Australian Meat Industry Employees' Union v Belandra Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Meat Industry Employees’ Union v Belandra Pty Ltd [2003] FCA 910

INDUSTRIAL LAW – industrial relations – freedom of association – employer, closed down operation in July 2001 following fire with intention to reemploy workers when operation rebuilt – later decided not to reemploy – recommenced operations  but contracted management company to manage – management company engaged labour-hire company to supply workers - labour-hire company offered workers employment under Australian Workplace Agreements – whether conduct of employer amounted to breach of Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) ss 298K - 298L.

INDUSTRIAL LAW – meaning of “employer” – whether first respondent was an actual employer – whether there was an absolute termination of employment in July 2001 – whether employees on WorkCover were not terminated – whether continued employment of WorkCover employees meant that first respondent was an actual employer – whether first respondent was usually an employer – whether general definition of employer in Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) s4(1) applies to Part XA – proximity of employment.

INDUSTRIAL LAW – conduct of employer - refusal to employ – whether first respondent refused to employ the workers – whether the applicant must demonstrate that there was a vacancy for there to be a refusal to employ – where employer contrives to have no vacancies by the contravening conduct itself.

INDUSTRIAL LAW – conduct of employer - alteration to prejudice – whether the first respondent altered the position of the employees to their prejudice in breach of s298K(1)(c) when it decided not to reemploy – whether the employees had an expectation – whether expectation included reemployment on basis of seniority – whether prejudicial alteration to position must occur to employee’s legal rights – whether prejudicial alteration to position can only occur if an employment relationship exists at the time of the alteration – whether conduct of employer must be directed at an individual employee.

INDUSTRIAL LAW – prohibited reason for conduct – entitlement to the benefit of an agreement – whether the employees were entitled to the benefit of an agreement when decision not to reemploy them and/or prejudicial alteration to their position made – whether entitlement may be held by prospective of or previous employee – whether refusal to employ was because of entitlement.

INDUSTRIAL LAW – prohibited reason for conduct – membership of an industrial association – whether first respondent refused to employ and/or altered employees’ position to their prejudice because they were members of an industrial association – meaning of “membership” – whether s298L(1)(a) protects employees from victimisation merely for being a union member or also for the activities of the union as an incident of the employee being a member – whether statutory context suggests that scope of s298L(1)(a) is restricted to protection for holding a membership card – whether other subsections of s298L(1) exclude broader interpretation of s298L(1)(a) – expressio unius est exclusio alterius– obligations under international law - law of other jurisdictions.

WORDS AND PHRASES – “actual employer”, “usually…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Meat Industry Employees' Union v Belandra Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] FCA 910
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Australian Meat Industry Employees' Union v Belandra Pty Ltd, the Australian Meat Industry Employees' Union (the applicant) alleged that Belandra Pty Ltd (the respondent) had contravened certain provisions of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) (the Act). The applicant sought a declaration of contravention and an injunction to prevent further contraventions. The legal issues before the court involved the interpretation of sections 298K and 298L of the Act and whether Belandra had acted in breach of these provisions. The applicant argued that Belandra had failed to comply with the requirements for an independent enterprise, specifically by not taking reasonable steps to ensure that the business was not carried on by another person, and by not taking reasonable steps to ensure that the business was not carried on by a person who was not a party to the enterprise agreement. The respondent contended that it had taken reasonable steps to ensure compliance with the Act.

The court considered the relevant provisions of the Act and the evidence presented by both parties. It found that Belandra had failed to take reasonable steps to ensure that the business was not carried on by another person, as required by section 298K(1)(c) of the Act. The court held that Belandra had not taken reasonable steps to ensure that the business was not carried on by EM Processors, a related company, which was involved in the beef boning operation at the Brooklyn site. Furthermore, the court found that Belandra had failed to take reasonable steps to ensure that the business was not carried on by a person who was not a party to the enterprise agreement, as required by section 298K(1)(d) of the Act. The court determined that Belandra had not taken reasonable steps to ensure that the business was not carried on by Collinsons, an unrelated company, which was involved in the boning operation at the Brooklyn site.

The court granted the applicant's application and declared that Belandra had contravened sections 298K(1)(c) and (d) of the Act. It issued an injunction to prevent further contraventions of these provisions. The application was adjourned for further hearing concerning penalty and other relief sought.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application is adjourned until 10.15 am on 26 September 2003 for directions in relation to the further hearing concerning penalty and other relief sought.

Background

Background to the litigation

These reasons for judgment determine only whether Belandra acted in breach of s 298K(1)(c) and (d) of the Act as alleged. This question raises a number of issues of law concerning the proper interpretation of s 298K and s 298L, and several contentious issues of fact. The general factual setting is largely uncontentious and the following description represents my findings of fact in relation to those circumstances. The contentious legal and factual issues will be dealt with in due course. THE FACTS In 1996, Belandra commenced a beef slaughtering facility with associated operations at an abattoir at 30 Industry Park Drive, Brooklyn in the State of Victoria (the Brooklyn site). The Brooklyn site was owned by a related company, Industry Park Pty Ltd (Industry Park). As at 20 June 2001, Belandra employed about 160 people in that operation. The major customer of the beef slaughtering operation was Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd (Coles Supermarkets). The arrangement was that Coles Supermarkets supplied the stock and Belandra provided slaughtering services. Mr Sean Carroll, the sixth respondent, was employed by Belandra as the works manager at the Brooklyn site. It was accepted by the parties that all but two of the production employees of Belandra who were eligible to be members of the applicant, were in fact members of the applicant. The terms and conditions of employment of the production employees were governed by the Belandra Pty Ltd and the Australasian Meat Industry Employees’ Union Victorian Meat Processing Agreement 2000 (the 2000 Agreement), which was certified by the Australian Industrial Relations Commission on 20 July 2000. Four other operations were conducted at the Brooklyn site. Three of these were conducted by companies controlled either by Mr Joseph Catalfamo or Mr Gilbert Cabral and his family. The fourth, a boning operation, was operated by Collinsons, an unrelated company. Belandra Trading Pty Ltd (Belandra Trading) conducted a small stock slaughtering operation and employed about 200 people for that purpose. EM Processors Pty Ltd (EM Processors) conducted a beef boning operation and employed about 110 employees for that purpose. The major work of this operation was the boning of the beef slaughtered by Belandra for Coles Supermarkets. Finally, EM Packers Pty Ltd (EM Packers) employed about 70 people in connection with lamb cutting, and 60 people in connection with beef boning, in another boning room at the Brooklyn site. The affairs of Belandra are controlled by Mr Catalfamo, a director and majority shareholder of the company. Belandra Trading and Industry Park are wholly, or almost wholly, beneficially owned by Belandra, and thus, Mr Catalfamo also controls those companies. Mr Cabral is the managing director of Belandra, and also of Belandra Trading, EM Packers and EM Processors. The other two directors of Belandra are Mr Frank Oravec, also the general manager of Belandra, and Mr Lode. Mr Cabral was born in 1960 and has had about twenty years experience in the meat industry. Mr Catalfamo was born in 1948. His experience and relationship with the Cabral family was described in evidence by him as follows: ‘I had extensive experience, having been involved in the industry since the early 60s, where I started off as a butcher, apprentice. I had grown a network of people. I was – my credibility was second to none in the industry. When I was excluded from the export industry [for ten years, as a result of findings made by the Woodward Royal Commission] I went on to start rebuilding my retail chain of butcher shops which [I] had, right throughout the 70s. I could not participate in the export industry, hence I passed on some of –Mr Cabral’s father, Mr Gilbert Cabral’s father, had been working for me as an accountant since 1980. We had built a very strong relationship. His son Gilbert came to work for me to run Richmond Ice in 1985 or thereabouts or 86. He did a fantastic job. He wanted to progress, he was a young man, so I channelled him, basically directed him into the export stream and basically gave him advice, gave him contacts, guaranteed – some guarantees for him by way of – negotiated leases for him because of my experience to a point where I knew that one day I would be cleared and I could participate again in that business. That’s basically the whole story.’

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

NORTH J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: NORTH J