Director of Public Prosecutions v Dalgliesh (a pseudonym)

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

KIEFEL CJ,
BELL, GAGELER, KEANE AND GORDON JJ

THE DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS  APPELLANT

AND

CHARLIE DALGLIESH (A PSEUDONYM)  RESPONDENT

Director of Public Prosecutions v Dalgliesh (a pseudonym)

[2017] HCA 41

11 October 2017

M1/2017

ORDER

1.Appeal allowed.

2.Set aside the order of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria made on 18 March 2016.

3.Remit the matter to the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria for determination of the appeal against sentence.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of Victoria

Representation

G J C Silbert QC with B L Sonnet for the appellant (instructed by Solicitor for Public Prosecutions (Vic))

O P Holdenson QC with P S Tiwana for the respondent (instructed by Joseph Burke Law)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. KIEFEL CJ, BELL AND KEANE JJ. Section 5(2)(b) of the Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic) ("the Sentencing Act") provides that in sentencing an offender a court must have regard to current sentencing practices.

  2. In the present case, the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria dismissed an appeal by the Director of Public Prosecutions ("the Director") against a sentence for the offence of incest.  The relevant ground of appeal was that the sentence was manifestly inadequate[1].  The Court of Appeal held that the sentence was within the range indicated by current sentencing practices and, on that basis, dismissed the Director's appeal, even though the Court also concluded that this range is so low that it "reveals error in principle" in that it is not proportionate to the objective gravity of the offending or the moral culpability of the offender[2].  Given that conclusion, the Court of Appeal erred by treating the range established by current sentencing practices as decisive of the appeal before it.  Accordingly, the appeal to this Court must be allowed.

    [1]The Director appealed on two grounds.  The second ground related to orders for cumulation, and was not the subject of appeal to this Court.

    The Sentencing Act

  3. Section 5(2) of the Sentencing Act relevantly provides:

    "In sentencing an offender a court must have regard to –

    (a)the maximum penalty prescribed for the offence; and

    …

    (b)current sentencing practices; and

    (c)the nature and gravity of the offence; and

    (d)the offender's culpability and degree of responsibility for the offence; and

    …

    (daa)the impact of the offence on any victim of the offence; and

    (da)the personal circumstances of any victim of the offence; and

    (db)any injury, loss or damage resulting directly from the offence; and

    (e)whether the offender pleaded guilty to the offence and, if so, the stage in the proceedings at which the offender did so or indicated an intention to do so; and

    (f)the offender's previous character; and

    (g)the presence of any aggravating or mitigating factor concerning the offender or…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Dalgliesh (a pseudonym) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] HCA 41
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia heard an appeal by the Director of Public Prosecutions against an order of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria. The dispute concerned the adequacy of a sentence imposed on the respondent for incest. The Director argued that the sentence was manifestly inadequate, a contention that the Court of Appeal acknowledged but ultimately did not fully address due to its interpretation of sentencing practices.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the Court of Appeal erred in its approach to sentencing, particularly in relation to the requirement under section 5(2)(b) of the *Sentencing Act 1991* (Vic) to have regard to "current sentencing practices." Specifically, the High Court considered whether the Court of Appeal's conclusion that current sentencing practices for incest were too low, yet constrained by them, prevented it from intervening to correct an error of principle.

The High Court reasoned that while sentencing involves balancing various factors, including current practices, this does not permit an appellate court to perpetuate an error of principle. The Court of Appeal had itself recognised that the sentence imposed was significantly lower than warranted by the gravity of the offence, the respondent's culpability, and the impact on the victim, but felt bound by the perceived narrow band of current sentencing practices. The High Court held that section 5(2)(b) did not mandate adherence to sentencing practices that were themselves demonstrably too low and reflected an error of principle.

Consequently, the High Court allowed the appeal, set aside the order of the Court of Appeal, and remitted the matter back to the Court of Appeal for a determination of the appeal against sentence, with the direction that the Court of Appeal should not be constrained by its previous interpretation of current sentencing practices.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed.

2. Set aside the order of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria made on 18 March 2016.

3. Remit the matter to the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria for determination of the appeal against sentence.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

KIEFEL CJ, BELL AND KEANE JJ GAGELER AND GORDON JJ
While it is true that, in the Appellant's Written Case filed by the Director with its notice of appeal, it was contended, inter alia, that comparable appellate cases demonstrated the extraordinary leniency of the sentence on charge 1, this contention was but one aspect of the Director's argument that the sentence was manifestly inadequate. It may therefore be concluded that the failure by the Court of Appeal to determine the appeal on the basis that the other aspects of the Director's argument were compelling was not due to any failure on the part of the Director to do what was reasonably required to assist the Court to avoid error.Conclusion and orders Given the Court of Appeal's conclusion that a sentence significantly higher than seven years' imprisonment for charge 1 was plainly warranted having regard to the maximum penalty prescribed for the offence, the gravity of the offence, the respondent's culpability, and the impact of the offence on the complainant, the Court should have allowed the Director's appeal. Section 5(2)(b) of the Sentencing Act did not require the Court to refrain from acting to remedy what it recognised to be a manifest injustice resulting from the perpetuation of an error of principle. The appeal to this Court should be allowed; and the order of the Court of Appeal dismissing the Director's appeal should be set aside. The matter should be remitted to the Court of Appeal for determination of the appeal against sentence. Section 5(2) of the Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic) specifies matters that a court "must have regard to" when sentencing an offender. One of the specified matters, under s 5(2)(b), is "current sentencing practices". Others include the maximum penalty prescribed for the offence, the nature and gravity of the offence, the offender's culpability and degree of responsibility, the impact of the offence on any victim, the personal circumstances of any victim and the presence of aggravating or mitigating factors concerning the offender. The mandatory considerations in s 5(2) are diverse. No particular consideration is required to be assessed in a particular manner or accorded particular weight. That is consistent with the proposition that the sentencing exercise requires the sentencing judge to identify and balance all relevant factors – factors that may point in different, conflicting and contradictory directions – and to make a judgment as to the appropriate sentence in the circumstances of the case[76]. Sentencing an offender is not a mechanical or mathematical exercise. And it is a task done in accordance with applicable statutory provisions governing sentencing[77]. [76]Wong v The Queen (2001) 207 CLR 584 at 611 [75]; [2001] HCA 64; Markarian v The Queen (2005) 228 CLR 357 at 373‑375 [37], 378 [51]; [2005] HCA 25; Muldrock v The Queen (2011) 244 CLR 120 at 131‑132 [26]; [2011] HCA 39.[77]Markarian (2005) 228 CLR 357 at 371 [26]; Elias v The Queen (2013) 248 CLR 483 at 493 [25]; [2013] HCA 31. In this case, the Court of Appeal stated that current sentencing practices for the offence of incest had "resulted in an unworkably narrow band within which judges are able to sentence for offending of this nature"[78] (emphasis added). In relation to the respondent, it concluded that "[b]ut for the constraints of current sentencing practice, the objective seriousness of the conduct constituting charge 1 demanded a considerably longer sentence"[79] and stated that "[b]ut for the constraints of current sentencing which … reflect the requirements of consistency, we would have had no hesitation" in finding the sentence manifestly inadequate[80]. The apparent explanation for not imposing a longer sentence was that, although current sentencing practices did not reflect the gravity of the offending and sentences were too low, it was not permissible to sentence, or to determine questions of manifest inadequacy, other than in conformity with a range or "band" established by those practices. [78]Director of Public Prosecutions v Dalgliesh (a pseudonym) [2016] VSCA 148 at [64].[79]Dalgliesh [2016] VSCA 148 at [53].[80]Dalgliesh [2016] VSCA 148 at [132].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: KIEFEL CJ, BELL AND KEANE JJ, GAGELER AND GORDON JJ