FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Burt v University of Sydney (Common Question) [2025] FCA 601
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Burt v University of Sydney (Common Question) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2025] FCA 601
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine whether a relationship of employment arose between the University and Dr Burt and between the University and the Group Members under the Scholarship Contract. The central legal issue was whether the Scholarship Contract constituted a contract of employment, thereby establishing a relationship of employment, or whether it was a scholarship agreement intended to provide financial support for educational purposes. This characterisation was critical in assessing whether the University contravened the Fair Work Act by failing to pay minimum entitlements under applicable Enterprise Agreements.
The court rejected Dr Burt's argument that the Scholarship Contract constituted a contract of employment. The court found that the enrolment as a postgraduate research student was a voluntary undertaking by the student to complete an agreed course of study or research for their own education. The payments received under the scholarship were considered to be in the nature of a stipend to assist with expenses incurred in undertaking the higher degree by research and other living costs, rather than remuneration for services rendered. The court held that the purpose of the scholarship payments was to support the educational endeavour and not to reward services in the nature of employment. Consequently, the court found that no relationship of employment was established between the University and Dr Burt or the Group Members.
The proceeding, in so far as it constitutes the individual claim of Dr Burt against the University of Sydney and the Commonwealth of Australia, was dismissed with no order as to costs. The court granted leave for the parties to provide submissions or evidence as to why any order under s 33ZB of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) binding group members should be made within 21 days of the revised reasons for judgment being published. The court will determine whether to dismiss the proceedings generally or make any s 33ZB order following the receipt of any evidence or submissions. Any time to appeal or time for leave to appeal relevant to Dr Burt will be extended to expire 28 days following the making of any order as contemplated by order 3 of these orders.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The proceeding, in so far as it constitutes the individual claim of Dr Burt against the University of Sydney and the Commonwealth of Australia, be dismissed with no order as to costs.
2. The parties to this proceeding and any group member have leave to provide any submissions or evidence as to why any order under s 33ZB of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) binding group members (s 33ZB order) should be made within 21 days of the revised reasons for judgment being published.
3. Following the receipt of any evidence or submissions in accordance with order 2 of these orders, the Court determine whether to dismiss the proceedings generally, or make any s 33ZB order.
4. Any time to appeal or time for leave to appeal relevant to Dr Burt be extended to expire 28 days following the making of any order as contemplated by order 3 of these orders.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether a relationship of employment arose between the University and Dr Burt and between the University and Group Members.
2. Whether a contract of employment was created by the relevant Scholarship Contract.
3. Whether the University contravened s 50 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by failing to pay minimum entitlements under applicable Enterprise Agreements.
Held
1. Whether a relationship of employment arose between the University and Dr Burt and between the University and Group Members.
The court concluded that no relationship of employment arose between the University and Dr Burt or between the University and the Group Members. As a result, the individual claim of Dr Burt against the University of Sydney and the Commonwealth of Australia was dismissed with no order as to costs.
2. Whether a contract of employment was created by the relevant Scholarship Contract.
The court concluded that the Scholarship Contract did not create a contract of employment. The payments received under the scholarship were in the nature of financial support to enable the HDR students to complete their educational endeavour and not as a reward for services in the nature of remuneration for the research work performed.
3. Whether the University contravened s 50 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by failing to pay minimum entitlements under applicable Enterprise Agreements.
The court did not specifically address this issue in its holdings, but the dismissal of the individual claim of Dr Burt against the University of Sydney implies that the court found no contravention of s 50 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by the University.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
This task of determining whether a contract for service has been created will often require characterising the purpose for which work is required to be performed and the purpose of the payment received. Hence, for the circumstances of this case, determining whether a person is performing research work for the purpose of rendering service for the University rather than for the purposes of education and learning is critical. In this regard, it is relevant to consider the identity of the parties (being a university and a higher education student), the subject-matter of the Scholarship Contract, and the broader context of the relationship. F CONSIDERATION Despite the clever and ably presented arguments of Ms Kelly on behalf of Dr Burt, the contention that a contract of employment was created by the Scholarship Contract cannot be accepted. Often first and common-sense impressions are telling and are simply confirmed by closer analysis. This is such a case. In short, and shorn of unnecessary complication, Dr Burt’s argument must be rejected because, objectively analysed, a candidate’s enrolment as a postgraduate research student to undertake an HDR is best characterised as a voluntary undertaking by the student to complete an agreed, identified course of study or research in furtherance of their own education, with the objective of obtaining the distinction of conferral upon them of a higher degree or qualification. Further, the receipt of payments under the scholarship reflects the payment by the University of moneys granted to it under a statutory scheme, reflecting a public policy that it is worth encouraging such educational attainment. This scheme creates a payment in the nature of a stipend to assist with covering expenses incurred in undertaking the HDR and other living costs. Properly analysed, this is a mechanism for financial support to enable the HDR students to complete their educational endeavour with assistance and does not constitute payments as a reward for services in the nature of remuneration for the research work performed in the course of study or research to attain an HDR. The starting point is that Dr Burt’s acceptance for the application to study to obtain a Doctor of Philosophy was not dependent on receipt of any scholarship. The offer of admission made no reference to the award or receipt of a scholarship. It was not a condition of the initial arrangement that Dr Burt be in receipt of a scholarship. As the facts disclose, Dr Burt did not apply for an APA scholarship until 16 May 2016, and he received an offer of the APA scholarship which he accepted by entering into the Scholarship Contract on 20 July 2016. Indeed, the experience of Dr Burt was not unique – the APA Conditions of Award 2015 (for domestic students) provide that eligibility for receiving an APA arises after enrolment in a full-time postgraduate research degree has occurred (APA Conditions of Award 2015 (for domestic students) at [3]). In application of these conclusions, it is worth making further observations by reference to two subheadings. F.1 The purpose or object of the alleged service