C, M v Commissioner of Police

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Criminal: Application)

C, M v COMMISSIONER OF POLICE

[2014] SASC 163

Reasons for Decision of The Honourable Justice Nicholson

5 November 2014

CRIMINAL LAW - PARTICULAR OFFENCES - OFFENCES AGAINST THE PERSON - SEXUAL OFFENCES - UNLAWFUL SEXUAL INTERCOURSE OR CARNAL KNOWLEDGE

CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCE - INTERPRETATION OF SENTENCING PROVISIONS

CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCE - SENTENCING ORDERS - ORDERS AND DECLARATIONS RELATING TO SERIOUS OR VIOLENT OFFENDERS OR DANGEROUS SEXUAL OFFENDERS - DANGEROUS SEXUAL OFFENDER - REGISTRATION, REPORTING AND LIKE MATTERS

In 1982 the applicant, aged 14 at the time, commenced a sexual relationship with an eight year old girl. The relationship continued over a six year period until sometime in 1988, and resulted in the victim giving birth to a child in early 1989. On 18 April 1995 the applicant pleaded guilty to, and was convicted of, two counts of unlawful sexual intercourse with a person of the age of 14 years. He was sentenced on 26 May 1995 to 12 months imprisonment with a non-parole period of nine months, which was suspended upon his entering into a bond to be of good behaviour for a period of two years.

The applicant qualifies as a registrable offender for the purpose of the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act 2007 (SA) and is therefore required to meet certain reporting obligations. The applicant now seeks an order pursuant to s37(2) of the Act that those reporting obligations be suspended. The applicant meets the threshold requirements of a registrable offender who is entitled to apply to this Court for such an order to be made. The question that arises is whether this Court can be satisfied, under s38(2), that the applicant does not pose a risk to the safety and wellbeing of any child or children.

Held:  application allowed.

Child Sex Offenders Registration Act 2006 (SA) s6, s15A, s37, s38; Acts Interpretation Act 1915 (SA) s22; Sex Offenders Registration Act 2004 (Vic) s11; Child Protection (Offender Reporting and Registration) Act 2004 (NT); Summary Procedure Act 1921 s99A, referred to.
Bowden v The Queen [2013] VSCA 382; Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336; R v ND [2014] NTSC 11, considered.

C, M v COMMISSIONER OF POLICE
[2014] SASC 163

Application pursuant to the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act 2006 (SA)

NICHOLSON J.   

  1. These reasons concern an application for an order pursuant to s37(2) of the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act 2006 (SA) that the applicant’s reporting obligations imposed on him by that legislation be suspended.

    Introduction

  2. On 18 April 1995, in the Port Adelaide Magistrates Court, the applicant pleaded guilty to and was convicted of two counts of unlawful sexual intercourse with a person of the age of 14 years.  He was committed to the District Court for sentence.  On 26 May 1995, a Judge of the District Court sentenced the applicant to 12 months imprisonment with a non-parole period of nine months.  This term of imprisonment was suspended upon the applicant entering into…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read C, M v Commissioner of Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] SASC 163
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of C, M v Commissioner of Police, the applicant sought to suspend his obligations under the Sex Offender Registration Act 2009 (SA). The applicant, a registrable offender, had previously been convicted of sexual offences against a minor and was subject to reporting obligations under the Act. The court had to determine whether the applicant qualified for an order suspending these obligations under section 38(2) of the Act, which requires a finding that the offender does not pose a risk to the safety and wellbeing of any child or children. Additionally, the court needed to consider the factors outlined in section 38(3) of the Act, including the applicant's history, present circumstances, and expert opinions on his risk of reoffending.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the applicant met the criteria for an order suspending his reporting obligations under the Sex Offender Registration Act 2009 (SA). This involved assessing whether the applicant posed a risk to the safety and wellbeing of any child or children, as required by section 38(2) of the Act. The court also had to consider the factors specified in section 38(3) of the Act, such as the length of time since the applicant's last sentence, his current risk of reoffending, and any other relevant circumstances. The court examined expert reports and testimonies to determine whether the applicant's risk of reoffending was sufficiently low to warrant a suspension of his reporting obligations.

The court found that the applicant had been sentenced 15 years ago and had not been on parole or subject to a reporting period in a foreign jurisdiction before becoming subject to such a period in South Australia. The court also considered the applicant's history and present circumstances, noting that the applicant had expressed feelings of shame, remorse, and guilt and demonstrated adequate victim empathy. The court accepted the opinion of the forensic psychologist that the applicant's risk of similar future sexualised offending behaviour was in the low range. Based on this assessment, the court concluded that the applicant did not pose a risk to the safety and wellbeing of any child or children and met the criteria for an order suspending his reporting obligations under section 38(2) of the Act.

Accordingly, the court made an order suspending the applicant's reporting obligations under the Sex Offender Registration Act 2009 (SA) for a period of two years. The court also directed that the applicant would be subject to random polygraph testing and that he must notify the Commissioner of Police of any changes in his circumstances that might affect his risk status.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Finally, with respect to s38(2) it is noted that whilst the legislation concerns the registration of child sex offenders, the requirement under s38(2) that a registrable offender does not pose a risk is not confined, by its terms, to the risk of sexual offending. The risk to be avoided is stated in more general terms – risk to the safety and wellbeing of any child or children. It is unnecessary, in this case, to consider whether this general statement of the risk to be avoided is to be interpreted and applied literally or to be read down in order to conform more precisely to the primary object of the legislation. On either approach and as explained later in these reasons, I am satisfied that s38(2) has been made out.The facts In order to address the matters raised in s38(3) and the requirement in s38(2) it will be necessary to canvass, in a little detail, the circumstances of the offending, the applicant’s history, the applicant’s present circumstances and the opinions of Mr Fugler and Mr Broomhall. The applicant committed the two charged offences of unlawful sexual intercourse with a person of the age of 14 years between 1 January and 31 December 1988. However, according to the sentencing remarks, this was a representative period in respect of a course of conduct that the applicant admitted had continued over a period of about six years. The applicant was sentenced on the basis that the offences with which he had been charged formed part of a course of conduct consisting of a series of criminal offences of the same or a similar character. The victim was the daughter of the second wife of the applicant’s father. A sexual relationship commenced in about 1982 when the victim was about eight years of age and the applicant was about 14. According to the applicant, it started with kissing and fondling and the like before progressing to include regular sexual intercourse. After the sexual relationship had continued for a period of about six years, the victim fell pregnant and, in early 1989, a baby was born. By this time the victim was 15 years of age and the applicant was 21. No further acts of sexual intercourse took place after some time in 1988. During sentencing submissions, the applicant, through his counsel, maintained that, at least towards the end of the six year period, there was a genuine relationship between the two. Nevertheless, the victim lodged a formal complaint with authorities some six or seven years after the offending conduct ceased. By then, at the latest, the psychological and emotional damage caused to the victim had become apparent and she had, with quite some justification, become very angry. In any event, the offending ceased some six years before the applicant was charged and sentenced, some 19 years before he became a registrable offender in 2007 and more than 25 years before the bringing of this application. The sentencing Judge, in his remarks, noted that whilst the applicant was only 14 years of age when the offending began it could not be ignored that, whatever his level of maturity might have been at the age of 14, he willingly continued with the unlawful conduct for about two years after he turned 18 and had come to be regarded by the law as being of full age and capacity.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

NICHOLSON J
As earlier indicated, a more recent report has now been obtained being that of the forensic psychologist, Mr Luke Broomhall, and dated 21 October 2014. I have read and considered this report. The history given by the applicant to Mr Broomhall is consistent with that given to Mr Fugler and that which has been given to the Court. The report by Mr Broomhall is extremely detailed and comprehensive. It is sufficient for present purposes to note the following, taken from Mr Broomhall’s summary of his conclusions and opinions.At interview [the applicant] expressed feelings of shame, remorse and guilt in his behaviour... . He demonstrated adequate victim empathy in taking responsibility for his actions, not blaming the victim and espousing the understanding of the negative impact his behaviours had not only on the victim but also their daughter and the victim’s family. . . . .Whilst there were indications of lowered self-esteem, guilt and remorse as well as periodic sadness and grief symptoms reactive to trauma/death, there were no indications that [the applicant] suffered from any diagnosable psychological or psychiatric conditions. While it was not clear whether [the applicant] would have met the diagnostic criteria for a paraphilic disorder such as paedophilic disorder at the time of the offending..., there were no indicia of paedophilia at the date of assessment.Actuarial risk assessment of static variables revealed that [the applicant’s] risk of similar sexualised offending was in the low range. More pertinently, actuarial risk of dynamic (current/changeable) risk factors were also in the low range. This indicated that there were no issues found at assessment with any dynamic risk factors shown in the relevant literature that correlate with a high risk of future sexual offending behaviour. As noted, it is not standard best-practice in forensic psychology to offer a definite and fixed opinion whether an individual will or will not actually offend. An opinion anchored in outcomes from the relevant literature on probability (Low to Very High) is seen as standard practice. In summary, it was my opinion based on the information gathered that [the applicant’s] risk of similar future sexualised offending behaviour (or indeed any general offending behaviours) was in the Low range. Conclusion I am satisfied that a period of 15 years has passed since the applicant was last sentenced in respect of a registrable offence, that he is not the subject of a lifelong reporting period under a corresponding law whilst in a foreign jurisdiction before becoming the subject of such a period in South Australia and that he is not on parole in respect of a registrable offence. Accordingly, I am satisfied that the threshold requirements under s37 of the Act have been made out, such that the applicant is entitled to apply to the Supreme Court for an order suspending his reporting obligations, otherwise applicable under the Act. My conclusions with respect to the matters that must be taken into account in accordance with s38(3) are as follows.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: NICHOLSON J