Nightingale v Recorder of Titles

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

[2018] TASSC 56

COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA

CITATION:                 Nightingale v Recorder of Titles [2018] TASSC 56

PARTIES:  NIGHTINGALE, Robert Frank
  NIGHTINGALE, Anita Ruth
  v
  RECORDER OF TITLES

FILE NO:  784/2017
DELIVERED ON:  1 November 2018
DELIVERED AT:  Launceston
HEARING DATE:  5 September 2018
JUDGMENT OF:  Brett J

CATCHWORDS:

Real Property – Torrens title – Amendment or variation of title record – Extent of Recorder's power – Application for rectification of boundary led to correction of Register on one of the relevant folios but not the other – Whether the Recorder has power to amend the erroneous folio – Recorder should exercise power to remedy the inconsistency to ensure the accuracy of the Register.

Land Titles Act 1980 (Tas), ss 32, 139, 142, 144.
Acts Interpretation Act 1931 (Tas), ss 10A, 20 (a).
Quarmby v Keating [2008] TASSC 71, 18 Tas R 284, referred to.
Purton v Jackson [2012] TASFC 2, applied.
Aust Dig Real Property [1236]

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
             Applicants:  L Sealy SC and P Sutherland
             Respondent:  P Turner
Solicitors:
             Applicants:  Murdoch Clarke
             Respondent:  Office of the Solicitor-General

Judgment Number:  [2018] TASSC 56
Number of paragraphs:  63

Serial No 56/2018
File No 784/2017

ROBERT FRANK NIGHTINGALE and ANITA RUTH NIGHTINGALE
v RECORDER OF TITLES

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  BRETT J

1 November 2018

  1. This application concerns the location of the boundary between two pieces of land. One property is owned by the applicants and the other by Mr and Mrs Yarnall. I will refer to each property as the Nightingale land and the Yarnall land respectively.

  2. The facts are not in dispute. In 1998, the applicants constructed a building which they deliberately located 200mm inside the common boundary between the two properties (the boundary).  They did this in order to leave room for guttering and drainage works.  The wall of the building facing the boundary was clad in Besser stone.  This was because of an arrangement with the then owners of the Yarnall land that there would be no fence erected on the boundary, and that the Besser stone wall would form a backdrop to their garden. The respective owners at that time agreed that the boundary had, prior to that construction, been on a line depicted by a paling fence.

  3. After Mr and Mrs Yarnall purchased the land in 2012, a dispute arose between the respective owners concerning the precise location of the common boundary. According to the applicants, this dispute arose because of a misunderstanding by Mr and Mrs Yarnall as to the location of the boundary, having regard to the absence of a fence and the location of the stone wall.  Shortly after the dispute arose, Mr and Mrs Yarnall engaged a surveyor, Mr Cromer, to survey the boundary. It is common ground that in late 2014 and early 2015, Mr and Mrs Yarnall lodged documents with the Recorder of Titles which, in effect, requested the Recorder to alter the boundary to accord with a plan of survey…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nightingale v Recorder of Titles and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] TASSC 56
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Nightingale v Recorder of Titles concerns a dispute regarding the rectification of a boundary and the subsequent amendment of title records under the Real Property Act. The applicants, Nightingale, sought rectification of a boundary between their property and that of the Yarnalls. The Recorder of Titles approved the application and amended the description of the Nightingale's land in the Register but did not amend the description of the Yarnalls' land. Nightingale then applied for the Recorder to amend the Yarnalls' title record to reflect the corrected boundary. The central legal issue was whether the Recorder had the power to amend the erroneous folio of the Yarnalls' land to ensure consistency and accuracy in the Register.

The court considered the scope of the Recorder's power to amend or vary title records under the Real Property Act. The Recorder's authority to rectify boundaries and amend the Register was examined in the context of achieving legislative goals of accuracy and certainty. The court noted that the Yarnalls were given notice and an opportunity to object, indicating that their land was considered capable of being affected by the boundary rectification. The court held that the Recorder's power to amend the Register must logically extend to any land sharing the common boundary to ensure consistency and accuracy. The court rejected the argument that the Recorder was functus officio and that the issue should be resolved through court proceedings between the parties. Instead, the court found that the Recorder should exercise her power to remedy the inconsistency to ensure the accuracy of the Register.

In conclusion, the court ruled that the Recorder has the authority to amend the Yarnalls' title record to reflect the corrected boundary, ensuring the accuracy and consistency of the Register. The court rejected the argument that the Recorder was without power to make such an amendment and found that the original application's scope was broad enough to encompass the type of relief sought by the applicants. The Recorder should ensure that the title records of all affected properties reflect the correct boundary to achieve the legislative purpose of certainty and accuracy in the Register.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr and Mrs Yarnall provided a statement of objection pursuant to the notice. They also provided evidence in support of their objection. The Recorder did not hold a formal hearing. At the conclusion of the investigation, the Recorder's determination was expressed in the following terms:"Decision of the Recorder of TitlesThe Assistant Recorder of Titles is not satisfied that the submissions and objection provide cogent evidence which alters the determination of the application as advised in the Notices dated 23 September 2015. The Assistant Recorder of Titles considers that the boundary determination by P169732 should prevail and that Application E10899 should be registered. The Assistant Recorder of Titles has determined to amend the description of land in Folio of the Register Volume 41150 Folio 2 to be 'Lot 2 on Plan 169732'." As already noted, there was no appeal from the Recorder's decision and the decision was subsequently registered in this Court. Mr Turner submits that the Recorder had no power to do what was requested of her by the applicants in their letter dated 10 October 2016, that is to amend the plan in respect of the Yarnall land to accord with the decision to rectify the boundary, because she had not been requested to make such an order in the application, and was now functus officio in respect of that application. Mr Turner submits that the Yarnall land could have been included in the original application, or the applicants could have appealed from the original decision. Further, he submits that there are other remedies available to the applicants to correct the current situation of conflicting titles, in particular, proceedings in court between the registered owners to obtain a declaration as to the position of the correct boundary. For the reasons already given, I reject the submission that the issue should be determined by proceedings in court inter partes. What is in issue in this case is not the position of the true boundary, but rather the accuracy of the Register. This is a matter for the Recorder. Further, I am satisfied that the ambit of the original application was wide enough to encompass the type of relief which is now sought by the applicants. The definition of "interested person" in subs (21) makes it clear that the application is primarily related to the piece of land of which the applicants are the registered proprietors. However, the procedures described, in particular, in subs (5)(a), are consistent with a legislative scheme whereby the Recorder is intended to have jurisdiction to rectify a boundary, which necessarily implies that the power to do so will relate not just to the land of the applicants, but also to other land which shares that boundary. Such land must come within the definition of any other land "which may be affected" by the application. The Yarnalls were made a party to the proceedings and were given an opportunity to, and did, lodge an objection. The fact that they were given notice indicates that the Recorder had correctly considered that their land was capable of being affected by the application. The orders under subs (14) are expressed in wide terms. In particular, the Recorder has power to "amend any plan, folio of the register, certificate of title …". This power must logically extend to the land affected by the rectification of the boundary. The whole point of the provision is to rectify error for the ultimate purpose of achieving certainty by ensuring the Register is accurate. It would defeat this legislative purpose if the result of the process leaves the Register unclear as to the true location of the boundary. Such certainty can only be achieved if the title to each piece of land sharing the common boundary shows the boundary in the same position.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established