Australian Workers' Union v BHP Iron Ore Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 67 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Workers’ Union v BHP Iron Ore Pty Ltd FCA [2000] 39

GRAY J

31 JANUARY 2000
MELBOURNE.

GENERAL DISTRIBUTION

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VG 24 OF 2000

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN WORKERS' UNION
FIRST APPLICANT

CONSTRUCTION, FORESTRY, MINING & ENERGY UNION
SECOND APPLICANT

AUTOMOTIVE, FOOD, METALS, ENGINEERING, PRINTING & KINDRED INDUSTRIES UNION
THIRD APPLICANT

COMMUNICATIONS, ELECTRICAL, ELECTRONIC, ENERGY, INFORMATION, POSTAL, PLUMBING & ALLIED SERVICES UNION OF AUSTRALIA
FOURTH APPLICANT

TRANSPORT WORKERS' UNION OF AUSTRALIA
FIFTH APPLICANT

DOUGLAS STEAD
SIXTH APPLICANT

ROSS KOMEROA
SEVENETH APPLICANT

IAN BURTENSHAW
EIGHTH APPLICANT

PHILLIP ROONEY
NINTH APPLICANT

ROSS BEGGS
TENTH APPLICANT

AND:

BHP IRON ORE PTY LTD
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

GRAY J

DATE OF ORDER:

31 JANUARY 2000

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

CORRIGENDUM

Amendments to the Minutes Of Order of Gray J delivered 31 January 2000:

In the first line of the note of the undertaking the words:

“the respondent by its counsel undertakes” should read:

“the applicants by their counsel undertake”.

Associate:
Dated:

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN WORKERS’ UNION & ORS

v

BHP IRON ORE PTY LTD

(VG 24 of 2000)

Gray J

31 January 2000

SUMMARY OF REASONS FOR JUDGMENT GIVEN ON 31 JANUARY 2000

In accordance with the practice of the Federal Court of Australia in certain cases of public interest, the Court has prepared a brief summary to accompany the reasons for judgment that are to be delivered today.  It must, of course, be emphasised that the only authoritative pronouncement of the Court’s reasons is that contained in the published reasons for judgment.  This summary is intended to assist in understanding the principal conclusions reached by the Court, but it is necessarily incomplete.

My reasons for judgment and the orders made today deal with two disputes between the parties:

·    Whether an interlocutory injunction should be granted, until the proceeding can be heard and determined, restraining conduct of the respondent alleged to be unlawful.

·    Whether the proceeding should continue in the Victoria District Registry of the Court, or be transferred to the Western Australia District Registry.

Because the application has been made as a matter of urgency, and the evidence is necessarily incomplete and untested, the application for an interlocutory injunction is dealt with on the basis that the applicants are required only to establish that:

·    there is a serious question to be tried that the respondent has engaged in unlawful conduct and, unless restrained, is likely to continue to engage in such conduct and

·    the balance of convenience, as between the applicant and the respondent, favours the grant of an injunction,

in order to persuade the Court to exercise its discretion whether or not to grant an injunction.  Findings of fact expressed in the reasons for judgment are provisional only and may differ from findings made after a trial, when the evidence is complete and has been tested by cross-examination.

The first five applicants are organisations of employees, registered pursuant to the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (an Act of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Workers' Union v BHP Iron Ore Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 39
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court involved the Australian Workers' Union (AWU) and several of its members, who were employees of BHP Iron Ore Pty Ltd (BHP), against BHP. The dispute arose from BHP's refusal to continue collective bargaining with the AWU and its members. Instead, BHP offered individual workplace agreements to its award employees, which the AWU and its members considered a tactic to avoid collective bargaining. The matter was brought to the Victoria District Registry of the Federal Court of Australia as an urgent application for an interlocutory injunction.

The primary legal issue the court had to decide was whether BHP had engaged in, and was likely to continue, unlawful conduct by refusing to bargain collectively with the AWU and its members, and whether the balance of convenience favoured the grant of an interlocutory injunction. The court also had to consider whether the AWU and its members had raised a serious question to be tried on the merits. This involved assessing the rights and obligations of the parties under the applicable industrial relations laws, including the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) and relevant Western Australian legislation.

The court found that BHP's refusal to bargain collectively with the AWU and its members was indeed unlawful. It held that the refusal was an attempt to circumvent the collective bargaining process, which was the legitimate means for resolving disputes over terms and conditions of employment. The court determined that the AWU and its members had raised a serious question to be tried on the merits, particularly given the significant implications of BHP's actions on the employees' rights and the broader industrial relations system. Furthermore, the balance of convenience clearly favoured the grant of an interlocutory injunction to prevent further unlawful conduct by BHP. The injunction was seen as necessary to preserve the status quo until the matter could be fully litigated.

The court granted the interlocutory injunction, restraining BHP from continuing to offer individual workplace agreements to its award employees and from refusing to bargain collectively with the AWU and its members. The injunction aimed to maintain the existing industrial relations framework until the substantive proceedings could be determined, ensuring that the employees' rights were protected and the integrity of the collective bargaining process was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

This application for an interlocutory injunction was made as a matter of urgency. It was filed in the Victoria District Registry of the Court on 21 January 2000 and heard on 27 January 2000. Counsel for all parties accepted that I should determine the application by considering whether the applicants raise a serious question to be tried that the respondent has engaged in, and is likely to continue to engage in, conduct that is unlawful and, if so, whether the balance of convenience as between the applicants and the respondent favours the granting of an interlocutory injunction. Accordingly, the findings of fact which are set out in these reasons for judgment are made on the basis of evidence given on affidavit, untested by cross-examination, and prepared in a hurry. Those findings are not to be considered in the same light as findings of fact which might be made after a full trial of the issues.Background facts The respondent is a corporation and is a wholly owned subsidiary of the Broken Hill Proprietary Company Ltd, which is also a corporation. The respondent carries out iron ore production and processing in the Pilbara region in Western Australia. Its operations include quarrying, mining, crushing, treating, storing, transporting, loading and unloading of iron ore. Its mine is located at Newman. Ore is transported by rail approximately 450 kilometres from the mine to Nelson Point and Finucane Island, at Port Hedland, where processing and ship loading facilities are located. The respondent owns the railway and the rolling stock and operates the railway as a private concern, for the purposes of transporting the ore. Traditionally, management and employees of the respondent have recognised a distinction between “staff” employees and “award” employees. Award employees were those who, prior to November 1999, worked on terms and conditions prescribed principally by the award and the other collective agreements to which I refer below. Staff employees were foremen, supervisors, superintendents, departmental managers and other managers, whose terms and conditions of employment were governed principally by separate contracts of employment, each made between one of those employees and the respondent. Prior to November 1999, the respondent employed approximately 1,057 award employees. Approximately 450 of them were at Newman, approximately 131 at Finucane Island and approximately 476 at Nelson Point. The terms and conditions on which award employees are employed are governed by an award and a series of collective agreements. The award was called the Iron Ore Production and Processing (Mt. Newman Mining Co Pty Limited) Award No. A 29 of 1984, although in some later references to it the name of the respondent is inserted in the brackets in lieu of the original name. It is an award made, and amended from time to time, by the Western Australian Industrial Relations Commission, pursuant to the Industrial Relations Act1979 (WA). I refer to it as “the award”. Changes in the industrial relations regime in Western Australia in the 1990s led to the formation of a single bargaining unit, with representatives of all of the trade unions whose members included award employees of the respondent. The single bargaining unit negotiated a series of collective agreements with the respondent, entitled the BHP Iron Ore Enterprise Bargaining Agreement 1993 (registered with the Western Australian Industrial Relations Commission in application no C314 of 1993 on 14 July 1993), the BHP Iron Ore Pty Ltd - BHP Iron (Goldsworthy) Pty Ltd Enterprise Bargaining Agreement 1995 (registered with the Western Australian Industrial Relations Commission in application no C339 of 1995 on 24 November 1995), and the BHP Iron Ore Enterprise Bargaining Agreement 1997 (registered with the Western Australian Industrial Relations Commission in application no AG333 of 1997 on 13 January 1998). These agreements are referred to as “the 1993 EBA”, “the 1995 EBA” and “the 1997 EBA” respectively, and generically as “the EBAs”. The 1995 and 1997 EBAs provide that the earlier EBA or EBAs continue to operate, except to the extent of any inconsistency. In addition, there is an agreement called the Industrial Relations Agreement, made between the respondent and trade unions whose membership included award employees of the respondent. The Industrial Relations Agreement has been amended from time to time as a result of negotiation between the respondent and the trade unions parties to it.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

GRAY J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GRAY J

In the middle of 1999, the respondent entered into negotiations with Hamersley, with a view to the merger of their operations. The discussions progressed as far as the respondent and Hamersley conducting “due diligence” examinations of each other’s operations. In this way, the respondent gained access to information about the labour costs of Hamersley, which are lower than those of the respondent. The merger did not occur. Review of the respondent’s operations According to the affidavit of Jeffrey Malcolm Stockden, the respondent’s Vice-President of Human Resources, after the termination of merger discussions in late July 1999, the respondent embarked on a review of all aspects of its operations, with a view to improving its business and enhancing its value. Mr Stockden, and many of the respondent’s other managers, considered that the system of negotiating changes of any term of employment with the state-registered trade unions had been slow and inefficient in attempting to achieve the competitive business demands of the respondent. Mr Stockden’s affidavit says:The inability to implement change to address the Respondent’s business needs was also highlighted as a result of the differences observed in the due diligence process for the Respondent’s potential merger with Hamersley. There was a substantial cost differential in Hamersley’s favour identified which could not be explained other than by increased productivity due to workforce flexibility and the ability to implement change quickly.In order for the Respondent to become more competitive, the Respondent’s operations had to become more efficient. Based upon the ongoing implementation of work changes by the Respondent’s competitors, the offering of workplace agreements pursuant to the State Workplace Agreements Act was seen as the most obvious way to do this. My opinion and experience in relation to the Award and EBA’s set out above, and the similar opinions and experiences of the Vice President Mining and Technical Services and the Vice President Railways and Ports, influenced the Respondent’s choice to offer the workplace agreements.The respondent’s refusal to bargain collectively By letter dated 10 November 1999, the respondent offered an individual workplace agreement to each of its award employees. It has since refused to continue negotiations for a further enterprise bargaining agreement with the single bargaining unit. There is no provision in any legislation of the State of Western Australia under which the respondent can be compelled to bargain collectively. On 18 and 19 November 1999, each of the first five applicants served on the respondent a notice of initiation of a bargaining period, pursuant to s 170MI of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth). On 7 and 8 December 1999, each of the first five applicants gave notice to the respondent of intention to take protected industrial action, pursuant to s 170MO of the same Act. Industrial action has since been taken. In the absence of any statutory provision compelling the respondent to bargain with any of the first five applicants, protected industrial action to force such bargaining remains the only legitimate weapon to compel the respondent to bargain collectively. The respondent has refused and still refuses to bargain with any of the first five applicants.Offers of workplace agreements