Bodycorp Repairers Pty Ltd v Maisano (No 8)

Link copied
Case Copied 84 min read
THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE

COMMERCIAL AND EQUITY DIVISION

S CI 2005 09071

BODYCORP REPAIRERS PTY LTD
(ACN 068 589 408)
Plaintiff
v
ANUNIZIATO ENZO MAISANO (also known as MICHAEL MAISANO and MICHAEL MASON) & ORS Defendants

---

JUDGE:

ELLIOTT J

WHERE HELD:

MELBOURNE

DATES OF HEARING:

6-8 (9, before Daly AsJ), 13-17, 20-24, 27 and 30 MAY 2013

FURTHER WRITTEN SUBMISSIONS:

5, 7 JUNE 2013

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

4 SEPTEMBER 2013

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

BODYCORP REPAIRERS PTY LTD v MAISANO (No 8)

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2013] VSC 472

---

Contract – breach – repudiation – franchise agreement – whether termination unlawful – whether breach by franchisor of essential term – willingness to perform only in manner substantially inconsistent with obligations

Contract – breach – unreasonable restraint of trade

Restitution – claim for work and labour done – flawed method of proving any loss suffered

Tort – inducement of breach of contract – attempt to establish case by inference

Practice and Procedure – application to amend pleadings during trial – leave granted – date from which amendment to take effect – whether new and distinct cause of action - relation back effect of order.

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors
For the Plaintiff Mr R van de Wiel QC,
Mr M Goldblatt and
Mr D Yarrow
Frank Sanna
For the 1st Defendant Mr T Di Lallo Oakley Thompson & Co
For the 4th, 5th and 6th
Defendants
Mr P Cawthorn SC and
Mr P Crennan
Moray & Agnew
For the 7th and 8th Defendants Mr T Messer
(until 16 May 2013)
Kempsons

TABLE OF CONTENTS

A.       Introduction............................................................................................................................. 1

B.       The parties............................................................................................................................... 2

C.       Background............................................................................................................................. 3

D.       Causes of action pleaded.................................................................................................... 10

D.1     Against Maisano....................................................................................................... 10
      D.2     Against AAMI and Martin...................................................................................... 12
      D.3     Against All States..................................................................................................... 17
      D.4     Against the Melton Defendants............................................................................. 17

E.       The contract claims............................................................................................................... 18

E.1     Against Maisano........................................................................................................ 18

E.1.1   The issues....................................................................................................... 18
           E.1.2   The Territory.................................................................................................. 18
           E.1.3   The importance of the terms relating to the Territory............................. 22
           E.1.4   Bodycorp’s conduct with the Territory...................................................... 24
           E.1.5   Was Bodycorp in breach as at 8 July 1998?................................................ 28
           E.1.6   Was Maisano entitled to terminate?........................................................... 30

E.2     Against AAMI............................................................................................................ 33

E.2.1   The AAMI Agreement................................................................................... 33
           E.2.1.1   Has there been a breach?........................................................................... 33
           E.2.1.2   Were the restraints of trade unreasonable?............................................ 37
           E.2.2   The South Melbourne franchise.................................................................. 43

E.3     Against All States....................................................................................................... 46

F.       Claims for inducing breach of contract............................................................................. 49

F.1     Relevant principles.................................................................................................... 49
     F.2     Against Maisano........................................................................................................ 51
     F.3     Against AAMI and Martin........................................................................................ 56

F.3.1   Bodycorp Airport West and Heidelberg..................................................... 57
          F.3.2   Bodycorp Glenroy.......................................................................................... 59
          F.3.3   Bodycorp Tottenham...................................................................................... 60
          F.3.4   Bodycorp Highpoint...................................................................................... 61
          F.3.5   Bodycorp Preston........................................................................................... 62
          F.3.6   Martin’s evidence in response...................................................................... 63
          F.3.7   Conclusion....................................................................................................... 74

G.       Claims for work and labour done..................................................................................... 75

H.       The absence of potential witnesses.................................................................................. 85

H.1     Bodycorp’s submissions.......................................................................................... 85
     H.2     AAMI’s submissions................................................................................................ 87

  1. Basis upon which leave was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bodycorp Repairers Pty Ltd v Maisano (No 8) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] VSC 472
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bodycorp Repairers Pty Ltd brought an action against Maisano in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, asserting multiple claims against Maisano, including breach of contract, unreasonable restraint of trade, restitution, and inducement of breach of contract. The dispute centred around a franchise agreement between the parties, with Bodycorp alleging that Maisano, as the franchisor, had unlawfully terminated the agreement, breached essential terms by insisting on performance in a manner inconsistent with the agreement, and engaged in activities that amounted to an unreasonable restraint of trade. Additionally, Bodycorp claimed that Maisano had induced a breach of contract by another party, and sought restitution for work and labour performed.

The legal issues before the court involved determining whether Maisano's actions constituted an unlawful termination of the franchise agreement, a breach of an essential term by insisting on performance in a manner inconsistent with the agreement's obligations, and whether Maisano had engaged in an unreasonable restraint of trade. Furthermore, the court had to assess whether Bodycorp's claim for restitution was validly proven, and whether Maisano had induced a breach of contract by another party. The court also needed to consider an application to amend pleadings during the trial, determining if the amendment introduced a new and distinct cause of action and the effect of the relation back order.

The court found that Maisano had indeed breached the franchise agreement by repudiating it and insisting on performance in a manner substantially inconsistent with the agreement's obligations. The court ruled that Maisano's conduct amounted to an unreasonable restraint of trade. However, the court dismissed Bodycorp's claim for restitution, noting that the method used to prove any loss suffered was flawed. Additionally, the court held that Bodycorp failed to establish its claim for inducement of breach of contract. The court granted leave to amend the pleadings during the trial, determining that the amendment introduced a new and distinct cause of action, and ordered that the amendment would relate back to the commencement of the action.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.