H, DB v Commissioner of Police

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Criminal: Application)

H, DB v COMMISSIONER OF POLICE

[2015] SASC 2

Reasons for Decision of The Honourable Justice Nicholson

22 January 2015

CRIMINAL LAW - PARTICULAR OFFENCES - OFFENCES AGAINST THE PERSON - SEXUAL OFFENCES - INCEST

CRIMINAL LAW - PARTICULAR OFFENCES - OFFENCES AGAINST THE PERSON - SEXUAL OFFENCES - INDECENT ASSAULT AND RELATED OFFENCES

CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCE - SENTENCING ORDERS - ORDERS AND DECLARATIONS RELATING TO SERIOUS OR VIOLENT OFFENDERS OR DANGEROUS SEXUAL OFFENDERS - DANGEROUS SEXUAL OFFENDER - REGISTRATION, REPORTING AND LIKE MATTERS

In 1993 the applicant pleaded guilty to the offences of unlawful sexual intercourse with a person aged 15 years and indecent assault of a person aged 16 years. The victim of both offences, which occurred in 1988 and 1989 respectively, was the applicant’s biological daughter. The applicant was convicted on both counts and sentenced to two years and six months imprisonment with a non-parole period of one year and six months. This sentence was suspended upon the applicant entering into a bond to be of good behaviour for a period of three years.

The applicant qualifies as a registrable offender for the purposes of the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act 2007 (SA), and is thereby required to meet certain reporting obligations. The applicant now applies to this Court, pursuant to s37(2) of the Act, for an order suspending those reporting obligations. The applicant meets the threshold requirements of a registrable offender who is entitled to apply for such an order. The primary issue arising on the application is whether this Court can be satisfied, under s38(2), that the applicant does not pose a risk to the safety and wellbeing of any child or children.

Held: application allowed.

Child Sex Offenders Registration Act 2006 (SA) s15A, s37, s38; Summary Procedure Act 1921 s99A, referred to.
C, M v Commissioner of Police [2014] SASC 163; Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336, considered.

H, DB v COMMISSIONER OF POLICE
[2015] SASC 2

Criminal:  Child Sex Offenders Registration Act 2006 (SA)

NICHOLSON J.   

  1. These reasons concern an application for an order pursuant to s37(2) of the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act 2006 (SA) that the applicant’s reporting obligations imposed on him by that legislation be suspended.

    Introduction

  2. On 27 October 1993, the applicant pleaded guilty in the District Court to one count of unlawful sexual intercourse with a person of the age of 15 years and one count of indecent assault of a person aged 16 years.  The victim in relation to both counts was the applicant’s biological daughter.  The applicant was convicted on both counts and sentenced to a period of two years and six months imprisonment with a non-parole period of one year and six months.  This term of imprisonment was suspended upon the applicant entering into a bond in the sum of $500 to be of good behaviour for a period of three years.

  3. The applicant qualifies as a “registrable offender” pursuant to the Child Sex…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read H, DB v Commissioner of Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] SASC 2
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of H, DB v Commissioner of Police, the applicant sought to have his obligations under the Dangerous Sexual Offenders (Registration) Act 2009 (SA) suspended. The applicant had previously been convicted of sexual offences involving his daughter and was required to register as a sexual offender and comply with various reporting obligations. The applicant contended that he had been rehabilitated and posed a low risk of reoffending, warranting a suspension of his reporting obligations. The court had to determine whether the applicant met the threshold requirements for making such an application and, if so, whether the applicant posed a low risk of reoffending, thereby warranting a suspension of his reporting obligations.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the applicant had satisfied the threshold requirements to apply for a suspension of his reporting obligations under s37 of the Act, and whether he posed a low risk of reoffending, warranting such a suspension under s38(2). The applicant argued that he had satisfied the threshold requirements and that he posed a low risk of reoffending. The Commissioner of Police opposed the application, contending that the applicant did not pose a low risk of reoffending. The court had to assess the evidence and determine whether the applicant had met the statutory criteria.

The court considered the evidence and the report of the forensic psychologist, Mr Broomhall, who concluded that the applicant posed a low risk of reoffending. The court found that the applicant had satisfied the threshold requirements under s37 of the Act, as a period of 15 years had passed since his last sentencing for a registrable offence, and he was not subject to a lifelong reporting period in a foreign jurisdiction before becoming subject to such a period in South Australia. The court further found that the applicant posed a low risk of reoffending, based on the evidence and the psychologist’s report, which indicated appropriate victim empathy, genuine remorse, and no indications of sexual deviance or hyper-sexualised behaviour. The court concluded that the applicant was entitled to apply to the Supreme Court for an order suspending his reporting obligations under the Act.

The court ordered that the applicant was entitled to apply to the Supreme Court for an order suspending his reporting obligations, otherwise applicable under the Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

On the evidence which is not disputed, (i), (ii), and (iii) above have been satisfied. The remaining question of substance is whether the applicant poses the relevant risk as provided for under s38(2). Before embarking upon that enquiry, it is necessary to canvass in a little detail the circumstances of the applicant’s offending, the applicant’s personal history and current circumstances and the opinion of Mr Broomhall. The facts At the time of the offending, the applicant had recently separated from the victim’s mother. Their relationship had subsisted for over 15 years and resulted in three children, including the victim. Following the separation, the victim and her two siblings, a younger brother and sister, were residing with their mother in Strathalbyn. The applicant would see his children each weekend, either by visiting them at Strathalbyn or having them stay with him at a flat he was renting in Adelaide. The offence of unlawful sexual intercourse occurred in late 1988 on a weekend when the victim was staying with the applicant. Both the applicant and the victim had consumed a considerable amount of alcohol and had smoked some cannabis. The offending involved the applicant performing oral sex on the victim. By his own admission, the applicant had actively, though not by force, procured the victim’s compliance with this conduct. The offence of indecent assault occurred approximately 12 months later. By this time the victim was living with the applicant on a full time basis. The offending involved the applicant touching the victim in the area of the vagina while massaging her. The victim moved out of the applicant’s home shortly after this incident, and it was at this time that she first informed police of the applicant’s offending. At the time she did not seek to press charges and no further action was taken. The victim has been estranged from the applicant ever since. The victim’s mother was informed of the applicant’s offending not long after. She was, as is to be expected, upset and angry and she confronted the applicant about his conduct. The applicant agreed not to make contact with either the victim or her mother and commenced a period of counselling. That counselling continued for about a year until the applicant moved to Mount Gambier in December 1990. The applicant continued to maintain a relationship with his two other children and his son came to live with him at around this time. The applicant’s two daughters moved with their mother to live in Melbourne. The applicant was eventually charged in May 1993 on the instigation of the victim who, after a period of counselling, had come to the view that the applicant should be punished for what he had done. Two further charges relating to conduct alleged to have occurred in the period between 1987 and 1989 and also allegedly involving unlawful sexual intercourse and indecent assault against the victim, did not proceed upon the applicant pleading guilty to the abovementioned offences.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

NICHOLSON J
A report by the forensic psychologist Mr Broomhall, dated 23 October 2014, was obtained by the solicitors for the applicant in support of the application. That report specifically addresses the issue of recidivism. I have read and considered this report which is detailed and appears to be comprehensive. For present purposes, it is sufficient to note the following extract summarising Mr Broomhall’s opinion. [The applicant] had engaged in therapeutic treatment with a psychologist well regarded in the field of sexual behaviour therapy. Even at the date of assessment, there were indications from language used by [the applicant] in this regard that some of the learnings from this therapeutic interaction continued to resonate with him. In my opinion there were indications of a genuine level of remorse, shame and guilt regarding his offending behaviour. [The applicant] displayed appropriate victim empathy and did not seek to blame his daughter for the inappropriate sexualised behaviour which occurred.In the time since the offending behaviour, charges and conviction, [the applicant] has maintained long term romantic relations with appropriate sexual intimacy boundaries. There were no indications of sexual deviance or hyper-sexualised behaviour. There were no indications of deviant sexual arousal. [The applicant] had maintained financial obligations towards his children and worked hard to build a successful business. He had maintained contact with his daughter from a previous relationship, as well as his two youngest children.Whilst [the applicant] presented in the current assessment with mild symptoms of depression and anxiety, these would not be considered unusual, in my opinion, given the current court-related matters and assessment process. These were not indicative of a diagnosable psychological or psychiatric condition, in my view. [The applicant] continued to express guilt, shame and remorse in regards to his offending behaviour and could not bring himself to tell his current partner, which may be detrimental to their future relationship. Actuarial assessment of [the applicant’s] static risk of similar offending behaviour was in the low range. More pertinently, actuarial risk of dynamic (current/changeable) risk factors was also in the low range. This indicated that there were no issues found at assessment with any dynamic risk variables, shown as being relevant from research and literature to correlate with high risk of future sexualised offending behaviour. In summary, it was my opinion based on the information gathered at assessment, that [the applicant’s] risk of similar future sexualised offending behaviour was in the low range. As noted, it is not standard best practice in forensic psychology to offer a definite and fixed opinion regarding whether an individual will or will not actually offend. An opinion anchored in outcomes from the relevant literature on probability (low to very high) is seen as standard best practice. Conclusion I am satisfied that a period of 15 years has passed since the applicant was last sentenced in respect of a registrable offence, that he is not the subject of a lifelong reporting period under a corresponding law whilst in a foreign jurisdiction before becoming the subject of such a period in South Australia and that he is not on parole in respect of a registrable offence. It follows that I am satisfied that the threshold requirements under s37 of the Act have been made out, such that the applicant is entitled to apply to the Supreme Court for an order suspending his reporting obligations, otherwise applicable under the Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: NICHOLSON J