Elliott v Kodak Australasia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Elliott v Kodak Australasia Pty Ltd (ACN 004 057 621) [2001] FCA 807

INDUSTRIAL LAW – Redundancy – Whether redundancy in breach of ss 298K and 298L of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) – Whether employee dismissed because he was a union delegate - Meaning of delegate under ss 298L(1)(a) and 298(1)(n) of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) – Whether redundancy selection criteria inherently biased against employee in role as delegate - Whether employee dismissed because he was a member of a union – Whether the contract between the employer and the employee had been terminated – Whether reasonable notice was given

Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) Pt XA, ss 298K, 298L, 298T, 298V
Photographic Industry (Kodak) Australasian Manufacturing and Distribution Award 1990
Commonwealth Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1904 (Cth)
Commonwealth Conciliation and Arbitration Act (No 2) 1914 (Cth)
Commonwealth Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1920 (Cth)
Commonwealth Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1947 (Cth)
Commonwealth Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1973 (Cth)
Industrial Relations Act 1988 (Cth)

Pearce v W D Peacock and Co (1917) 23 CLR 199 referred to
National Union of Workers v Qenos Pty Ltd [2001] FCA 178 considered
Plumton v Cathay Hotel Pty Ltd (1987) 21 IR 410 considered
Cuevas v Freeman Motors Pty Ltd (1975) 25 FLR 67, 8 ALR 321 considered
Stapleton v African Lion Safari Pty Ltd  (1982) 65 FLR 61 considered
Australian Municipal, Administrative, Clerical and Services Union v Ansett Australia Ltd [2000] FCA 441, (2000) 175 ALR 173 at [59] referred to
Kenefick v Australian Submarine Corporation (1995) 62 IR 107 at 117- 118 referred to
Ralph v Fortis Australia Ltd (Australian Industrial Relations Commission, Commissioner Smith, 14 December 2000, T4482) referred to
Community and Public Sector Union v Telstra Corporation Ltd [2001] FCA 267 compared
Byrne v Australian Airlines (1995) 185 CLR 410 considered
Brackenridge v Toyota Motor Corporation Australia Ltd (1996) 67 IR 162 followed
Australian National Hotels Pty Ltd v Jager (2000) 9 TasR 153, [2000] TASSC 43 cited
Brackenridge v Toyota Motor Corporation Australia Ltd (1996) 142 ALR 99 referred to
Quinn v Jack Chia (Australia) Ltd (1991) 43 IR 91 at 103 referred to

Macken, McCarry & Sappideen The Law of Employment 4th ed. 1997 at 166 - 167

JOHN ELLIOTT & AUSTRALIAN LIQUOR, HOSPITALITY AND MISCELLANEOUS WORKERS' UNION v KODAK AUSTRALASIA PTY LTD (ACN 004 057 621)

V 513 OF 2000

MARSHALL J
MELBOURNE
29 JUNE 2001

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

V 513 OF 2000

BETWEEN:

JOHN ELLIOTT
FIRST APPLICANT

AUSTRALIAN LIQUOR, HOSPITALITY AND MISCELLANEOUS WORKERS' UNION
SECOND APPLICANT

AND:

KODAK AUSTRALASIA PTY LTD (ACN 004 057 621)
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

MARSHALL J

DATE OF ORDER:

29 JUNE 2001

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.        The application be dismissed.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

V 513 OF 2000

BETWEEN:

JOHN ELLIOTT

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Elliott v Kodak Australasia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] FCA 807
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Elliott v Kodak Australasia Pty Ltd, the applicant, Mr Elliott, sought to challenge the redundancy selection process undertaken by the respondent, Kodak, in relation to his employment. Mr Elliott was employed by Kodak at its Coburg site and had been a delegate for the LHMU union for some time before he was made redundant in June 2000. Mr Elliott argued that he was selected for redundancy because of his role as a union delegate and in breach of the terms of the applicable industrial instruments. The primary legal issue before the court was whether Kodak had complied with the applicable industrial instruments when selecting Mr Elliott for redundancy. Specifically, the court needed to determine whether Kodak had genuinely applied relevant selection criteria when selecting employees for redundancy and whether there was any bias against Mr Elliott because of his union activities.

The court found that Kodak had applied the selection criteria in a manner consistent with the applicable industrial instruments. The court held that the process by which Kodak assessed employees for redundancy was objective and that there was no evidence of bias against Mr Elliott due to his union activities. The court noted that while the selection criteria were subjective, there was no evidence that the process was inherently biased against union delegates. The court also found that Kodak had followed the necessary procedures in selecting employees for redundancy, including consulting with relevant supervisors and obtaining the approval of the General Manager.

Consequently, the court dismissed Mr Elliott's application. The court held that Kodak had discharged the onus of proving that the selection criteria were applied genuinely and that there was no bias against Mr Elliott because of his union activities. The court also found that the decision-making process was fair and in accordance with the applicable industrial instruments.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The matter was heard over a number of days in late February and late March 2001. Mr Mark Irving of counsel appeared for the applicants. Mr Michael McDonald of counsel appeared for the respondent. 1. FACTUAL BACKGROUND Mr Elliott commenced employment with Kodak in November 1982 at its Coburg site. There are approximately 500 employees engaged in manufacturing at this site. Mr Elliott was involved in the dispersion area (which involves the mixing of chemicals for the treatment of photo paper) and worked in Building 2. The terms and conditions of Mr Elliott’s employment were regulated by the Photographic Industry (Kodak) Australasian Manufacturing and Distribution Award 1990 (“the award”) and the Kodak Australasia Pty Ltd Manufacturing Operations 2000 Enterprise Bargaining Agreement. Soon after commencing employment with Kodak, Mr Elliott became a member of the LHMU. The LHMU has a strong presence at Kodak with nearly 100% membership in its areas of coverage at the Coburg site. Within each building at the Coburg site there may be two or more delegates to represent different shifts, or different areas of work. There is also a site delegate, who at all material times was Spiros Vasilakis. In April 1999 Mr Elliott was elected, unopposed, by members of LHMU in Building 2 as the delegate for the dispersion area. At the same time, Mr Hall was elected as the delegate for the emulsions section in Building 2 and Mr Burns was elected as the delegate for chemical preparations section in Building 2Mr Elliott’s Activism The terms and conditions of Mr Elliott’s employment were regulated by the Photographic Industry (Kodak) Australasian Manufacturing and Distribution Award 1990 (“the award”) and by the Kodak Australasia Pty Ltd Manufacturing Operations 2000 Enterprise Bargaining Agreement (“the EBA”). Mr Elliott gave evidence that prior to his election as a delegate he was active in pursuing numerous complaints about industrial issues on behalf of himself and others with whom he worked. Those issues included various health and safety issues and matters connected to the introduction of 12 hour shifts. After becoming a union delegate Mr Elliott was involved in several industrial issues that affected LHMU members in the dispersion section. Those issues included the following:· the payment of overtime rates for the working of an extra shift from August 1999· changing the way “improvement time” was scheduled· shift changes in November/December 1999· shift changes in February 2000 and the ensuing payment of an additional loading of 3.57% of employees in the dispersion section· the introduction of new solvent· the provision of a female toilet in the section· discussions in April/May 2000 about further shift changes It is generally accepted that Mr Elliott was an active delegate, who had considerable success in issues he had been involved in negotiating. Mr Elliott was also involved in other issues that were more concerned with conflict between different sections of the workforce rather than conflict between employee and management interests. Those issues included:· problems with chemical preparations section employees, including:Ø the transfer of gel barrelsØ confrontations with Mr Burns and with Ms Gillies, the Supervisor for the chemical preparations section· problems with an industrial chemist, Mr Guinea

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 21 June 2000, the rankings were discussed with Mr Walshe. Mr Walshe was at all material times the General Manager of Kodak’s Coburg operations. He was the person with the ultimate authority to terminate the employment of employees. Mr Walshe suggested a change in one of Mr Elliott’s scores, which reduced his overall score, but made no difference to his selection for redundancy.Mr Lay’s Evidence Mr Lay is employed by Kodak as its Operations Manager in Compress Manufacturing Color Paper Flow (Building 2). He commenced in that position in March 2000 but has been continually employed by Kodak since January 1990. He was at all material times responsible for the operations in Building 2 at Kodak’s Coburg plant. Mr Lay gave detailed evidence in which he described the process he and Mr Shannon went through in ranking the employees. Mr Lay gave evidence that by 8 June 2000 he and Mr Shannon had ranked the twenty-three employees into four groups for the purposes of the criteria. He said:“Each employee received a rating of either 0, 3, 6 or 9 against each criteria depending on which 4 groups they fell into. A score of 0 simply meant that a person ranked in the lowest of the 4 groups. For example, a score of 0 for teamwork meant that a person ranked in lowest of the four groups for teamwork, not that the person had no teamwork skills.” Mr Lay added that:“We worked through the process by criteria rather than by person as we thought this would make the process more objective. We did not know a person’s total score or ranking until after that meeting - I added up the scores after the meeting. We also got to compare everyone at once against the one criteria. I thought that this made the process more ‘blind’. The aim was to have the scores against each criteria (sic) equally spread, but if it was apparent that a particular employee did not fit into a particular rating, we did not force them into that rating.” In the period 8 June 2000 to 15 June 2000 it became known to Mr Lay that Mr Elliott was likely to receive a score which would make him liable to be made redundant. It was also known by Mr Lay that Mr Elliott would be likely to be the only employee to be made redundant against his will. Therefore, in the period 8 June to 15 June 2000, Mr Lay compiled a series of file notes dealing with incidents relevant to Mr Elliott’s low score. No file notes were made in relation to other employees but it was clear that Mr Elliott was the only person likely to be made redundant who may challenge his selection either in the Australian Industrial Relations Commission or in this Court. Mr Lay went to some lengths to attempt to justify the scores given to Mr Elliott. It is not for the Court to examine in detail and evaluate the scores given so as to sit as a defacto appellant tribunal reviewing the scores given to employees. It is the function of the Court to consider whether, on the evidence as a whole, Kodak has discharged the onus imposed on it by s298V of the Act.

Decision

Reasons for decision

MARSHALL J
Although, as noted above, I have general reservations about subjective selection criteria, I do not consider that in this particular instance the selection criteria was inherently biased against Mr Elliott in his role as a union delegate or union delegates in general. 2.4 THE DECISION MAKING PROCESS The input of each of the respondent’s witnesses into the decision making process differs considerably. Mr Lay and Mr Shannon played a fundamental role in that they were in charge of applying the selection criteria and allocating the initial scores to employees. Mr Lay and Mr Shannon were pivotal in allocating Mr Elliott the score he received that ultimately led to his redundancy. After allocating the initial scores Mr Lay and Mr Shannon met with Mr Thompson and Ms Gillies to discuss the ranking of the employees, given that each of the supervisors had a different understanding of the capacities of certain employees. After consultation with Mr Thompson and Ms Gillies, one change was made to the score of an employee other than Mr Elliott. Mr Lay asked Mr McGowan to review the ranking. Mr McGowan had managed the dispersion section prior to Mr Lay taking on that role. Mr McGowan agreed that Mr Elliott and four others, whom he knew, should be retrenched. On 21 June 2000, the rankings were discussed with Mr Walshe. Mr Walshe was at all material times the General Manager of Kodak’s Coburg operations. He was the person with the ultimate authority to terminate the employment of employees. Mr Walshe suggested a change in one of Mr Elliott’s scores, which reduced his overall score, but made no difference to his selection for redundancy.Mr Lay’s Evidence Mr Lay is employed by Kodak as its Operations Manager in Compress Manufacturing Color Paper Flow (Building 2). He commenced in that position in March 2000 but has been continually employed by Kodak since January 1990. He was at all material times responsible for the operations in Building 2 at Kodak’s Coburg plant. Mr Lay gave detailed evidence in which he described the process he and Mr Shannon went through in ranking the employees. Mr Lay gave evidence that by 8 June 2000 he and Mr Shannon had ranked the twenty-three employees into four groups for the purposes of the criteria. He said:“Each employee received a rating of either 0, 3, 6 or 9 against each criteria depending on which 4 groups they fell into. A score of 0 simply meant that a person ranked in the lowest of the 4 groups. For example, a score of 0 for teamwork meant that a person ranked in lowest of the four groups for teamwork, not that the person had no teamwork skills.” Mr Lay added that:“We worked through the process by criteria rather than by person as we thought this would make the process more objective. We did not know a person’s total score or ranking until after that meeting - I added up the scores after the meeting. We also got to compare everyone at once against the one criteria. I thought that this made the process more ‘blind’. The aim was to have the scores against each criteria (sic) equally spread, but if it was apparent that a particular employee did not fit into a particular rating, we did not force them into that rating.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MARSHALL J

Full text does not contain this section.