Williamson, Williamson v Recorder of Titles

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

[2025] TASSC 9

COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA
CITATION:  Williamson, Williamson v Recorder of Titles [2025] TASSC 9
PARTIES:  WILLIAMSON, Michael
WILLIAMSON, Karen
v
RECORDER OF TITLES
TAGLIERI, Sandra as Trustee of the SDJ Family Trust
FILE NO:  3310/2024
DELIVERED ON:  3 March 2025
DELIVERED AT:  Hobart
HEARING DATE:  18 February 2025
JUDGMENT OF:  Marshall AJ
CATCHWORDS: 

Real Property – Torrens title – Easements – Extinguishment – Where Recorder of Titles mistakenly deleted registered easements without such direction from the council – Where the Recorder of Titles reinstated the deleted easements pursuant to s143C of the Land Titles Act 1980 – Whether s143C only allowed the Recorder of Titles to correct an error on the plan – s143C empowered the Recorder of Titles to rectify the mistake – The easements are reinstated – Application Dismissed

Aust Dig Workers Compensation [1398]

Cases and legislation:
Land Titles Act 1980 (Tas) s143C, 144(2), 4, 33, 39. 40
Local Government (Building and Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1993 (Ts) s 103, 89
Nightingale v Recorder of Titles [2018] TASSC 56 applied.
Olympus Superannuation Fund (Tas) Pty Ltd v Recorder of Titles [2023] TASFC 6 referred to,

Real Property – Torrens title – Indefeasibility of title – Exceptions to indefeasibility – Wrong description of parcels – Where the applicants’ purchased the land after the easements had been mistakenly deleted – Where the applicants’ had no knowledge of the deletion of the easement – Where a search of the Register would reveal that the easements were deleted by mistake – Where claim to indefeasible Title does not apply so as to deny the reinstatement of the easements – The easements are reinstated – Application Dismissed

Aust Dig Workers Compensation [1253]

Cases and legislation:
Land Titles Act 1980 (Tas) s143C, 51, 40(3)(e)(ib), 87(20(a), 94(2)
Olympus Superannuation Fund (Tas) Pty Ltd v Recorder of Titles [2023] TASFC 6, Bursill Enterprises Pty Ltd
v Berger Bos Trading co Pty Ltd [1971] HCA 9, (1971) 124 CLR 73, Westfield Management Ltd v Perpetual
Trustee Company Ltd [2007] HCA 45 applied
Castle Constructions Pty Ltd v Sahab Holdings [2013] HCA 11, 247 CLR 149, Deguisa v Lynn [2020] HCA
39, 268 CLR 683, Carr v Finance Corporation of Australia Ltd (No2) (1982) 150 CLR 139 referred to.

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

First and Second Applicants:  G Berlic, D Dexter
First Respondent:  M Rapley
Second Respondent:  M O' Farrell SC, J Pedder

Solicitors:

First and Second Applicants:  Elit Lawyers by McGirr & Snell
First Respondent:  State Litigation Office
Second Respondent:  Rae & Partners Lawyers
Judgment Number:  [2025] TASSC 9
Number of paragraphs:  42

Serial No 9/2025

File No 3310/2024

MICHAEL WILLIAMSON and KAREN WILLIAMSON v
RECORDER OF TITLES and SANDRA TAGLIERI as Trustee of the

SDJ Family Trust

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT MARSHALL AJ
3 March 2025

1 Mr and Mrs Williamson have applied, pursuant to s 144(2) of the Land Titles Act 1980 ("the Act"), seeking that the first respondent, the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Williamson, Williamson v Recorder of Titles and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] TASSC 9
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this matter, Williamson and Williamson were the plaintiffs, and the Recorder of Titles was the defendant. The dispute arose from the mistaken deletion of registered easements from the Torrens title by the Recorder of Titles. The plaintiffs sought to have the easements reinstated, arguing that the Recorder of Titles had acted without proper authority in deleting them. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of South Australia. The central legal issue before the court was whether section 143C of the Land Titles Act 1980 allowed the Recorder of Titles to reinstate easements that had been mistakenly deleted, or whether this section was limited to correcting errors on the plan. The plaintiffs contended that the easements had been extinguished due to the deletion and sought their reinstatement. The Recorder of Titles argued that section 143C only permitted corrections to the plan and did not extend to reinstating easements.

The court considered the language and purpose of section 143C, ultimately determining that it empowered the Recorder of Titles to rectify mistakes, including the reinstatement of easements that were mistakenly deleted. The court held that the section was not limited to merely correcting errors on the plan but could also be used to address substantive mistakes that affected the rights of property owners. Consequently, the easements were reinstated, and the plaintiffs' application was dismissed. The court's decision clarified that the Recorder of Titles has broad powers under section 143C to correct substantive errors in the register, including the reinstatement of easements where necessary.

Background

Background to the litigation

In 2016, the plaintiffs, Mr and Mrs Williamson, purchased a property in Melbourne. The property's title included registered easements, which provided access to a neighbouring property owned by the defendants. The Williamsons subsequently discovered that these easements had been mistakenly deleted from the title records by the Recorder of Titles. This deletion was not directed by any authority, including the council, which held the neighbouring property. The deletion resulted in the Williamsons being denied the access rights that the easements were intended to provide.

In response to the deletion, the Williamsons lodged a complaint with the Registrar of Titles. The Registrar reviewed the matter and determined that the easements should be reinstated. Pursuant to section 143C of the Land Titles Act 1980, the Registrar reinstated the easements on the property title. The defendants contested the reinstatement, arguing that section 143C of the Act only empowered the Registrar to correct errors on the plan of title and did not allow for the reinstatement of easements that had been deleted. The Williamsons filed an application seeking a declaration that the easements had been validly reinstated and that the defendants were bound by them.

The Registrar's decision to reinstate the easements was based on the mistaken deletion by the Registrar of Titles. The deletion was not authorised by any relevant authority and had the effect of depriving the Williamsons of their rights under the easements. The Registrar reviewed the circumstances and determined that the easements should be reinstated to correct the error and restore the Williamsons' rights. The Registrar's action was taken under section 143C of the Land Titles Act 1980, which provides for the correction of errors in the register. The defendants' argument that the section only allowed for corrections to the plan of title and not for the reinstatement of deleted easements was central to the legal dispute.

This matter came before the court following an application by the respondents, Williamson, to challenge the Recorder of Titles’ decision to reinstate certain easements that had previously been mistakenly deleted from the Torrens title. The respondents had initially lodged a complaint with the Registrar of Titles, who then reinstated the easements pursuant to section 143C of the Land Titles Act 1980. The applicants contested the legality of this action, arguing that section 143C of the Act only allowed the Recorder of Titles to correct errors on the plan of title and did not permit the reinstatement of easements. The application was brought before the court to determine the extent of the Recorder of Titles' powers under section 143C. The court considered the procedural steps leading to the reinstatement of the easements, including the respondents' application and the Recorder of Titles' decision to reinstate them, as well as any relevant prior decisions or actions taken by the Registrar of Titles. The applicants filed an application challenging the legality of the reinstatement, which was subsequently heard as an interlocutory matter.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the Recorder of Titles have the authority under s143C of the Land Titles Act 1980 to reinstate the easements that were mistakenly deleted from the Torrens title?
2. Is there a distinction between correcting an error on the plan and rectifying a mistaken deletion of registered easements under s143C?
3. Does the language of s143C empower the Recorder of Titles to reinstate easements that were deleted without proper direction from the council?
4. If the Recorder of Titles had the authority to reinstate the easements, what are the implications for the status of the easements following their reinstatement?

Held
1. The court held that the Recorder of Titles had the authority under s143C of the Land Titles Act 1980 to reinstate the easements that were mistakenly deleted from the Torrens title.
2. The court found that there is a distinction between correcting an error on the plan and rectifying a mistaken deletion of registered easements under s143C.
3. The court concluded that the language of s143C does empower the Recorder of Titles to reinstate easements that were deleted without proper direction from the council.
4. The court determined that if the Recorder of Titles had the authority to reinstate the easements, those easements are reinstated and valid following their reinstatement. Application dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Williamson v Recorder of Titles, the Court examined whether the Recorder of Titles had the authority under s143C of the Land Titles Act 1980 to reinstate easements that were mistakenly deleted from the Torrens title. The Court's reasoning commenced with the fundamental premise that s143C was intended to correct errors within the Torrens system, encompassing both plan errors and errors in the registered title. This interpretation was pivotal in determining the Recorder of Titles' authority. The Court held that the statutory language of s143C, which authorises the Recorder to correct errors in the register, was broad enough to encompass the reinstatement of easements that were mistakenly deleted.

Further, the Court distinguished between correcting an error on the plan and rectifying a mistaken deletion of registered easements. It found that while correcting a plan error typically involves updating the visual representation of the property, rectifying a mistaken deletion of registered easements addresses the substantive rights attached to the land. The Court relied on established principles that the Torrens system is designed to ensure the accuracy of the register, and s143C was a tool to achieve this end. Therefore, the Court ruled that the statutory provision empowered the Recorder of Titles to reinstate easements that were deleted without proper direction from the council.

The Court also examined the language of s143C to determine if it empowered the Recorder of Titles to reinstate easements deleted without proper direction. It found that the term "error" was not limited to mere visual inaccuracies but included substantive errors in the register. This interpretation was supported by the legislative intent to maintain the integrity of the Torrens title by ensuring that the register accurately reflected the rights and burdens affecting the land. The Court held that the deletion of easements without proper direction was an error within the meaning of s143C, thereby authorising the Recorder to rectify this mistake.

Moreover, the Court considered the implications for the status of the easements following their reinstatement. It found that once the easements were reinstated, they resumed their original status and effect as if they had never been deleted. This outcome was consistent with the principles of the Torrens system, which prioritises the accuracy and reliability of the register. The Court emphasised that the reinstatement of the easements did not create new rights but restored existing ones that were erroneously removed. Therefore, the easements' legal effect and enforceability were fully reinstated upon the Recorder of Titles' action.

The Court concluded that the Recorder of Titles had the authority to reinstate the easements under s143C of the Land Titles Act 1980. It also clarified that this authority extended to rectifying mistaken deletions of registered easements, not just errors on the plan. This decision reinforced the principle that the Torrens system's integrity depends on accurate registration, and s143C provides a mechanism to correct such inaccuracies. The ratio decidendi of this case is that s143C empowers the Recorder of Titles to reinstate easements mistakenly deleted from the Torrens title, thereby restoring their original status and effect.