BYMD and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

Applicant:BYMD

Respondent:  Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Tribunal Number:                2021/4437

Tribunal:Senior Member A. Nikolic  

Place:Melbourne

Date:4 November 2024  

Decision:The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

..............[SGD]..........................................................

Senior Member A. Nikolic

Catchwords
MIGRATION – mandatory visa cancellation – citizen of Ethiopia – where Applicant granted Class BA (Subclass 200) Refugee visa –  failure to pass good character test – substantial criminal record since 2005 including rape and other sexual and violent offending – formal warning from Department – Applicant committed further sexual and violent offences –  mandatory visa cancellation – non-revocation decision – matter twice remitted by Federal Court of Australia – whether another reason to revoke the mandatory cancellation of Applicant’s visa – Ministerial Direction no. 110 applied – decision affirmed

Legislation
Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 (Cth)
Migration Act 1958 (Cth)
Migration Amendment (Clarifying International Obligations for Removal) Act 2021 (Cth)
Migration and Maritime Powers Legislation Amendment (Resolving the Asylum Legacy Caseload) Act 2014 (Cth)
Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth)
Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic)
Sex Offenders Registration Act 2004 (Vic)

Cases
Ali v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 650
Assistant Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Splendido (2019) 271 FCR 595
Ayoub v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2015) 231 FCR 513
Bettencourt v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs (2021) 287 FCR 294
BDQ19 v Minister for Home Affairs (2019) 167 ALD 38
BFMV v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FCAFC 199
BHL19 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2020] FCAFC 94
Bowden v The Queen (2013) 44 VR 229
Brown v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2009] 112 ALD 67
Brown v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2010] 183 FCR 113
CGX20 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs (2021) 284 FCR 416
CRNL v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2023] FCAFC 138
CTK17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2020] FCA 1211
CVN17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2019) 163 ALD 101
DLZZ and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2023] AATA 3922
DOB18 v Minister for Home Affairs [2018] FCA 1523
DQM18 v Minister for Home Affairs (2020) 278 FCR 529
Falzon v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2018) 262 CLR 333
Frugtniet v Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2019) 266 CLR 250
FYBR v Minister for Home Affairs (2019) 272 FCR 454
FYBR v Minister for Home Affairs and Anor [2020] HCA Trans 056
Hughes v The Queen (2017) 263 CLR 338
HZCP v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 1803
Ibrahim v Minister for Home Affairs (2019) 270 FCR 12
Ismail v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2024] HCA 2
Jagroop v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2016) 241 FCR 461
James v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCA 410
Leota v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs 

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BYMD and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] ARTA 16
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) involved the applicant, a citizen of Ethiopia, who had been granted a Class BA (Subclass 200) Refugee visa in Australia. The dispute centred on the mandatory cancellation of the applicant's visa due to his substantial criminal record, which included multiple convictions for serious sexual and violent offences. The central legal issues were whether the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs was correct in affirming the decision to cancel the applicant's visa and whether there were any additional reasons to revoke this cancellation.

The Tribunal examined the statutory framework, particularly sections 501(3A), 501(6), and 501(7) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth), which mandate visa cancellation for individuals with a substantial criminal record serving a term of imprisonment. The Tribunal also considered the Ministerial Direction no. 110, which provides guidance on the application of these provisions. The applicant had a significant history of criminal activity dating back to 2005, with convictions for rape, sexual assault, and other violent crimes. Despite receiving a formal warning from the Department in 2013, the applicant reoffended, leading to the visa cancellation decision.

The Tribunal assessed the evidence, including the applicant's criminal history, his mental health diagnosis of schizoaffective disorder in 2020, and his participation in various rehabilitation activities in detention. The Tribunal noted the applicant's claims of remorse and his engagement in rehabilitation efforts, but also highlighted the severity and persistence of his criminal behaviour. The Tribunal concluded that the Minister's decision to affirm the visa cancellation was supported by the evidence and that there were no additional grounds to revoke the cancellation. The Tribunal's reasoning focused on the mandatory nature of the visa cancellation provisions and the applicant's extensive criminal record.

The Tribunal ultimately affirmed the Minister's decision, finding that the mandatory visa cancellation was justified under the Migration Act and that there were no additional reasons to revoke the cancellation. The Tribunal's decision was based on the legislative framework and the substantial criminal record of the applicant, which met the criteria for visa cancellation.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the following reasons the Tribunal affirms the reviewable decision BACKGROUND The Applicant is a 42-year-old citizen of Ethiopia and a Christian of the Oromo ethnic group.[1] He arrived in Australia in November 2000 at the age of 18.[2][1] Exhibit R1, 1357.[2] Ibid 310. The Applicant has an extensive criminal history since 2005.[3] His offending includes convictions for two counts of rape, sexual assault, multiple counts of indecent assault, recklessly causing injury to a former female partner, several counts of resisting police, criminal damage, carrying a prohibited weapon,[4] repeated breaches of conditional liberty,[5] and crimes involving dishonesty. He has also committed several driving offences, including by exceeding the prescribed alcohol limit, driving in a careless manner, driving while disqualified, and driving over the speed limit.[6] [3] Ibid 73-5.[4] Ibid 367.[5] Ibid 337, 357.[6] Ibid 420. The Applicant was convicted for his most serious crimes in 2010, which included two counts of rape and five counts of indecent assault. He received a cumulative sentence of five years and seven months imprisonment, with a non-parole period of three years and eight months.[7] The Applicant sought leave to appeal his convictions[8] but this was dismissed by the Court of Appeal.[9] [7] Ibid 74.[8] Ibid 476.[9] Ibid 412-14. On 10 September 2012, the Applicant was served with a notice of intention to cancel his visa.[10] On 16 July 2013 he was advised that his visa would not be cancelled, but that a formal warning would instead be issued as follows:[11]‘Please note that visa cancellation may be reconsidered if you commit further offences or otherwise breach the character test in future. Disregard of this warning will weigh heavily against you if your case is reconsidered’.(Emphasis in original.)[10] Ibid 220-5.[11] Ibid 226-8. The Applicant reoffended after being released from prison for the rape and indecent assault offences. In 2020 he was convicted for sexual assault and two counts of contravening bail. He received a sentence of 12 months imprisonment and was placed on the Sex Offenders Register for life.[12] The latter requires him to comply with certain reporting obligations under the Sex Offenders Registration Act 2004 (Vic). [12] Ibid 483, 487. In early 2020 the Applicant was diagnosed with schizoaffective disorder.[13] In the same year he also tested positive for the Human Immunodeficiency Virus (“HIV”).[14][13] Ibid 751.[14] Ibid 1072.Procedural history This application has an extensive procedural history and is being heard by the Tribunal for a third time. On 10 September 2020, while the Applicant was serving a sentence of imprisonment for the sexual assault and breach of bail offences, the Respondent cancelled his visa under the mandatory cancellation provision at s 501(3A) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”).[15] The Applicant was invited to make representations to have the cancellation decision revoked and did so within the permissible period and in the manner specified.[15] Ibid 211; Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (‘The Act’).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The following documents were tendered into evidence:(a)Remittal bundle numbering 1411 pages;[32](b)Additional remittal bundle numbering 144 pages;[33](c)Six-page statement of the Applicant dated 5 July 2024;[34](d)2023 Country Reports on Human Rights Practices: Ethiopia, from the United States Department of State;[35](e)Human Rights World Report 2024: Events of 2023, in which the section on Ethiopia is at pp 215-223;[36] and(f)DFAT Country Information Report Ethiopia dated 12 August 2020.[37][32] Exhibit R1.[33] Exhibit R2.[34] Exhibit A1.[35] Exhibit A2.[36] Exhibit A3.[37] Exhibit A4.Applicant’s evidence At the commencement of his evidence the Applicant adopted a statement dated 5 July 2024 as true and correct. He referred to unnamed ‘inmates’ who assisted him with this. The Applicant’s oral testimony is now summarised.Life prior to arrival in Australia The Applicant said he travelled to Addis Ababa, the capital of Ethiopia, at the age of 15 and lived there for 18 months or two years while ‘waiting for approval to go to Kenya’. After living in a refugee camp for ‘one year and eight months’, he claimed to have been provided with a travel document issued by the ‘Kenyan Embassy’ to refugees. He recalled that his sister and brother-in-law sponsored his migration to Australia. The Applicant was asked about different histories about his early life taken a decade apart by forensic psychiatrists Dr Ryan and Dr McInerney: The Applicant said that aspects of the history taken by Dr Ryan were ‘totally wrong’ and claimed he must have been ‘out of his mind’ when making them. Life in Australia After arriving in Australia, the Applicant said he studied English for about six months and later worked as a forklift driver for about two-and-a-half years and a machine operator for about two years. He also claimed to have undertaken carpentry and hospitality courses at TAFE. There is no corroborating evidence for his work claims or past vocational training.Offending The Applicant agreed that the criminal history in evidence accurately summarises his past offending.[40] He initially claimed in both documentary[41] and oral evidence that he could not recall the particulars of his crimes because he was ‘under the influence of drugs and alcohol’ and his memory is ‘not that good’ because of prolonged substance abuse. When asked by Mr Duldig during cross-examination whether he remembers any of his offending, the Applicant responded: ‘No I don’t’. He claimed that his memory problems commenced in 2003 and he now has a poor recollection of events from even a year ago. During his oral testimony, however, the Applicant was able to recall that his life circumstances in 2007 were contextualised by ‘family problems, stress, anxiety, and depression’. He was also able to recall the precise length of his sentences for sex offending in 2010 and 2020, when he was diagnosed with HIV and schizoaffective disorder, some of the brand names of the medications he takes, frequency of consultations with mental health experts, and other specific details of his past. When challenged that his claimed inability to recall crimes did not appear to extend to other issues, the Applicant conceded: ‘I do remember my offending a little bit – I’m just too ashamed to talk about it’. This is a different submission to that originally made in his documentary and oral evidence.[40] Ibid 73-5.[41] Exhibit A1, 2 [12].

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 29 June 2021, a delegate of the Minister decided not to revoke the mandatory cancellation of his visa (“non-revocation decision”).[16] He has since been assisted with his application by Refugee Legal.[17][16] Exhibit R1, 48.[17] Ibid 318, 320-3. On 5 July 2021, the Applicant asked the Tribunal to review the non-revocation decision.[18][18] Ibid 41-6. On 29 September 2021, the Tribunal, differently constituted, affirmed the reviewable decision (“first hearing”).[19] [19] BYMD and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2021]AATA 3476. The Applicant appealed and, on 15 August 2022, Justice S.C. Derrington upheld three grounds of appeal and remitted the matter to the Tribunal for redetermination according to law.[20] Her Honour found that the Tribunal member denied the Applicant procedural fairness by not giving him an opportunity to explain why his child’s best interests were served by revocation, notwithstanding that the child and his mother were living in New Zealand. Her Honour also found there was a denial of procedural fairness by the Applicant not being advised that the precise location of his resettlement in Ethiopia was in issue, in the context of the Tribunal member finding there was only a ‘remote chance’ of him being a victim of societal violence and could safely return to Addis Ababa.[21] [20] Exhibit R1, 656-79.[21] Ibid 676. On 22 June 2023 his application was re-heard, and the reviewable decision was again affirmed (“second hearing”).[22](a)On 24 July 2023, the Applicant appealed. On 12 March 2024, Justice Rofe quashed the second decision by consent of the parties and remitted the matter for redetermination according to law.[23] That decision gives rise to the current proceeding.[22] BYMD and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2023]AATA 1774.[23] Ibid 1339-41.LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK Section 13 of the Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 (Cth) (“the ART Act”) and s 500(1)(ba) of the Act are the sources of the Tribunal’s jurisdiction in this matter. Section 501(3A) of the Act, read in conjunction with ss 501(6) and 501(7), obliges the Minister to cancel a person’s visa if the Minister is satisfied the person does not pass the character test and is serving a full-time sentence of imprisonment. The ‘character test’ is defined in s 501(6) of the Act and a person does not pass it if they have a ‘substantial criminal record’ as defined by s 501(7). This includes if they have been sentenced to a term of imprisonment of 12 months or more: s 501(7)(c). Under s 501CA(3) of the Act, the Minister is obliged to give notice of a cancellation decision as soon as practicable after it is made, and to invite the affected person to make representations about revocation. Provisions relating to the form and process of those representations are found in reg 2.52 of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth). Section 501CA(4) of the Act confers a discretionary power upon the Minister to revoke the original decision, if the person whose visa has been cancelled makes representations in accordance with the invitation, and the Minister is satisfied that the person passes the character test, or there is another reason why the original decision should be revoked.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Applicant contextualised his abuse of substances as mixing with ‘wrong people [he] met on the street’ who had ‘no job, no life – their lives depended on alcohol and drugs’. He claimed to have last used alcohol and drugs prior to imprisonment in 2019. Prior to a line of questioning about his past drug use, the Applicant was reminded of his privilege against self-incrimination. This is because there are no drug convictions recorded in his criminal history, but the evidence he and his representatives tendered refers to polysubstance drug abuse and persistent addiction. The Applicant chose to answer these questions. He agreed that he previously used cannabis, ecstasy, cocaine, crystal methamphetamine (“ice”), and heroin to varying degrees. He claims, for example, to have started using cannabis in ‘around 2005’ but stopped doing so ‘around 2007’ because it caused him to become ‘paranoid and hallucinate’. He also recalled being given cocaine and speed ‘by people in clubs and pubs’. When asked if this made him lose control, he responded: ‘most likely’. When asked if persistent drug use may have caused his schizoaffective disorder, the Applicant responded: ‘Most likely – I’m not sure’. When asked by Ms Jackson if he used any illicit drugs in custodial settings, he responded: ‘No’. When asked by Ms Jackson if others use drugs in detention, he responded: ‘I don’t know’. The Applicant recalled experiencing drug and alcohol urges in ‘past years’, but not now. He agrees that he still requires drug and alcohol rehabilitation.Previous formal immigration warning The Applicant could not recall receiving a formal warning from the Respondent in 2013 about the consequences of further offending.[42] He did not deny receiving the warning, for which there is a signed acknowledgement in evidence,[43] just that he had no memory of it. [42] Ibid 226.[43] Ibid 228.Remorse and rehabilitation The Applicant recalled feeling shame, disgust, and sorrow for his past conduct and the effect on his victims. He contextualised this in part by claiming that previous mental health medications did not work. He claimed to have completed a six-month sex offender’s program in 2010 while imprisoned, which he recalled was in a group setting and consisted of weekly sessions. When asked by Ms Jackson what kind of things were talked about, the Applicant responded: ‘behaviour, respect women…it was a long time ago’. The Applicant said after being diagnosed and treated for schizoaffective disorder in 2020 while in prison, he experienced a turning point that caused him to feel ‘normal…awake … and aware of [him]self and [his] surroundings’. He has subsequently seen general practitioners, psychologists, and psychiatrists in custodial settings since 2019, but ‘less often in detention due to high demand’. The Applicant said during his time in immigration detention he has engaged in activities such as art and English classes, Coffee Club, and attending the gym. He has not undertaken offence-specific rehabilitation courses in detention because there are none but talks to health practitioners about his mental and physical health. The Applicant said he is prescribed daily medication and takes it each evening at a ‘counter’ run by nurses.