Western Park Village Ltd v Baho

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV 2012-404-2727 [2013] NZHC 1909

BETWEEN  WESTERN PARK VILLAGE LIMITED Plaintiff

ANDSINAN ABED BAHO Defendant

DARRYLL LAWRENCE HEAVEN First Counterclaim Defendant

EVELYN HEAVEN
Second Counterclaim Defendant

TRUSTEE MANAGEMENT LTD Third Counterclaim Defendant

Hearing:                   29, 30 and 31 July 2013

Counsel:                  D Chesterman for Plaintiff/Counterclaim Defendants

J E M Lethbridge for Defendant/Counterclaimant

Judgment:                31 July 2013

JUDGMENT OF HEATH J

This judgment was delivered by me on 31 July 2013 at 2.00pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

WESTERN PARK VILLAGE LIMITED v BAHO [2013] NZHC 1909 [31 July 2013]

Introduction

[1]      Western Park Village Ltd (Western Park) bought a residential unit from Mr Baho in May 2007.  It was situated at 4/30 Augustus Terrace, Parnell and was part of a unit title complex, known as the Augustus Apartments.

[2]      During the course of pre-contractual negotiations, the director of Western Park, Mr Heaven, says that he asked Mr Baho whether “there were any problems or issues with the unit” that he “should know about”.  Mr Heaven alleges that Mr Baho told him that the only problem involved minor leaks on one wall that would be repaired through an insurance payment from his insurer.  Mr Heaven says that Mr Baho omitted to tell him that the Body Corporate of the Augustus Apartments was being sued in nuisance for removal of rock and debris that had fallen from a cliff on the Body Corporate’s grounds.  Mr Heaven complains that Mr Baho should have told him about both the rock fall that had led to the dispute between the two body corporates and the nuisance claim itself.

[3]      On various legal bases, Western Park sues Mr Baho.  It seeks cancellation of the agreement for sale and purchase and consequential orders designed to put the parties back into the position they would have been at the time the agreement was signed.  The consequential orders involve discharging a second mortgage in favour of Mr Baho that was entered into to secure the vendor finance needed to enable Western Park to complete the purchase.  Mr Baho counterclaims to seek repayment of moneys that he contends are owing under the mortgage granted in his favour.

Objection to supplementary evidence in chief

[4]      At  the  commencement  of  the  trial,  Ms  Lethbridge,  for  Mr  Baho,  took objection to the evidence of two expert witnesses whom the Western Park interests intended to call.  Supplementary written statements had been served shortly before the hearing.   The two witnesses are an engineer, Mr Luxford, and a valuer, Mr Cheyne.

[5]      Mr  Chesterman,  for  the  Western  Park  interests,  submits  that  the  two

witnesses  are  required  to  reply  to  a  written  statement  tendered  by  Mr  Baho’s

valuation expert, Mr Taylor.  An engineer needs to give evidence, Mr Chesterman contends,  because  Mr Taylor  has  strayed  into  areas  outside his  expertise  and  a response from a properly qualified expert is required.   Mr Cheyne’s evidence is a response to Mr Taylor’s criticisms of the valuation…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Western Park Village Ltd v Baho and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 1909
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand was asked to determine whether supplementary evidence from two expert witnesses should be admitted in the case of Western Park Village Limited v Baho. Western Park Village Ltd had purchased a residential unit from Mr Baho in 2007 and alleged that he had failed to disclose material information about the property. They sought to admit supplementary evidence from an engineer, Mr Luxford, and a valuer, Mr Cheyne, to counter evidence from Mr Baho’s valuation expert, Mr Taylor. Mr Baho objected to the admission of this evidence, arguing that it was submitted too late and would prejudice the trial. The court was required to decide whether the supplementary evidence should be admitted under Rule 9.8 of the High Court Rules, which gives the trial judge discretion to allow supplementary evidence if it is in the interests of justice. The court found that while Mr Taylor’s evidence on engineering issues was not admissible, his valuation evidence was permissible and could be used to establish the factual foundation for his opinion. However, the court did not find that Mr Luxford’s evidence was necessary to respond to Mr Taylor’s evidence. On the other hand, the court found that Mr Cheyne’s evidence was necessary to provide an independent source to test the valuation methodology employed by Mr Morley, which had been challenged by Mr Baho. The court exercised its discretion under Rule 9.8 and allowed Mr Cheyne’s evidence to be admitted but refused to admit Mr Luxford’s evidence.
The court held that the supplementary evidence of Mr Luxford would not be admitted as Mr Taylor’s evidence, although not qualified as an expert in engineering, was admissible for valuation purposes only. Therefore, there was no need for Mr Luxford to provide a reply to Mr Taylor’s evidence. In contrast, the court held that the supplementary evidence of Mr Cheyne was necessary to provide an independent source to test the valuation methodology employed by Mr Morley, which had been challenged by Mr Baho. The court found that it was fair to admit Mr Cheyne’s evidence in order to provide an independent source from which the methodology might be tested. The court exercised its discretion under Rule 9.8 and allowed Mr Cheyne’s evidence to be admitted but refused to admit Mr Luxford’s evidence.