Castle Constructions Pty Ltd v Sahab Holdings Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

HAYNE, CRENNAN, KIEFEL, BELL AND GAGELER JJ

CASTLE CONSTRUCTIONS PTY LIMITED  APPELLANT

AND

SAHAB HOLDINGS PTY LTD & ANOR  RESPONDENTS

Castle Constructions Pty Limited v Sahab Holdings Pty Ltd

[2013] HCA 11

10 April 2013

S263/2012

ORDER

1.Appeal allowed.

2.Application for special leave to cross-appeal refused.

3.The first respondent pay the appellant and the second respondent the costs of the appeal and of the application for special leave to cross-appeal.

4.Set aside the orders of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales made on 5 April 2012 and, in their place, order that the appeal to that Court be dismissed with costs.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of New South Wales

Representation

M L D Einfield QC with J Horowitz for the appellant (instructed by Domain Legal Pty Limited)

G K Burton SC for the first respondent (instructed by Kanjian & Company)

P B Walsh with L Walsh for the second respondent (instructed by Land and Property Information)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

Real property – Torrens system land – Easements – Registered proprietor of servient tenement requested Registrar-General remove easement from Register – Easement removed from Register without objection from registered proprietors of dominant tenement – Subsequent purchaser of dominant tenement requested that Registrar-General restore easement to Register – Registrar-General refused – Whether deliberate removal of easement from Register "omission" within meaning of s 42(1)(a1) of Real Property Act 1900 (NSW) ("Act") – Whether subsequent purchaser of dominant tenement barred from action against Registrar-General under s 12A(3) of Act for removal of easement – Whether subsequent purchaser "person who is dissatisfied" with Registrar-General's decision under s 122 of Act.

Words and phrases – "in the case of the omission", "omission", "person who is dissatisfied".

Real Property Act 1900 (NSW), ss 12(1)(d), 12A, 32(6), 41, 42(1), 42(1)(a1), 122, 136, 138.

  1. HAYNE, CRENNAN, KIEFEL AND BELL JJ.   This appeal concerns two pieces of land in Northbridge, Sydney.  The rear boundary of the piece known as 69 Strathallen Avenue ("the Strathallen land") abuts part of the western boundary of the other piece, known as 134 Sailors Bay Road ("the Sailors Bay land").  Each piece of land is, and at all times relevant to these proceedings was, subject to the provisions of the Real Property Act 1900 (NSW) ("the RPA"). Although many issues were touched on in argument in this Court, the determinative issue in the appeal can be stated briefly.

  2. The RPA provides[1] that a registered proprietor holds the estate or interest in land recorded in a folio of the Register subject only to other estates and interests recorded in that folio.  An exception[2] is "in the case of the omission" of an easement validly created under the RPA. After giving notice to the then dominant tenement holders, and without objection, the Registrar‑General removed an easement from the folios…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Castle Constructions Pty Ltd v Sahab Holdings Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] HCA 11
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of *Castle Constructions Pty Ltd v Sahab Holdings Pty Ltd* concerned a dispute over an easement registered under the Torrens system. Castle Constructions, the registered proprietor of the servient tenement (134 Sailors Bay Road), had requested the Registrar-General remove an easement from the Register. The easement, originally created in 1921, provided access to the dominant tenement (Strathallen land). The owners of the dominant tenement at the time did not object to the removal, and the Registrar-General subsequently removed the easement from the Register in 2001. Sahab Holdings, a later purchaser of the dominant tenement, sought to have the easement restored to the Register, but the Registrar-General refused. The matter ultimately came before the High Court of Australia.

The High Court was required to determine whether the deliberate removal of an easement from the Register constituted an "omission" within the meaning of s 42(1)(a1) of the *Real Property Act 1900* (NSW). This section provides an exception to the indefeasibility of title in cases of omission. Additionally, the court had to consider whether Sahab Holdings, as a subsequent purchaser, was barred from taking action against the Registrar-General under s 12A(3) of the Act, and whether Sahab Holdings was a "person who is dissatisfied" with the Registrar-General's decision under s 122 of the Act.

The High Court held that the deliberate removal of an easement from the Register, even if later found to be erroneous, could not be characterised as an "omission" for the purposes of s 42(1)(a1). The court reasoned that an omission implies that the easement continues to exist but is not recorded, whereas a deliberate removal signifies that the easement is no longer recorded because it was actively taken off the Register. Furthermore, the court found that s 12A(3) of the Act barred any action against the Registrar-General by a person who had been given notice of a proposed alteration to the Register and had not obtained a court order restraining that action. As Sahab Holdings' predecessors in title had been notified and had not sought such an order, their claim, and by extension Sahab Holdings' claim, was barred.

The High Court allowed the appeal, set aside the orders of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales, and ordered that the appeal to that Court be dismissed with costs. The court concluded that Castle Constructions' land was no longer subject to the easement, and consequently, the associated covenants no longer applied. The application for special leave to cross-appeal was refused, and the first respondent (Sahab Holdings) was ordered to pay the costs of the appeal and the application for special leave to cross-appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed.

2. Application for special leave to cross-appeal refused.

3. The first respondent pay the appellant and the second respondent the costs of the appeal and of the application for special leave to cross-appeal.

4. Set aside the orders of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales made on 5 April 2012 and, in their place, order that the appeal to that Court be dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

These reasons will show that this was not such a case. There was no "omission" of the easement.Facts and course of proceedings In 1921, the Strathallen land and the Sailors Bay land each formed part of a larger piece of land owned by Mr and Mrs Middleton. In that year, the Middletons sold the Strathallen land to Mr Davis. The instrument of transfer ("the 1921 transfer") created an easement of way over the western boundary of the land the Middletons retained in favour of the land they sold. The easement provided access from Sailors Bay Road to the rear of the land the Middletons sold. The 1921 transfer also included some covenants about the fencing of the boundary between the land sold and the land retained, the use of the easement and the use of the land that was sold. In 1958, part of the land retained by the Middletons was subdivided and, as a result, the covenants and the easement burdened the land which became known as 134 Sailors Bay Road. In June 2001, the appellant (Castle Constructions Pty Limited – "Castle") bought the Sailors Bay land. In September 2001, Castle asked the Registrar‑General to remove the easement over its land from the Register maintained[3] for the purposes of the RPA. A statutory declaration was filed in support of the application, which asserted that the easement, according to its terms, subsisted only for so long as Mr Davis (or his successors other than on sale) owned the Strathallen land. As will later appear, the correctness of this assertion is disputed but need not be decided.[3]s 31B(1). The Registrar‑General notified the then owners of the Strathallen land, Mr and Mrs Howard, that he intended to remove the easement from the Register. They did not object to this proposed course of action and, in November 2001, the Registrar‑General removed the easement from the folios of the Register relating to the Sailors Bay land (which had been the servient tenement) and the Strathallen land (which had been the dominant tenement). In April 2007, well after the Registrar‑General had taken these steps, the first respondent (Sahab Holdings Pty Ltd – "Sahab") became the registered proprietor of the Strathallen land. In September 2008, Sahab asked the Registrar‑General to restore the easement to the Register but the Registrar‑General refused to do so. Sahab brought proceedings in the Supreme Court of New South Wales against the Registrar‑General seeking a declaration that the easement had been wrongly extinguished and an order requiring the Registrar‑General to restore the easement to the Register. On its application, Castle was joined as a party to those proceedings. In October 2009, the primary judge (Slattery J) decided[4] that the Registrar‑General was bound to give Sahab reasons for the 2001 decision to remove the easement from the Register and ordered the Registrar‑General to do so. [4]Sahab Holdings Pty Ltd v Registrar‑General (2009) 75 NSWLR 629. In accordance with these orders, the Registrar‑General provided to Sahab a copy of the Registrar‑General's minute papers relating to the removal of the easement. Those minute papers relevantly recorded[5] "[n]o objection received to the applications. Applications granted." The letter from the Registrar‑General which enclosed the copy minute papers said that:"For the sake of further clarity I advise that 'objection' referred to any objection to the Registrar General's notice of 8 October 2001 to the owners of the dominant tenement giving them notice of intention to cancel the recording of the easement and restrictive covenant.The notice was sent because the Registrar General agreed with the applicant of Request 7924028, that the easement and covenant had expired by virtue of its own terms."[5]The minute papers also set out some identifying folio numbers and like details.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

HAYNE, CRENNAN, KIEFEL AND BELL JJ GAGELER J
Fourth, and most importantly, Sahab's reference to and reliance upon the remedial provisions of the RPA (in particular s 12(1)(d)) depended upon Sahab showing that this was a case of "omission". And Sahab's case in relation to both ss 12(1)(d) and 42(1)(a1) ultimately depended upon reading "omission" in each as including a case where an easement, once registered, had been deliberately removed from the Register. As earlier explained, while it may be right to observe that, after its removal, the easement is "not there", this observation provides only a snapshot of the state of the Register. It is more accurate to say that the easement is "no longer there because it was deliberately removed". That is not a case of the omission of an easement.Conclusion and orders Because Castle's land is no longer subject to the easement created by the 1921 transfer, the covenants which related to the easement no longer apply. The questions which Sahab sought to agitate by cross‑appeal are not reached and need not be considered. The appeal to this Court should be allowed. The application for special leave to cross‑appeal should be refused. The first respondent should pay the appellant and the second respondent the costs of the appeal and of the application for special leave to cross‑appeal. The orders of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales made on 5 April 2012 should be set aside and in their place there should be orders that the appeal to that Court is dismissed with costs. I agree with the orders proposed by Hayne, Crennan, Kiefel and Bell JJ and am content to adopt their statement of facts and their abbreviations. However, I consider the determinative issue to be different. The proceedings in the Supreme Court of New South Wales Sahab brought against the Registrar-General, to which Castle was joined, were in substance for judicial review of two decisions of the Registrar-General. The first was the decision in November 2001 to remove the easement from the Register under s 32(6) of the RPA ("the 2001 decision"). The second was the decision in October 2008 not to restore the easement to the Register under s 12(1)(d) of the RPA ("the 2008 decision"). Sahab's case, shorn of detail, was that the 2001 decision was a nullity because the Registrar-General erred in law in making it and that, in making the 2008 decision, the Registrar-General failed to perform a statutory duty to correct the error made in the 2001 decision. Sahab invoked the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court under each of ss 122 and 138 of the RPA and s 65 of the Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW). In my view, once it was found that the Registrar-General had notified Sahab's predecessors in title in accordance with s 12A(1) of the RPA before making the 2001 decision – a finding that should not now be disturbed – s 12A(3) of the RPA provided the short and complete answer to the whole of Sahab's case. Section 12A of the RPA provides:"(1)The Registrar-General may, before taking any action that alters the Register, give notice of the proposed action to any person that the Registrar-General considers should be notified of it.(2)Where the Registrar-General has given notice pursuant to the powers conferred upon the Registrar-General by subsection (1), the Registrar-General may refuse to take the action until after the expiration of a period specified in the notice and the Registrar-General may proceed to take the action at or after the expiration of the period so specified unless the Registrar-General is first served with, or with written notice of, an order of the Supreme Court restraining the Registrar-General from so doing.(3)Where a person given notice under subsection (1) does not within the time limited by the notice serve upon the Registrar-General or give the Registrar-General written notice of an order made by the Supreme Court restraining the Registrar-General from taking the action, no action by that person or by any person claiming through or under that person shall lie against the Registrar-General in respect of the taking of the action specified in the notice.(4)No action shall lie against the Registrar-General for failure to give a notice under subsection (1)."

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: HAYNE, CRENNAN, KIEFEL AND BELL JJ, GAGELER J

Other considerations intrude when an easement created under the RPA by registration of a dealing has later been removed by the Registrar‑General. When an easement has been previously recorded on the Register, but is no longer recorded because it has been deliberately removed from the Register, it could be said that the easement was "not there". It is more accurate, however, to say that the easement is "no longer there because it has been removed". The significance to be given to the fact of the easement's removal from the Register requires attention to fundamental principles. The relevant exception to the paramountcy of the registered proprietor's title is "in the case of the omission" of an easement (where the hypothesis is that the easement continues to exist but is not recorded). Because the RPA provided for title by registration, the deliberate removal from the Register of an easement created by registration cannot be treated as a "case of the omission ... of an easement" for the purposes of s 42(1)(a1). The presupposition for the operation of s 42(1)(a1), that the easement continues to exist, is not valid. The easement has been removed from the Register.The RPA's provisions for the alteration of the Register Section 32(6) of the RPA gave[32] the Registrar‑General power "to cancel in such manner as the Registrar‑General considers proper any recording in the Register that the Registrar‑General is satisfied does not affect the land to which the recording purports to relate". If the Registrar‑General was satisfied that the easement no longer subsisted, s 32(6) empowered cancellation of the recording of the easement on the folios relating to both the dominant and the servient tenements. The RPA gave the Registrar‑General other powers in respect of the recording of easements, including power under s 49(1) to cancel the recording of abandoned easements, but the ambit of those other powers need not be examined.[32]Power of this kind was first given to the Registrar‑General by s 37(b) of the Conveyancing (Amendment) Act 1930 (NSW), which inserted s 32(3) into the RPA. The inserted provision deemed the Registrar‑General always to have had the power. Where the Registrar-General removes an easement from the Register after giving notice under s 12A(1) to the owner of the dominant tenement, that owner would not have an action against the Registrar-General in respect of that removal. Section 12A(3) provided that where a person given a notice under s 12A(1) did not serve on the Registrar‑General (or give the Registrar‑General notice of) an order of the Supreme Court restraining the Registrar‑General from taking the proposed action altering the Register, "no action by that person or by any person claiming through or under that person shall lie against the Registrar‑General in respect of the taking of the action specified in the notice". Section 12A(3) would bar a claim by the owner of the dominant tenement for any relief against the Registrar‑General in respect of the removal of the easement, including any form of relief that would compel the Registrar‑General to restore the easement to the Register.