Details
- Case
- [2023] FedCFamC2G 427
- Decision Date
-
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The applicant, a Faili Kurd born in Iraq and deported with his family to Iran, applied for a Safe Haven Enterprise visa after arriving in Australia as an unauthorised maritime arrival. His application was rejected by a delegate of the Minister, a decision affirmed by the Immigration Assessment Authority. This decision was quashed by the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia and upheld by the Federal Court of Australia. The Authority again affirmed the delegate's decision, which is now the subject of judicial review.
The court was required to determine whether the Authority's decision was lawful and whether it was open to the Authority to conclude that the applicant would not face serious harm if returned to Iran. This involved considering the applicant's health issues, the risk of serious harm, and the likelihood of the applicant finding work in Iran.
The court found that the Authority was not obliged to accept the applicant's claim of statelessness and that the Authority's conclusion that the applicant would not face serious harm if returned to Iran was open to it. The court held that the Authority was entitled to consider the country information and the applicant's access to healthcare and employment opportunities in Iran. The court found that the Authority's reasons demonstrated a consideration of the applicant's health issues and concluded that there was no real risk of serious harm to the applicant if returned to Iran.
The application for judicial review was dismissed with costs. The court held that the Authority's decision was lawful and that it was open to the Authority to conclude that the applicant would not face serious harm if returned to Iran.
Background
Background to the litigation
This is an application for review of a decision made by the Immigration Assessment Authority. In that decision, the Authority affirmed a decision of a delegate of the Minister not to grant the applicant a Safe Haven Enterprise visa (“SHEV”) pursuant to s.65 of the Migration Act 1958 (“the Act”).BACKGROUND The applicant is a Faili Kurd who was born in Iraq and deported with his family to Iran in the 1980s. He claimed to be stateless. He arrived in Australia as an unauthorised maritime arrival on 22 September 2012. On 31 March 2016, the applicant applied for a SHEV. On 19 October 2017, a delegate of the Minister refused the SHEV application. Since 6 July 2017, the applicant has been in immigration detention. On 27 November 2017, the Authority affirmed the delegate’s decision (“the Authority’s first decision”). The applicant sought judicial review of the Authority’s first decision in this court. On 22 August 2019, this court dismissed the application in FSG17 v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCCA 2050. On 11 March 2020, the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia overturned the decision of this court, and set aside the Authority’s first decision in FSG17 v Minister for Immigration (2020) 274 FCR 456; [2020] FCAFC 29. On 25 May 2020, the Authority again affirmed the delegate’s decision (“the Authority’s second decision”). On review, this court quashed the Authority’s second decision in CRS20 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FedCFamC2G 189. The Federal Court upheld the decision of this court in Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs v CRS20 [2022] FCA 579. On 27 September 2022, the Authority again affirmed the delegate’s decision (“the Authority’s third decision”). It is the Authority’s third decision that is presently before the court.MATERIAL RELIED UPON The applicant relied upon:(a)his application filed on 28 October 2022, amended on 13 January 2023 and further amended on 2 February 2023 (“the application”);(b)the court book filed on 25 November 2022;(c)his written submissions filed on 13 January 2023;(d)his written submissions in reply filed on 1 February 2023;(e)the affidavit sworn by Rachel Saravanamuthu on 1 February 2023;(f)his list of authorities filed on 1 February 2023; and(g)his further written submissions filed on 10 February 2023. The Minister relied upon:(a)his response filed on 9 November 2022;(b)the court book filed on 25 November 2022;(c)his written submissions filed on 27 January 2023;(d)his bundle of authorities filed on 1 February 2023;(e)his further written submissions filed on 2 March 2023; and(f)the affidavit affirmed by Siran Nyabally on 23 February 2023.GROUND 1 The first ground of review in the application arises in circumstances where the delegate had accepted that the applicant was stateless. In the Authority’s third decision, its primary position was that it did not accept that the applicant was stateless. The Authority found that the applicant and his family had acquired Iranian nationality prior to 2001 through paternal links to Iran that he had not disclosed. However, the Authority had a separate and alternative strand of reasoning in which it accepted that the applicant was stateless.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
The relevant passages from the Authority's reasons for decision are as follows:35.In his new statement the applicant claims that his mental health had been adversely impacted since 2017 for a number of reasons and provides further updated information in that regard. He also states that he continues to suffer pain from a back injury, and he will be unable to undertake manual work in Iran. These are new claims. Also attached to the submissions were three reports from the International Health and Medical Services (IHMS), one dated on 18 January 2022, one dated 18 February 2022 and the other dated 26 July 2022. They outline the applicant’s health issues for which he is receiving treatment in immigration detention. These documents are also new information. It is submitted that without access to this treatment, the applicant’s mental and physical health will deteriorate, and he will face serious harm, including death and that his profile, including his statelessness, will prevent him from accessing appropriate healthcare. It is also submitted it is further evidence he will be unable to undertake manual labour and will not be able to find employment and subsist in Iran. In so far as these claims relate to the above new information about his ongoing health issues, I am satisfied they are new information. The applicant’s new claims and the supporting medical reports post-date the delegate’s decision and I am satisfied they meet s.473DD(b)(i). I am also satisfied they are credible personal information about the applicant’s health which were not known to the delegate that may have affected consideration of the applicant’s claims. I am satisfied s.473DD(b)(ii) of the Act is met. Having regard to this, I am satisfied there are exceptional circumstances to justify considering this new information.…100.In his recent statement to the IAA the applicant claimed that, from around the end of 2020, he had been experiencing chronic lower back pain since he slipped and fell whilst in immigration detention. He claims he is not sure how long it will take for his back to heal or if it will ever fully heal and it might be something he needs to live with for the rest of his life.101.Provided in support of these claims was a medical report from IHMS regarding a General Practitioner Consultation held with the applicant on 18 January 2022. It noted that the applicant had complained of pain in his Coccyx region since falling on his buttock last year while running on slippery floor. He was also complaining of pain in his left hand after falling in the shower. He was diagnosed with ‘Coxitis (disorder)’ and ‘Fracture of metacarpal bone (disorder)’ and was referred for an X-ray. It appears from this document that he suffered this injury in 2021 not 2020. The applicant claims that the nurse told him he had to keep his feet up. He claimed he cannot do any manual labour jobs.102.The July 2022 IHMS report noted that the applicant had ongoing back pain for which he had been prescribed anti-inflammatory medication after consulting with a GP in February 2022. It noted that, on 8 July 2022, the applicant had reported low back pain for which he was referred to attend for physiotherapy and on 18 July 2022 a physiotherapist provided a treatment program for the applicant. However, it noted he had not yet commenced the program. In his recent statement to the IAA the applicant claimed he started attending physiotherapy in July 2022. The report also noted that the applicant had declined a referral for an x-ray for his lefthand injury due to quarantine requirements on return and had since not reported any issues or concerns regarding this injury since February 2022 and the IHMS considered this health issue to be resolved. (emphasis added)103.I accept the applicant suffered a back injury whilst in immigration detention and has been prescribed medication and started attending physiotherapy in July 2022. I also accept he complained of pain in his left-hand in early 2022 and an x-ray revealed a fracture to his finger but has not since raised any further concerns about it and IHMS considers this issue to be resolved.…116.… It is also submitted that the applicant cannot do any manual labour jobs due to his back injury and if he returns to Iran, he will not be able to find work because stateless Faili Kurds can only find manual labour work.117.I have not accepted the applicant is stateless. I do not accept he will be restricted to finding only manual labour work in Iran or will be prevented from accessing relevant health care on this basis.…139.Assuming his status in Iran is as claimed, the applicant would be unable to obtain Iranian identity documents, and not receive the same benefits, rights or services normally given to citizens or registered refugees. Nevertheless, having considered the country information before me, I am not satisfied there is a real chance that as an unregistered stateless Faili Kurd he will be unable to access informal work, accommodation or paid medical services in Iran from the Iranian authorities or any other group or person. Although DFAT has stated that Faili Kurds are frequently employed in low-paying manual labour it does not suggest that this is always the case. In Australia, the applicant has accessed medication for his depression and insomnia and OSTP injections for his substance abuse. The applicant has also accessed medication and physiotherapy for a back injury. I am not satisfied there is a real chance he will be prevented from accessing treatment for these issues in Iran if needed. I accept the applicant has suffered a previous fracture to his finger whilst in detention but the most recent IHMS report from July 2022 indicated he had not raised any recent concerns about it, and it had been considered resolved. The medical evidence provided by the applicant does not indicate he is unfit for work due to his mental and/or physical health issues. On the evidence before me, I am not satisfied the applicant’s health issues and status will prevent him from finding informal (including some manual) work in Iran. I accept his father has passed away, but I note that his mother and brother remain in living in Qom. I am not satisfied there is a real chance the applicant, as an unregistered stateless Faili Kurd refugee, will experience significant economic hardship that threaten his capacity to subsist or will be denied access to basic services or the capacity to earn a livelihood, or will face any other harm that may be considered serious harm. (emphasis added)…150.As an unregistered stateless Faili Kurd refugee, the applicant will not be able to obtain Iranian identity documents or access the same benefits, rights or services normally given to citizens or registered refugees. Nevertheless, having considered the country information before me, I am not satisfied there is a real risk he will be denied access to paid medical services, accommodation, or informal work as an unregistered stateless Faili Kurd refugee. The applicant has accessed medication and physiotherapy for a back injury sustained in Australia, and medication to treat his diagnosed depression, insomnia and substance abuse. I am not satisfied there is a real risk he will be prevented from accessing paid treatment for his health issues in Iran if needed. He also suffered a fractured finger whilst in detention, but the most recent medical reports provided by the applicant dated in July 2022 indicate he had not raised any recent concerns about it, and it was considered resolved. The medical evidence provided by the applicant does not indicate he is unfit for work due to his health issues. I am not satisfied his health issues or status will prevent him from finding informal work in Iran. His mother and brother also remain residing in Qom where he previously resided. For these reasons I am not satisfied he will face a real risk of significant harm. I am not satisfied he will face a real risk of being arbitrarily deprived of his life, being subject to the death penalty or torture as defined. I am also not satisfied there is a real risk he will be subjected to cruel or inhuman treatment or punishment or degrading treatment or punishment as defined.
Decision
Reasons for decision
For these reasons, ground 5 fails.CONCLUSION As none of the applicant’s grounds has been made out, the application will be dismissed with costs.