Orb Holdings Pty Ltd v WCL (Qld) Albert St Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Orb Holdings Pty Ltd v WCL (Qld) Albert St Pty Ltd & Ors [2022] QSC 190

PARTIES:

ORB HOLDINGS PTY LTD

(Applicant)

v

WCL (QLD) ALBERT ST PTY LTD

(First Respondent)

AND

STATE OF QUEENSLAND

(Second Respondent)

AND

REGISTRAR OF TITLES

(Third Respondent)

FILE NO/S:

SC No 6514 of 2019

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Trial

ORIGINATING COURT:

Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

8 September 2022

DELIVERED AT:

Rockhampton

HEARING DATE:

16, 17 and 18 May 2022

JUDGE:

Crow J

ORDER:

I make the following declarations:

(a)   A declaration that the land described on Lot 11 RP1073, also known as Beatrice Lane, has been dedicated as, and is a public road.

(b) A declaration that by operation of s 369 of the Land Act 1962 (Qld) (repealed), the land described as Lot 11 on RP1073 known as Beatrice Lane, vested in and remains vested in the Crown.

CATCHWORDS:

REAL PROPERTY – TORRENS TITLE – INDEFEASIBILITY OF TITLE – EXCEPTIONS TO INDEFEASIBILITY – RIGHTS OF HIGHWAY – where the first respondent acquired a lot of land in 2014 – where the first respondent subsequently closed the lot off from public access - where the applicant is the owner of a nearby lot of land – where the applicant had relied upon the use of the lot acquired by the first respondent to access their business carpark – where the applicant seeks a declaration that the lot has been, and is, a public highway or public road at common law – whether the registered landowner in 1876 manifested an intention to dedicate the lot as a public road – whether there was acceptance by the public of the proffered dedication – whether the dedication was lawful.

Acts Interpretation Act 1954 (Qld), s 36
Grammar Schools Act 1860 (Qld), s 6
Local Government Act 1878 (Qld), s 3
Land Act 1962 (Qld), s 369
Real Property Act 1861, s 44, s 119, s 122

City of Keilor v O'Donohue (1971) 126 CLR 353, followed
Ex parte Le Gould (1864) 1 QSCR 130, cited
Greenwich Board of Works v Maudsley (1870) LR 5 QB 397, followed
Mayberry & Ors v Mornington Peninsula Shire Council (2019) 59 VR 383, followed
Newington v Windeyer (1985) 3 NSWLR 555, distinguished
Orb Holdings Pty Ltd v WCL (Qld) Albert Street Pty Ltd [2019] QSC 265, cited
Orb Holdings Pty Ltd v WCL (Qld) Albert St Pty Ltd [2020] QCA 198, followed
Palmisano v Hawse & Ors [2003] NSWSC 566, applied
Re O’Quinn (1879) 1 QLJ (Supp) 7, considered
Rangeley v Midland Railway Co (1868) LR 3 Ch App 306, cited
The Centre Pty Ltd v Thomas R Magnus Pty Ltd (1969) Qd R 452, applied
Weber v Ankin [2008] NSWSC 106, followed

COUNSEL:

J. D. McKenna QC with J.P Hastie for the applicant
S. B. Whitten and AL Lowe for the first respondent
D Keane and S Russell for the second and third respondents

SOLICITORS:

HWL Ebsworth…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Orb Holdings Pty Ltd v WCL (Qld) Albert St Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QSC 190
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Orb Holdings Pty Ltd v WCL (Qld) Albert St Pty Ltd, the dispute involved a claim by the applicant, Orb Holdings Pty Ltd, that a lot of land acquired by the first respondent, WCL (Qld) Albert St Pty Ltd, had been dedicated as a public road at common law. The applicant had relied on the use of this lot for access to their business carpark. The central issues before the court were whether the landowner in 1876 intended to dedicate the lot as a public road, whether the public accepted this dedication, and whether the dedication was lawful. The case required a detailed examination of historical land title documents, the applicable common law, and statutory regimes governing the creation of roads in the late 19th century.

The court had to determine if the registered landowner in 1876 manifested an intention to dedicate the land as a public road, whether there was public acceptance of this dedication, and if the dedication was lawful. This involved scrutinising documentary evidence from the period, including land title documents, and understanding the legal frameworks for the creation of roads at that time. The court also had to consider the impact of subsequent legislative changes, particularly the Local Authorities Act Amendment Act 1923 (Qld), which altered the law regarding the creation of public roads and required statutory basis for any dedication.

The court reasoned that the documentary evidence provided sufficient proof of the land title and the historical circumstances surrounding the dedication. The court found that the landowner in 1876 had indeed manifested an intention to dedicate the lot as a public road, and that there was public acceptance of this dedication. Furthermore, the court concluded that the dedication was lawful under the laws applicable at the time. Therefore, the court made the following declarations: (a) that the land described on Lot 11 on RP1073, also known as Beatrice Lane, had been dedicated as, and is, a public road; and (b) that by operation of s 369 of the Land Act 1962 (Qld) (repealed), the land described as Lot 11 on RP1073 known as Beatrice Lane, vested in and remains vested in the Crown.

Orders

Orders of the court

I make the following declarations:

(a) A declaration that the land described on Lot 11 RP1073, also known as Beatrice Lane, has been dedicated as, and is a public road.

(b) A declaration that by operation of s 369 of the Land Act 1962 (Qld) (repealed), the land described as Lot 11 on RP1073 known as Beatrice Lane, vested in and remains vested in the Crown.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The first issue is whether the competent landowner manifested an intention to dedicate the land as a public road.[5] If so, the second issue is whether there was an acceptance by the public of the proffered dedication. The third issue is whether the dedication was lawful. It is necessary to consider the evidence, the common law and the statutory regimes for the creation of interests in land and roads in the late 19th Century, and then determine the findings of fact.[5]See Windeyer J in Permanent Trustee Co of NSW Ltd v Campbelltown Municipal Council (1960) 105 CLR 401 at 420.Documentary Evidence Given the passage of much time, the documentary evidence is the most important evidence in this case. Prior to the Torrens system of land transfer, the common law system of transfer of land was by deed. The common law system had several disadvantages, the principal of which was the insecurity of ownership of land as it was reliant upon production of and proof of deeds. The revolutionary Torrens system provided for a central registry and title by registration and was first introduced in South Australia by the Real Property Act 1858. Queensland was the second State to adopt the Torrens system when it passed the Real Property Act 1861. The establishment of a register not only provided certainty in respect of title to land, it provided, by s 122, a means of proof of that certainty as certified copies of any registered instrument was “prima facie proof of all the matters contained or recited in or endorsed on the original instrument.” The affidavit of Mr Walker, solicitor, comprehensively sets out the Land Title documents that came into existence prior to and subsequent to 1861 in respect of the subject land.[6] The documents provide “prima facie proof” of the property interests in the subject land. [6]Joint Trial Bundle (Exhibit 1) at volume 2, part 1, pages 1 – 244. A matter which is uncontroversial is that the law with respect to the creation of public roads was fundamentally altered with the Local Authorities Act Amendment Act 1923 (Qld) which prevented the private creation of new roads at common law and required the dedication of any public road or public highway to have a statutory basis under that Act. The relevant factual history, therefore, primarily relates to the period prior to 1924. On 25 November 1851, the colony of New South Wales advertised for sale of Lots 31 to 50 of the town lots of the Police District of Brisbane. Survey Plan B.1182.29 shows a survey of Lots 7, 8, 9 10 and 11 on Section 37 as follows:[7] Although the original lots pre-dated the Real Property Act 1861, that act provided for parcels of land to be brought under its provisions and, therefore, certificates of title to issue. Certificates of title in respect of the subject land were subsequently issued, showing that the trustees of the Brisbane Grammar School purchased Lots 8, 9, 10 and 11 by memorandum of conveyance registered on 13 November 1874.[8] The certificates of title also evidence the history of the land grants that were made.[8]Joint Trial Bundle (Exhibit 1) at volume 2, part 1, page 4.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The presumption of regularity is sufficient to dispose of this point in the applicant’s favour, however, it seems to me that the only proper inference to be drawn from the evidence is that sanctions had been obtained as required from the Governor and Executive Council. Form of Declaration In their amended points of claim,[100] the applicant seeks:(a)A declaration that Beatrice Lane has been dedicated as, and is, a public highway or public road;(aa)A declaration that, by operation of s 369 of the Land Act 1962 (Qld) (repealed) Beatrice Lane vested, and remains vested in, in the Crown.[100]Amended Points of Claim filed by applicant 26 October 2021 (Court document no 40). The second and third respondents submit that the declarations ought to take the following form:[101](a)The land described on Lot 11 on RP1073 has been dedicated as, and is, a highway at common law;(b)By operation of s 369 of the Land Act 1962 (Qld) (repealed), the land in the highway so dedicated vested in, and remains vested in the Crown.[101]Second and Third Respondents’ Outline of Submissions filed by second and third respondent 16 May 2022 (Court document no 68). Although ostensibly the form of the declarations appears similar, they have, in fact, a significantly different effect. On behalf of the second and third respondents, it is argued that the orthodox position at common law, as pointed out by the Court of Appeal in Orb Holdings Pty Ltd v WCL,[102] that the dedication of a public road does not constitute a disposition of the owner in the fee simple but rather creates the incorporeal right of a member of a public to pass upon that fee simple and so s 369 authorises only the disposition of that fraction of the land which is necessary to preserve the public’s incorporeal right to pass over the right of way.[103] [102][2020] QCA 198.[103]Second and Third Respondents’ Outline of Submissions filed by second and third respondent 16 May 2022 (Court document no 68) at paragraph [7]. The appellant submits that the form of declaration that is submitted is consistent with the purpose of s 369 of the Land Act. Section 369 of the Land Act 1962 (Qld) (repealed) provides:“369. Roads dedicated to the public by private persons (1910, s. 196)All land which, having been before, is at the commencement of this Act, or which may on or after the commencement of this Act be, dedicated by the owner thereof, not being the Crown, to public use as a road shall, by virtue of such dedication be vested (and in the case of land so dedicated before the commencement of this Act, is hereby declared to have always been vested) in the Crown and may be dealt with in the same manner as roads which have been dedicated to public use by the Crown.” The entire point of s 369 was to allow the Crown to deal with roads which have been dedicated to the public by private persons in the same manner as roads which have been dedicated to public use by the Crown. That cannot occur if the word “land” in s 369 is narrowly construed to mean only that portion, perhaps unidentifiable, which has been dedicated by private persons to public use.