Simmons v New South Wales Trustee and Guardian

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

Court of Appeal


Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Simmons v New South Wales Trustee and Guardian [2014] NSWCA 405
Hearing dates:15 September 2014
Decision date: 02 December 2014
Before: Beazley P at [1];
Barrett JA at [2];
Gleeson JA at [4]
Decision:

1. Appeal allowed in part, as against the first respondent.

2. Set aside order 1 made by Hammerschlag J on 15 November 2013 insofar as it relates to the first respondent.

3. Grant leave to the appellant to amend the statement of claim as against the first respondent in the form of the draft amended statement of claim dated 31 October 2013.

4. Direct the appellant to file and serve the amended statement of claim against the first respondent within seven (7) days.

5. The appellant's costs in this Court as against the first respondent shall be the plaintiff's costs in the proceedings below.

6. Appeal dismissed, as against the second and third respondents.

7. The appellant to pay the second and third respondents' costs in this Court.

8. The appellant, if otherwise qualified, shall have a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951 (NSW) in respect of the costs of the appeal as against the first respondent.

[Note: The Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 provide (Rule 36.11) that unless the Court otherwise orders, a judgment or order is taken to be entered when it is recorded in the Court's computerised court record system. Setting aside and variation of judgments or orders is dealt with by Rules 36.15, 36.16, 36.17 and 36.18. Parties should in particular note the time limit of fourteen days in Rule 36.16.]

Catchwords: APPEAL - Whether primary judge erred in considering delay and prejudice - Whether primary judge erred in refusing to permit cross-examination during interlocutory proceedings - Courts must have regard to the overriding purpose of facilitating the just, quick, and cheap resolution of the real issues in proceedings
APPEAL - Summary dismissal - Whether the primary judge erred in summarily dismissing the application to amend - Whether the claims were so obviously untenable or groundless that there was 'a high degree of certainty' that they would fail if allowed to go to trial - Assessment must be made taking the plaintiff's case at its highest
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - Pleadings - Leave to amend statement of claim refused by primary judge - Whether primary judge erred in concluding that the proposed amendments were inadequate - Whether proposed amendments sufficiently pleaded fraud or a personal equity against the second and third defendants - Claim of knowing receipt or knowing assistance under first and second limb Barnes v Addy - Claim that second and third defendants were "primary wrongdoers" - Allegations must be expressly pleaded and sufficiently particularised PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - Pleadings - Fraud exception to a claim of indefeasibility - Fraud must be specifically and clearly pleaded - Particulars of fraud must be given under UCPR r15.3 - Whether proposed amendments sufficiently pleaded fraud - Personal equities arising…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Simmons v New South Wales Trustee and Guardian and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NSWCA 405
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned an application by the appellant, Father Simmons, for leave to amend his statement of claim against the first respondent, the New South Wales Trustee and Guardian, and the second and third respondents, Mr Henwood and Dorothy Simmons. The primary judge had refused to grant leave to amend the statement of claim, summarily dismissing the application. The appeal was heard by Beazley P, Barrett and Gleeson JJA.

The central legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether the primary judge erred in refusing to permit cross-examination during interlocutory proceedings, whether the primary judge erred in summarily dismissing the application to amend the statement of claim, and whether the proposed amendments sufficiently pleaded fraud or a personal equity against the second and third defendants, particularly in light of the defence of indefeasibility under s 42 of the Real Property Act. The Court also considered whether the claims were so obviously untenable or groundless that there was a high degree of certainty they would fail if allowed to go to trial, and whether the primary judge had regard to the overriding purpose of facilitating the just, quick, and cheap resolution of the real issues.

The Court of Appeal found that the primary judge had erred in refusing to grant leave to amend the statement of claim as against the first respondent. The Court reasoned that the proposed amendments, when assessed at their highest, did not demonstrate a high degree of certainty of failure. However, the Court held that the primary judge had not erred in refusing leave to amend the statement of claim against the second and third respondents. This was because the proposed amendments did not sufficiently plead fraud, which must be specifically and clearly pleaded with particulars under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules. Furthermore, personal equities arising under *Barnes v Addy* cannot prevail against indefeasibility under s 42 of the Real Property Act, and such equities require an acknowledgment, agreement, or undertaking from the registered proprietor that they later resile from, which was not adequately pleaded.

The appeal was allowed in part, with the order of the primary judge set aside insofar as it related to the first respondent. Leave was granted to the appellant to amend the statement of claim against the first respondent, with directions for filing and service. The appellant was ordered to pay the second and third respondents' costs in the Court of Appeal, while the appellant's costs against the first respondent were to be the plaintiff's costs in the proceedings below. The appellant was also granted a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951 (NSW) in respect of the costs of the appeal as against the first respondent.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed in part, as against the first respondent.

2. Set aside order 1 made by Hammerschlag J on 15 November 2013 insofar as it relates to the first respondent.

3. Grant leave to the appellant to amend the statement of claim as against the first respondent in the form of the draft amended statement of claim dated 31 October 2013.

4. Direct the appellant to file and serve the amended statement of claim against the first respondent within seven (7) days.

5. The appellant's costs in this Court as against the first respondent shall be the plaintiff's costs in the proceedings below.

6. Appeal dismissed, as against the second and third respondents.

7. The appellant to pay the second and third respondents' costs in this Court.

8. The appellant, if otherwise qualified, shall have a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951 (NSW) in respect of the costs of the appeal as against the first respondent.

[Note: The Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 provide (Rule 36.11) that unless the Court otherwise orders, a judgment or order is taken to be entered when it is recorded in the Court's computerised court record system. Setting aside and variation of judgments or orders is dealt with by Rules 36.15, 36.16, 36.17 and 36.18. Parties should in particular note the time limit of fourteen days in Rule 36.16.]

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 7 May 2012 Hammerschlag J dismissed Father Simmons' claim against Mr Henwood and Dorothy Simmons: Paul Ernest Simmons v Protective Commissioner of New South Wales (aka NSW Trustee & Guardian) [2012] NSWSC 455 (the first judgment). The basis for this conclusion was summarised by Emmett JA in the 2013 Appeal as follows: One aspect of the statement of claim, which was the subject of the summary dismissal order, should be mentioned. At [37] Hammerschlag J observed that Father Simmons: As will be seen, the proposed amendments to Father Simmons' claim (the subject of the present appeal), include claims for equitable compensation against Mr Henwood and Dorothy Simmons. On 25 June 2013 this Court granted leave to appeal against the first judgment and, by majority, allowed the appeal. This Court found that the primary judge had erred in his conclusion that the present proceeding is an abuse of process because it attempts to litigate or relitigate the central issue decided in the earlier proceeding. This Court also found there was no error by the primary judge in concluding that, on the pleading before him, the claim against Mr Henwood and Dorothy Simmons was doomed to fail by reason of the defence of indefeasibility afforded by s 42 of the Real Property Act: at [87]. Nonetheless at [97] of the 2013 Appeal, Emmett JA (with whom I agreed) said that the matter should be remitted to the primary judge for consideration: At [96] Emmett JA also said: Following the remittal of the proceeding to the Equity Division, Father Simmons filed a motion on 2 August 2013 seeking leave to amend the statement of claim. No leave was sought to file a reply to the existing defences of Mr Henwood and Dorothy Simmons which had pleaded indefeasibility as a defence to Father Simmons' claims. The amendments proposed to the statement of claim were lengthy. For ease of reference, it is convenient to include the text of the proposed pleading at the end of these reasons. It is to be noted that the amendments in paragraphs 23A and 30A of the proposed statement of claim were abandoned before the primary judge. Before the primary judge a written outline of oral submissions was provided by Father Simmons' counsel on the day of the hearing. This stated (WB 1/136) that Father Simmons' claims of constructive trust and equitable compensation against Mr Henwood and Dorothy Simmons were put in three ways: It may be observed that the written submissions of Father Simmons did not contend that the proposed statement of claim pleaded fraud against Mr Henwood or Dorothy Simmons. Indeed, before the primary judge, counsel for Father Simmons contended at one stage that fraud did not need to be pleaded in the proposed statement of claim, as it could be pleaded by way of a reply to the amended defences once filed by Mr Henwood and Dorothy Simmons (WB 1/122; T 53, lines 1-6). Later in oral argument before the primary judge, counsel for Father Simmons contended that fraud had been pleaded in the proposed statement of claim and referred to paragraph 27B (WB 1/123; T 51, lines 3-21).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established