Orders
Orders of the court
ORDERS
MLG 1972 of 2017
BETWEEN:
ECC17
Applicant
AND:
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION
First Respondent
IMMIGRATION ASSESSMENT AUTHORITY
Second Respondent
ORDER MADE BY:
JUDGE RIETHMULLER
DATE OF ORDER:
29 JULY 2021
Amended pursuant to 16.05 of the Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 on 31 July 2021
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1. A writ of certiorari issue directed to the Second Respondent, quashing the decision of the Second Respondent dated 24 August 2017.
2. A writ of mandamus issue directed to the Second Respondent, requiring the Second Respondent to determine the application for review according to law.
3. The First Respondent pay the Applicant’s costs fixed in the sum of $7,467 AND THAT these costs be paid directly to the applicant’s legal representative.
AND THE COURT NOTES THAT:
A. These Orders have been amended pursuant to rule 16.05 of the Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth).
Background
Background to the litigation
At the conclusion of the hearing, on 31 May 2021, I granted the parties liberty to file further material. The First Respondent filed a Statement of Agreed facts on 7 June 2021, addressing the aspects of the audio recording of the interview before the delegate. The applicant filed a Further Amended Application and supporting Further Outline of Submissions. The Amended Application still sets out the same single ground for review, but adds subsection (aa), to which the Minister filed a response on 28 June 2021.BACKGROUND The applicant was born on 21 June 1989 and is a citizen of Sri Lanka, of Tamil ethnicity and Hindu faith. The applicant left his home country in October 2012 and arrived at Cocos Island on 14 November 2012. An ‘Entry Interview’ was conducted on Christmas Island on 16 January 2013. The applicant applied for an Australian Safe Haven Enterprise (‘SHEV’) visa on 16 January 2013. He was interviewed by a delegate for the Minister on 10 April 2017 and a decision was made on 14 June 2017, refusing his application. This decision was referred to the IAA for review pursuant to Pt 7AA of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (‘the Act’). The IAA affirmed the delegate’s decision not to grant the protection visa on 24 August 2017. That decision is the subject of this review.Applicant Case The applicant claims to be from [applicant’s village], Jaffna in the Northern Province of Sri Lanka, an area designated as a ‘high security zone’ by local authorities: see paragraph [4] of the Applicant Submissions filed on 7 August 2019. At his initial interview, the applicant stated that his life was in danger in Sri Lanka, where he had been detained and beaten by the Sri Lankan Army (‘SLA’), on at least twenty-five occasions: see paragraph [3] of First Respondent Submissions filed on 28 August 2019. The applicant says the SLA subjected him to continuous harassment and mistreatment. The applicant’s claims are set out at pages 71 to 73 of the Court Book (‘CB’) as follows:2. I was born on 21 June, 1989 in Jaffna, Northern Province. I grew up near [V] and from the age of ten lived in [applicant’s village], [A], Jaffua, Northern Province, with my parents and siblings. By the end of 1994, I had five siblings - an older brother and two older sisters, and two younger brothers. My father was a farmer and my mother was a home-maker, until her death in 1994. My father and my five siblings still live in [applicant’s village], Jaffna, Northern Province Sri Lanka. My older brother has married and lives in a separate house in [V]. My father lives together with my two sisters and my two younger brothers. My two sisters have both now married and are preparing to move out to live with their husbands. Relevant experiences 3.My problems first began in 2008 when I was 19 years old. There is an army base camp near [applicant’s village] where I lived with my family, plus a number of smaller army camps also nearby. The area is known as a 'high security zone'. The army would conduct regular patrols around the village and through every part of the village. They would patrol in regular groups of around ten men in each patrol, sometimes coming together in larger groups. On a number of occasions I was stopped, questioned and harassed, and frequently hit or beaten, by members of the army patrols. For example, they would stop me when I was walking home from working on my family's farm land and question me and slap me across the face when I tried to answer their questions. This happened at least fifteen or twenty times.4. On a number of occasions, around five or six times, I was ordered to report to an army camp at a set time in the evening. It was not always the same camp - there were three camps that I ended up reporting to, including [Union Camp] - but it was always in the evening I had to be there. When I reported to an army camp they would again throw questions at me, and beat me and slap me around. 5. My older brother left [V] around 1997-98 to work in Tricamolee, where he met and married his wife. He did not return to [V] until around 2006 when he returned with his wife and two small daughters to live near my father in [V]. Because he was a married dad with two small girls, he escaped the attention of the authorities during the turbulent period from 2008 onwards. My two younger brothers were only primary school children during those years, so they also escaped the attention of the authorities.Instances of harm 6. When I was ordered to report to [Union camp] one time they detained me and kept me there for over six hours. This was near the beginning of 2009. They beat me very badly with a wooden baton and attacked my private parts, badly bruising me all over. But they never told me why they were detaining or beating me. It was hard for me to understand their broken Tamil, but they just kept yelling at me 'tell us why do you think you are standing here?’, ‘how many people in the LTTE do you know?, ‘tell us everything you know about the LTTE’. These sorts of things would be yelled at me every time I had to report to an army camp and I was always beaten, but that time at [Union camp] was the worst time.7. The war between the army and the LTTE intensified in early 2009 and the LTTE was defeated by the end of May 2009. The army presence in Northern Province intensified after that and every time a new command came to one of the camps near our village the harassment would begin anew. I was living in continual fear and the beatings and orders to attend the army camp continued. My sisters even had to come to beg for the army to let me go on one occasion. 8. April 14th 2012 was New Year's Day according to the Tamil Calendar and a holiday in Sri Lanka. The Sri Lankan army organised a New Year celebration for all the local people. But nearly all the local people who attended were Tamil Hindus, while the army personnel organizing the event were Sinhalese Buddhists. Around midnight when I was standing together with two of my friends listening to the music being played on the stage at the event, army personnel began rounding up a larger group of young men standing nearby. When the army mem saw myself and my two friends they came over and asked for our ID cards and asked where we were from. Because we came from an area which the army considered ' high security', the eight army officers around us decided to take us to the military base. When we arrived at the military camp the senjor officer there said 'you are from a high security area, so what were you doing out at that place at midnight?', then he slapped me and pushed my head hard against a wall. They kept up for over two hours before finally letting us go.9. The harassment and continual stoppings and beatings got worse after the event of 14 April 2012. Almost daily I was harassed and the men doing the harassing always carried guns. I became very ill and fearful under the pressure of this continued harassment. By September 2012 I was very weak and unable to work on the farm. 10. One day in September 2012 the husband of my father's sister, who I call uncle, came to om house and said 'you are leaving this country - just follow my instructions'. Near the end of October 2012, following my uncle's instructions, I travelled by bus, together with around 35 other men, from [V] to [P] arriving in [P] around 9 pm. That night, around midnight, we boarded a small boat sailing for about three hours to a bigger boat. There were around 96 men, women and children on the larger board which took nearly three weeks to arrive on Cocos Island. During the voyage we were often scared and we were shouted at by the men in command of the boat, who were Sinhalese.Identity documents 11. I have never owned or possessed a passport. When I boarded the boat in [P], I carried only my Sri Lankan national ID card. My Sri Lankan driver's license came to me via a friend of my family, a citizen of Australia, who visited my family on a visit to Sri Lanka. A copy of my birth certificate was sent to me by email from Sri Lanka.Fears on return 12. I cannot return to Sri Lanka. If I am forced to return, I will be detained upon arrival because I left Sri Lanka illegally. I will be arrested and likely charged. My family cannot afford bail to obtain my release, so I will be forced to remain in detention. In detention I fear I will not only be interrogated, but also harassed and beaten, or worse, because I am a young Tamil man from northern Sri Lanka.13. I cannot return to my home village or to anywhere near my home. The army still patrols the area and regularly calls in at the house where my father and my siblings live to harass then and to interrogate them about me and where I am. If the army finds out I have returned to Sri Lanka, and they will find out as soon as my arrival is documented, they (the army) will seek to interrogate, detain and harass me, or worse. I am now on the army records as having been a person of attention and a person who has left Sri Lanka illegally so they will definitely try to detain me. 14. The army is very powerful in Sri Lanka and many members of the police force and government are former army members and/ or have close connections to the army. Neither the civilian police nor the government have any desire or interest in protecting me. Nor is there anyone else in Sri Lanka who can offer any such protection.15. I would not be able to live free from harm or danger if forced to move to another part of Sri Lanka. In Colombo I have no connections or supports and I cannot properly speak the dominant language in that part of the country, which is Sinhalese. Nor would I be able to feel safe in any of the Tamil speaking areas in the North and Eastern parts of Sri Lanka as these areas are now full of military personnel, and more and more Sinhalese are living there. Being a young male of Tamil ethnicity from such a high security area as [V] was means that I am immediately a red flag to the army in Sri Lanka. They would never let me live in peace. In any event, even if I am released on bail after my return to Sri Lanka, the conditions of my bail will require me to report to the police in my home area, so I will not be able to go and live anywhere else.16. For these reasons, I seek protection in Australia. IAA Findings