Qantas Airways Ltd v Australian Licensed Aircraft Engineers Association

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Qantas Airways Limited v Australian Licensed Aircraft Engineers Association [2012] FCAFC 63

Citation: Qantas Airways Limited v Australian Licensed Aircraft Engineers Association [2012] FCAFC 63
Appeal from: Australian Licensed Aircraft Engineers Association v Qantas Airways Ltd & Anor [2011] FMCA 58
Parties: QANTAS AIRWAYS LIMITED and PETER CAWTHORNE v AUSTRALIAN LICENSED AIRCRAFT ENGINEERS ASSOCIATION
File number: NSD 381 of 2011
Judges: GRAY, NORTH AND BESANKO JJ
Date of judgment: 4  May 2012
Catchwords:

INDUSTRIAL LAW – Adverse action – where respondent alleged appellants altered employee’s position to his prejudice – consideration of what constitutes prejudicial alteration - whether effect of alteration real and substantial – whether employee in cadre of people to whom action is directed – consideration of time at which action is to be assessed

INDUSTRIAL LAW – Coercion – consideration of elements of coercion – procedural fairness – where federal magistrate raised one basis of the element of unlawfulness with the parties but decided claim on another basis – where appellants alleged reasons of federal magistrate were inconsistent with his earlier decision refusing respondent leave to amend pleadings – whether finding outside pleaded case - conduct of parties in the case determinative

Legislation: Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)
Cases cited: Community and Public Sector Union & Another v Telstra Corporation Limited (2001) 107 FCR 93 considered
Australian Meat Industry Employees Union v Belandra Pty Ltd (2003) 126 IR 165 considered
Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118 cited
Date of hearing: 18 November 2011
Place: Sydney
Division: FAIR WORK DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 96
Counsel for the Appellants: R C Kenzie QC with E J Prince
Solicitor for the Appellants: Blake Dawson
Counsel for the Respondent: R T Beech-Jones SC with A Slevin
Solicitor for the Respondent: Maurice Blackburn

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

FAIR WORK DIVISION

NSD 381 of 2011

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

QANTAS AIRWAYS LIMITED
First Appellant

PETER CAWTHORNE
Second Appellant

AND:

AUSTRALIAN LICENSED AIRCRAFT ENGINEERS ASSOCIATION
Respondent

JUDGES:

GRAY, NORTH AND BESANKO JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

4 MAY 2012

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal is allowed in part by substituting for the declarations made by the Federal Magistrates Court on 23 March 2011, the following:

(a)Declare that Qantas Airways Limited contravened s 340(1)(a)(ii) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by altering the position of Mr Luke Murray to his prejudice because he exercised a workplace right, in that, on 26 March 2010 Qantas Airways Limited suspended overseas postings for an indeterminate period and thereby denied Mr Murray the opportunity to obtain an overseas posting in late 2010 or early 2011 which he otherwise expected to receive, and Qantas Airways Limited took such action, at least in part, for the reason that Mr Murray had made a claim for entitlements arising from his posting at Narita between 4 December 2009 and 16 January 2010.

(b)Declare that Mr Peter Cawthorne contravened s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Qantas Airways Ltd v Australian Licensed Aircraft Engineers... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCAFC 63
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, Qantas Airways Limited and Peter Cawthorne, both appellants, appealed against two amended declarations made by the Federal Magistrates Court on 23 March 2011. The respondent, the Australian Licensed Aircraft Engineers Association, brought the application against the appellants for contraventions of s 340 and s 343 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (the Act). The appellants argued that the Federal Magistrates Court erred in its findings and conclusions, which led to the declarations. The court was required to decide whether the Federal Magistrates Court correctly interpreted the Act and whether the appellants contravened the Act by taking adverse action against Mr Luke Murray, a Licensed Aircraft Maintenance Engineer employed by Qantas Airways Limited.

The court considered the legal issues related to what constitutes a prejudicial alteration under s 340 of the Act and whether the effect of the alteration was real and substantial. The court also examined the elements of coercion under s 343 of the Act and whether procedural fairness was observed. The court found that the Federal Magistrates Court correctly interpreted the Act and that the appellants contravened the Act by taking adverse action against Mr Murray. The court held that the suspension of overseas postings for a temporary period was a prejudicial alteration to Mr Murray's position, and that Mr Cawthorne's threat to withhold future overseas postings was an act of coercion. The court further held that there was no denial of procedural fairness in the case.

The appeal was allowed in part by substituting the declarations made by the Federal Magistrates Court with new declarations that Qantas Airways Limited contravened s 340(1)(a)(ii) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and that Mr Peter Cawthorne contravened s 343(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The appeal was otherwise dismissed, and the balance of the proceeding was remitted to the Federal Magistrate for determination of issues concerning penalties.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is allowed in part by substituting for the declarations made by the Federal Magistrates Court on 23 March 2011, the following:

(a) Declare that Qantas Airways Limited contravened s 340(1)(a)(ii) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by altering the position of Mr Luke Murray to his prejudice because he exercised a workplace right, in that, on 26 March 2010 Qantas Airways Limited suspended overseas postings for an indeterminate period and thereby denied Mr Murray the opportunity to obtain an overseas posting in late 2010 or early 2011 which he otherwise expected to receive, and Qantas Airways Limited took such action, at least in part, for the reason that Mr Murray had made a claim for entitlements arising from his posting at Narita between 4 December 2009 and 16 January 2010.

(b) Declare that Mr Peter Cawthorne contravened s 343(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by taking action against Mr Luke Murray with intent to coerce him to not exercise a workplace right, in that, on 8 March 2010 Mr Cawthorne threatened Mr Murray that if he did not withdraw his claim for entitlements arising from his posting at Narita between 4 December 2009 and 16 January 2010, Mr Murray would not be given any further overseas postings.

2. The appeal is otherwise dismissed.

3. The balance of the proceeding is remitted to the Federal Magistrate for determination of issues concerning penalties.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Before the Court is an appeal from two amended declarations made by the Federal Magistrates Court on 23 March 2011. One declaration, which will be referred to as the adverse action declaration, was that the first appellant, Qantas Airways Ltd, “subjected Mr Luke Murray to adverse action by suspending international postings in contravention of s.340(1) Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)” (the Act). The other declaration, which will be referred to as the coercion declaration, was that the second appellant, Peter Cawthorne, “took action against Mr Luke Murray with intent to coerce him to not exercise a workplace right in contravention of s.343(1) of the Act. THE FACTS Mr Luke Murray is a Licensed Aircraft Maintenance Engineer (LAME) employed by the first appellant. He is based in Brisbane. He is a member of the Australian Licensed Aircraft Engineers Association, the respondent. LAMEs based in Australia also travel to overseas ports for short periods to relieve LAMEs posted overseas. Mr Murray was posted to Narita in Japan from 4 December 2009 to 16 January 2010. As a result of the hours he worked in that posting, Mr Murray made claims for additional payment from the first appellant, and for some additional time off on his return to Australia. There is some complexity, and indeed confusion about the basis of the claim. The detail is not relevant to this proceeding and was not addressed by counsel. It is sufficient to know that there was a claim made by Mr Murray which was not recognised initially by the first appellant. In Brisbane, Mr Honsa was responsible for selecting LAMEs for overseas postings. He reported to Mr Thompson, the Manager, Line Maintenance Operations, also in Brisbane, who was responsible for approving or declining requests for overseas postings. Mr Cawthorne was based in Sydney and was responsible for supporting LAMEs based in Australia who were posted overseas in Asia and the Pacific Islands. He reported to Mr Panagiotopoulos, the Manager, Line Maintenance Operations, who was also based in Sydney. Mr Murray discussed his claims with Mr Cawthorne in late February 2010. Then, on 8 March 2010, Mr Murray and Mr Cawthorne exchanged emails on the issue. This exchange led to a heated telephone conversation. What was said in the telephone conversation was the basis of the coercion allegation. On 25 March 2010, Mr Murray sent an email to Mr Cawthorne, which he copied to Mr Thompson and Mr Panagiotopoulos. In the email he said that Mr Cawthorne had no right to reject his claim, and that he was initiating the dispute resolution process available under the Enterprise Bargaining Agreement which governed his employment. On the next day, 26 March 2010, Mr Thompson and Mr Panagiotopoulos decided to suspend all overseas postings for LAMEs out of Brisbane. On 21 April 2010, the respondent filed an application in the Federal Magistrates Court alleging contraventions of s 340 and s 343 of the Act by the appellants. On 27 April 2010, the first appellant lifted the suspension of overseas postings for Brisbane LAMEs. THE AMENDED CLAIM UNDER THE FAIR WORK ACT

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The appellants had no response of substance to the argument that all parties conducted the case on the assumption that the contravention of s 343 would be made out if the respondent established that Mr Cawthorne intended to force Mr Murray to withdraw his claim by threatening to withhold future overseas postings. Thus, the parties approached the case on the basis that assumed the second element of coercion was made out if the first element was established. There was no denial of procedural fairness arising from the way the amended claim notified the appellants of the respondent’s claim under s 343 of the Act. The alleged inconsistency between the judgment of 9 December 2010 and the coercion finding This argument relied on a judgment given by the federal magistrate on the last day of the hearing. In the course of the argument in reply at that hearing the respondent sought to amend the claim brought under s 340 of the Act. At the time, that claim alleged that the appellants injured Mr Murray in his employment by verbally abusing him. This was an allegation of adverse action in contravention of s 340(1) as defined in item 1(b) of the table set out in s 342(1) of the Act. By the amendment the respondent sought to allege that the appellants altered the position of Mr Murray in his employment by verbally abusing him. This amendment raised an allegation of a contravention of s 340(1) as defined in item 1(c) of the table in s 342(1). The federal magistrate refused the application. He relied on Aon Risk Services Australia Limited v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175; [2009] HCA 27 to conclude that such an application is not to be lightly granted. The federal magistrate said at [3]:To my mind, it is now too late to alter the basis of the claim to add an additional complaint as is sought, even if it was hinted at during the course of the proceedings. The difficulty is that the respondent would, at the very least, have to pore through the transcript to work out whether or not the matter had been properly dealt with in questioning and cross-examination. In respect of a case that has already taken some days, I do not think a party should be required to do that. It is for those reasons I decline to grant the amendment. The appellants submitted that it was inconsistent of the federal magistrate to refuse the amendment of the s 340 claim in the 9 December 2010 judgment, but, in effect, allow such an amendment to the s 343 claim. On 9 December 2010, the federal magistrate refused the respondent’s application to amend the claim by pleading the verbal abuse as an alteration to the position of Mr Murray to his prejudice. Nonetheless, so it was argued, the federal magistrate relied on the prejudicial alteration of the position of Mr Murray in contravention of s 340 as the element of unlawfulness required to establish coercion under s 343. It may be accepted that the picture presented by the federal magistrate’s refusal of the amendment, then his reliance on the adverse action as an element of unlawfulness is less than perfect. But the question is whether it amounts to a denial of procedural fairness which should be corrected on appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Each of these arguments will now be addressed.The Prejudicial Alteration IssueThe federal magistrate’s reasons It is common ground that Mr Murray had exercised workplace rights within the meaning of s 340(1) of the Act by making the claims arising from the Narita posting and by initiating the dispute resolution process. The federal magistrate addressed the prejudicial alteration issue at [42] as follows: Did the suspension injure Mr Murray in his employment or alter his position to his prejudice? The respondent argues that there was no way that Mr Murray was likely to be going on a secondment during the period in which the suspension was operative because he had just been away and had been put at the bottom of the list. I do not think that is a correct way to articulate the test. Mr Murray was a LAME in Brisbane whose employment provided him with a number of benefits one of which was the opportunity to volunteer for overseas postings. That benefit was removed by the decision to suspend postings to everyone. When the suspension was put in place, there was no temporal limit, whatever Mr Thompson’s intentions may have been. Mr Murray may have been the person at the back of the list but it was not a very long list and other persons may well have had reasons why they did not wish to undertake such a posting at a particular time. Mr Murray had the benefit of being able to apply for an overseas posting on 24 March 2010 but not on 26 March. To my mind, his employment was adversely impacted by the decision and he was thereby injured or, at the very least, had his position altered to his prejudice which was the alternative way in which the action was pleaded.The first appellant’s submission The first appellant contended that there was no impact at all on Mr Murray by its decision to suspend overseas postings. The first appellant relied on the federal magistrate’s finding that the suspension was temporary, that is to say, that it lasted only until 27 April 2010. It also relied on the federal magistrate’s finding at [36] in the discussion concerning the first appellant’s reasons for imposing the suspension as follows:Mr Thompson said he believed the problem could be resolved quickly and that he had no intention of permanently suspending postings from Brisbane and I fully accept both of those statements.Further, the first appellant relied on the respondent’s further and better particulars of the future possible international postings which were allegedly denied to Mr Murray as follows: For the years 2004 to 2010 Mr Murray has received an international posting every year. He was next due to receive an international posting at the end of 2010 or early 2011. Finally, it relied on the following exchange which occurred in cross examination of Mr Murray: And you certainly haven’t suggested in your affidavit that during the suspension of postings, … you proposed to volunteer for overseas postings or expected to get overseas posting during that particular month? --- No.