W, IB v Commissioner of Police

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Applications Under Various Acts or Rules: Criminal)

W, IB v COMMISSIONER OF POLICE

[2018] SASC 87

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Stanley

26 June 2018

CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCE - SENTENCING ORDERS - ORDERS AND DECLARATIONS RELATING TO SERIOUS OR VIOLENT OFFENDERS OR DANGEROUS SEXUAL OFFENDERS - DANGEROUS SEXUAL OFFENDER - REGISTRATION, REPORTING AND LIKE MATTERS

Application pursuant to s 37(2) of the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act 2006 (SA) (the Act) for an order suspending reporting obligations.

In 1990 the applicant pleaded guilty to three counts of unlawful sexual intercourse. The victim was a child within the meaning of the Act. As a result, the applicant is a registrable offender for the purposes of the Act and is subject to a range of reporting obligations. The applicant meets the threshold requirements of a registrable offender who is entitled to apply for such an order.

The primary issue arising on the application is whether this Court can be satisfied under s 38(2) that the applicant does not pose a risk to the safety and wellbeing of any child or children.

Held: Application granted.

Child Sex Offenders Registration Act 2006 (SA) s 3, s 6, s 37, s 38, referred to.
C, M v Commissioner of Police (2014) 121 SASR 106; K, MP v Commissioner of Police [2017] SASC 38, applied.

W, IB v COMMISSIONER OF POLICE
[2018] SASC 87

Criminal

STANLEY J:           

Introduction

  1. This is an application pursuant to s 37(2) of the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act 2006 (SA) (the Act) for an order that the applicant’s reporting obligations be suspended.

  2. In 1990 the applicant pleaded guilty in the District Court to three counts of unlawful sexual intercourse.  The circumstances of that offending were that on three occasions, over a three-week period, he digitally penetrated a 15 year old girl who resided in the house in which the applicant was boarding at the time.  He was convicted and sentenced to a term of imprisonment for two years, which was suspended on him entering a bond of $500 to be of good behaviour for three years.

  3. This offending is a registerable offence within the meaning of the Act. As a result, on 9 March 2016 the applicant was registered on the Australian National Child Offenders Register pursuant to s 6 of the Act. That subjects him to a range of reporting obligations.

    Reporting obligations

  4. Those reporting obligations are substantially prescribed in Division 2 of Part 3 of the Act.

  5. A registerable offender must report his personal details to the Commissioner of Police (Commissioner) annually.[1]  The personal details are prescribed in s 13(1) of the Act as follows:

    [1]    Section 15.

    (1)The details the registrable offender must report are as follows:

    (a)     his or her name, together with any other name by which he or she is, or has previously been, known;

    (b)     in respect of each name other than his or her current name, the period during which he or she was known…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read W, IB v Commissioner of Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] SASC 87
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, who was convicted of a registrable offence in 1990, applied for an order under section 38 of the Serious or Violent Offenders (Registration and Reporting) Act 2006 (SA) to suspend his reporting obligations. The Commissioner of Police neither supported nor opposed the application. The applicant's history includes significant trauma, including physical and emotional abuse by his adoptive mother, an attempted suicide at the age of 11, and severe physical injuries from industrial accidents. He has not sexually reoffended since 1990, and his criminal history mostly consists of driving and property offences from his youth. The court had to determine whether the applicant's reporting obligations should be suspended based on his low risk of reoffending, as supported by psychological evaluations.

The court considered whether the applicant posed a risk to the safety and wellbeing of any child or children, both presently and in the future. It was satisfied that the applicant does not pose such a risk, based on his lack of sexual reoffending for 28 years, his remorse, and the low sexual risk assessment by two forensic psychologists. The court also noted the applicant's breach of reporting obligations in 2018, but found it did not indicate a risk to children. Given these factors, the court concluded that the applicant met the threshold requirements and that suspending his reporting obligations would not compromise the Act's objective of protecting children from sexual predators.

The court exercised its discretion under section 38(1) of the Act and ordered the suspension of the applicant's reporting obligations as a registrable offender. The decision was based on the applicant's low risk of reoffending and the lack of evidence suggesting any risk to the safety and wellbeing of any child or children, both presently and in the future. The court was satisfied that the applicant does not pose a risk of reoffending, and the suspension of his reporting obligations would not undermine the Act's protective objectives.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

In this case the Commissioner neither supports nor opposes the application for an order suspending the applicant’s reporting obligations. Applicant’s background The applicant was raised by adoptive parents. He did not know his biological parents. He describes being physically and emotionally abused by his adoptive mother, particularly from the age of five when his twin sister drowned. He says his adoptive mother blamed him for her death. As a result, at the age of 11 he attempted suicide and suffered a severe electric shock resulting in burns to 82 per cent of his body, which has left him with severe scarring from his neck to his ankles. He spent nine months as an inpatient at the Adelaide Children’s Hospital. He required extensive skin grafts. He ran away from home and was sent to a reformatory on some six occasions. From the age of 14 until 18 he resided at a boys’ home. Thereafter, he was homeless for approximately nine months before obtaining employment. He is a hard worker who has done well and is financially secure. In adult life, however, he has not escaped further tragedy. In 1988, his de facto partner, and the mother of his second and third children, left him, taking the children with her. This was the background to his registrable offending. In 2008, his eldest daughter died from a drug overdose. In 2012, his wife of 22 years had a heart attack, fell into a bath and drowned. The applicant was devastated and became severely depressed. In addition, he has suffered severe physical injury. In 1980, the applicant nearly lost his right foot in an industrial accident. He suffers ongoing chronic pain in his right foot as a result. In 2004, he suffered an horrific industrial accident which resulted in a traumatic amputation of his penis and testicles, and a rupture of his femoral artery. He nearly died. He required major genital reconstructive surgery. This has caused significant sexual dysfunction. The applicant is now 60 years of age. He has been in a relationship for the last four years, with a Thai woman. She is a widow with two daughters aged 15 and 22. She is employed as a high school teacher in Thailand. The applicant’s past offending, apart from the registrable offence in 1990, mostly consists of driving offences and some property offences from his youth. However, he does have an earlier conviction for indecent assault which occurred when he was 14 years old. He gives a history of this involving consensual sexual contact with his 15 year old girlfriend.Previous breach of reporting obligations In 2018 the applicant was convicted of failing to comply with his reporting obligations. The conviction resulted from the applicant’s failure to report a change of address within the prescribed timeframe. The circumstances of this offence are explained in the affidavit of PO. PO has been a friend of the applicant for some 12 years. In 2013 he moved into a rural property situated at Mallala. He became a hobby farmer. In 2015, PO’s property was badly affected in the Pinery bushfire. Extensive damage was caused to the property.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The applicant explained that he overlooked the need to report his change of address. He was charged with a breach of his reporting obligations and pleaded guilty in the Adelaide Magistrates Court. He was convicted and a 12 month good behaviour bond in the sum of $200 was imposed.The psychological evidence The Court received reports from two consultant forensic psychologists, Richard Balfour and Luke Broomhall, who assessed the applicant. They considered various factors, including the applicant’s family, educational, occupational, recreational, interpersonal, developmental, medical, financial, legal, drug and alcohol, mental health and psychosexual development histories against the background of his offending. It is unnecessary to recite the detail of their reports. Mr Balfour interviewed the applicant in August 2016, and on 27 March 2018. He provided two reports dated 30 December 2016 and 28 March 2018. He obtained an extensive history from the applicant. In his first report, Mr Balfour concludes that the applicant possesses few of the traditional static and dynamic criminogenic risk factors that have been identified by researchers as predisposing an individual towards offending behaviour. Mr Balfour considers the applicant does not suffer from any major psychopathology. Since the age of 19 years, he has lived a largely lawful and productive life occupied by work and family commitments. He has been exposed to several traumatic events during his life. In relation to the registrable offence, Mr Balfour considers that the offending was opportunistic rather than highly premeditated and predatory. He observes that the applicant is very remorseful and has exhibited victim empathy. He has not sexually reoffended since 1990. On the contrary, he has re-established a lawful and productive life. Mr Balfour administered the RSVP, a widely-recognised international measure of sexual risk and recidivism in sex offenders. The applicant was assessed as having a low level of sexual risk. Mr Balfour considers that one of the best predictors of sexual offending behaviour is past behaviour. He describes the possibility of the applicant reoffending as being very low. In his first report, Mr Balfour considers that the applicant’s prognosis to continue to remain offence free is excellent. He forms his opinion on the basis of various factors, being: the fact that the applicant has not reoffended for the past 28 years; that he assesses the level of sexual risk the applicant poses to adolescent females as being in the lowest range possible; that the applicant has developed a low libido and suffers from sexual dysfunction; that the applicant does not suffer from any co‑morbid psychopathology that would predispose him to further offending; that he has a stable life; and that he is very remorseful and has developed his own psychological strategies to ensure he does not reoffend. In his more recent report, Mr Balfour adheres to the opinions he expressed in his earlier report, notwithstanding that, in the interim, the applicant breached his reporting obligations. Mr Balfour considered there was no evidence of any sinister intent in this breach. He continues to believe that the level of sexual risk and recidivism posed by the applicant is extremely low.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The jurisdictional fact in s 38(2) being satisfied, the issue is whether it is appropriate for this Court to exercise the discretion conferred by s 38(1) and order the suspension of the applicant’s reporting obligations. In my opinion, it is appropriate to do so. The same reasons that have led me to conclude that the applicant does not pose a risk to the safety and wellbeing of any child or children lead me to conclude that the discretion should be exercised suspending his reporting obligations. I am satisfied that the Act’s object of protecting children from sexual predators[11] will not be compromised by making the order sought.[11] Section 3.Conclusion I would allow the application. I am satisfied that the applicant does not pose a risk to the safety and wellbeing of any child or children at present and, on the evidence before me, I am satisfied that he poses no such future risk. I am satisfied that it is appropriate to exercise the discretion conferred on this Court by s 38(1) of the Act to suspend the applicant’s reporting obligations as a registrable offender. Pursuant to s 38, I order the suspension of the applicant’s reporting obligations.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The assessment of whether a registrable offender poses a risk to the safety and wellbeing of any child or children is not confined to an assessment of present risk, but also requires an assessment of any future risk he or she poses.[9] [9] C, M v Commissioner of Police [2014] SASC 163 at [17], (2014) 121 SASR 106 at 112; K, MP v Commissioner of Police [2017] SASC 38 at [18].Consideration The applicant submits that his reporting obligations should be suspended because it has been 28 years since he committed a registrable offence; he has not committed any further sexual offending in that period; his recent conviction for breach of his reporting obligations is not evidence that he poses a risk to the safety and wellbeing of any child or children; and, in fact, he does not pose such a risk, nor does he exhibit any paedophilic tendencies. I am satisfied that the applicant has met the threshold requirements prescribed in s 37(2) of the Act. Further, having regard to the provisions of s 38(3), I find that, while the registrable offences committed by the applicant in 1990 are serious offences, 28 years have elapsed since that offending and there has been no further sexual offending by the applicant in that time; the applicant has not been subject to a restraining order, nor a declaration under Part 2A or an order under s 15A of the Act; the applicant was 32 years of age at the time of the registrable offences and the victim of those offences was 15 years old; and the applicant is now 60 years of age. I have also had regard to the applicant’s total criminal record as described above. I rely upon the opinions and the reports of Mr Balfour and Mr Broomhall. They are relevant to the question of whether I am satisfied that the applicant does not pose a risk to the safety and wellbeing of any child or children. Any suggestion that the applicant poses any risk to the safety or wellbeing of a child or to children, at present or in the future, arises from the fact of his offending some 28 years ago. He does not satisfy the diagnostic criteria for paedophilia. His sexual orientation is not to children, whether pubescent or pre-pubescent. From 1990 to 2016, he was not the subject of any reporting obligations, and yet there is no evidence of any sexual offending of any kind during that period. There are a range of factors, identified by Mr Balfour, which evidence the unlikelihood of him offending against children in the future. I do not overlook the breach of his reporting obligations in 2017. However, I am satisfied that the circumstances of that offence do not evidence him posing a risk to the safety and wellbeing of any child or children. Both Mr Balfour and Mr Broomhall assessed the applicant’s risk of offending against a child in the future as low. Again, I note that, in forming that evaluation, Mr Broomhall considered that the actuarial assessment of his static risk factors indicate that his past offending behaviour place the applicant in the low-moderate range for future risk of similar offending. For reasons explained by each of the psychologists, they could not assess the applicant as posing no risk of reoffending. The constraint upon the psychologists in that regard does not apply to this Court, as was observed by Hinton J in K, MP v Commissioner of Police.[10][10] [2017] SASC 38 at [46].