Shire of Narracan v Leviston

Link copied
Case Copied 57 min read
3 CLR 846

PRESIDENT &. OF THE SHIRE OF

NARRACAN

DEFENDANTS. LEVISTON

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF Highway-Dedication-Presumption from public user-User attributable to ag

ment -Dedication by mortgagor. MELBOURNE,

An intention to dedicate land as a highway will not be presumed fi March 30;

mere user if that user is explained by circumstances negativing such May 28, 29;

Barraclough v. Johnson, 8 A. &E., 99, followed. If the user is attributable to an implied agreement between the owner of land and the Crown, or between the owner and a public body having power acquire the land for a highway on paying compensation therefor, that owner would permit the public to use the land as a highway pending exercise of that power, the intention to dedicate is negatived.

Under the Land Act 1869, A. selected land, and a licence was issued to by the Crown in 1877, containing a condition that the Crown might resu any part of the land for roads, paying compensation therefor, and a provis that the lease to be subsequently issued should contain a similar condition. track was in 1879 blazed through the land, the cost of which was paid subscriptions from neighbouring settlers. In the same year, at the request the municipality in whose district the land was situated, a surveyor was by the Department of Lands who surveyed a road one chain wide follow the blazed track. Thereafter this road appeared in maps of the locality, a from time to time the municipality at its own cost cleared, made and repair

3 CLR 847

the road, which was during all that time continuously used by the public as a highway. In 1884 the municipality requested that the Crown should proclaim as public roads the roads within the shire, including the road so surveyed, and were informed that no proclamation would be made until all the roads were surveyed. No proclamation was, however, made of this road. In the same year, 1884, a Crown lease of the block of land, through which the road ran, was issued to A. without any condition as to resumption for roads. In 1886, A. mortgaged his lease, and in 1889 the mortgagee, under powers con- tained in the mortgage, sold and transferred the land to B., to whom a Crown Grant was issued in the same year without any excision of the road. Nine days after the issue of the Crown Grant B. mortgaged the land. In 1901, B.'s mortgagee sold the land to C. who sold to the plaintiff in 1902. C., having obstructed the road by locking a gate in a fence across the road where it entered his land, the municipality removed the fence and gate, whereupon C. brought an action for trespass.

Held, that the user of the road by the public should, in its inception, be attributed to an implied agreement between the municipality and A. that he would permit the public to use the road pending its proclamation as a public road,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Shire of Narracan v Leviston and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1906] HCA 34
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia considered a dispute between the Shire of Narracan and the respondents, Mr. and Mrs. Leviston, concerning a claim of dedication of a road over the Levistons' land. The Shire asserted that a public highway had been dedicated by public user, while the Levistons disputed this claim.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the use of a strip of land by the public, which the Shire contended constituted dedication as a highway, could be attributed to an agreement between the Levistons and the Shire. Specifically, the Court had to determine if this user was permissive and therefore not indicative of an intention to dedicate, and whether a mortgagor could effect a dedication of land subject to a mortgage.

The High Court held that the user of the land by the public was not sufficient to establish a dedication as a highway. Their Honours reasoned that the user was attributable to an agreement between the Levistons and the Shire, which permitted the public to use the land for a specific purpose. This permissive user did not demonstrate the necessary intention on the part of the landowners to dedicate the land as a public road. Furthermore, the Court affirmed that a mortgagor, who retains possession and control of the mortgaged land, can indeed dedicate it as a highway, provided the necessary intention is present and the dedication does not prejudice the rights of the mortgagee. However, in this instance, the permissive nature of the user negated the intention to dedicate.

The High Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the orders of the Supreme Court of Victoria and ordering that the Levistons' claim for a declaration that the strip of land was not a public highway be dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established