Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd v Mashaghati

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Allianz Australia Insurance Limited v Mashaghati [2017] QCA 127

PARTIES:

ALLIANZ AUSTRALIA INSURANCE LIMITED
ABN 15 000 122 850
(appellant/cross respondent)
v
MEHRANG MASHAGHATI
(respondent/cross appellant)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 11149 of 2016
DC No 1540 of 2016

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

General Civil Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:


District Court at Brisbane – [2016] QDC 245

DELIVERED ON:

9 June 2017

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

20 April 2017

JUDGES:

Sofronoff P and McMurdo JA and Applegarth J
Separate reasons for judgment of each member of the Court, each concurring as to the orders made

ORDERS:

1.   Appeal allowed.

2.   Orders of the District Court made on 29 September 2016 be set aside.

3.   Cross-appeal dismissed.

4.   Order that there be a retrial.

5.   The respondent to pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal and the cross-appeal.

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – NEW TRIAL – IN GENERAL AND PARTICULAR GROUNDS – PARTICULAR GROUNDS – IMPROPER ADMISSION OR REJECTION OF EVIDENCE – WHEN NEW TRIAL GRANTED – where the respondent was injured in a motor vehicle accident for which the appellant admitted liability – where the respondent instructed two medical experts to observe the trial – where the respondent tendered fresh reports written by these experts midway through the trial – where the appellant objected to the admission of these fresh reports – where the trial judge admitted these reports into evidence at the trial – where these reports were relied upon by the trial judge in evaluating quantum – where the appellant claims that the admission of these reports midway through the trial was unfair

Rules of the Supreme Court 1900 (Qld), r 29A, r 29B, r 29C, r 29D, r 29E
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules
1999 (Qld), r 5, r 423, r 426, r 427, r 429, r 429B, r 550, r 551, r 552, r 553, r 554, r 547, r 548, r 549

AON Risk Services Australia Limited v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175; [2009] HCA 27, applied
Campbell v Jones
[2003] 1 Qd R 630; [2002] QCA 332, applied
International Finance Trust Co Ltd v NSW Crime Commission (2009) 240 CLR 319; [2009] HCA 49, applied
Jones v National Coal Board [1957] 2 QB 55; [1957] EWCA Civ 3, applied
Parr v Bavarian Steak House Pty Ltd
[2001] 2 Qd R 196; [2000] QCA 429, approved
Stead v State Government Insurance Commission (1986) 161 CLR 141; [1986] HCA 54, applied

COUNSEL:

G F Crow QC for the appellant/cross respondent
K C Fleming QC for the respondent/cross appellant

SOLICITORS:

McInnes Wilson for the appellant/cross respondent
Bennett & Philp for the respondent/cross appellant

  1. SOFRONOFF P:  On the night of 1 May 2011 the respondent, a man then in his mid-thirties, was riding his motorcycle eastbound on Wynnum Road.  The first defendant in the proceeding, who took no part at the trial or on the appeal, was driving her car in the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd v Mashaghati and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] QCA 127
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd sought to appeal against a decision of the District Court of New South Wales which had found for the respondent, Mashaghati, in a motor accident personal injury claim. The appellant admitted liability for the accident but contested the amount of damages awarded. The respondent had tendered fresh expert evidence midway through the trial, which the appellant claimed was unfair and prejudicial, warranting a new trial. The court was required to decide whether the admission of the fresh expert evidence midway through the trial was so unfair as to warrant a new trial. The court also needed to consider the effect of the failure to disclose the expert evidence in accordance with the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW).

The court found that the trial judge had exercised a discretion in admitting the fresh expert evidence, but had done so without consideration of the appellant's submissions. The court held that the trial judge should have considered whether the admission of the fresh evidence was unfair, and whether it was in the interests of justice to admit the evidence. The court found that the appellant had been unfairly prejudiced by the admission of the fresh evidence, and that it was in the interests of justice to order a new trial. The court noted that the evidence was relevant and important to the respondent’s claim, but that the late disclosure had caused significant prejudice to the appellant, who had been unable to adequately respond to the evidence. The court held that the appellant’s right to a fair trial had been compromised, and that a new trial was necessary to remedy this. The court also noted that the trial judge had relied upon the fresh evidence in evaluating quantum, which further supported the grant of a new trial.

The appeal was allowed and the orders of the District Court were set aside. The court ordered that there be a retrial of the matter. The respondent was ordered to pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal and the cross-appeal. The court emphasised the importance of adherence to the disclosure requirements of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) and the need for courts to ensure that trials are fair and just. The court held that the admission of fresh expert evidence midway through a trial is a serious matter, and that the court must carefully consider whether such admission is fair and in the interests of justice.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed.

2. Orders of the District Court made on 29 September 2016 be set aside.

3. Cross-appeal dismissed.

4. Order that there be a retrial.

5. The respondent to pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal and the cross-appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Consistently with the objective of the Rules to avoid undue delay, expense and technicality, rule 429 requires expert reports to be disclosed between parties within the time limits established by that rule by one party to the others. In the case of a plaintiff, this must be done within 90 days after the close of pleading and, in the case of a defendant, within 120 days after the close of pleading. In the case of parties who are neither a plaintiff nor a defendant, disclosure must be made within 90 days after the close of pleading for that party. Rule 427 provides as follows:“427 Expert evidence(1)Subject to subrule (4), an expert may give evidence-in-chief in a proceeding only by a report.(2)The report may be tendered as evidence only if —(a)the report has been disclosed as required under rule 429; or(b)the court gives leave.(3)Any party to the proceeding may tender as evidence at the trial any expert’s report disclosed by any party, subject to producing the expert for cross-examination if required.(4)Oral evidence-in-chief may be given by an expert only—(a)in response to the report of another expert; or(b)if directed to issues that first emerged in the course of the trial; or(c)if the court gives leave.” Rule 429B empowers the court to direct experts to meet in order to identify matters upon which they agree or disagree and in order to attempt to resolve any disagreement. It can be seen that these Rules, in combination, are directed towards early and full disclosure of expert evidence in order to assist in achieving either an early settlement of the claim that is the subject of the proceedings or, if that cannot be done, then an efficient trial in which the parties and the Court can concentrate upon the essential issues only. Tactical surprise is thus avoided. On the other hand, relevant expert evidence which has not been dealt with in accordance with the Rules may still be admitted in evidence if the interests of justice in ensuring a fair trial require it. The power of the Court to grant leave to a party to tender a non-compliant report or to permit oral evidence to be given by an expert is unfettered by any express provision of the Rules. However, the discretion is informed by the purpose of the Rules set out in rule 5, namely to facilitate the just and expeditious resolution of the real issues in civil proceedings at a minimum of expense. The discretion is also informed by rule 5(2) which obliges the Court to apply the Rules with the objective of avoiding undue delay, expense and technicality. Of course, these express provisions which guide the Court in the exercise of discretion are subject to the overarching obligation of the Court to ensure that a trial is fair. Unlike the general provisions of Part 5 of Chapter 11, Part 2 of Chapter 14 is concerned specifically with proceedings for damages for personal injury or death. Rule 547 provides, relevantly:“547 Plaintiff’s statement of loss and damage(1)The plaintiff must serve on the defendant a written statement of loss and damage, signed by the plaintiff, within 28 days after the close of pleadings.(2)The statement must be served before a request for trial date is filed.(3)The statement must have the following information – …(f)the documents in the possession or under the control of the plaintiff about the plaintiff’s injury, loss (including economic loss) or treatment …”

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.