Body Corporate 406198 v Argon Construction Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2017-404-001772

[2023] NZHC 1072

IN THE MATTER OF The Bianco Apartments

BETWEEN

BODY CORPORATE 406198 & HHTS LIMITED & ORS

Plaintiffs

AND

ARGON CONSTRUCTION LIMITED & ORS

Defendants

CALLANDER ELECTRICS LIMITED & ORS

Third Parties

PACIFIC CONSULTANTS BUILDING ENGINEERS LIMITED

(DISCONTINUED) & ORS

Fourth Parties

Hearing: 2 May 2023

Appearances:

D R Bigio KC, I J Stephenson, R D Butler and H Chung for Plaintiffs

W A McCartney and D A Cowan for First Defendant

S C Price, M J Ferrier and C M Fairnie for Second Defendant D W Grove for Fifth Defendant and Second Third Party (HW Coyle)

R J Latton for Sixth Defendant

D J Neutze for Seventh Defendant and Ninth Third Party (Beca) G R Grant for First Third Party

J C Dymock for Third Third Party

Judgment:

5 May 2023


REASONS JUDGMENT OF ANDREW J

[Plaintiffs’ supplementary briefs of evidence]


BODY CORPORATE 406198 & ORS v ARGON CONSTRUCTION LTD & ORS [2023] NZHC 1072 [5 May 2023]

[1]    On 3 May 2023, I issued a minute granting the plaintiffs’ applications to adduce reply/supplementary evidence from Mr August and Mr Hakin

[2]This judgment contains my reasons for granting the applications.

Introduction

[3]    This is defective building litigation. It involves the 157-unit residential unit title development (two towers) known as the Bianco Off Queen Apartments (Bianco Off Queen).

[4]    The Body Corporate and individual unit owners sue in negligence. The defendants include the building contractor, Argon Construction Ltd (Argon), and the Auckland Council.

[5]    The principal defects at issue are weathertight-related. The plaintiffs say the building was built with cantilevered balconies that have defective waterproofing (defect 1). They also say that the waterproofing on the ground level (including the podium common areas) suffers from similar problems (defect 2). The overwhelming majority of the damages sought relate to the cost of remedying defect 1.

[6]    The primary difference between the parties relates to the scope and cost to remedy defect 1 and who among the defendants/third parties bear responsibility for those remedial costs.

[7]    The trial has just commenced. It is scheduled for 14 weeks but it now appears that it will be of shorter duration. At this late stage, the plaintiffs seek leave to file two reply briefs of expert evidence relating to the scope of repairs in respect of defect 1 (waterproofing of balconies).

[8]    The application, which I shall treat as an application to file supplementary briefs under r 9.8 of the High Court Rules 2016 is opposed by the Auckland Council.

The application

[9]    The plaintiffs seek leave to adduce supplementary briefs of evidence from both Mr Darryl August, a building surveyor, and Mr Andrew Hakin, a façade engineer.

[10]   Mr August’s first brief of evidence is dated 4 February 2022. Mr August outlines what consequential works, in his opinion, would need to be undertaken in order to restore the cantilevered balconies (waterproofing defect) and put…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate 406198 v Argon Construction Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZHC 1072
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, the case of Body Corporate 406198 and others versus Argon Construction Limited and others was heard, involving a dispute over defective building works at the Bianco Off Queen Apartments. The plaintiffs, including the Body Corporate and individual unit owners, sued in negligence against the defendants, which included the building contractor Argon Construction Ltd and the Auckland Council. The primary defects in question were related to weathertightness, particularly concerning the waterproofing of cantilevered balconies and ground-level areas. The plaintiffs sought to adduce supplementary briefs of evidence from two experts, Mr Darryl August, a building surveyor, and Mr Andrew Hakin, a façade engineer, in response to evidence from the defendants' experts. The application was opposed by the Auckland Council but was granted by Justice Andrew.

The court considered the relevant legal principles, particularly under Rule 9.8 of the High Court Rules 2016, which allows for supplementary briefs at the discretion of the trial judge. The court balanced the interests of justice, considering factors such as the relevance of the evidence, the stage of the proceedings, and the potential prejudice to the opposing parties. The court found that the evidence was crucial to the plaintiffs' case, particularly in establishing the scope and cost of necessary repairs, and that the application, while late, was not without justification due to the evolving nature of expert evidence and the mediation and expert conferral processes.

The court granted the plaintiffs' applications to adduce the supplementary briefs of Mr August and Mr Hakin, noting the importance of allowing the plaintiffs to fully present their case, especially given the significant nature of the claims and the substantial delay in bringing the application. The court also noted that while the applications were made late, the evidence was directly responsive to key issues in the case and would aid in refining the areas of disagreement, potentially reducing the duration of the trial. The court declined to make a costs order, finding no basis to do so in the circumstances.

The final orders of the court were that the plaintiffs were granted leave to adduce the supplementary briefs of evidence from Mr August and Mr Hakin, and no costs order was made.