Chibanda v Chief Executive, Queensland Health

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Chibanda v Chief Executive, Queensland Health & Anor [2018] QSC 128

PARTIES:

JOHN CHIBANDA

(applicant)

v
CHIEF EXECUTIVE, QUEENSLAND HEALTH
(first respondent)
MEDICAL BOARD OF AUSTRALIA

(second respondent)

FILE NO/S:

BS No 12141 of 2017

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

4 June 2018

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

24 May 2018

JUDGE:

Applegarth J

ORDERS:

1.     The applicant’s application for an extension of time is dismissed.

2.     The applicant’s proceeding is dismissed. 

CATCHWORDS:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – JUDICIAL REVIEW – PROCEDURE AND EVIDENCE – TIME FOR APPLICATION – where applicant applies for judicial review several years after “decisions” made – whether applicant ought be granted extension of time where no adequate explanation for delay

Judicial Review Act 1991 ss 6, 27, 48 and 49

Aurukun Bauxite Development Pty Ltd v Queensland [2016] QSC 263; (2016) 222 LGERA 107 cited
Hoffman v The Queensland Local Government Superannuation Board [1994] 1 Qd R 369 cited
Kuku Djungan Aboriginal Corporation v Christensen [1993] 2 Qd R 663; [1992] QSC 417 cited

COUNSEL:

The applicant appeared on his own behalf
M T Hickey for the first respondent

S A McLeod for the second respondent

SOLICITORS:

The applicant appeared on his own behalf
Crown Law for the first respondent

Minter Ellison for the second respondent

  1. The applicant seeks judicial review of what are said to be “decisions” made several years ago. Each respondent applies pursuant to s 48 of the Judicial Review Act 1991 (“JRA”) to dismiss the proceeding because:

    (a)it was filed years after the time limit for commencing such a proceeding; and

    (b)the proceeding does not disclose a reasonable basis to conclude that the decisions are amenable to judicial review.

    The applicant cross-applies for an extension of time.

    Background

  2. This background is drawn principally from an annexure to the applicant’s affidavit filed 16 November 2017 and documents exhibited to his affidavit filed 16 May 2018.

  3. The applicant was employed as a Senior Medical Officer by Queensland Health in 2007 and, after a period in Rockhampton, worked at the Emerald Hospital. He had been registered by the Medical Board of Queensland for the period 17 September 2008 to 16 September 2009 for a “Special Purpose” pursuant to s 135 of the Medical Practitioners Registration Act 2001. The special purpose activity was to fill an area of need as a Senior Medical Officer at the Emerald Hospital. His registration required him to comply with various conditions.

  4. In 2009 the applicant failed in his second attempt to pass the Australian Medical Council Multiple Choice Examination.  His recent failure was noted at a meeting of the Registration Advisory Committee of the Medical Board of Queensland on 19 October 2009.

  5. Certain allegations in relation to the applicant’s conduct and competence were investigated by Queensland Health.  By letter dated 4 November 2009, the applicant was advised by the District Chief Executive Officer of Queensland Health that he had been suspended from duty.  The letter…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Chibanda v Chief Executive, Queensland Health and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QSC 128
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Chibanda v Chief Executive, Queensland Health involved the applicant, a former Senior Medical Officer, seeking judicial review of decisions made several years prior by the Chief Executive of Queensland Health and the Medical Board of Queensland. The applicant alleged these decisions were flawed and sought an extension of time for filing his application due to the delay. The respondents sought to dismiss the application on grounds of untimeliness and lack of a reasonable basis for judicial review. The court was tasked with deciding whether the applicant should be granted an extension of time for filing the application, and if the application itself disclosed a reasonable basis for judicial review.

The court considered whether the applicant provided an adequate explanation for the significant delay in filing the application. It noted that the applicant had failed to provide a satisfactory explanation for the delay. The court also examined whether the decisions in question were amenable to judicial review under the Judicial Review Act 1991. The applicant's application was deemed to be confusing and did not clearly identify the decisions to be reviewed or the grounds for judicial review. Furthermore, the applicant had previously withdrawn a review proceeding before the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal, which the court found undermined the applicant's claim that the earlier proceeding fell through on a technicality.

The court ultimately dismissed the application for an extension of time, finding no adequate explanation for the delay. The court also dismissed the proceeding itself, concluding that the application did not disclose a reasonable basis for judicial review. The court held that the applicant had not demonstrated that the decisions were amenable to judicial review or that there was a reasonable prospect of success in the review.

The court made two final orders. Firstly, the applicant’s application for an extension of time was dismissed. Secondly, the applicant’s proceeding for judicial review was dismissed. The court found that the applicant had not met the necessary criteria for either an extension of time or a successful judicial review application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant’s application for an extension of time is dismissed.

2. The applicant’s proceeding is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant seeks judicial review of what are said to be “decisions” made several years ago. Each respondent applies pursuant to s 48 of the Judicial Review Act 1991 (“JRA”) to dismiss the proceeding because:(a)it was filed years after the time limit for commencing such a proceeding; and(b)the proceeding does not disclose a reasonable basis to conclude that the decisions are amenable to judicial review.The applicant cross-applies for an extension of time.Background This background is drawn principally from an annexure to the applicant’s affidavit filed 16 November 2017 and documents exhibited to his affidavit filed 16 May 2018. The applicant was employed as a Senior Medical Officer by Queensland Health in 2007 and, after a period in Rockhampton, worked at the Emerald Hospital. He had been registered by the Medical Board of Queensland for the period 17 September 2008 to 16 September 2009 for a “Special Purpose” pursuant to s 135 of the Medical Practitioners Registration Act 2001. The special purpose activity was to fill an area of need as a Senior Medical Officer at the Emerald Hospital. His registration required him to comply with various conditions. In 2009 the applicant failed in his second attempt to pass the Australian Medical Council Multiple Choice Examination. His recent failure was noted at a meeting of the Registration Advisory Committee of the Medical Board of Queensland on 19 October 2009. Certain allegations in relation to the applicant’s conduct and competence were investigated by Queensland Health. By letter dated 4 November 2009, the applicant was advised by the District Chief Executive Officer of Queensland Health that he had been suspended from duty. The letter stated that the suspension was based on the reasonable belief that due to the nature of certain allegations against him he may be liable to disciplinary action. In January 2010 the Medical Board of Queensland refused to renew his registration. Queensland Health then terminated his employment. The application for a statutory order of review filed 16 November 2017 indicated that the relevant decision of the first respondent (then incorrectly named) was “Approval of an investigation report of misconduct allegations against Applicant”. On 16 March 2018 Mullins J made a number of orders which included an order that the application be amended to clearly state the decisions to which the application relates. The amended application filed on 23 March 2018 is a very confusing document in terms of its identification of each decision which is amenable to judicial review under the JRA and the grounds for judicial review. The solicitors for each respondent requested further and better particulars. The applicant’s response to the first respondent’s request identified the decision sought to be reviewed as follows:“Decision made by way of report and its approval on (sic) investigations by the first respondent. The report does not indicate under what section or Act it was made. The report was approved on the 20th of January 2011.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The report, which the applicant stated at the hearing was 450 pages, is not in evidence before me. The applicant told me that he had a copy of the report and parts of it were redacted. Exhibited to his affidavit filed 21 May 2018 is an excerpt from the report. In any case, exhibit R1-6 to the applicant’s affidavit filed 16 May 2018 is a Memorandum to the Director General of Health. Its subject is an investigation report undertaken by the Ethical Standards Unit which was said to have completed its investigation. The Memorandum refers to four allegations relating to the applicant, three of which were found to be substantiated, and two allegations about the performance of senior staff who were supposed to manage and supervise the applicant at Emerald Hospital. The investigation was said to have been a multi-disciplinary investigation coordinated by the Ethical Standards Unit in conjunction with officers from other entities. The Memorandum was signed by the Manager - Investigation Services, Ethical Standards Unit on 17 November 2010, signed by the Director – Ethical Standards Unit on 15 December 2010 and approved by the Director General on 20 January 2011.The challenged “decisions” of the second respondent The amended application for a statutory order of review seeks to review the “refusal of conditional registration of Applicant by the Second Respondent”. However, it appears that the applicant seeks to challenge two decisions of the second respondent. His response to the request for further and better particulars refers to the second respondent’s “refusal of renewal of Applicant’s registration” and “the decision to find the Applicant guilty of misconduct”. The first matter relates to a decision of which the applicant was advised by letter dated 17 February 2010. The Medical Board of Queensland had decided to refuse the applicant’s application for renewal of a special purpose registration under s 135 of the Medical Practitioners Registration Act 2001. The letter, a copy of which is exhibit AES2‑1 to the affidavit of Ms Smith filed by leave on 24 May 2018, enclosed an information notice relating to the Board’s decision, which outlined the reasons for the decision and informed the applicant of review rights by which he might apply to review the decision to the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT). Shortly stated, the Board was not satisfied the applicant had made reasonable progress towards general, specialist or special purpose s 138 registration. He had twice failed the relevant multiple choice exam. He had received borderline assessments from his supervisor. His exam results and assessments raised concerns about his suitability to perform the duties of a Senior Medical Officer. On or about 25 February 2010 the applicant brought a review proceeding in QCAT. On 21 June 2010 he withdrew the proceeding. He contends in this proceeding that the “application fell through on technicality”. However, he was legally represented at the time. By letter dated 21 June 2010, the solicitors then acting for the Board informed it that at a directions hearing leave was granted for the application for review to be withdrawn and indicated that the withdrawal of the application concluded the matter.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.