CFU17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

CFU17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2023] FCA 1107

Appeal from: CFU17 v Minister for Immigration [2020] FCCA 3364
File number(s): NSD 17 of 2021
Judgment of: MORTIMER CJ
Date of judgment: 15 September 2023
Catchwords: MIGRATION – appeal from decision of Federal Circuit Court of Australia (FCC) – where FCC dismissed application for judicial review of a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal) – where Tribunal affirmed decision to refuse to grant a protection visa – where Tribunal not satisfied that appellant faced serious or significant harm on the basis of being HIV positive – whether Tribunal decision was affected by jurisdictional error for failure to perform its statutory task by considering country information – whether Tribunal decision was affected by jurisdictional error for failure to consider an integer of the appellant’s claims – appeal dismissed
Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth) s 36
Cases cited:

ADU18 v Minister for Home Affairs [2020] FCA 366

ARK16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 825

BKQ16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2019] FCA 40; 163 ALD 127

CAL15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCA 1344

CCU21 v Minister for Home Affairs [2023] FCAFC 87

CPE15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCA 591

Hossain v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] HCA 34; 264 CLR 123

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v MZYTS [2013] FCAFC 114; 230 FCR 431

Nathanson v Minister for Home Affairs [2022] HCA 26; 403 ALR 398

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Number of paragraphs: 67
Date of last submissions: 14 August 2023
Date of hearing: 21 July 2021
Counsel for the Appellant:  Mr A Smorchevsky
Solicitor for the Appellant:  HIV/AIDS Legal Centre
Counsel for the First Respondent:   Mr N Swan
Solicitor for the First Respondent:  MinterEllison
Counsel for the Second Respondent:  The Second Respondent filed a submitting notice, save as to costs

ORDERS

NSD 17 of 2021
BETWEEN:

CFU17

Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

MORTIMER CJ

DATE OF ORDER:

15 SEPTEMBER 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Leave to rely on ground 2(b) of the notice of appeal dated 6 January 2021 be granted.

2.Leave to rely on ground 2(c) of the notice of appeal dated 6 January 2021 be refused.

3.The appeal be dismissed.

4.If the parties agree on appropriate costs orders, they are to file a proposed minute of order on or before 29 September 2023.

5.In the absence of any agreement as to costs:

(a)the first respondent file any submissions on costs, limited to 3 pages, on or before 13 October 2023; and

(b)the appellant file any submissions in response, limited to 3 pages, on or before 27 October 2023.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CFU17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultu... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 1107
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of CFU17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs, the appellant, a citizen of Nepal who had entered Australia on a Visitor visa, sought judicial review of a decision by the Federal Circuit Court of Australia to dismiss his application for judicial review of a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The Tribunal had affirmed a decision of the delegate to refuse to grant the appellant a protection visa, finding that he had not satisfied the criteria for protection under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). The appellant argued that the Tribunal's decision was affected by jurisdictional error for failure to perform its statutory task by considering country information and for failure to consider an integer of the appellant’s claims.

The appeal raised two grounds for review. The first was that the Tribunal did not consider country information about Nepal in its assessment of the appellant’s claims. The second was that the Tribunal failed to consider the appellant's claim that he would be forced to hide his HIV status in order to protect himself and his family from degrading treatment, as well as significant stigma and discrimination. The Court considered whether these alleged errors constituted jurisdictional errors that could lead to the Tribunal’s decision being quashed.

In dismissing the appeal, the Court found that the Tribunal had not erred in failing to consider country information as it was not relevant to the appellant's claims. The Tribunal had considered the appellant's detailed evidence about his past difficulties in accessing treatment in Nepal and found that the appellant had not provided sufficient evidence to establish that he would be unable to access treatment if returned to Nepal. Regarding the claim about hiding his HIV status, the Court held that the Tribunal had sufficiently considered this claim in its overall assessment of the appellant's circumstances and found that the appellant had not demonstrated that he would be forced to hide his HIV status to the extent claimed.

Therefore, the Court concluded that the Tribunal had not made a jurisdictional error in its decision. The appeal was dismissed, and the original decision of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia was upheld. The Court did not order costs against the appellant, but gave the parties an opportunity to agree on costs or to file submissions if they could not agree.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave to rely on ground 2(b) of the notice of appeal dated 6 January 2021 be granted.

2. Leave to rely on ground 2(c) of the notice of appeal dated 6 January 2021 be refused.

3. The appeal be dismissed.

4. If the parties agree on appropriate costs orders, they are to file a proposed minute of order on or before 29 September 2023.

5. In the absence of any agreement as to costs:

(a) the first respondent file any submissions on costs, limited to 3 pages, on or before 13 October 2023; and

(b) the appellant file any submissions in response, limited to 3 pages, on or before 27 October 2023.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow, the appeal should be dismissed.BACKGROUND The appellant is a citizen of Nepal who first entered Australia in July 2014 as the holder of a Visitor (subclass 600) visa. He described himself as having come to Australia to attend a seminar. On 4 August 2014, the appellant lodged an application for a protection visa. The application was accompanied by submissions prepared by his then migration agent, dated 30 July 2014. On 17 March 2015 and 27 May 2015, the appellant’s representatives made further submissions citing and appending country information. On 20 July 2015, the delegate refused to grant the appellant a protection visa. On 19 August 2015, the appellant applied to the Tribunal for merits review of the delegate decision. In the Tribunal, the application did not progress for some time. On 27 January 2017, the appellant’s representatives provided the Tribunal with an outline of the appellant’s claims and further submissions a few days later, referring to some country information about Nepal. On 2 February 2017, the Tribunal conducted a hearing at which the appellant appeared with his representative. Post-hearing submissions were made shortly after, and they included updated medical and country information. On 20 April 2017, the Tribunal affirmed the delegate’s decision not to grant the visa on the basis that the appellant had not satisfied the criteria for protection in 36(2)(a) or in s 36(2)(aa) of the MigrationAct 1958 (Cth). On 24 May 2017, the appellant applied to the FCC for judicial review of the Tribunal decision, filing an amended application on 23 November 2017. On 10 December 2020, the FCC dismissed the application for judicial review: see CFU17 v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2020] FCCA 3364. On 6 January 2021, the appellant filed a notice of appeal from the orders of the FCC. CLAIMS FOR PROTECTION The appellant contracted Human Immunodeficiency Virus through injected drug use in 2003 or 2004. He claimed to fear persecution in Nepal due to:(a)his membership of two particular social groups, being “people living with HIV/ Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome (AIDS)” in Nepal; and “injecting drug users in Nepal”; and(b)his positive HIV status. In the Outline of Claims submitted to the Tribunal, the appellant claimed that if returned to Nepal: 1.[The appellant] will not be able to access the appropriate medical treatment which will result in the deterioration of his health and eventual death; 2.[The appellant] will be forced to hide his HIV status in order to protect himself and his family from degrading treatment, as well as significant stigma and discrimination;3.In an attempt to protect the disclosure of his HIV status, [the appellant] will be forced to live without treatment which will result in the deterioration of his health and eventual death;4.Despite attempts to conceal his HIV condition, [the appellant]’s HIV status will be disclosed to his family, community and employers, limiting his ability to subsist due to rampant discrimination that will likely eventuate;5.[The appellant] will face physical violence and psychological harassment due to his history of being an injecting drug user;6.[The appellant]’s family, being his wife and children, will face severe stigma and discrimination to the point of causing severe psychological harm and significant harm as a result of [the appellant]’s HIV condition and drug use history;7.[The appellant] and his wife will be unable to obtain and/or retain gainful employment in order to subsist as a result of [the appellant]’s HIV condition and drug use history;8.[The appellant]’s extended family and the community will not support [the appellant] and his family as a result of [the appellant]’s HIV condition and drug use history;9.The Nepalese/Indian governments and authorities will be unable and/or unwilling to protect [the appellant] and/or his family from this harm, leaving [the appellant] and his family unable to subsist; and10.It is not reasonable for [the appellant] to relocate so as to avoid this harm[.]

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The latter two points were a reference to whether the appellant could relocate to India to avoid harm, which was not put in issue by the Tribunal and plays no part in this appeal.TRIBUNAL DECISION The Tribunal’s decision is careful and fulsome. After first summarising the procedural history and setting out the criteria for a protection visa, the Tribunal recorded its key findings in a section titled “Assessment of the applicant’s claimed circumstances”: see [9]-[67]. Although information is interwoven throughout that section, the Tribunal there set out:(a)the material before it;(b)the appellant’s background;(c)the appellant’s claims for protection; and(d)the Tribunal’s assessment of those claims. Relevantly to the grounds of appeal, the Tribunal summarised the appellant’s claims in the following way (at [19]-[20]):[The appellant’s] 2014 Declaration is to the following effect: a. he fears returning to Nepal due to his HIV positive status and his history of drug use;b. he fears for his health, safety and wellbeing in Nepal “to the extent that my capacity to subsist will be threatened if forced to return to Nepal”; c. he fears ostracism from his family and community; and that he will not be able to earn an income “which will impact upon my capacity to subsist”. He fears that if he cannot access treatment and becomes sick in Nepal “it is only a matter of time before my whole family find out about my condition. My father, who is a former policeman, will be very angry if he finds out that I am HIV positive and he will cut me off from the family both financially and socially”. He states that only his wife, doctor, counsellor and some close friends who he met through [the HIV charity] know of his HIV status. At another point he adds that he fears that “my brother and my father may even try to physically harm me or even kill me”;d. he also fears that his wife and children will face harm in connection with his HIV status and history of drug [use], which will cause him significant psychological harm. He fears that they will be assumed by the community to be HIV positive even though they are not;e. people living with HIV/AIDS (PLWHA) in Nepal are treated badly by their families and communities;f. HIV treatment is difficult to get in Nepal with limited free treatment available which is subject to long queues. Generally people need money to access treatment in Nepal;g. he fears that “without adequate access to treatment I will develop an AIDS defining illness leading to being hospitalised and eventually death”. [The appellant’s] 2014 Declaration … also details the situation regarding access to HIV treatment in Nepal. Relevantly he states:a. he was not on any HIV treatment from 2003 until 2011 but would occasionally see a doctor to monitor his HIV condition. However, he attended an AIDS conference in Vienna in 2010 and “understood more clearly from my attendance at the conference the importance of being on treatment”;b. in 2011 “an aid agency in Pokhara made funds available for the purchase of HIV medication”;c. he “arranged for a friend to buy HIV medicine for me. My friend was also HIV positive however he came from a different town. I would arrange the treatment by telling the clinic that I was sending someone else to collect my medication”;d. his treatment in Nepal involved taking two tablets twice a day, which gave him headaches, loss of energy and made him feel unwell. In Australia his treatment involves a single tablet and no side effects;e. there are “strict criteria” for accessing free HIV treatment in Nepal and if you can pay for some or all of the treatment access is more readily available. [The appellant] was not put on HIV treatment when he was diagnosed with HIV due to the high costs of treatment, the limited availability of treatment and the additional travel costs and time. He could not ask his parents for money despite them providing “me with financial support on a daily basis”. Eventually he got money from an aid agency to access treatment;f. when he started treatment he had to travel two hours to see a doctor but for viral load testing he would have had to travel six hours to Kathmandu. He states “I did not check my viral load”;g. he worries that the aid funding he had access to in Nepal will not be available to him on his return which will adversely impact his ability to access HIV treatment on his return to Nepal. He also notes that there are other costs including travel and clinic attendance fees he would need to pay;h. he adds that “due to fears of stigma and discrimination he was always careful not to let anyone see me go to a clinic in case someone recognised me and discovered that I was HIV positive. I did not even access the treatment myself but instead had a friend attend the clinic for me”.i. he also fears breaches of confidentiality amongst medical service providers in Nepal which could lead to community knowledge of his HIV status;j. he notes that ignorance about HIV transmission is also present amongst medical service providers such that he may be denied treatment for non-HIV related matters.(Footnotes omitted.)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 19 August 2015, the appellant applied to the Tribunal for merits review of the delegate decision. In the Tribunal, the application did not progress for some time. On 27 January 2017, the appellant’s representatives provided the Tribunal with an outline of the appellant’s claims and further submissions a few days later, referring to some country information about Nepal. On 2 February 2017, the Tribunal conducted a hearing at which the appellant appeared with his representative. Post-hearing submissions were made shortly after, and they included updated medical and country information. On 20 April 2017, the Tribunal affirmed the delegate’s decision not to grant the visa on the basis that the appellant had not satisfied the criteria for protection in 36(2)(a) or in s 36(2)(aa) of the MigrationAct 1958 (Cth). On 24 May 2017, the appellant applied to the FCC for judicial review of the Tribunal decision, filing an amended application on 23 November 2017. On 10 December 2020, the FCC dismissed the application for judicial review: see CFU17 v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2020] FCCA 3364. On 6 January 2021, the appellant filed a notice of appeal from the orders of the FCC. CLAIMS FOR PROTECTION The appellant contracted Human Immunodeficiency Virus through injected drug use in 2003 or 2004. He claimed to fear persecution in Nepal due to:(a)his membership of two particular social groups, being “people living with HIV/ Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome (AIDS)” in Nepal; and “injecting drug users in Nepal”; and(b)his positive HIV status. In the Outline of Claims submitted to the Tribunal, the appellant claimed that if returned to Nepal: 1.[The appellant] will not be able to access the appropriate medical treatment which will result in the deterioration of his health and eventual death; 2.[The appellant] will be forced to hide his HIV status in order to protect himself and his family from degrading treatment, as well as significant stigma and discrimination;3.In an attempt to protect the disclosure of his HIV status, [the appellant] will be forced to live without treatment which will result in the deterioration of his health and eventual death;4.Despite attempts to conceal his HIV condition, [the appellant]’s HIV status will be disclosed to his family, community and employers, limiting his ability to subsist due to rampant discrimination that will likely eventuate;5.[The appellant] will face physical violence and psychological harassment due to his history of being an injecting drug user;6.[The appellant]’s family, being his wife and children, will face severe stigma and discrimination to the point of causing severe psychological harm and significant harm as a result of [the appellant]’s HIV condition and drug use history;7.[The appellant] and his wife will be unable to obtain and/or retain gainful employment in order to subsist as a result of [the appellant]’s HIV condition and drug use history;8.[The appellant]’s extended family and the community will not support [the appellant] and his family as a result of [the appellant]’s HIV condition and drug use history;9.The Nepalese/Indian governments and authorities will be unable and/or unwilling to protect [the appellant] and/or his family from this harm, leaving [the appellant] and his family unable to subsist; and10.It is not reasonable for [the appellant] to relocate so as to avoid this harm[.]