26, s 32, s 48
Medical Practitioners Registration Act
2001 (Qld), s 132, s 133, s 134, s 135, s 140
Public Service Act 2008 (Qld), s 189, s 191

Ainsworth v Criminal Justice Commission (1992) 175 CLR 564; [1992] HCA 10, applied
Attorney-General (NT) v Minister for Aboriginal Affairs (1986) 67 ALR 282; [1986] FCA 269, cited
Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond (1990) 170 CLR 321; [1990] HCA 33, cited
Edelsten v Health Insurance Commission (1990) 27 FCR 56; [1990] FCA 449, cited
Griffith University v Tang (2005) 221 CLR 99; [2005] HCA 7, applied
Kelson v Forward (1995) 60 FCR 39; [1995] FCA 1584, cited
Margarula v Minister for the Environment (1999) 92 FCR 35; [1999] FCA 730, cited
Pancontinental Mining…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Chibanda v Chief Executive, Queensland Health and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QCA 144
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Chibanda v Chief Executive, Queensland Health, the applicant, Chibanda, sought judicial review of decisions made by Queensland Health that resulted in the termination of his employment and his conditional registration as a medical practitioner. The trial judge dismissed the application because it was made more than five years after the decisions were made, without an adequate justification for the delay. Chibanda subsequently sought to appeal out of time and applied to adduce further evidence on appeal. The key legal issues were whether the new evidence could overcome the delay in bringing the application and whether the trial judge had erred in determining it was in the interests of justice for the application to be dismissed.

The court considered whether the new evidence provided a satisfactory explanation for the delay in bringing the application for judicial review. The new evidence included allegations of marital difficulties, the applicant's pursuit of relief in other forums, delays in receiving relevant documents from the respondents, and the applicant's own inquiries into the misconduct allegations. However, the court concluded that none of these factors adequately explained the seven-year delay. Additionally, the court noted that an alternative avenue of appeal to the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) was available and had been initiated but subsequently withdrawn. The court held that the new evidence did not overcome the critical matters of the significant delay and the availability of other avenues of review.

The court refused the application to adduce further evidence and dismissed the appeal with costs. The court found no error in the trial judge's decision and granted the application for an extension of time to appeal, but refused the application to adduce further evidence.

ORDERS:
1. Grant the application for an extension of time to appeal.
2. Refuse the application to adduce further evidence.
3. Dismiss the appeal with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Grant the application for an extension of time to appeal.

2. Refuse the application to adduce further evidence.

3. Dismiss the appeal with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On the material before him, Applegarth J was right to conclude that the failure to pursue the statutorily provided avenue of appeal to QCAT defeated the applicant’s application for judicial review.[65][65]Chibanda v Chief Executive, Queensland Health & Anor [2018] QSC 128 at [13].Application to adduce fresh evidence By the evidence which the applicant wishes to have admitted on appeal, the applicant seeks to explain the delay in bringing the application for judicial review and seeks to explain why the QCAT proceedings were abandoned. His submission must be that it was not in “the interests of justice”[66] to dismiss the application even though there was an alternative avenue of review.[66]Judicial Review Act 1991 (Qld), s 13. The applicant’s proposed new evidence makes a series of allegations and assertions attempting to explain the delay in filing the application for judicial review. These include:(a)the applicant had marital difficulties;(b)he sought relief in both the QCAT and the Queensland Industrial Relations Commission as a result of his dismissal;(c)the respondents delayed in releasing relevant documents to him; and(d)the applicant spent time making his own inquiries into the misconduct allegations. If the new evidence is admitted, none of it overcomes critical matters:(a)The refusal to renew the applicant’s special purpose registration was made on 17 February 2010, over seven and a half years before the application for judicial review was filed.(b)An avenue of appeal to QCAT was statutorily provided, therefore enlivening s 13 of the JR Act.(c)An application to QCAT was filed on 25 February 2010.[67](d)The QCAT application was subsequently withdrawn on 21 June 2010.[67]ARB, p 193 (Exhibit AES2-2 to the Affidavit of AE Smith, sworn 24 May 2018). There is nothing in the evidence which satisfactorily explains the seven year delay and nothing which would suggest that it is not in the interests of justice for the judicial review application to be dismissed pursuant to s 13 of the JR Act. For those reasons, I would refuse the application to adduce fresh evidence.Conclusion No error by Applegarth J has been identified. I would grant the application for an extension of time to appeal, refuse the application to adduce further evidence and dismiss the appeal with costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Whether a report is itself a reviewable decision depends upon the proper construction of the relevant statute. Where a statute provides for the making of a report, the report is arguably a “decision made … under an enactment”[33] and is therefore reviewable independently of any administrative decision made consequent upon the report.[34][33]Judicial Review Act 1991 (Qld), ss 4 and 9.[34]Compare Pancontinental Mining Ltd v Burns (1994) 52 FCR 454; Edelsten v Health Insurance Commission (1990) 27 FCR 56; and see Ainsworth v Criminal Justice Commission (1992) 175 CLR 564 at 580-581.Report approval decision It is clear from the memorandum of 20 January 2011 (the report approval decision) that the report is one prepared by the Ethical Standards Unit within Queensland Health and forwarded to the Crime and Misconduct Commission (the CMC). The CMC was a body established under the Crime and Misconduct Act 2001 (the CMC Act). The CMC Act has been substantially amended and is now the Crime and Corruption Act 2001. The CMC is no longer in existence and its successor is the Crime and Corruption Commission. The CMC Act cast upon the CMC functions concerning “misconduct”.[35] “Misconduct” included “official misconduct” which was defined as conduct including that which, if proved, was “a disciplinary breach providing reasonable grounds for terminating the person’s services, if the person is or was the holder of an appointment”.[36][35]Section 33. [36]Section 15. Where a complaint was received about “official misconduct”, the CMC could refer the complaint back to the relevant “unit of public administration” for investigation.[37] Here, that was Queensland Health. The CMC may then monitor the investigation[38] and the investigation may lead to disciplinary or criminal action.[39] [37]Section 35.[38]Section 48.[39]Section 49. By s 48 of the CMC Act:“48 Commission’s monitoring role for official misconduct(1)The commission may, having regard to the principles stated in section 34—[40][40]Section 34 guides the CMC on how it should exercise its misconduct investigating role. (a) issue advisory guidelines for the conduct of investigations by public officials into official misconduct; or(b) review or audit the way a public official has dealt with official misconduct, in relation to either a particular complaint or a class of complaint; or(c) require a public official—(i)to report to the commission about an investigation into official misconduct in the way and at the times the commission directs; or(ii)to undertake the further investigation into the official misconduct that the commission directs; or(d) assume responsibility for and complete an investigation by a public official into official misconduct.(2)The public official must—(a) give the commission reasonable help to undertake a review or audit or to assume responsibility for an investigation; and(b) comply with a requirement made under subsection (1)(c).(3)If the commission assumes responsibility for an investigation, the public official must stop his or her investigation or any other action that may impede the investigation if directed to do so by the commission.(4)In this section—complaint, about official misconduct, includes information or matter involving official misconduct.” (emphasis added)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.