SR v Commissioner of Police

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Criminal: Application)

SR v COMMISSIONER OF POLICE

[2020] SASC 195

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Nicholson

13 October 2020

CRIMINAL LAW - PARTICULAR OFFENCES - OFFENCES AGAINST THE PERSON - SEXUAL OFFENCES - INDECENT ASSAULT AND RELATED OFFENCES

CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCE - SENTENCING ORDERS - ORDERS AND DECLARATIONS RELATING TO SERIOUS OR VIOLENT OFFENDERS OR DANGEROUS SEXUAL OFFENDERS - DANGEROUS SEXUAL OFFENDER - REGISTRATION, REPORTING AND LIKE MATTERS

Application for reporting obligations under the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act 2006 (SA) to be suspended.

Held: application allowed.

Child Sex Offenders Registration Act 2006 (SA) s 15A, s 37, s 38; Summary Procedure Act 1921 (SA) s 99A, referred to.
C, M v Commissioner of Police [2014] SASC 163; H, DB v Commissioner of Police [2015] SASC 2, considered.

SR v COMMISSIONER OF POLICE
[2020] SASC 195

Criminal: Application

  1. NICHOLSON J:  These reasons concern an application for an order pursuant to s 37(2) of the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act 2006 (SA) (the Act) that the applicant’s reporting obligations imposed on him by that legislation be suspended.

    Introduction

  2. On 18 March 2000, the applicant was sentenced in the District Court with respect to 12 counts of unlawful sexual intercourse to a period of imprisonment for 19 months with a non-parole period of eight months.  This term of imprisonment was wholly suspended upon the applicant entering into a bond in the sum of $500 to be of good behaviour for a period of three years.

  3. The applicant qualifies as a “registrable offender” pursuant to the Act which came into operation on or about 18 October 2007.

  4. The applicant has provided his own sworn affidavit evidence, unchallenged by the respondent, in which he deposes to becoming registered on the Australian National Child Offender Register pursuant to s 6 and Schedule 1, Part 2 of the Act.  As such, he is subject to lifelong reporting obligations, subject to any successful application to have them suspended.  The applicant has further deposed to having consistently observed his annual reporting obligations.  The respondent, the Commissioner of Police, has had an opportunity to enquire into the applicant’s compliance with the registration and reporting requirements imposed by the Act.  There has been no suggestion that the applicant has done anything other than fully comply with his obligations.

  5. This Court has the power, pursuant to s 38(1) of the Act, to make an order suspending the reporting obligations of certain registrable offenders that would otherwise be imposed by the Act. That power is enlivened upon an application being made to this Court by a registrable offender pursuant to s 37(2).

  6. By application filed on 24 September 2020, the applicant has sought an order suspending his reporting obligations.  In support of his application, the applicant relies on his own affidavit, sworn 11 September 2020, to which is exhibited, inter alia:

    (i)the sentencing remarks of his Honour Judge Herriman dated 29 March 2000;

    (ii)a clinical psychological report by Mr Allen Fugler dated 16…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SR v Commissioner of Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] SASC 195
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Supreme Court of South Australia, SR applied for an order to suspend his obligations under the Dangerous Sexual Offenders (Registration and Reporting) Act 2004 (SA). The applicant, SR, had previously pleaded guilty to multiple counts of unlawful sexual intercourse with a student in 1999 and was sentenced to a suspended prison sentence. The court was required to determine whether SR met the criteria for an order to suspend his reporting obligations under the Act. Specifically, the court needed to assess whether SR had lived offence-free for 15 years, if he was not under a lifelong reporting period in another jurisdiction, and if he was not on parole for a registrable offence. Additionally, the court had to evaluate whether SR posed a risk to the safety and wellbeing of any child or children.

The court considered the opinion of Mr Broomhall, a forensic psychologist, who assessed SR’s risk of reoffending. Mr Broomhall concluded that SR’s risk of future sexualised offending behaviour was in the "very low" range, based on actuarial estimates, literature on the length of time living offence-free, and analysis of dynamic forensic psychological risk factors. The court accepted Mr Broomhall's opinion, noting that it was not scientifically possible to accurately predict future reoffending. The court also took into account SR's personal history, including his successful lifestyle, marriage, and family life, as well as the positive observations of those who regularly interact with SR and his children. Given these factors, the court found that SR did not pose a risk to the safety and wellbeing of any child or children.

The court found that SR met the threshold requirements under section 37 of the Act, entitling him to apply for an order to suspend his reporting obligations. The court accepted the forensic psychologist's assessment that SR's risk of reoffending was very low and found no evidence that SR posed a risk to children. Consequently, the court granted the application, suspending SR's reporting obligations under the Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

On the evidence which is not disputed, (i), (ii), and (iii) above have been satisfied. The remaining question of substance is whether the applicant poses the relevant risk as provided for under s 38(2). Before embarking upon that enquiry, it is necessary to canvass in brief the circumstances of the applicant’s offending, the applicant’s personal history and the opinion of Mr Broomhall. The facts The applicant pleaded guilty to 12 counts of unlawful sexual intercourse which took place between June and August 1999. The applicant was a school teacher and was 24 years of age and the victim, who was 16 and a half, was one of his students. The circumstances of the offending are set out in detail in Judge Herriman’s remarks. The following bare summary is sufficient for present circumstances. The applicant and the young girl shared common interests and started to spend time together. After a time an intimate sexual relationship developed. They behaved towards each other and, at times, presented to other persons, as boyfriend and girlfriend who thought they loved each other. The association between the two was well known to the young girl’s parents and to the school principal. It was not discouraged, indeed to the contrary, it was openly encouraged. However, neither the young girl’s family nor the principal appreciated the extent of the risk or indeed the eventuation of the risk, of a sexual relationship developing. Judge Herriman recounted a significant number of mitigatory and aggravating features of the offending, not necessary to detail here. It should be noted that, as would be expected, the appellant has experienced quite disadvantageous extra curial consequences as a result of the offending, in addition to the suspended prison sentence penalty. The psychological report prepared at the time by Mr Fugler was comprehensive. The applicant was described as then having an immature, naïve and inadequate personality and a person who abused his position of responsibility. As a result of counselling then being received by the applicant, the fact that the applicant thought he was in love, the existence of his basic Christian principles and the salutary experience of his contact with the criminal justice system, Mr Fugler expressed the opinion that “it would be surprising if a repeat of any offending behaviour occurred”. This prognostication has proved accurate over the last 20 years or so. Since the offending, the applicant enjoyed a relatively successful and unremarkable lifestyle. Having lost his teaching registration in 1999, he had to rethink his career options. He, in time, entered the landscaping field. He is now 45 years old, he married his present wife some years ago and they have two young children. The applicant and his family recently moved to Queensland where the applicant is now undertaking higher education studies. He has no criminal record apart from the offending in 1999. Both KC and EB who are aware of the applicant’s past and who regularly engage with him in family activities involving young children, describe him as a caring, hardworking and genuine person. They have no concerns arising from their knowledge of his interactions with children, including his own.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Broomhall reached these conclusions.In my opinion it needs to be clearly stated that it is not scientifically possible to accurately predict whether or not an individual will or will not actually reoffend in the future. Therefore it is not possible to conclude categorically whether an individual is or is not a risk to the safety of children. The best which can be offered, consistent with professional opinion and literature in this area, is an estimate from “very low” to “very high” ranges which is anchored to empirical literature specifying features associated with risk along with sound clinical and forensic analysis and formulation of how these features might operate in the individual subject to the assessment. The risk assessment process is necessarily multi-faceted, combining in general terms the use of actuarial approaches and an assessment of the relative presence or absence of individual dynamic (changeable) risk factors which contribute to the pattern of sexual offending behaviour.On the basis of the current assessment methodology including actuarial estimates, literature surrounding length of time living offence free in the community and analysis of dynamic forensic psychological risk factors, it was my opinion that [the applicant’s] risk of future sexualised offending behaviour was in the “very low” range: the lowest risk range possible. In my view there were no recommendations to be made relating to improving [the applicant’s] mental health or psychological status nor were there recommendations which would further reduce [the applicant’s] risk of future inappropriate sexualised or offending behaviours.Conclusion I am satisfied that a period of 15 years has passed since the applicant was last sentenced in respect of a registrable offence, that he is not the subject of a lifelong reporting period under a corresponding law whilst in a foreign jurisdiction before becoming the subject of such a period in South Australia and that he is not on parole in respect of a registrable offence. It follows that I am satisfied that the threshold requirements under s 37 of the Act have been made out, such that the applicant is entitled to apply to the Supreme Court for an order suspending his reporting obligations, otherwise applicable under the Act. Having recently conducted a forensic psychological assessment of the applicant, Mr Broomhall has formed the view that the applicant’s risk of similar sexualised offending behaviour in the future is in the very low range. Mr Broomhall has indicated that, in accordance with the standard best-practice protocols in forensic psychology to which he adhered at the time of writing, it was not appropriate to offer an absolute opinion regarding whether an individual will or will not actually reoffend. I accept the opinion expressed by Mr Broomhall with that qualification. Furthermore, the nature of the applicant’s sexual offending and the circumstances in which it occurred, in addition to the applicant’s behavioural history for the more than 20 years that have since passed, fully support this opinion. As far as s 38(2) is concerned, I am satisfied that the applicant does not pose a risk to the safety and wellbeing of any child or children.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established