Employment Advocate v Barclay Mowlem Construction Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Employment Advocate v Barclay Mowlem Construction Limited
[2005] FCA 16

INDUSTRIAL LAW – Freedom of association – alleged termination of a contract for services with an independent contractor for prohibited reasons – where no formal contract – whether contract formed – whether a reasonable observer would conclude from the dealings between the two companies that they intended to conclude a bargain

INDUSTRIAL LAW – Freedom of association – alleged termination of a contract for services with an independent contractor for prohibited reasons – where no formal contract – whether contract formed – whether respondent’s representatives had actual or ostensible authority to enter into a subcontract binding the respondent

INDUSTRIAL LAW – Freedom of association – alleged refusal to engage an independent contractor for prohibited reasons – whether respondent refused to engage – whether material distinction between refusing to engage an independent contractor and deciding to award subcontract to one independent contractor in preference to another

INDUSTRIAL LAW – Freedom of association – prohibited reasons – onus of proof – statutory presumption that respondent engaged in alleged conduct for prohibited reasons – where more than one prohibited reason alleged – whether respondent must rebut statutory presumption in relation to each alleged prohibited reason – whether applicant must prove the facts forming the basis of each prohibited reason

WORDS AND PHRASES – ‘refuse to engage’

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 60 and s136
Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) s 83BA, s 170LT, s 298K, s 298L, s 298U and s 298V

Australasian Meat Industry Employees’ Union v Belandra Pty Ltd (2003) 126 IR 165 followed
Australian Broadcasting Corporation v XIVth Commonwealth Games Ltd (1988) 18 NSWLR 540 applied
Booth v Bosworth (2001) 114 FCR 39 cited
Burnie Port Corporation Pty Ltd v Maritime Union of Australia (2000) 104 FCR 440 followed
Employment Advocate v Williamson (2001) 111 FCR 20 referred to
Maritime Union of Australia v Burnie Port Corporation Pty Ltd (2000) 101 IR 435 cited
Maritime Union of Australia v CSL Australia Pty Ltd (2002) 113 IR 326 cited
Pacific Carriers Ltd v BNP Paribas (2004) 208 ALR 213 cited

NIGEL HADGKISS ACTING AS DELEGATE OF THE EMPLOYMENT ADVOCATE v BARCLAY MOWLEM CONSTRUCTION LIMITED ACN 009 830 460

NSD 2497 of 2003

BRANSON J
20 JANUARY 2005
SYDNEY

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 2497 of 2003

BETWEEN:

NIGEL HADGKISS ACTING AS DELEGATE OF THE EMPLOYMENT ADVOCATE
APPLICANT

AND:

BARCLAY MOWLEM CONSTRUCTION LIMITED ACN 009 830 460
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

BRANSON J

DATE OF ORDER:

20 JANUARY 2005

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT further hearing of the application be stood over to a date to be fixed.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 2497 of 2003

BETWEEN:

NIGEL HADGKISS ACTING AS DELEGATE OF THE EMPLOYMENT ADVOCATE
APPLICANT

AND:

BARCLAY MOWLEM CONSTRUCTION LIMITED ACN 009 830 460
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

BRANSON J

DATE:

20 JANUARY 2005

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

INTRODUCTION

  1. This application…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Employment Advocate v Barclay Mowlem Construction Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] FCA 16
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court involved the Employment Advocate and Barclay Mowlem Construction Limited. The Employment Advocate, acting on behalf of the workers, alleged that Barclay Mowlem Construction Limited had contravened the Fair Work Act 2009 by refusing to engage a subcontractor, Robsons, as an independent contractor. The court was tasked with determining whether a contract was formed between the two companies and whether the refusal to engage Robsons was for prohibited reasons. The court examined the written guidelines established by Barclay Mowlem Construction Limited, which outlined the limits of authority for executives and managers regarding the procurement of services and subcontracts. The guidelines indicated that only a Group General Manager had the authority to approve project purchasing within budget exceeding $1 million, and Mr Munnings, the General Manager, was responsible for approving recommendations for the engagement of subcontractors.

The court found that, although there was no formal contract signed, the actions and communications between the parties suggested an intention to form a binding agreement. The respondent's practice of using a standard subcontractor agreement, the confirmation of a formal contract to be drawn up, and the exchange of important information and assurances between the parties indicated an intention to enter into a contract. However, the court also found that the respondent's refusal to engage Robsons as an independent contractor was for prohibited reasons, as presumed under the statutory presumption contained in s 298V of the Fair Work Act 2009. Therefore, the court's power to make orders under s 298U of the Act was activated. The court concluded that the respondent had engaged in conduct in contravention of Part XA of the Act and listed the proceeding for a further hearing to determine the appropriate orders.

The final orders of the court, to be determined in the further hearing, would likely involve remedies such as requiring Barclay Mowlem Construction Limited to engage Robsons as an independent contractor and to compensate Robsons for any losses incurred as a result of the refusal. The court's decision emphasised the importance of adhering to the provisions of the Fair Work Act 2009 and ensuring that subcontractors are treated fairly and not discriminated against based on prohibited reasons.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

I have reached the conclusion that the contention of the respondent that it had not at the relevant time entered into a contract with Robsons should be upheld. However, for the reasons set out below, I have formed the view that the respondent did ‘refuse to engage’ Robsons as an independent contractor within the meaning of par 298K(2)(d). I have also formed the view that, by reason of the statutory presumption contained in s 298V of the Act, it is to be presumed that the respondent’s refusal to engage Robsons as an independent contractor was for prohibited reasons. The Court’s power to make orders under s 298U of the Act is thus enlivened.BACKGROUND FACTS There is little dispute between the parties as to the relevant primary facts. The position of Employment Advocate is created by s 83BA of the Act. The Employment Advocate is authorised by par 298T(2)(d) to make an application to the Court for orders under s 298U in respect of conduct in contravention of Part XA of the Act. The respondent has not challenged the entitlement of the applicant to institute this proceeding as a delegate of the Employment Advocate (see s 83BE of the Act). The respondent is a company that operates in the building and engineering industry. The NSW Building Group is a business unit of the respondent. At all relevant times Peter Thomas Munnings (‘Mr Munnings’) was the General Manager, Steven Murphy (‘Mr Murphy’) was the Administration Manager, Bill McGarry (‘Mr McGarry’) was the Design Manager and Bill Chatfield (‘Mr Chatfield’) was the Commercial Manager of the NSW Building Group. The respondent has established written guidelines intended to define the limits of authority of executives and managers of the respondent relating to the purchase and disposal of chattels and the procurement of services and subcontracts (‘the Guidelines’). The Guidelines, which were received in evidence, indicate that a contract under seal requires the joint signatures of either two Directors or the Company Secretary and a Company Director and that a contract not under seal requires the signature of the Group General Manager. The Guidelines also indicate that only a Group General Manager has authority to approve project purchasing within budget in an amount in excess of $1 million. Mr Munnings was at the relevant time a Group General Manager within the meaning of the Guidelines. Mr Munnings gave evidence that his role with the respondent involved him in approving recommendations for the engagement of subcontractors. The only evidence touching on the authority of officers and employees of the respondent to formulate recommendations for the engagement of subcontractors is referred to in [49] below. Robsons is a company that provides excavation and other civil construction works to developers and builders. Robsons operates mainly in New South Wales in the areas of northern Sydney, the Central Coast, the Hunter region and Lake Macquarie. Kevin Francis Rigg (‘Mr Rigg’) is the Operations Manager and Andrew Arthur Newberry (‘Mr Newberry’) is a Project Manager for Robsons. Mr Rigg and Mr Newberry gave affidavit evidence in this proceeding. Neither of them was cross-examined and I accept their respective evidence.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

BRANSON J
The respondent submitted that Robsons, as a corporation, could not give evidence in a proceeding under an industrial law. I do not understand the applicant to have pressed reliance on this alleged prohibited reason. It is not necessary to give it further consideration.CONCLUSION For the above reasons I find that the respondent has engaged in conduct in contravention of Part XA of the Act. The proceeding will be listed for a further hearing onthe question of the order or orders, if any, that it is appropriate in all of the circumstances of the case for the Court to make.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BRANSON J

Robsons did not undertake work as subcontractors to the respondent in respect of the Gosford Project.CONSIDERATIONWas a contract formed? The first issue to be determined is whether, as the applicant contends, a contract was entered into on or about 26 November 2002 between the respondent and Robsons for the undertaking by Robsons of excavation works on the Gosford project. The relevant test is whether a reasonable observer would conclude from the dealings between the respondent and Robsons that the two companies intended, on or about 26 November 2002, to then and there conclude a bargain (Australian Broadcasting Corporation v XIVth Commonwealth Games Ltd (1988) 18 NSWLR 540 per Gleeson CJ at 548‑551). A significant factor relevant to the objective determination of the companies’ respective intentions is that Mr McGarry confirmed late in the course of the meeting held on 26 November 2002 that a formal contract would be drawn up to govern the relationship between the respondent and Robsons and that Robsons would have to sign the formal contract. The respondent’s practice of using a standard subcontractor agreement had first been raised by Mr McGarry on 22 November 2002. Mr Newberry did not at any time challenge the suggestion that a formal contract would have to be signed by Robsons (see [20] above). Another significant factor relevant to an objective determination of the companies’ respective intentions is that during the course of the meeting held on 26 November 2002 Mr Newberry agreed to provide to the respondent copies of Robsons’ public liability and workers compensation certificates of insurance and also a considerable body of additional information. The information to be provided by the completion of the documents given to Mr Newberry on 26 November 2002 included important formal information such as the legal name and ABN number of Robsons. More significantly, it also included information apparently relevant to a judgment as to the appropriateness of Robsons as a subcontractor (eg the names of trade creditor referees for Robsons, details of similar projects completed by Robsons recently, and confirmation that Robsons has no contractual claims currently running). Completion of the documents was also calculated to result in Robsons giving assurances as to project specific safety planning and undertakings to provide the respondent with information touching on, amongst other things, Robsons’ industrial relations throughout the life of the Gosford project. The request for, and the provision of, the information, assurances and undertakings provided by the completion of these documents suggests against the parties proceeding on the basis that they had already entered into a binding agreement. Each of the above factors, in my view, suggests against the respondent and Robsons intending during the meeting held on 26 November 2002 then and there to conclude an agreement. The nature of the subject matter of the proposed subcontract and its monetary value are additional factors that tend to support a conclusion that the intention of the respondent and Robsons on 26 November 2002 was to postpone the creation of contractual relations until, at least, the respondent had formally approved Robsons as a subcontractor and possibly until a formal contract was drawn up and executed.