Orb Holdings Pty Ltd v WCL (Qld) Albert Street Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 64 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Orb Holdings Pty Ltd v WCL (QLD) Albert Street Pty Ltd [2019] QSC 265

PARTIES:

ORB HOLIDNGS PTY LTD

(applicant)

v
WCL (QLD) ALBERT STREET PTY LTD

(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

BS 6514 of 2019

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

29 October 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

25 September 2019

JUDGE:

Davis J

ORDERS:

1.   Application BS 6514 of 2019 is dismissed;

2.   Orb Holdings Pty Ltd pay the costs of WCL (Qld) Albert Street Pty Ltd of application BS 6514 of 2019 including the costs of the application for judgment.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – ENDING PROCEEDINGS EARLY – SUMMARY DISPOSAL – SUMMARY JUDGMENT FOR PLAINTIFF OR APPLICANT – where the applicant seeks a declaration against the respondent that certain land has been dedicated as, and is, a public highway or public road – where the respondent applied for judgment in the application – whether the respondent as registered proprietor in fee simple of the land, is not subject to any unregistered interest created by or as a result of a common law dedication of a road

REAL PROPERTY – TORRENS TITLE – INDEFEASIBILITY OF TITLE – EXCEPTIONS TO INDEFEASIBILITY – RIGHTS OF HIGHWAY – where the applicant submitted that land had been dedicated as a public road and that that dedication was not affected by the transfer of the land to the respondent and registration of the respondent as proprietor in fee simple – whether the respondent has indefeasible title to the land – whether common law public rights of passage over land take priority over registered interest

Acts Interpretation Act 1954, s 13

City of Brisbane Act 2010, s 3, s 5, s 63, s 65, s 65(2)(a), s 65(2)(b), s 66, s 81

Grammar Schools Act 1860

Grammar SchoolsAct 1975

Land Act 1962, s 369

Land Act 1994, s 93, s 94, s 95

Land Title Act 1994, s 3, s 5, s 6, s 7(1), s 7(2), s 19, s 24, s 27, s 28, s 29, s 31, s 48, s 50, s 51, s 51A, s 54, s 60, s 179, s 180, s 181, s 182, s 183, s 184, s 185, s 186, s 187, s 200, s 201

Real Property Act 1861, s 11, s 119

Real Property Act 1900 (NSW), s 46, s 47, s 48, s 49, s 50, s 51, s 52, s 53, s 54, s 55, s 56, s 57, s 72, s 73, s 74, s 88, s 89, s 90, s 91, s 92, s 93, s 94

Transport Infrastructure Act 1994, s 24, s 53

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999, r 8(2), r 11, r 14, r 134, r 135, r 291, r 292, r 293, r 658, r 681

Agar v Hyde (2000) 201 CLR 552, followed

Anderson v City of Stonnington and Anor (2017) 227 LGERA 176, considered

Assets…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Orb Holdings Pty Ltd v WCL (Qld) Albert Street Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QSC 265
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Orb Holdings Pty Ltd v WCL (Qld) Albert Street Pty Ltd, the matter involved a dispute over the status of a parcel of land located at the intersection of Margaret, Albert, and Alice Streets in the Central Brisbane Business District. The applicant, Orb, sought a declaration that certain land had been dedicated as a public highway or public road, while the respondent, WCL, applied for judgment in the application on the basis that it held an indefeasible title to the land as the registered proprietor in fee simple. The court had to determine whether the respondent's title was subject to any unregistered interest created by a common law dedication of a road.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the respondent, as the registered proprietor in fee simple of the land, was subject to any unregistered interest created by or as a result of a common law dedication of a road. The court had to consider the principles of indefeasibility of title under the Torrens Title system and exceptions to indefeasibility, specifically whether rights of highway or public passage over land took priority over a registered interest.

The court examined the historical context and evidence provided by the parties, including the expert opinion of Dr Beanland, which suggested that Lot 11 had been used as a public road since the 1880s. The court noted that there was evidence to support the first two elements of Orb's case, but the decisive question was whether the dedication of Lot 11 as a public road prior to 1923 created an interest that defeated WCL's registered interest. The court concluded that WCL's interest as the registered proprietor of the fee simple was not held subject to any interest of the State arising from the common law dedication of Lot 11 as a road. The court held that the respondent's interest was not subject to any unregistered interest created by the common law dedication of a road, and therefore, WCL should have judgment in the principal application.

The court dismissed the application BS 6514 of 2019 and ordered that Orb Holdings Pty Ltd pay the costs of WCL (Qld) Albert Street Pty Ltd of the application, including the costs of the application for judgment. The court found that WCL's registration as the proprietor of the fee simple gave it priority over any unregistered "interests" and that the exceptions to indefeasibility did not apply in this case. The court did not find it necessary to exercise its power under the 1994 Act to correct errors in the register or to order the correction of the register.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Application BS 6514 of 2019 is dismissed;

2. Orb Holdings Pty Ltd pay the costs of WCL (Qld) Albert Street Pty Ltd of application BS 6514 of 2019 including the costs of the application for judgment.

Background

Background to the litigation

WCL has applied under r 658 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (UCPR) and alternatively the inherent jurisdiction, for judgment in the application.Background A significant amount of material was filed on the application for summary judgment. Mr Dunning QC who led for WCL accepted during argument that there were factual disputes that cannot be decided on an application such as the present. He based the application for summary judgment on discreet points any of which he submitted were fatal to Orb’s application.[1][1] T1-31. It follows then, that it is only necessary to refer to the evidence to the extent required to identify those issues and their relevance and of course to decide them, if indeed it is appropriate to decide them on this application for summary judgment. The dispute relates to parcels of land on the corner of Margaret, Albert and Alice Streets in what is now the Central Brisbane Business District. Registered Plan 1073 (RP1073) was registered in September 1876. By that point, the Torrens Title System had been established in Queensland.[2] The registered proprietors of the land who caused the plan to be registered were the trustees of the Brisbane Grammar School (the Grammar School). [2] Real Property Act 1861. RP1073 shows:(i)on the corner of Margaret, Albert and Alice Streets are nine individual lots;(ii)Lots 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 front Albert Street although Lot 1 also has a boundary with Margaret Street;(iii)Lot 6, 7, 8 and 9 front Alice Street although Lot 6 also has a boundary with Albert Street;(iv)along what can be described as the rear of all of the lots, runs an “L” shaped piece of land marked “Right of Way”. That right of way is marked with a notation “Lot 11 (balance)”;(v)each end of the “L” shaped Lot 11 fronts onto a street being either Albert Street or Margaret Street. A person could physically then travel on foot or by other means from Margaret Street to Albert Street or vice versa (and therefore past all of the lots) across Lot 11;(vi)running along the southern boundary of that part of Lot 11 which sits behind Lots 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 is a shaded area which is a reserve and is about 30 centimetres wide (the reserve). After registration of RP1073, the Grammar School, between 1876 and 1881, disposed of the lots except Lot 11. Orb relies upon the expert opinion of an historian Dr Denver Beanland. In that report, Dr Beanland annexes various historical documents and opines that from the 1880s Lot 11 became known as “Beatrice Lane” and was in use as a public road. In 1927 the reserve was resumed by the Brisbane City Council and it was dedicated as a road in 1928. In 1971, solicitors acting for an interested party enquired of the status of the area marked “Right of Way”. The Registrar of Titles conducted an investigation (the 1971 investigation) and responded to the solicitors as follows:“It is considered that the area shown ‘Right of Way’ on Plan 1073 still forms part of the land in the original titles for Allotments 9, 10 and 11 of Section 37, City of Brisbane.[3]The original conveyances of Subdivisions 1 to 5 all describe these subdivisions as bounded by a ‘Right of Way’ and there has never been any express dedication of the land as a Road.”[3] The parcel subdivided by RP1073.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

It is worth mentioning the Transport Infrastructure Act 1994 only because it is a statute which concerns, among other things, roads. That Act though only concerns “State controlled roads” which exist over land declared to be a State controlled road.[96][96] Sections 24 or 53.Conclusions In order to succeed in the principal application, Orb must establish:1.The Grammar School manifested an intention to dedicate Lot 11 as a public road.2.The public accepted the dedication.3.The dedication has led to the creation of rights which defeat WCL’s right to enjoy Lot 11 without the restriction of maintaining it as a public thoroughfare. There is evidence to support the first two elements of Orb’s case such that it is not clear (for the purposes of an application for summary judgment) that Orb’s case must fail at trial for want of proof of those elements. The best case for Orb is that RP1073 delineates Lot 11 as a public thoroughfare (a road for present purposes) and by the Land Act 1962 Lot 11 vested in the State. Whether that interest defeats the registered interest of WCL does not depend on the resolution of any contentious matters of fact. For the reasons I have explained, WCL’s interest as registered proprietor of the fee simple is not held by it subject to any interest of the State’s[97] arising from the common law dedication of Lot 11 as a road prior to 1923.[97] Vested by s 369 of the Land Act 1962. There is no need for a trial. WCL should have judgment in the principal application. The appropriate order is to dismiss application BS 6514 of 2019.Costs Rule 681 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 provides that unless the court otherwise orders, costs ought follow the event. Mr Bain QC who led for Orb conceded that if WCL’s application for judgment was successful then there was no defence to an order for costs of both WCL’s application and Orb’s. Orders I order that:(i)application BS 6514 of 2019 is dismissed;(ii)Orb Holdings Pty Ltd pay the costs of WCL (QLD) Albert Street Pty Ltd of application BS 6514 of 2019 including the costs of the application for judgment.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As well as an interest of a proprietor in fee simple, there are interests in land which may be registered under the 1994 Act: leases,[37] mortgages,[38] easements,[39] covenants[40] and profits a prendre.[41] Subdivisions A and B of Division 2 of Part 9 deal with the consequence of registration and indefeasibility. They provide:[37] Division 2 of Part 6.[38] Division 3 of Part 6.[39] Division 4 and 4AA of Part 6.[40] Division 4A of Part 6.[41] Division 4B of Part 6.“Division 2 Consequences of registrationSubdivision A General180 Benefits of registrationThe benefits of this division apply to an instrument whether or not valuable consideration has been given.181 Interest in a lot not transferred or created until registrationAn instrument does not transfer or create an interest in a lot at law until it is registered.182 Effect of registration on interestOn registration of an instrument that is expressed to transfer or create an interest in a lot, the interest—(a) is transferred or created in accordance with the instrument; and(b) is registered; and(c)vests in the person identified in the instrument as the person entitled to the interest.183 Right to have interest registeredA person to whom an interest is to be transferred or in whom an interest has been created has a right to have the instrument transferring or creating the interest registered if—(a) the instrument has been executed; and(b) the person lodges the instrument and any documents required by the registrar to effect registration of the instrument; and(c) the person has otherwise complied with this Act in relation to the registration of the instrument.Subdivision B Indefeasibility184 Quality of registered interests(1) A registered proprietor of an interest in a lot holds the interest subject to registered interests affecting the lot but free from all other interests.(2) In particular, the registered proprietor—(a) is not affected by actual or constructive notice of an unregistered interest affecting the lot; and(b) is liable to a proceeding for possession of the lot or an interest in the lot only if the proceeding is brought by the registered proprietor of an interest affecting the lot.(3) However, subsections (1) and (2) do not apply—(a) to an interest mentioned in section 185; or(b) if there has been fraud by the registered proprietor, whether or not there has been fraud by a person from or through whom the registered proprietor has derived the registered interest. WCL’s registration as proprietor of the fee simple gives it priority over any unregistered “interests”. At least on the face of s 184, WCL’s interest would defeat the interest in Lot 11 vested in the State by s 369 of the Land Act 1962. Section 185 prescribes the exceptions to indefeasibility. Public rights in a common law road are not an exception expressed in s 185 and neither is the improper omission of an endorsement on a plan of a public use area, such as a road. Section 186 of the 1994 Act empowers the Registrar to correct errors in some circumstances and s 187 empowers this court to order the correction of the register in other circumstances. Neither party argued that either the power of the registrar or the jurisdiction of the Court is enlivened here to act under ss 186 or 187 respectively in aid of Orb’s position.