A, C v Commissioner of Police

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Criminal: Application)

A, C v COMMISSIONER OF POLICE

[2021] SASC 139

Judgment of the Honourable Justice Stein  

3 December 2021

CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCE - SENTENCING ORDERS - ORDERS AND DECLARATIONS RELATING TO SERIOUS OR VIOLENT OFFENDERS OR DANGEROUS SEXUAL OFFENDERS - DANGEROUS SEXUAL OFFENDER - REGISTRATION, REPORTING AND LIKE MATTERS

On 18 April 1994, the applicant, then aged 20 years old, pleaded guilty to two counts of unlawful sexual intercourse with two victims, one who was 15 years old and the other who was 16 years old. The applicant was sentenced to three years imprisonment with a non-parole period of 12 months for the offending.

In 2007, the applicant became subject to reporting obligations due to the commencement of the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act 2006 (SA) (“the Act”).

The applicant is eligible to seek an order pursuant to s 37(2) of the Act suspending the applicant’s reporting obligations. The Court may make such order pursuant to s 38(1) if it is satisfied under s 38(2) the offender does not pose a risk to the safety and wellbeing of any child or children, taking into account the matters prescribed in s 38(3) of the Act.

Held: Application granted.

Child Sex Offenders Registration Act 2006 (SA) s 37 and s 38; Summary Procedure Act 1921 (SA) s 99AA, s 15A and Part 2A, referred to.
Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336; C, M v Commissioner of Police (2014) 121 SASR 106, applied.

A, C v COMMISSIONER OF POLICE
[2021] SASC 139

  1. The applicant seeks an order pursuant to s 37(2) and s 38 of the Child Sex Offenders Registration Act 2006 (SA) (“the Act”) suspending the applicant’s reporting obligations pursuant to the Act.

    Background

  2. On 18 April 1994, the applicant pleaded guilty to two counts of unlawful sexual intercourse with two victims, one who was 15 years old and the other who was 16 years old (“offending”). The applicant was sentenced to three years imprisonment with a non-parole period of 12 months for the offending.

  3. The Act came into operation in 2007. The applicant was characterised as a registerable offender for the purposes of the Act and was therefore required to comply with the reporting obligations contained in the Act.

  4. The Supreme Court has power pursuant to s 38(1) of the Act to make an order suspending a registerable offender’s reporting obligations.

  5. On 29 October 2021, the applicant filed an application pursuant to s 37(2) and s 38 of the Act seeking an order suspending the applicant’s reporting obligations pursuant to the Act. The application is supported by an affidavit of the applicant. The affidavit exhibits a number of documents including a detailed report of Mr Luke Broomhall, registered psychologist.

  6. The respondent, the Commissioner of Police, has indicated that the application is not opposed. Counsel confirmed the jurisdictional pre-conditions in s 37(2) to the making of an order are met.

    The Act

  7. Sections 37 and 38 of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read A, C v Commissioner of Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] SASC 139
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of A, C v Commissioner of Police, the applicant, a man who committed an offence in 1993 when he was 20 years old, sought to be removed from his reporting obligations as a dangerous sexual offender. The applicant had engaged in sexual activity with two intoxicated victims, one of whom was close to 17 years old. The applicant took advantage of the victims, but he pleaded guilty, expressed contrition, and the victims did not have to testify. The applicant has not re-offended in the nearly 29 years since the offence. He has a stable family life, has completed an apprenticeship, and has successfully run various businesses, including one that requires overseas travel. The applicant's registration as a dangerous sexual offender has caused him difficulties when travelling.

The court was required to determine whether the applicant's reporting obligations should be suspended under the relevant legislation. The court followed a three-stage process, beginning with a consideration of the threshold requirements in section 37(2) of the Act. The court found that the applicant met the criteria and was entitled to make the application. The second stage involved consideration of the matters set out in section 38(3) of the Act, including the seriousness of the offence, the applicant's age at the time, his contrition, and the lack of any further offences. The court accepted the opinion of an expert who assessed the applicant's risk of future sexualised offending as very low. The third stage required the court to exercise its discretion, which it did in favour of the applicant.

The court concluded that the applicant did not pose a risk to the safety and wellbeing of any child or children. The court granted the applicant's application, ordering the suspension of his reporting obligations pursuant to the Act.

ORDERS:
The application was granted, and the applicant's reporting obligations as a dangerous sexual offender were suspended.

Orders

Orders of the court

Held: Application granted.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant has a partner and numerous adult children and grandchildren. Background Facts The applicant committed the offending in 1993. At the time of the offending he was 20 years old. The circumstances of the offending were that the applicant and victims were known to each other. On the occasion in question, the victims visited the applicant’s home and arrived intoxicated. The applicant had intercourse with both victims. He did not know the age of one victim and knew the other was close to 17 years old. The sentencing Judge noted that the applicant took advantage of the victims, but that the applicant was contrite, regretted his actions and pleaded guilty so the victims did not have to give evidence. A co-offender was discharged without conviction. Approximately 29 years has passed since the date of the offence in July 1993. The applicant has not re-offended and does not have any record, either prior to or since the offending, of being charged with any other sexual offence. Prior to the offending, the applicant had been in a relationship and he has two children from that relationship. The applicant also has two children with his ex-wife, with whom he had a relationship for about 17 years. The applicant has six grandchildren. He is close to his children and grandchildren. He deposed to his children and grandchildren visiting and staying with him and his current partner frequently. The applicant completed an apprenticeship and worked as a locksmith for a period of time. Following incarceration and upon his release, the applicant could not work as a locksmith as he needed a security clearance. After working as a courier and then in real estate, he bought a café and then a restaurant and worked successfully in those businesses before buying and running a farm. The applicant’s affidavit deposes to the applicant having set up a business including assisting with sales of products overseas. The applicant’s business interests are said to necessitate him travelling. He deposed to travelling to Hong Kong in 2019 for which travel he obtained all the necessary approvals in advance. The applicant deposed to being subject to lengthy questioning at both Hong Kong airport and upon return to Australia in Sydney as a consequence of his registration. He seeks removal from his reporting obligations to enable him to travel and pursue his business interests overseas. Consideration The first of the three stage process referred to by Nicholson J in C, M v Commissioner of Police[8] is consideration of the threshold requirements in s 37(2) of the Act. I am satisfied that the period of time since the offending is nearly 29 years, that the applicant is not on parole in respect of a registrable offence and that he is not the subject of lifelong reporting under a corresponding law while in a foreign jurisdiction before becoming the subject of such a period in South Australia. I am therefore satisfied that the applicant is entitled to make the application pursuant to s 37(2) of the Act.[8] (2014) 121 SASR 106 at [12].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On the basis of current assessment methodology, Mr Broomhall concludes that the applicant’s risk of future sexualised offending is in the very low range, the lowest risk range possible. In his opinion there are no recommendations to be made relating to further decreasing the applicant’s forensic risk profile nor recommendations related to improving his mental health or psychological presentation. Conclusion The third stage of the three stage process is for me to determine whether to exercise the discretion. I have determined to do so. I accept the opinion of Mr Broomhall. Given the matters taken into account by Mr Broomhall and considering the applicant’s age, the length of time since the offending, the lack of any further sexual offending and the matters referred to by the sentencing judge in relation to the offending, I am satisfied that the applicant does not pose a risk to the safety and wellbeing of any child or children. I have reached that conclusion on the balance of probabilities, acting with caution.[9][9] Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336. I therefore order the suspension of the applicant’s reporting obligations pursuant to the Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The applicant completed an apprenticeship and worked as a locksmith for a period of time. Following incarceration and upon his release, the applicant could not work as a locksmith as he needed a security clearance. After working as a courier and then in real estate, he bought a café and then a restaurant and worked successfully in those businesses before buying and running a farm. The applicant’s affidavit deposes to the applicant having set up a business including assisting with sales of products overseas. The applicant’s business interests are said to necessitate him travelling. He deposed to travelling to Hong Kong in 2019 for which travel he obtained all the necessary approvals in advance. The applicant deposed to being subject to lengthy questioning at both Hong Kong airport and upon return to Australia in Sydney as a consequence of his registration. He seeks removal from his reporting obligations to enable him to travel and pursue his business interests overseas. Consideration The first of the three stage process referred to by Nicholson J in C, M v Commissioner of Police[8] is consideration of the threshold requirements in s 37(2) of the Act. I am satisfied that the period of time since the offending is nearly 29 years, that the applicant is not on parole in respect of a registrable offence and that he is not the subject of lifelong reporting under a corresponding law while in a foreign jurisdiction before becoming the subject of such a period in South Australia. I am therefore satisfied that the applicant is entitled to make the application pursuant to s 37(2) of the Act.[8] (2014) 121 SASR 106 at [12]. The second stage requires consideration of the matters set out in s 38(3) of the Act. I set out below my consideration of those matters. The offences were serious. However, the applicant pleaded guilty and did not require the victims to give evidence. He was found to be contrite by the sentencing judge. The applicant submitted that the offences were committed by him when he was young, far less mature and constituted an error of judgment by an immature person. Importantly, the applicant has not committed any further offences of a sexual nature. Mr Broomhall concluded from his assessment of the applicant that, in his opinion, it was most likely that the offending was an example of a young man in a state of intoxication taking opportunistic advantage in a sexual way with the victims. Mr Broomhall said there were no indications of paedophilic sexual interests, low empathy or victim blaming characteristics. Mr Broomhall stated the applicant presented as being cognisant of the wrongfulness of his behaviours and sympathetic to the impact on the victims. There were no indications the applicant attempted to externalise responsibility for the actions nor blame the victims. The period of time since the offending is substantial. During that time, the applicant has not committed any further offences which would give rise to concerns about potential risk to the safety and wellbeing of children.