Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v BHP Coal and Steven Rae

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v BHP Coal Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 590

Citation: Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v BHP Coal Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 590
Parties: CONSTRUCTION, FORESTRY, MINING AND ENERGY UNION v BHP COAL PTY LTD (ACN 010 595 721) and STEVEN RAE
File number: QUD 270 of 2009
Judge: COLLIER J
Date of judgment: 11 June 2010
Catchwords:

INDUSTRIAL LAW – application by union seeking declaration and imposition of penalties against employer for contravention of s 340 Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) – employer investigation into incident at mine site – alleged breach of workplace agreement at a meeting related to investigation – whether clause 44 of workplace agreement applied to the meeting – relevance of distinction between investigatory and disciplinary purposes of the meeting – whether clause 44 of workplace agreement meant that human resources staff were excluded from the meeting – whether statements made by mine manager at the meeting constituted adverse action – whether statements made by mine manager injured or altered the position of the employee in his employment or threatened to do so

Held: application dismissed

Legislation: Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 340, 342
Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth)
Cases cited: Employment Advocate v Williamson (2001) 111 FCR 20 cited
Patrick Stevedores Operations No 2 Pty Ltd v Maritime Union of Australia (No 3) (1998) 195 CLR 1 cited
Date of hearing: 29 and 30 March 2010
Place: Brisbane
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 72
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr WL Friend
Solicitor for the Applicant: Hall Payne
Counsel for the First and Second Respondents: Mr A Herbert
Solicitor for the First and Second Respondents: Freehills

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

QUD 270 of 2009

BETWEEN:

CONSTRUCTION, FORESTRY, MINING AND ENERGY UNION
Applicant

AND:

BHP COAL PTY LTD (ACN 010 595 721)
First Respondent

STEVEN RAE
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

COLLIER J

DATE OF ORDER:

11 JUNE 2010

WHERE MADE:

BRISBANE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

The application be dismissed.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
The text of entered orders can be located using Federal Law Search on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

QUD 270 of 2009

BETWEEN:

CONSTRUCTION, FORESTRY, MINING AND ENERGY UNION
Applicant

AND:

BHP COAL PTY LTD (ACN 010 595 721)
First Respondent

STEVEN RAE
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

COLLIER J

DATE:

11 JUNE 2010

PLACE:

BRISBANE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. This case involves, in summary, an interpretation of clause 44 of the BHP Coal Pty Ltd Workplace Agreement 2007 (“clause 44”).

  2. The applicant (“the union”) claims that a meeting called by the first respondent (“BHP Coal”) on 30 October 2009 was pursuant to clause 44, and that according to the terms of clause 44 its member (Mr Chris Lohmann) was entitled to insist on the participation at the meeting of only Mr Lohmann, Mr Lohmann’s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v BHP Coal a... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 590
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union sought a declaration and imposition of penalties against BHP Coal and Steven Rae, for alleged contravention of section 340 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The union alleged that the employer had contravened the law by attending an investigation meeting at the Goonyella Riverside Mine, near Moranbah in central Queensland, where an incident involving an employee had occurred. The union argued that the meeting was a disciplinary meeting under clause 44 of the Workplace Agreement, and that the employer should have excluded human resources staff from the meeting. The union also argued that the mine manager’s statements at the meeting constituted adverse action, which injured or threatened to injure the employee in his employment.

The court found that the meeting in question was not a "clause 44 meeting" as the parties believed, and that clause 44 of the Workplace Agreement did not apply to the meeting. The court found that clause 44 was only relevant to the disciplinary procedure, and that the meeting was an investigatory meeting, not a disciplinary one. The court found that the distinction between investigatory and disciplinary purposes of the meeting was relevant, and that clause 44 did not mean that human resources staff were excluded from the meeting. The court also found that the mine manager’s statements did not constitute adverse action, as they did not injure or threaten to injure the employee in his employment.

The application was dismissed, and the court made no orders for costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

The application be dismissed.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

A threshold issue for determination in these proceedings is whether the meeting of 30 October 2009 was in fact a “clause 44 meeting” as the parties believed, and, if so, what that meant so far as concerned attendance at the meeting.BACKGROUND The relevant background facts to these proceedings are as follows. The Goonyella Riverside Mine near Moranbah in central Queensland (the Mine) is operated by the BHP Billiton Mitsubishi Alliance (BMA). BHP Coal is the employer of staff engaged in the conduct of the Mine. The union and BHP Coal are parties to the BHP Coal Pty Ltd Workplace Agreement 2007 (the Workplace Agreement). Mr Christopher Lohmann and Mr Christopher Sammut were employed by BHP Coal under the terms of the Workplace Agreement to perform work at the Mine. Mr Sammut is a Vice President of the Goonyella Riverside Lodge of the union. On 17 October 2009 at approximately 2.40 pm, Mr Lohmann and two other employees of BHP Coal entered a Hilux Duel Cab Ute at the Mine. Mr Lohmann subsequently drove the vehicle along a road on the mine site towards a reject dump where they were working. Mr Lohmann gave evidence that on the way to the reject dump he unsuccessfully attempted to take a right hand corner in the road. The vehicle rolled over. Fortunately no-one in the vehicle was seriously injured. On 19 October 2009, Mr Lohmann attended a meeting in the preparation plant conference room at the Mine as part of the safety investigation into the incident. It is common ground that other persons attending the meeting were:·Ms Dayle Wilke, a human resources officer;·Mr Peter Anderson, the Mine’s safety manager;·Mr Shawn Classen, the manager of the preparation plant and Mr Lohmann’s supervisor;·Mr Murray Franks, the Mine’s superintendent; and·Mr Ross Ogden, a union lodge check inspector. BHP Coal also claims that Mr Barry Denny, a production coordinator with the Mine, attended the meeting. On 21 October 2009, another meeting was held attended by the same people (although possibly this time excluding Mr Denny), as well as an external investigator, Mr George Foessel. On 22 October 2009, Mr Classen rang Mr Lohmann and requested him to attend a further meeting on 26 October 2009. Mr Lohmann’s evidence was that Mr Classen said words to the following effect:We would like you to come in for a meeting on Monday. The meeting is being held under Clause 44 of the Workplace Agreement and its purpose is to discuss disciplinary action in relation to the accident last Saturday.(affidavit of Christopher Lohmann sworn 16 February 2010 para 31) In comparison, Mr Classen’s evidence was that when he made the telephone call to Mr Lohmann he read from a script prepared for him by Ms Wilke, and that the script said in part:Calling to advise that we would like to meet with him to discuss how his behaviour contributed to the incident that occurred on 17 October 2009.This meeting will be held in accordance with clause 44 of the Workplace Agreement 2007 (disciplinary procedure) and therefore, if you would like, you are invited to arrange for an employee representative to accompany you to this meeting.(affidavit of Shawn Classen affirmed 9 March 2010 paras 28-30)(It is, however, not in dispute that Mr Classen referred to clause 44 in his conversation with Mr Lohmann.)

Decision

Reasons for decision

In my view this meeting was not held in accordance with clause 44.3, and accordingly the identity of personnel in attendance was in no way determined by clause 44.3, which is the only subclause prescribing attendance at meetings. I form this view for the following reasons.1. Framework of the Workplace Agreement so far as concerns clause 44 and the Just Culture Decision Tree (Appendix B) First, it is clear from an examination of clause 44 and the Just Culture Decision Tree (Appendix B) in the Workplace Agreement that these provisions together prescribe a process following the occurrence of an incident which is attributable to human error. It is also clear that the Just Culture Decision Tree specifically provides for categorisation of error – either as intentional or unintentional – and that clause 44.3 lists forms of possible disciplinary approach dependent (in part) upon the categorisation of the error under the Just Culture Decision Tree. More specifically, it is clear that:·Once an incident occurs BHP Coal is required to investigate to determine whether the incident was the result of human error. An incident which is not the result of human error falls outside the scope of either clause 44 or the Just Culture Decision Tree.·When it is clear that the incident is attributable to human error, the Just Culture Decision Tree applies to determine whether the incident was the result of unintentional or intentional human error.·It appears that clause 44.3 is applicable whether the incident arises from intentional or unintentional human error.·If the incident was a result of human error which constitutes serious misconduct, the steps listed in clause 44.3 never become relevant (clause 44.2).·If the incident was a result of human error which did not constitute serious misconduct, then BHP Coal will consider the error together with the particular circumstances and severity of each case. It will then determine the appropriate step/s to be taken with respect to an employee in accordance with clause 44.3.·Clause 44.3 describes four steps in a disciplinary procedure. Three of those steps include counselling and a meeting at which the counselling is delivered. Step 4 simply provides for the taking of disciplinary action commensurate with the severity and/or frequency of the act/s of misconduct.·Clause 44.3 appears to contemplate that more than one of the steps listed in that subclause can be taken in appropriate circumstances. So, for example, it is possible within the scope of clause 44.3 in response to conduct of an employee that BHP Coal could issue a final warning to the employee (step 3) and discipline the employee otherwise than through the counselling measures in steps 1-3 (step 4).·Not all steps in clause 44.3 contemplate meetings. Step 4 in clause 44.3, for example, contemplates the imposition of discipline without the occurrence of a meeting. From this analysis, it is clear that the steps in clause 44.3 only become relevant when:·It is clear that an incident was the result of human error; and·It is clear that an incident does not give rise to serious misconduct by the employee.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the Workplace Agreement and the Just Culture Decision Tree to determine the applicability of clause 44 to the meeting in question. Clause 44 outlines a process following an incident attributable to human error, with specific steps listed in subclause 44.3. However, the court found that the meeting did not adhere to the requirements of clause 44.3, as the incident did not constitute serious misconduct, and the steps outlined in clause 44.3 did not apply to the meeting. The court further clarified that clause 44.3 only becomes relevant when an incident is the result of human error and does not give rise to serious misconduct by the employee.

The distinction between investigatory and disciplinary purposes was also considered, with the court concluding that the meeting did not strictly follow the disciplinary process outlined in clause 44. Human resources staff were not excluded from the meeting as per clause 44, as the court found that the clause did not determine attendance at the meeting. Statements made by the mine manager at the meeting were not deemed adverse action, as they were part of the investigation into the incident and did not injure or alter the position of the employee in his employment or threaten to do so. The application was dismissed as a result of these findings.